Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout11-24-2008 CHPC MINUTES _ � CALDWELL HISTORIC PRESERVATION COMMISSION MINUTES Meeting of November 24, 2008 — 6pm ,..r,..�_.�,�.,..... ___. A����v�r� � Caldwell Public Library — Idaho Room ,��� � f � I. Call to order — Co-Chair Chuck Randolph called the meeting to order at approximately 6:10 p.m. II. Roll Call — Members Present: Chairperson Lorene Oates, Co-Chair Chuck Randolph, Vice-Chair Elaine Carpenter, Commissioners: Jan Boles, Elaine Leppert, Gina Lujack, Eileen Davidson and City Council liaison Rob Hopper Members Absent: Co-Chair Steve Maughan, Commissioners: Anita Shore, Ron Blakley Staff Present: Brian Billingsley (Planning Director), April Cabello (Planning Technician) III. Approval of Agenda: Items added to the agenda by Staff and the Commission Members under section VIII Old Business: • Idaho Heritage Trust — The Hat - Jan • 2008-2009 CLG Grant — Elaine C. • Amendment to the nomination of "The Hat" — Chuck MOTION TO APPROVE: Commissioner Lujack; SECOND: Chairperson Oates, motion passed. IV. Approval of Minutes: MOTION to approve October 27, 2008 Minutes with the following corrections: page 3 under section VIII Actions Since Last Meeting, corrections to CA-126-08 the address 16907 Blaine Street to 1907 Blaine Street and correction under section IX Old Business (fl, correction of spelling the to thev. MOTION TO APPROVE: Vice-Chair Carpenter; SECOND: Chairperson Oates, motion passed. V. Certificate of Ap�ropriateness Interviews Case Number CA-127-08 — 701 Main Street — application submitted by Debbie Geyer for the City of Caldwell Friends of the Depot; requesting approval from the CHPC to build a storage shed for the Train Depot. April Cabello, City Staff, swore in the applicants. Debbie Geyer, Applicant's Representative, provided supporting testimony and submitted exhibit HP-1000. Ms. Geyer read into the record the narrative and provided a color picture of the site. Co-Chair Randolph asked Ms. Geyer who is the owner of the land. Ms. Geyer stated that Union Pacific owns the land and Union Pacific is very supportive of the beautification that is tak�ng place at the depot. Commissioner Lujack stated she was not aware the depot had a basement and asked what condition it is in. MS. ��j�el' �X�'i111i1e� i�'1E �JaS�il'i�i�i �i1Ci �JE�Ci :,leane Ol;t 18Si'y'�ai aCi scrr�e ligr�ting was pat il'S ari(1 iS US2C� riy the Friends of the Depot to store their hats and tee shirts. CHPC Minutes 11-24-08 1 Commissioner Lujack asked if a 10 x 10 shed is big enough for what they would like to store. Ms. Geyer replied the shed will be big enough to store the tables and chairs on large racks and the placement of the shed will allow easy access to unload for an event in the depot or in the plaza. Rob Hopper, City Council liaison, asked Ms. Geyer from the west site line, how much of the building will the shed infringe on. Gorden Reed, City of Caldwell Street Department, stated it will be 9 feet wide and 11 feet high. Mr. Hopper asked about the roofing. Mr. Reed stated they are trying to imitate the depot as much as possible. Mr. Hopper asked if the tree will be moved. Mr. Reed stated he did not think the tree would have to be moved. Ms. Geyer stated that Mr. Don Watts from SHPO explained to her the idea is not to completely duplicate the depot but should be a design and would not want to over kill what was originally there. Commissioner Boles asked if the Boy Scouts would still be needed to move the tables and chairs. Ms. Geyer stated the Streets department helps take out the tables and chairs and then the Boy Scouts helps with the set up. Commission Boles asked if the shed could be located 100 feet from the building. Ms. Geyer explained the shed would be in the parking lot if moved 100 feet from the building. Commissioner Davidson suggested putting the shed on an existing dumpster pad. Ms. Geyer stated all the dumpster pads are being used for dumpsters. Commissioner Boles and Commissioner Lujack stated their concern about compromising the clear view of the depot. Commissioner Lujack asked if there is any other location this shed could be placed. Mr. Reed and Ms. Geyer stated the reason for the (ocation of the shed is for the ease of access to the back door of the depot. Ms. Geyer and Commissioner Davidson explained the Right of Ways around the depot was an issue for the Fire Marshal to begin with and the shed can not be placed in the Right of Ways. The Commission continued discussion with the applicants regarding the location of the shed. Co-Chair Randolph asked if there would be a possibility of moving in a rail car for a storage shed. Ms. Geyer explained it is a large expense to get a rail car or a push car; they are also very hard to locate. Mr. Reed stated when completed this will not look Iike a storage shed and is a needed structure due to the hazard of bringing the table and chairs up the narrow stairs. He believes at some point someone is going to get hurt. CHPC Minutes 11-24-08 2 . < , . Ms. Geyer stated the floor is very low, has a sharp turn, and is very dangerous. Commissioner Lujack confirmed this shed is not a want but is a true need. Co-Chair Randolph stated his concern regarding T1-11 siding. Mr. Reed stated they are open to any suggestions regarding siding. Dave Williams, Friends of the Depot, stated there is a panel type of siding that is applied to a lot of homes that the CC& R's require rock frontage. The Commission continued discussion with the applicants regarding the location of the shed. Approval of Case Number CA-127-08 — MOTION: Vice-Chair Carpenter; SECOND: Commissioner Boles — The Commission voted to recommend Approval with the following conditions: • Shed is to be located inline with the heating/air conditioning unit along the west fence line of the depot • Siding to be historically specific • Review of conditions by a Commission Member with a quick sign off on the C of A Motion Passed. VI. Audience Participation: None VII. Actions Since Last Meeting: • Property Listing 1510 Blaine — Staff Member Cabello, gave background and update: Patricia Gooding — Coldwell Banker, will remove wording from the listing stating potential assisted living facility or group home and Co-Chair Randolph stated he spoke with the potential buyers agent regarding the homes eligibility of being on the National Register and that the home is not but it is contributing to a historical neighborhood. • Case Number: CA-125-08 — 406 S. 14` Ave. — Co-Chair Randolph gave background and update. Conditional C of A issued on 10-28-08 for placement of two signs. VIII. Old Business • Idaho Heritage Trust — The Hat — Commissioner Boles stated that Idaho Heritage Trust has awarded the Historic Preservation Commission $3,500.00 toward the final steps to restore "The Hat". The funds would be used towards the pointing of the bricks and correcting the drainage problem. Commissioner Boles said he felt the commission will make the match with the balance left on the account of $2,130.00 and in the minutes the City of Caldwell pledged $2,000.00 for match and has a verbal commitment for pro bono removal of the two concrete benches. • Amendment to the nomination of "The Hat" — Co-Chair Randolph gave an update on the information that Commissioner Boles found for Madeline Buckendorf to use for the amendment and the cost to amend and resubmit the nomination would cost about $500.00. Co-Chair Randolph suggested we use the previous grant money that was not used from the Idaho Heritage Trust but the City Treasurer needs to locate th� money that is left from the grant. Co-Chair Randolph asked Brian to find out from the Mayor and or the City Treasurer about the money that is some where from the Idaho Heritage Trust or per Vice- Chair Carpenter stated the Mayor has contingent money set aside for the commission. Co-Chair Randolph stated he has one more option for funds as a last resort if all other options fail. MOTION: Commissioner Boles, SECOND: Chairperson Oates CHPC Minutes 11-24-08 3 i • r ♦ . • 2008-2009 CLG Grant — V ice-Chair Carpenter gave a detailed report of a phone conversation she had with Tricia at SHPO regarding the Reconnaissance Survey of Dave Dorsey Homes and an email that Ann at SHPO sent with the RFP for the Reconnaissance Survey of Dave Dorsey Homes but Ann had a few questions that needed a response from the Commission no later than December 8`�'. Ann from SHPO needs a list of 50 Dave Dorsey Homes, the dates the Dorsey Construction Company was active and a list of consultants. The commission had a discussion and Commissioner Leppert will supply the dates that the Dorsey Construction Company was active and give to Staff Member Cabello before December 8`�'. Vice- Chair Carpenter will talk with Commissioner Blakley to obtain the list of Dave Dorsey Homes and give to Staff Member Cabello before December 8th. The commission members choose six consultants to whom the RFP for the Reconnaissance Survey of Dave Dorsey Homes and two Walking Tour Brochures will be mailed to. Staff Member Cabello will contact Ann at SHPO. IX. New Business • Review of Ordinances — Staff Member Billingsley (Planning Director) reviewed Bill No. 28, Ord. 2748 Fencing in the Steunenberg Residential Historic District and Bill No. 4, Ord. 2724 Caldwell Historic Preservation Commission. • Comprehensive Plan Update — Staff Member Billingsley explained to the commission he is updating the Comprehensive Plan and would like the commissions input and knowledge with the Special Sites (Historic Areas) portion. Staff Member Billingsley asked the commission to help fill in the blanks and remove any items that do not belong in the sections: EXHIBIT 9: CALDWELL HISTORIC SITES IN NATION REGISTER OF HISTOR PLACES, EXHIBIT 10: AREAS OF HISTORIC SIGNIFICANCE. Some items were deleted and some items were added or updated. X. For the Good of the Commission : None XI. Adjournment — Co-Chair Randolph adjourned the meeting at 9pm. MINUTES APPROVED AND SIGNED BY CO-CHAIR CHUCK RANDOLPH ON THE DATE NOTED BELOW: ! ' _ ',� r ��- a� .-.. � G / � �'` / � � � / I/ / � Chuck Randolph Co-Chair Date CHPC Minutes 11-24-08 4