HomeMy WebLinkAbout4-21-2008 CHPC MINUTES J
Mi nutes APP�� ) 7 � /\ E� / D
CG.�CZLs�1L1d.._
Historic Preservation Commission
Monday, Apri121, 2008- 6:00 P.M.
Caldwell Public Library- Idaho Room
1010 Dearborn, Caldwell, Idaho
I. Call to order By acting chair Steve Maughan
II. Roll Call Present: Ron Blakley, Elaine Carpenter, Elaine Leppert, Gina
Lujack, Steve Maughan, Anita Shore, and City Staff Brian Billingsley.
Absent: Lorene Oates Chairman, Jan Boles, Eileen Davidson, Chuck Randolph,
and City Staff April Cabello and City Council Liaison, Rob Hopper
III. Approval of Agenda Added under New Business Boone Memorial Church
IV. Approval of Minutes
February 25, 2008 — revised O.K. to sign
March 24, 2008 - Moved to approve as written, Elaine L. Second - Elaine C.
Motion passed.
V. Certificate of Appropriateness Interviews
a 1609 Blaine Street — new construction — vacant lot — duplex
Chris Laraway was here as a representative for Marty Camberlango, who is one of the
owners of this property. The other owner, Sam Banda, was also here. Both men were
sworn. Steve M reported that this is the second time this proposal has been brought
before us. Elaine C told him that in our district the houses all have a much different roof '
line than this proposal. The other concern is the proposed rock trim on the front of the
building. Chris L said this would be a single level building. He felt that he could work to
achieve the roof design that would be more like the roofs of other houses in the District.
There was some discussion of what could be accepted. During this discussion, Chris L
was doing some drawing on his plans. What he drew was more acceptable than the
submitted plans. Sam B mentioned that he would like to proceed as soon as possible.
Elaine C moved that we have Chris L revise his plans and that Sam B and Marty C
submit a letter stating their consent to the changes and then take them to Brian B. Steve
M could then go to City Hall review the plans and sign the Certificate of
Appropriateness. Gina L seconded the motion. Motion passed. The subject of other
items, such as paint, siding, fencing, landscape and shingles came up. Any living trees
to be removed must be discussed with the City Forester.
1
i
s
I. Audience Participation
1401 Blaine Street — new construction — vacant lot — single family home
Mr Fenwick was sworn. He has owned this property for about 30 years. It was sold
once, but he had to repossess it. He said he is impressed with what we are trying to do in
the District. He said he felt what we are trying to achieve makes sense. He is trying to
figure out what he can do with this property to make it more marketable. He has three
lots. Steve M explained that our main concern was appearance from the curb. Mr.
Fenwick showed the plans he has selected for the house, which it appears would be a nice
addition to the district and it would be nice not to have vacant lots.
II. Actions Since Last Meeting
• Letters to the Realtors were mailed on 3/31/08. Please see the spread sheet
in your docket for dates and which realtors received letters. Brian B has
updated the letters to realtors and they have been mailed.
• 1702 Cleveland Blvd — Certificate of Appropriateness was issued and the
applicant has pulled the building permits for the work to be done.
Building permit has been issued and work has started.
• 1204 Dearborn Street — code enforcement mailed letter to the home owner
regarding window alterations that was done with no certificate of
appropriateness. The owners, who are not English speaking, have been
into City Hall to discuss this. They are aware that they must have a
Certificate of Appropriateness and Building Permit. They have removed
some windows and put in frames. It does not appear to be done
professionally. Brian B suggested that we might want them to bring an
interpreter when they come for the Certificate of Appropriateness.
III. Old Business
• Steunenberg District Rezone — Brian B reported that this as approved at
the last City Council meeting. April 7, 2008. There were no objections.
Good job Brian.
• The Hat — In the absence of Jan B., Steve M reported that the College is
moving forward on signs for the Hat. It will have the appearance it had in
1935. Jan B is working on the concrete pad issue.
• CLG Grant for 2008 —$3,200.00 — Nomination of the "Hat" by Madeline
Buckendorf for $1,000.00 and corrections and reprint of the Down Town
Walking tour pamphlet and Historical Walking Tour pamphlet for
$2,200.00. Possible extra CLG Grant money of $2,000.00 if the
commission would like to use it for another nomination or training. Elaine
C reported that Lorene O was considering attending a National Historic
meeting, if we have ihe iundir�g. The �ast of this tcur woul� ��at about
2
$500.00 from the Walking Tour Brochure. There was discussion
regarding the Downtown Walking Tour and the District Tour. This has
been tabled until next month.
• Auxiliary Committee Reports
1) Streetscape Committee — Due to the fact that Eileen was
absent, there was nothing reported.
2) School District Committee Representative No report.
3) Downtown Committee — Steve has not attend a recent meeting.
He should have something to report at our next meeting.
• "Gazebo" discussion/update - Steve M reported that the City Council
has given their approval of the Gazebo and work has started to move
forward again. Brian B said there is a new ordinance update in the works.
• Metal Roof in the Indian Creek Corridor — Brian - Also, part of the
ordinance update. Any structure in the Indian Creek Corridor will have to
go through Design Review. Planning and Zoning does not want to ban
metal roofs. However, each roof will have to go through the Review
process.
IV. New Business
• Boone Memorial Church - Members of the church have met with Elaine C
and Steve M to voice their concerns about future improvements to their
property and parking lots. Part of the problem is their congregation is
outgrowing the present site. Elaine C said there is a two story house
located on 13� and Dearborn, which is currently broken into about five
units. The church would like to purchase this house and demolish it and
use the site for a parking lot.
i
They would like some assurance that if they proceeded they would be able !,
to later enlarge the Church, purchase houses near the church to tear down '
and enlarge the church area. Elaine C and Steve M suggested a couple of
Church members meet with a couple of Caldwell Historical Preservation
Commission members, somewhere offsite to discuss this matter. Ron B
suggested The Church might want to work with the members they have
and not try to enlarge the congregation. Elaine C and Steve M felt it was to
solve other problems, such as their kitchen, which is in the basement,
along with the growing congregation that they were thinking of. Elaine
asked Brian B to sit in on any future meetings.
X. For the Good of the Commission - Brian B brought in the Walking Tour
Brcchure for po�..it Caldw�e H� wo�:ld ?ik� ±� numbPr ±he map ar.d thP
3
,
1
�
sites. Elaine C suggested if we have left over CLG monies we should help with
the Downtown Brochure.
XI. Adjournment. Elaine C. motion. Anita S second. Motion passed.
Respectfully submitted by Anita Shore, Secretary.
Next meeting will be on May 27, 2008
ATTESTED TO: _
Signed:
Co-Chair
Date: J Z � ��
�
I
4