HomeMy WebLinkAbout01-25-2010 CHPC MINUTES !
• ' l�����V�� $
P+ ��� �����(� !
ti'C.J--�;6F+ii..i-13[�
CALDWELL HISTORIC PRESERVATION COMMISSION MINUTE5
Meeting of January 25, 2010 @ 6:00 P.M
Caldwell Public Library — Community Room
I. Call to Order. Chairperson Chuck Randolph called the meeting to order at 6:00 p.m.
IL Roll Call
Members Present. Chairperson Chuck Randolph, Vice-Chair Lorene Oates, Elaine Leppert,
Elaine Carpenter, Megan Dixon, Anita Shore, Eileen Davidson.
Members Absent. Jan Boles, Steve Maughan, Gina Lujack.
Others Present. Brian Billingsley, Planning & Zoning Director, April Cabello, Planning
Technician.
Others Absent. Rob Hopper, City Council Liaison.
III. Approval of Minutes. MOTION TO APPROVE November 23, 2009 minutes with the
correction to section IX, spelling of last name from Trips to Tripp.
MOTION: Elaine C., SECOND: Eileen D., MOTION PASSED.
IV. Certificate of Appropriateness Interviews.
A. Case No. CA-144-10 — 1802 Cleveland Blvd. — A request by Lisa Adams for approval of a
home occupation bed and breakfast.
1) Chairperson Chuck Randolph opened the meeting and asked the applicant to give her
testimony.
2) Lisa Adams, applicant, stated she would like approval for a home occupation Bed &
Breakfast. Ms. Adams stated the home is on the national register with a connection to the
College of Idaho and would like to share the home with parents of students attending C of
I. Ms. Adams explained that the three upstairs bedrooms would be used for the Bed &
Breakfast with breakfast only.
3) Elaine C. asked if Southwest District health needs to do an inspection.
4) Brian B. asked the applicant she would be putting up any signage.
5) Lisa A. stated there would be no signage for the Bed & Breakfast.
6) Megan D. asked if the applicant p(anned to make any modifications to the house.
7) Lisa A. stated there will be no modifications at this time but in the future would like to
install an ADA ramp at which time she would come before the commission for approval.
8) Chuck asked the applicant where the patrons would park.
9) Lisa A. replied the parking would be on the street and will contact C of I and ask if she
may purchase parking passes for the C of I parking lot.
10) Megan D. asked the applicant if she had contacted the College to learn more history
about the home.
11) Lisa A. responded that she had not contacted the college but has spoken with parents
and people in the community but intends to contact the college.
1
12) Megan D. suggested the applicant contact the admissions office to promote her Bed &
Breakfast.
13) Chairperson Randolph closed public testimony.
MOTION TO APPROVE: Elaine L., SECOND: Elaine C. MOTION PASSED.
V. Audience Participation. None
VI. Actions Since Last Meeting.
A. Chairperson Randolph stated he approved C of A Case No. 143-09 1414 Dearborn Street for
repair / replacement of pillar material on front porch with grey bricks.
B. April C. informed the commission members that 1220 Everett Street that has been in
violation due to a front covered porch built without a C of A or a building permit will be
removed by the end of January.
VII. Old Business.
• April C. stated she found a web site that the commission might want to look into for building
the Historic Preservation Web page. The Commission stated they would like to look into it
more and have April C. to do more research — ACTION: Continued to the next meeting.
• April C. stated two consultants of the six submitted their proposals for the 2010 CLG Grant:
➢ Madeline Buckendorf Consulting, LLC., Caldwell, ID 83605
➢ TAG Historical Research and Consulting, Barbara Perry Bauer, Boise, ID
April C. asked the commission to vote for one of the two consultants. The Commission
stated they would like staff to ask Madeline Buckendorf to reconsider her bid or maybe
split the project into two years and if that is not possible to award the contract to TAG
Historical Research and Consulting. MOTION TO APPROVE: Elaine C., SECOND:
Anita S. MOTION PASSED. — ACTION: April C. will contact Madeline Buckendorf
to renegotiate her bid and if not possible to renegotiate the bid to award the contract to
TAG Historical Research and Consulting.
• Brian B. stated on January 5`�' City Council appointed Elaine C., Lorene O., Anita S. and
Megan D. for a term of three years expiring on December 31, 2012 and City Council
appointed Jan B. as an alternate for a term of three years expiring on December 3 l, 2012.
VIII. New Business
• None
IX. Commission Reports
• Eileen D. gave a report on Bess Stuenenberg scrapbook and reference to the "Hat".
• Elaine C. gave a report about a Shot Gun House in Santa Monica that was saved.
• Elaine C. stated the extra index for the Statton Studio has been found.
• Elaine C. shared a picture of what the TVCC will look like.
. Elaine L. stated she worked on a list of PEO Presidents and Members.
• Lorene O. gave an update on the Daughters of the American Revolution.
• Chuck R. stated his term on the Design Review Committee has expired.
• Chuck R. stated the house on 13`'' & Blaine that received a C of A is now up for sale.
2
. •
• Elaine C. stated Hartwell is planning on nominating the Isaacs House, 823 Albany for the
orch "r d award.
• Brian B. stated the Willful Neglect ordinance will go to City Council in March.
• Chuck R. stated his concern regarding the house next to Boone Memorial Church is still
standing with open windows and doors.
X. Adjournment. Chairman adjourned the meeting at approximately 7:15 p.m.
Respectfully submitted by April Cabello.
MINUTES APPROVED AND SIGNED BELOW BY CHAIRPERSON CHUCK RANDOLPH ON
THE DATE NOTED BELOW.
�
�GL �i/(, �� - _ � , �' l ��
Chuck Randolph, Chairperson Date
� � � `
�
� -�-' z / 2 � ���
ATTEST: Brian Billingsley, P&Z Director Date
3