Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout08-22-2011 CHCP MINUTES _ . • CALDWELL HISTORIC PRESERVATION COMMISSION IVIINUTES Mee#ing of August 22, 2011 @ 6:00 P.M. �r����,�� ��; , , ��, u Caldwell Public Library — Idaho Room t— ��. 1. CaU to order. Chairperson Randolph called the meeting to order at approximateiy 6:01 p.m. li. Roll Call Members Present. Chuck Randolph, Jan Boles, Elaine Carpenter, Eileen Davidson, Elaine Leppert, Gina Lujack, Steve Maughan, Lorene Oates, Anita Shore. Mennbers Absent. Megan Dixon. Others Present. April Cabello, Planning Technician; Anne Marie Skinner, Senior Planner; Rob Hopper, City Council Liaison; Brian Billingsley, Planning & Zoning Director. III. Approval of Minutes. MOTION TO APPROVE THE MfNUTES 4F JULY 25, 2011: MOTION: Elaine C., SECOND: Anita S., MOTION PASSED. IV. Certificate of App�opriateness Interviews. None. V. Audience Participation. A. Chairperson Randolph reported on the couple who lives in the 1900 block af Fillmore that may still want to attend a meeting in the future. They were invited to attend last month's and tonight's meeting but were unable to at#end. They are interes#ed in doing some modifications to their house and they are curious about the process and what kind of steps they have to go through with this Commission. They are looking for help and constructive criticism from this group regarding their project. They are on the odd-numbered side af the street across fram Jack and Sylvia Hunt. VI. Actions Since Last Meeting. A. l.etter cf Support — Chairperson Randolph reporEed he submitted on behalf of the commission to the CaldweA Economic Development Council, Steve Fultz, a letter of suppo�t for the Indian Creek Investmertt Project and read the letter to the commission_ �...�. �.��...�,�.�.� CHPC Meeting August z2, 2011 Page 1 , � ' VII. O!d Business A. FY 2012 CLG Grant — Ann Swanson, SHPO representative, thanked the commission and April Cabello for the fimely close out and billing of the FY 2011 CLG Grant. SHPO will attempt to Mave the reimbursement money to the city by the requested date of September 9, 2011. Ms. Swanson reported that Ms. Cabello relayed to her the ideas for the FY 20'f 2 CLG and stated she came to the meeting to help the comrnission sort through their ideas and come up with a project SHPO can fund. The money for tt�e grant comes from the Nationai Parks Service who services the HPF fund, Nat+onal Register program, money for traditionally black co{leges, tribal Historicaf Preservation officers, Presenre America grants and Save America's Treasures grant. Overall, t�e HPF fund was cut but SHPO will recei"v� more money to distribute and she guesses it wi{I be late again this next year. Ms. Swanson inquired what priorities the commissian has for the 2012 CLG Gran#. Chairperson Randolph reported the commission had a brainstorming session after the email sent by SHPO stating the priority for #he next couple of years will be the identification of sites associated with the eariy settlement of Idaho and/or sesquicentennial. Chairperson Randolph stated four sites came to mind; first being Cu�tis Parlc. He gave a brief history and the reasons why Curtis Park and ' the Curtis cabin should be studied. Ms. Swanson wondered if each subject should be discussed separa#ely and the commission agreed. Ms. Swanson stated SHPO has a limit of what this program can assist with and many towns have log cabins. Generally, they are not listed on the National Register because they are out o# conEext, but Caldwell's may nat be too far out of context and asked where the Curtis cabins were originally located. Chairpersan Randolph responded the cabin was originally located in Curtis Park but was moved to the Memorial Park. He further said Idaho Heritage Trust, Union Pacific Foundation, and City of Caldwell have put money aside and the city has accepted ownership of the Curtis cabin and farm eguipment. Ms. Swanson explained the Curtis cabin is important but cann�t consider it as a CLG Grant projecE and she is taking it off the table. Ms. Swanson further explained if a11 this activity took place in Curtis Park and the daughter and brother settled af that tocation there may not be any above surface remains but there maybe be subsurface remains, which means an archeological project. SHPO almost never funds archeotogica! projects because of the expense and wili not fund anything unless they kr�ow there is enough funding to finish the project. It can happen. SHPO is worlcing with Adams County and the U of l, doing surface surveys. Ms. Swanson further stated if the commission wants to consider ti�e • archeological project, it would be a big project. SHPO will talk to the state archeologist and have #hem look at the project. The first fhing that will need to happen is to map the area to see what is there and devise a project. Once we know it's thece and think its eligib4e then you write fhe National Register Nomination and then can do the interpretation, This would be a 3-4 year project most tikely requiring more funding from other sources aEong with the CLG Grant money. Ms. Swanson also suggested using ldaho State Historical Saciety Grants Program to fund signage along the Boise River. CHPC Meeting August 22, �011 Page 2 Commissioner Elaine Carpenter wonde�ed if a survey nomination for Curtis Park, ifself, was still an option. Ms. Swanson responded yes, the nomination could talk abou� city beautification, city planning, how paiics are important to the community, establish wt�y this is impoctant, and would mention the history of Curtis Park. Commissioner Steve Maughan noted if the commission approached signage through the Idaho Historical Society, it would be a way to link the Oregon Trail elements that are associated with Canyon Hilt and Curtis Park. � Ms. Swanson expressed her frustrations with SHPO not being able to help the commissian with these important and major events but it is not in the fine print. Chairperson Randolph states there are three final things that #it with a11 this. First, the pilings in the river from the interurban railroad, second Larry Jones took the commission on a field trip between Plymouth ancf Cu�tis Park stating there is a draw because af rope bums on the rocks caused from the wagons that roped their way down to the cemetery. Thirdly, one of the three theories of where Canyon Hill and Canyon County got their names was the canyon where Curtis Park is located. Ms. Swanson further noted she went on a field trip with Larry Jones, which brought up more questions. Due to overgrown landscaping, they could not see the rope burns and it was questionable where the ruts were located and have had no response #rom the property owner giving permission to access the property. Chairperson Randolph stated there is an increased city ownership up that corridor of the wetland and asked Councilman Rob Hopper to address the question. Councilman Hopper responded #hat he was not sure of the boundaries of the . property that the city purchased. He does not believe the property boundaries go up to the river or the pilings. He was also not sure if the city owns the apron where the �uts come dawn the hill. Ms. Swanson explained that just as Con�missioner Maughan pointed out, if you have a gaod signage program then you could bring in a!I the history without owning the land. Cammissioner Gina Lujack stated she is hopeful for a donation of land and stated the property had been platted for a subdivision but it is gone. Brian Billingsley responded that the land was not platted. They had prelim plat approval but the applicant never foflowed through with the plans to develop and now #he plat is expired. Councilman Hopper and Mr. Billingsley both responded that it was a shame the subdivision expired because the Order of Decision had a condition of approval tha# would have required a 50-foot right-of-way corridor. Ms. Swanson sugges#ed putting together some funding to purchase the property. CHPC Meeting August 22, 2011 Page 3 , Commissioner Maugl�an declared it is an extraordinary evocative subject, the Oregon Trail; canyon county canyon, itself, the site itself is extraordinary yet to be developed. Commissioner Lujack stated Curtis Park itseff was a big social center; even people ftom Boise attended the social events. Councilman Hopper explained city cauncil is stiil working with the Sta#e of Idaho Parks Department to develop some kind of Oregon Trail Interpretive Park. Commissioner Lujacic questioned how CHPC woufd know what city council is doing. Councilman Happer responded nothing would be done until the City assumes full ownership sometime next year. Chairperson Randolph suggested the second possible project is listed on the Early sites in Canyon County email dated 5-27-2011 would be IHSI# 27-7897. An area that is under interpreted in Caldweli that goes back to the early times around 1880's is Caldwell Merr►orial Park; also tt�e Fairview golf course across the street which was a dried lake bed. The park had the arigina! artesian well that fed Caldweli's water system and was called Waterworks Park un#i1 after WWI then named Memorial Park. The Idaho State Fair was housed across #he street ' where the Fairview Clubhouse sits today and they have letterhead and pictures dating from 1912 to 1916. There is no interpretive signage about Herbert Hoover, Bora and the band shelt. It is clear the park is understudied with bits and pieces of history here and there but never one complete study. Ms. Swa�son replied she thinks this subject is interesting and explained SHPO does nat have good records an the parks. She wondered if having an in�entory of Caldwefl parks with little nistories of each of the parks wouid help them to decide whether there is a multiple property documentation nomination. The survey would talk about the history of parks, the city beautiful movement, competition, railroad and stuff that happened at the parks and what still remains. Ms. Swanson suggested doing a reconnaissance survey and report on city parks, and fett it would be an interesting and allowable project. Chairperson Rando[ph noted that Carrie Adell Strahorn may have stated that Cald�rvell Park was the backyard of her house, Sunnyside Ranch, and watched railroad crews plant 500 trees in 1884. Commissioner Maughan noted that the Caldwell Night Rodeo was held at this site until after WWII, which is important information. The fact that it is a memorial park and studies of inemorialization of the first world war, the kinds of things that were done, the way historical memory was built around sacrifice, the way • national identity was built in the 1920's, have become very important topics in recent publications among professional historians nat only in. Caldwell and the US but afso throughout a(I of Europe. We have a memorial parlc and we have indications tisd to memorial park that were designed specifically to memorialize the sacrifice of sofdiers and sacrifice of people who gave their lives for the country. If we take that angie, we have mare sofid ground to rest a project on. . CHPC Meeting August 22, 2�11 Page 4 Ms. Swanson responded that she liked the idea very much and it is coming up on the 100-year anniversary for VWV1. She stated that we are losing the physicai remains of that period and it would be an interesting approach. Chairperson Randolph responded there are two or three parks besides Curtis Park that have significance to be included in the project; th� Rose Garden was part of the City Beautiful movement along Canyon Hil{ to Ceme+..�ry Hili. Ms. Swanson replied this is something that has not been done before but felt the CLG Grant funding wil! cover the cost to inventory some if not a!I the ea�ly parks of Caldwelf. Commissioner Maughan wondered about the founding date of Luby Park. Chairperson Randolph expiained the naming of Luby Park came lafer in 1960's ° but Luby Park was one of Caldwell's two veteran bills and had long wooden veteran housing. Commissione� Boles wondered about and suggested studying the military marlcers in the Ca�yon Hill cemetery. Ms. Swanson stated the Pa�lcs Service does not normally accept cemeteries to the national register because they are exempt unless they exhibit a certain landscaping feature. However, we do not know what is in the cemetery until we do the survey and suggested to include it in the survey but should be ready to remove it from the survey depending on the bids. Commissioner Maughan stated if it is a general park survey the cemetery can be considered as a functioning park design and could be reasonably incEuded in the survey. Chairperson Randolph continued down the fist of Early sites in Canyon County to IHSI# 27-25 Canyon Ferry Site and stated that a nomination and survey were done by Dafe Gray on the steel bridge and this was marked at one time by an early version of this commission but the sign has been destrayed. The ferry preceded the free bridge that Carrie Adell Strahorn fought for and then in 1922 or 1924 the current steel bridge on Plymouth comes across it. The earlier . commission has done things at the site but did not really do anything with the ferry crossing; Larry Jones was abfe ta propose a sign that is hidden away and talks about immigrant crossing and again did not talk about the ferry. It tafks about the river boftom, depth, fish and the sand. The information is on a regular state highway historical marker on old HWY 30. The other marking was the Ward IVlassacre site but when the intersection of Middleton Road was widened, the sign was removed and placed in Canyon County's Ward Massacre Park. Ms. Swanson responded that there are no physical remains that they know of at the ferry sites nor at the Alexander Rosses campsites but there is probably something at everyone of the ferry sites because there would be barns or items peopie lost or left behind. This wou{d be a big task requiring an archeotogical project and suggested signage as a good way to mark the spo�. Chairperson Randolph conEinued down the list of Early sites in �anyon Co�nty to IHSI# 27-18984 Riverside Canal, ending up with another water project because , - CHPC Meeting August 22, 2011 Page 5 this is in the same place as the steel bridge by HWY 30, the Caldwell green bett, the Riverside Canal, farmers ditch and the Boise River that a!I come together in a diversion that was historically important. Eiemen#s rernain and the upstream � diversion dam that can be raised and Iowered is still there and has been for over 60 years. Ms. Swanson wondered who owns the Riverside Canal. Chairperson Randolph and Councilman Hopper respo�ded they were not sure who owns the canal but thought that maybe the irrigation company owned it. Ms. Swanson suggested starting with the irrigation companies to figure out wha owns the Riverside Canal. She further stated SHPO has many irrigation projects on the National Register. Huge projects fike Milner Dam and Swan Falfs Dam or a less successful project like Salmon Falls Dam along with irrigation canals, which is a very important topic in southern Idaho. Ms. Swanson stated to do the Riverside Canal project would be important particularly if the h;story of the cana( was limited. Ms. Swanson further stated SHPO would be happy to accompany someone ta ga speak with the irrigation company and suggested having a consultant do a reconnaissance intensive level survey. Councilman Happer expressed the City of Caldwell's concern regarding designating a site as historically significant because of perspective af the irrigation districts; it would become difficult for development and work that would improve the canal or site. Ms. Swanson addressed Councilman Hopper's concern and stated it is just a perception because 4�aving a canal on the Nationa! Register actually moves a project to change the canal along because they are going to do a federal permit of some kind. Usually the first question asked on the permit will be is it eligible for iisting and if you know i# is listed then you may move to question two instead of having to hire a consultant to do a survey and then the request for listing it on the national register. There is nothing in the national register that says you cannot do what yau want to do to the builtfing, eventuallv, and SHPO does not have the power to protect their resources. Chairperson Randolph stated the Green Belt Civic League might have all the background information on the Riverside Canal. Ms. Swanson wondered why the commission was not writing the national registration nomination for the 2010 CLG Grant mid century house survey. Ms. Cabello responded because of the emai! from SHPO stafing the commission should focus on the Early Sites in Canyon County. Ms. Swanson stated the email Early sites in Canyon County were suggestions and it is up to the commission to choose their priority and if they were already � working on the mid century homes and have gaod vibes from the neighborhood, then she would suggest continuing on with the national registration nomination. In addition, she suggested another possible use for the CLG Grant maney would be the National Alliance o# Preservation Commissions Biennia! Nationaf Commission Forum the week of July 18-22 in Norfolk, VA. . CHPC Meeting August 22, 2011 Page 6 The commission and Ms. Swanson discussed replacement or restoratian of wood windows and Ms. Swanson stated SHPO can help the commission put on a window workshop to teach haw to repair wood windows. They also discussed design review and the impo�tance of having the most complete design guidelines. Ms. Swanson expressed her concerns regarding the corrimission's approvai process and woncfers whether the process is allowed. Ms. Cabello responded she would forward a copy of the Historic Preservation ° Ordinance to Ms. Swanson for review. The commission discussed the due date of the 20'! 2 CLG grant proposai and the date af #he September CHPC meeting. Commissioner Maughan motioned for the 2012 CLG Grant to move forward v►rith the Caldwell Parks Survey project. Commissioner Davidson seconded the motion. Commissioner Carpenter wondered and expressed her concern about the mid c�ntury houses and if it was pushed to 2013 they run the risk of changes to the homes and neighborhood. Commissioner Maughan responded he woufd be supportive if it is the sense of the commission to finish the 2d11 CLG Grant mid century house project. Commissioner 8oles wondered if the commission is closer t� comp(etion of the mid century project rather than launching a new project. Chairperson Randoiph responded he felt they are closer ta the completion of the mid century project, if t#�at is the way the commission wants to go. Commissioner Lujack wondered about obligations to the homeowners in the mid century neighborhood that the commission had already approached. Chairperson Randolph confirmed with Brian Billingsley that the commission could , pursue making this a national district. Mr. Billingsfey confirmed. Ms. Cabello clarified and confirmed with Mr. Billingsley that because this would be a national (evel district, no public workshops or public hearings would be required. Public Hearings and workshops would only be held if the neighborhood were to become a locaf district. Mr. Billingsley confirmed. Commissioner Maughan stated the parks project is more fun but the mid century house projec# is more responsible and as a practicing historian i� you never finish and bring together what you have discovered you have squander all that energy. �� CHPC Meeting August 22, 2011 Page 7 Commission�r Boles wondered if putting the mid century project on the back burnsr w�uld discount #he wark that has been completed on the 2010 and 2011 CLG Grant projec#s. Ms. Swanson responded the project can be picked back up but every year that goes by things in that district change and with the 2010 and 2011 surveys, a determination of how the district looked was made in 2011 and then the commission will have to look af the district again in 2015 for new a determination. Ms. Swanson informed the commission that she thinks #he Caldweli Parks is an eligibie project but suggested the commission pick their first choice and an alternate choice just in case SHPO does not see the parks as an eligible project. Commissioner Maughan stated he would entertain a friendly amendment to his motion. He further stated he is not sure which direction the commission wants to take and would be happy if the commission picks the mid century house project. Commissioner Lujack stated she thought the commission shou(d go with the mid century housing project. Chairperson Randolph stated he liked the idea of the parks and the Memorial situation but sees it that the commission should camplete the mid century project and put the parks as the backup or the 2013 CLG Grant project. Comrrtissioner Carpenter stated she preferred to finish what they started with the , mid century project and the parks will always be there and the parks could be a 2-year praject. Commissioner Boles voted to finish the mid century project. Commissioner Shores voted ta finish the mid century pr�ject. Cammissioner Davidson wondered what needed to be done to complete the mid century praject. Ms. Swanson replied that a survey was completed and now need to take that informatien and write the national register nomination. Commissioner Davidson confirmed with Ms. Swanson that the nomination is for the district not each indi�idual home and stated she would stuy with her vote of for the survey of the parks. Cammissioner �ates passed on her vote. Commissioner Maughan withdrew his motion for the 2Q12 CLG Grant fo survey Caldwell Parks and voted ta finish the mid century project. Chairperson Randolph stated the maker of the motion has withdrawn the mation � and have a straw poN out and asked for a secand motion to come before the cornmission. Commissioner Carpen#er made a motion to use the 2012 CLG Grant application to complete the work on the mid century surveys for the national nomination. �.�.�.. CHPC Meeting August 22, 2011 Page 8 Commissioner Shore seconded the motion. Chairperson Randolph confirmed the first choice for 2012 CLG is the mid century modern project and the second choice would be the Caldwell parks with the stipulation if the Caldwell parks project is not used on the 2092 CLG then the commission would move forward in 2013 with the Caldwetl p�rks project on the 2013 CLG Grant. MOTI�N: Elaine C., SECOND: Anita S., MOTION PASSED. Ms. Swanson commented that she is excited about the Caldwell Parks project and suggested the commission should start callec#ing information naw and at the next mee#ing. City staff should provide a list of city parks. The cammission then , should look at what they knaw about the parks historically and skart refi�ing the information so they are ready to proceed with the 2013 Caldwell Parks CLG project. B. Work session establishing boundaries of North Caldwell Historic District, Downtown District and new Local District — April Cabello explained per Chairperson Ra�dolph's request this item was added as a topic of discussion /work sessians on the next couple of ineeting agendas to establish the boundaries of new local districts and to pick which National Register sites should be included in an initial National Register Local Histaric District. Ms. Cabello stated that Anne Marie Skinner was unable to attend tonight's meeting and asked Ann Swanson to speak about this subject on behalf of SHPO. Discussion between Ms. Swanson and the commission ta�k place regarding expanding the North Caldwell Historic District as �nrel! as makir�g a new multiple property district. Chairman Randoiph also stated tt�is would include the properties that are on the National Register that are not in a local or national district and the commission would have design review over these properties. Ms. Swanson informed the commission that anyone may write a national register nomination and SHPO gets a!f kinds of nominations submitted to their offrce. Ms. Swanson stated if someone off the street comes in and wants their house listed on the national register SHPO thinks that is good if it meets the criferia. However, with the City of Caldwell's iocal law it would kick in a completely different thing. The commission then wil! have to regulate the district(s) and al! properties listed on #he nationa€ register. Ms. Swanson went on ta say she did not think it was a good idea and is not sure the commission wants fo regulate all properties listed on the nationa! register. She stated that is not the intent of the nationa! register, it is an honorary designation. When a local district is formed, it automatically linlcs design review and the national register. It will emanate farward a misconception in every other community about whaE the national �egister is and SHPO would go info the ather communities and say the national register does not regutate you except in Caidwell where it does. She further stafed that it is public policy that when you regulate s�meane you must have many public meetings, it must be the will of #he people or you would end up in court battling everyone constantly. CHPC MeetingAugust 22, 2011 �� 9 Councilman Hopper stated he did not think it was the intent o€ the commission to be an automatic iink but felt the concern o# the commission is if they want to protect fhe sites and do have properEy owner interest, then it woufc! be possible to pick parcels out and cr�ate an amalgam of properties and form a different kind of • a local historic clistrict. Ms. Swanson responded the state law that deals with giving communities the power to regulate historic properties is one �f the worsf writ#en laws of Idaho. If , asked, the SHPO office states the law says, if you are going to do focal design review the properties must be in a national register eligible district. There is such a thing as a discontinuous natianal register district and an example would be the Twin Falls Warehouse District consisting of two iittle pieces with nothing in- between. Twin Falls Historic Presen►ation has regulatory authority over the two pieces because its one national register district. When you write a national register nomination, you have to develop a rationale of why you think these properties are important, establish a time line and a general theme that connects #hem all together. The mid century modern can say they are alf built on this street geographically so we have a little geographic box, built in this period and reflect a spec�c architecturaE style. You must make a case for the hom�s. Ms. Cabello wondered if the commission could taice homes that are on the national register but are spotted throughout the city and make them into a local and national district. Councilman Hopper responded that it might be possible as a discontinuous district but the commission would have to state the case why this grouping is, . what it is and felt the link between the properties would be because they are ail on the Na#ional Register. Ms. Swanson stated when a property or site is listed on the national register, technically, there are no obligations for the prirrate property owner but under section 106 of the historic preservation act, if tt�ey get any laan or permits or if the city does a pcoject with federal money that thert triggers the consultatian process. When yau have properties listed there are ramifications and you want to make sure to incfude all of those when you get something listed. C. 2011 CLG Grant Update — April Cabello stated that Ann Swanson had given the report at the beginning of the meeting and confirmed the close out of the 2011 CLG Grant paperwork. Invoicing has been submitted and accepted by SHP� and hopes to have the reimbursement money #o the city by September 9� Commissioner Carpenter wondered if TAG would come give the commission a presenta#ion of the finished survey. Ms. Cabello replied that TAG is scheduled to give fhe presentation of the finished work of the 2011 CLG Grant at the next CHPC meeting on September 26`�. D. 2011 Signage Project Update — Brian Billingsley gave a progress update on the , signage project and handed out a task sheet to each commissioner. Mr_ Billingsley reviewed the task sheet and expiained it was split into three categories and reviewed each category noting which task was assignecf to each commissioner. The ssgnage project is an ongoing project and at the next CHPC Meet�ngAugust 2Z, 20J.1 Page 10 meeting, Mr. Billingsley will ask the commission mem�ers assigned a task for upciates of their assigned tasks. VIII. New Business. A. Nane. IX. Commission & Staff Reports. A. Gina Lujack wondered about the Sebree apricot tree. She st�red the tree needs attention from someone who knows what they are cfoing. Chairperson Randolph informed the cammissiorr that the tree had been planted by the Sebree family and is supposedfy 113 years old documented by the State of Idaho and is on a state list of important trees. Ms, Lujack suggested Justin Parker to readjust the weight and resurrect it. B. Elaine Carpenter inquired about the house wi#h the half-built fence on the corner of Bfaine and 13 Ms. Carpenter requested status from the city. April Cabello will follow up on the possible code violation and give a report ak the next meefing. C. Gina Lujack wondered about a seethrough tent in the front yard of a house on Blaine Street. Chairperson Randolph stated he would visit the site and call April Cabello with the address to follow up with a passible code violation. D. Jan Boles reminded the commission fhat on September 15'", the Idaho Heritage Trust Board will be in Caldwell visiting the Trein Depot ar�d The Hat. Mr. Boles encouraged the commission to make time to visi# with the board. X. Meeting adjourned at approximately 7:55 p,m. Respectfully submitted by April Cabello, MINUTES APPROVED AND SIGNED BE�OW BY CHAIRPERSON CHUCK RANDOLPH ON THE DATE N�TED BELOW. � �� � ��� 9��// Ch�persan Randolph Date � � � � f !O �� � ! ATTEST: Brian Billingsley, P& Z Director Date CHPC Meeting August 22, 2011 �� '�"'�—` Page 1 i