HomeMy WebLinkAbout03-28-2011 CHPC MINUTES r
s �
CALDWELL HISTORIC PRESERVATION COMMISSION MINUTES
Meeting of March 28, 2011 @ 6:00 P.M.
i �1F'�F� "`°` � .
� A`t �-- s , ,
Caldwell Public Library — Idaho Room �`�`� ��L _..
�.,.�_._..v.__....
I. Call to order. Chairperson Randolph called the meeting to order at approximately at
6:03 p.m.
11. Roll Call
' Members Present. Chuck Randolph, Elaine Leppert, Gina Lujack, Elaine Carpenter
Members Absent. Anita Shore, Jan Boles, Eileen Davidson, Lorene Oates, Megan
Dixon, Steve Maughan.
Others Present. April Cabello, Planning Technician, Anne Marie Skinner, Senior
Planner, Brian Billingsley, Planning & Zoning Director
Others Absent., Rob Hopper, City Council Liaison.
III. Approval of Minutes.
MOTION TO APPROVE THE MINUTES OF FEBRUARY 28, 2011:
CONTINUED TO APRIL 25, 2Q11 MEETING.
IV. Certificate of Appropriateness Interviews.
None.
V. Audience Participation.
None.
VI. Actions Since Last Meeting.
None. �
VII. Old Business
A. CHPC Jurisdiction. Anne Marie Skinner explained to the commission that after
comparing State and City Code, it is pretty clear that under current City code the
historic preservation commission only has jurisdiction over a district that has
been established by ordinance and further research back through city records
shaws that there is only one such district established by ordinance which is the
Ste�nertberg Residential Historicat District. There is a map in the comprehensive
ptan that shows Caldwelf Historic Sites National Register of Historic Places and it
shows two other districts but they have not been adopted officially through
ordinance. If the commission wishes to have jurisdiction over the Caldwell
Historic District and the North Caldwell Historic Districts, the commission would
�eed to adopt the districts officially through fhe ordinance process and then any
property in fhose districts would need to follow the C of A process. Chairman
R�ndolph confirrr�ed with Anne Marie that in effect the commission did not have
eHPC Meeting March 28, 2011
jurisdiction when the commission had the Roberts go through the C of A process
for the restoration of the Isaacs House. Anne Marie responded that is correct.
Chairman Randolph stated for the record that the commission was informed they
had jurisdiction over the Steunenberg Residential Historic District,
Caldwell
Historic District, the North Caldwell Historic Districts, and other historic registered
buildings. Anne Marie stated that the commission could have jurisdiction over
sites on the national register if the ordinance is changed then the commission
would have jurisdiction over properties on the NR and if the commission further
wanted jurisdiction over properties in the districts the commission would need to
establish the district officially by ordinance. Elaine C. confirmed the other two
districts mentioned are the Caldwell Historic District and North Caldwell Historic
District. Anne Marie further stated that the commission has jurisdiction over
properties in City Center that are listed on the NR because of chapter 10, 10-12-
07 / 10-12-08 and the way the City Center code was written but if the commission
wants jurisdiction over properties located in the Caldwell Historic District in City
Center but are not listed on the NR then the commission would need to establish
the district officialty by ordinance. Chairman Randolph asked Anne Marie to apply
the current code to the Subia C of A issued for window replacement and painting.
Anne Marie explained that the Subias building is on the NR and because the
property is in City Center, chapter 10 specifically states that alterations of all
properties listed on the NR shall fotlow The Secretary of the Interior's Standards
for Rehabilitation Guide and the pattern book for historic structures in City Center
should be referenced however, we do not have the pattern book for historic
structures. Chairman Randolph stated back when the ordinance was written the
City was operating under the design review guidelines. April C. stated the she
found in a staff report from September 13, 2005 that the Pattern Book for Historic
Structures was never developed. Anne Marie stated that the Design Guidelines
book is for residential and wou{d pertain to Down Town or City Center. Elaine C.
said the Design Guidelines was for the Steunenberg Residential Historic District.
Chairman Randolph stated there was a set of design review guidelines paid out
of the CLG grant money by Burchiurm Rantom and they were set up with
examples for downtown. Chairman Randolph stated he will try to locate a copy of
this document. Anne Marie responded to Chairman Randolph that if he could find
a copy of the Pattern Book for Historic Struetures, have the commission revamp
and update it then give it that title she could take it to City Council for adoption.
Chairman Randolph asked Anne Marie to confirm how many districts there are in
Caldwell and the locations. Anne Marie explained there are three districts;
Steunenberg Residential Historical District, North Caldwell District and the
�aldwell District located in City Center and the commission has jurisdiction over
the Steunenberg Residential Historical District and properties in City Center that
are trsted on the NR based upon Chapter 10, but the r�st of the properties
designated on the map as Caldwell Historic District the commission does not
have jurisdiction because Caldwell Historic District has not been officially
establisf�ed by ordinance. Elaine C. stated that at one point there was concern
abot�t sensitive areas, that motivated the commissior► to draw the map to
uindicate the areas that were areas significant enough of historic importance, and
that things should not run roughshod over those a�eas. Brian B. said these areas
are stilt on the comprehensive plan and the map is for historically sensitive areas
and highlights properties not on the NR but are historicalfy sensitive. Elaine L.
stated that highlighting the histqrically sensitive areas still gives the commission
no jurisdiction. Elaine C. stated this was an attempt to bring awareness to the
faet that there are many historically sensitive areas in Caldwell that were not
pro}ected but there is some importance. Anne Marie stated even though the
cpmm�ssion has no jurisdiction over those properties, when the historically
CHPC Meeting March 28 201 r
sensitive praperties do come in to P&Z they are referred to SHPO because they
are on the NR and they are supposed to follow the guidelines. Chairman
Randolph stated the steel bridge is a good example of that and confirmed with
Anne Marie if they came in to do work on the bridges they would be referred to
the state. Anne Marie responded that is the way it should happen. Elaine C.
asked Anne Marie what the commission needs to do to get ordinances in place to
protect properties they currently do not have control over. Anne Marie responded
that there are two things the commission can do; 1 St thing would be to amend
chapter 2 article, 17 in all the places under section 23 where it refers to
designated historic district simply add something like and or a nationa/ site on
the NR and then the commission will have jurisdiction not only of the
Steueneberg Residential District but also all the properties listed on the NR.
Brian B. confirmed that change would be C of A jurisdiction, Anne Marie
confirmed. 2" thing that needs to be done is officially adopt through ordinance
both the Caldwell Historic District and the North Caldwell Historic District.
Chairman Randolph asked if there is a reason why the Caldwel! Historic District
was never adopted. Brian B. stated the old comp plan reference an attempt in
1988 to adopt the Caldwell Historic District but was never approved. April C.
stated she looked through all the old minutes and could not find a reason why it
was never adopted. If the commission wants jurisdiction over the two districts
then the commission needs to amend chapter 2, article 17 and adopt the
Caldwell Historic District and the North Caldwell Historic District by ordinance.
B. Down Town Design Review. Anne Marie informed the commission that there is
a design review committee made up of Gene Shaffer, Stephanie Rohrdanz,
Steve Maughan and Jim McGarvin. Brian B. stated the rules are very specific
about the type of people who can serve on the committee, like someone from the
construction field, an engineer, an architect and one at large. Gina L. stated there
used to be a steering committee for five years and then two weeks later there
was a new committee and the new people she spoke to never knew what the
previous committee worked on. Anne Marie stated she understood what Gina L.
is saying but the way the ordinance is written it does not necessarily matter
because the ordinance is written such as all applications that come in for new
construction in City Center are reviewed against the criteria in the ordinance and
P&Z reviews the application against that criteria. If the application meets all the
criteria then the application does not need to go before Design Review because it
is not required to. The criteria are very specific and if the application does not
meet the criteria then it goes to design review for approval or denial of a
variance. Elaine C. confirmed that the ordinance calls out height and theme,
Anne Marie confirmed and stated there are four different architectural types the
application has to meet or it will trigger design review. In addition, a complete
exterior renovation, taking out windows, doors or complete new fa�ade would
trigger design review but no new applications have been submitted since DL
Evans. DL Evans triggered design review because of waivers to their project and
since then one of their waivers for a two story building would not apply as the
three story building limitation has been removed from the ordinance. The only
other new construction was NCC but the application met all requirements so
design review was not required. Gina L. asked if DL Evans does build, would
they have a drive up window. Anne Marie responded yes, that was one of the
waivers. Chairman Randolph stated this is where he goes crosswise with the
group, because DL Evans application was the first one out of the shoot and was
asking for waivers and one of the waivers was the back door situation. The
applicant did not know they were supposed to have the exemption or make other
arrangements for parking and he was hung up over traffic pattern. Then TVCC
GHP� Meeting Marc� 28, 2411
submitted their application and they did not go before design review because
they did not ask for any waivers that would trigger design review. Chairman
Randolph stated for confirmation that the design review committee would only
meet if the applicant were asking for a waiver; otherwise, there is no design
review. Anne Marie responded that is correct and when you think of design
review, a true design review, reviews everything so iYs not a true design review
in that respect. The committee reviews the things that are not following the
ordinance exactly and denies or grants permission for the requested variances,
work may begin on everything else that meets the ordinance. Elaine C. asked if
there were historic buildings with historic facades. Anne Marie said that is the
one caveat, that if the building is in City Center and is on the NR it has to go
before the commission. Elaine C. asked what if it is not on the NR then what.
Anne Marie responded that is why the commission would need to do the
ordinance change. If the Caldwell Historic District were established by ordinance
then the commission has jurisdiction for buildings within that district. Elaine C.
stated it is important to get the ordinance underway and there is no better time
than before things start happening. Anne Marie asked the commission if she
answered all their questions about Down Town Design Review. Gina L. asked
about signage and Anne Marie responded that signage does not fall under pown
Town Design Review as long as they meet the requirements. Gina L. asked how
you change the requirements because the ordinance does not explain today's
reader boards. Anne Marie responded that reader boards have always been
allowed in City Center from the original ordinance and has never required design
review. Chairman Randolph asked if the current sign ordinance was drafted with
the intent that reader boards were put up letters on the board than an electronic
board. Anne Marie stated that the original City Center ordinance from 2005
specifically references the electronic animated reader board. Gina L. asked Anne
Marie what her opinion would be if every store downtown had a reader board.
Anne Marie responded not every store downtown would have a reader board
because they are very expensive, they are limited in size, they have to be put on
a post, and pole signs are not allowed without approval from the P&Z. Most of
the businesses down town are side by side and no place to put a reader board
except on the front wall and then would count as a wall sign. The current wall
sign ordinance has restrictions and due to the restrictions, most business could
not have a reader board because there is not enough room. The only business
that could have a reader board would have to be on a corner so they have a
corner wall, example would be Superior Signs or they have to have a large
enough site where they have property to place a post or pole sign like Key Bank.
Gina L. stated that Verns Tavern could have a nice sign and he had put up a cute
BSU sign. Anne Marie responded they keep a close eye and he did put up
something but the City requested Vern to remove the sign because his colors did
not meet the requirements of the sign ordinance. Brian B. stated that P8�Z has
not approved any new pole signs down town but have approved replaceme�t
signs. Anne Marie stated all pole signs down town have been there and many of
the banks have upgraded or replaced the existing signs but no new pole signs
and from the perspective of the businesses, signs are a hot topic and if their
signage is restricted, they become very angry. Chairman Randolph asked about
City ordinances for removal of signs after a business is gone or changed. Anne
Marie respondecf yes, the ordinance goes into effect when a business is out of
business or vacant for 6 months or more. P&Z tries to track businesses citywide.
Katie, P&Z Code Enforcement will take a picture, note the date and track it for 6
months_ Katie is currently following Curt & Hal Meineke, Bronco Athletic Elite
and the Sundowner. Elaine C. said the City needs to be careful with the
Sundowner signs; they are so classic and are very sensitive. Anne Marie
CHPC Meeting March 28, 2011
responded until someone makes a complaint she can wait but if someone
submits a complaint, P&Z Code Enforcement will have to comply with the
ordinance. Chairman Randolph stated that the Waldorf and Sweet Water Saloon
are on the NR, the signs are still up and wanted to know if they are two different
businesses. Anne Marie stated she considers the Watdorf sign historic and does
not want it taken down and thought that the Sweet Water Saloon is still in
business. Chairman Randolph stated he did not want the sign taken down either
but was just asking.
C. Continued discussion - Selection of Valley Regional Transit Bus Stop
Benches. Anne Marie reported she emailed each commission member the only
bench that was less than $600.00 and the majority voted on Tavern Green. She
sent the information to the project coordinator at Valley Regional Transit and the
benches will be installed sometime this summer at each of the bus stops within
the Steunenberg District. Chairman Randolph asked if it the benches are for all
the bus stops in the district or just some of the bus stops. Anne Marie responded
there are 10 stops that will be receiving the benches. Chairman Randolph asked
if the notification have been sent to the homeowners. Anne Marie stated that
Valley Regional Transit is coordinating all of this and the stops are already there
but she will double check with Valley Regional Transit to make sure. Anne Marie
said she herself will get a list of the stops put together with a picture of the bench
and send something out to the applicable property owners. Chairman Randolph
asked Anne Marie how to explain to his neighbors the how Valley Regional
Transit has authority, this is a hot topic item for two of his neighbors. Anne Marie
said that any of the property that is in the strip of grass by the street is not their
property it is public right of way so if the bus stop people are going on to the
property owners property and not staying on the right of way, she suggests they
put up a fence to help deter them. In addition, the City does not have jurisdiction
over Cleveland or the right of way, ITD does. Anne Marie stated she asked
Valley Regional Transit about moving some of the stops because she has
received complaints from property owners and Valley Regional c�aims they have
met with the property owners and have done surveys to determine the best
places for bus stops and these are the best places. Chairman Randolph
suggested moving one bus stop from Rick Lancaster property at 15 & Cleveland
up one block to 16 & Cleveland, a bus stop at that location would hurt no one
because its vacant, it's gravel and it's un-kept and open. Anne Marie responded
that bus stop is not one that she had received a request to be moved. Chairman
Randolph said Rick probably went directly to the transit company. Anne Marie
said she would call the transit company to see if the bus stop could be moved.
Anne Marie stated the authority for the placement and maintenance of the bus
stops are Valley Regional Transit, the City nor ITD have anything to do with it, it
is all Val{ey Regional Transit. Anne Marie will specifically check with Valley
Regional to move the 15�' & Cleveland bus stop fo 16 8� Cleveland.
Anne Marie spoke about trees and stated that the City Forester spoke with her
and the code enforcement officer about doing a survey this summer of all the
trees along Blaine and Cleveland to identify the trees that need to be removed.
Anne Marie asked if the property owners were aware the trees would be
removed not just trimmed but removed. April C. stated that was part of the
discussion that came up at the meeting with the commission and Lynn the City
Forester. Lynn wanted to know who would notify the property owners because he
did not have the resources. Chairman Randolph asked if the trees were out of
compliance. Anne Marie responded that the trees along Blaine and Cleveland
should not be along streets because they are too big and the sidewalks are
CHPC Meeting March 28, 20l 1
.. ,
buckling. The only way to repair the sidewalk is to remove the roots, trunk, the
tree and then pour new sidewalk. Trees to be planted along the streets are much
smaller and do not get the bi�q roots that grow and buckle the sidewalk. Gina L.
asked about a tree along 12 & Dearborn, it's a huge tree that has a massive
double trunk and lean� across the street, the trees by Flahiff Funeral Home and
across from Pioneer Title, she feels they are all hazards. Anne Marie explained
to the commission the problem with sending letters to the property owners is the
property owner is responsible for the cost and removal of the trees but most do
not remove the trees. Anne Marie also said the City can issue citations but the
property owner will not pay the citation and that does not solve the problem.
Elaine C. said there are a couple of ways to look at the situation and understands
when planting new trees, making sure the trees are appropriate; however looking
back in history any city or historic housing area they planted elms, sycamore and
the big trees and you will find sidewalks that are buckled. Elaine C. stated are the
sidewalks unsafe, yes, is there history there, yes; can we sanitize every bit of our
life or should we. At the college by Blatchely Hall, the sidewalk was poured
around the tree and some places and cities sidewalks go around the trees and
they should think long and hard before they start removing trees. Anne Marie
stated that was the 2" part of her meeting with the City Forester and his
supervisor to come up with some solutions because she took a complaint about a
tree on Cleveland and yes the roots have come up but the tree appears to be
alive, no branches dangling and she did not understand what the safety issue
was. Anne Marie stated the City does not have the resources to remove the trees
nor do the home owners and what can we do to identify the one that are dead so
the tree can be removed also identify the ones with dead tree limbs and have
them pruned. Chairman Randolph stated he hopes the City thinks about this and
picks its fights, he agrees there are dead trees and trees with dead limbs and
trees that are sight barrier but as long as the City allows parking along Blaine and
Cleveland blocking the views the City does nat have any legal or moral ground to
stand on and the City needs to approach it reasonably. Anne Marie responded
and said Lynn the Forester will identify the trees but P&Z will send the letter and
will make sure not to send out letters on trees that are not appropriate. Elaine C.
stated one of the goals of the commission is to reforest Cleveland and Blaine and
loosing the big trees along Cleveland and Blaine without some good reason will
take their heart and souls. Chairman Randolph stated if the City is going to
remove trees along Cleveland and Blaine then the City needs to think about
reforestation and sidewalk LIDs.
D. Continued discussion - North Caldwell District Expansion. Chairman
Randolph would like this item kept on the monthly agenda and could be a
possible future CLG Grant project.
E. 2011 CLG Grant Update. April C. stated she spoke with Ann Swanson of SHPO
and Ann stated no final budget from Congress. April C. stated that the Mayor has
signed all contracts and mailed to SHPO. SHPO will hold all contracts and will
not sign or process them until congress passes the budget.
VI11. New Business
A. Night Vision Reflective Adciress Signs. April C. stated she received a call from
someone that wants to self and instaif night vision reflective address signs in
residential front yards, throughout the City of Caldwell. April C stated she gave
her the approval for the entire City except for the Steunenberg Historical District.
CHPC Meeting March 28, 2011
., ,
April C spoke with Chairman Randolph and he felt the commission should decide
if they were okay with giving the approval or if they wanted this person to come
before them with an application for C of A. April C. also stated she verified with
the City Clerk this person did not need a peddler's license as long as she did not
have direct contact with the homeowners. The commission discussed this among
themselves and felt the answer would be "no" but decided to have the applicant
submit a C of A application and bring a sample sign to the next meeting.
B. Commission projects for 2011. Brian B. stated the signage for the NCHD was
finished with funds from last year's budget and this year has budgeted a
$1,000.00 for HPC to use and they are 6 months into this budget year and have
6 months to spend it. Brian B. stated use it or lose it and suggested the possibility
of putting up signs in front of home that are on the NR within the Steunenberg
District. Chairman Randolph first suggested replacing the existing Steunenberg
Historic District Signs as they are damaged or age with ones that have pictures
of the actual house that it is in front of, second suggestion would be after the
NCHD is adopted locally as a district to expand the district and mark some of
those places that are no longer existing such as the original C of I or the first
School House. Brian B. said what they need to do is drive the district and figure
out how many signs there are and the addresses and figure out how many
pictures we have in our files. Chairman Randolph said the sign at 16tn �
Cleveland and most of the signs along Blaine 8� Cleveland are damaged and
should be replaced. Brian B. stated he would talk to Superior Signs for price
estimates for re-work of signs and new signage.
IX. Commission 8� Staff Reports.
A. April C. informed the commission of a possible C of A for a possible detached
garage at 1811 Cleveland Blvd.
B. Brian B. discussed with the commission the date and time for the "Walk Around
The Block" and wanted to make sure the commission was comfortable hosting
this event. Brian B. suggested holding the walk after Orchids and Onions on May
14 around 3:30pm. The commission thought this was a great idea.
C. Brian B. stated that Nancy Roberts left him a kind message regarding the NCHQ
sign that was placed in front of her home at 823 Albany. Nancy stated that she
thought it was a beautiful sign, which had been placed in the right spot.
X. Meeting adjourned at approximately 7:45 p.m.
Respectfully submitted by April Cabello,
MINUTES APPROVED AND SIGNED BELOW BY CHAIRMAN CHUCk� RANDOLPH ON
THE DATE NOTED BELOW.
�. I
,��_. ,� � � �-�/� � �.� f�
�� �� � �
Chairperson Randolph Date
' �° `�-
A ST: Brian Billingsley, P& Z Director Date
CHPC Meeting March 28, 2011