Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout10-22-2007 CHPC MINUTES � y , � CALDWELL HISTORIC PRESERVATION COMMISSION OCTOBER 22, 2007 CALDWELL PUBLIC LIBRARY - Idaho Room APP�RO�/E[� C �.2_�_��� I. Call to Order At 6:00 P.M. by Chair Elaine Carpenter. II. Roll Call Present: Elaine Carpenter Chairman, Jan Boles, Eileen Davidson, Elaine Leppert, Gina Lujack, Steve Maughan, Anita Shore, and City Staff Brian Billingsley. , Absent: Ron Blakley, Lorene Oates, Chuck Randolph, and City Council Liaison, -- - Rick Wells and City Staff David Richey. , ,., :, . Guest: No guests. III Approval of Agenda: Added under New Business School Bond - Existing Historic School District Buildings. Motion to approve as amended Gina L. Second Steve M. Motion passed. IV. Approval of Minutes September 24, 2007 one spelling correction. U nder Old Business paragraph 6(sincer should be since). Motion to approve as corrected, Steve M. Second Eileen D. Motion passed. V. Certificate of Appropriateness Interview CA-103-07, Carl Christensen, 1700 Fillmore, re-side and CA-105-07 Carl Christensen, 215 S 18th St., re-side. Carl Christensen, after being sworn, testified that he owns both of these residences. He reported that the house at 1700 Fillmore has some steel siding, some clad siding and some areas with no siding. He brought a sample of the proposed siding. The house located at 215 lh S 18th, already has the proposed siding installed. Brian B. passed around color photos of both of these houses. Neither of these houses is considered contributing. Gina L ask if he would have trouble disposing of the existing siding. Carl said that BFI has told him he can take it to the landfill. Elaine C ask him if there would be any changes in the windows or doors. The answer is no. Steve M moved to approve both applications. Jan B seconded. Anita S stated that Carl was her accountant, but that would not affect her vote. Motion passed. CA-104-07, Marty Camberlango, 1609 Blaine St., An application to construct a new duplex at 1609 Blaine St. Continued to next month. Mr. Camberlango is working with Brian B to achieve a plan that might be more acceptable to the Commission. Brian had a few questions for the Commission. There followed a discussion regarding Set Backs and garages facing Blaine Street. Elaine C recommended the re-examine the roof pitch. Brian B will take our suggestions back to Mr. Camberlango. VI. Audience Participation Elaine L introduced her niece, Diane. VII. Actions Since Last Meeting - Jan B reported that he, Chuck R and Brian B met with six or seven men from the Idaho Transportation Department (ITD) for a walking tour to express our concerns regarding the curbs on Blaine and Cleveland. ITD has a"Punch List" with all of the problems ITD has already noticed, although our three did not see this list. ITD listened to all the comments that Jan B. Chuck R. and Brian B. Jan had the feeling that we are just being placated and that ITD will not take any kind of action. Steve M. questioned the elevation problem at 16th and Cleveland. 16th is about a foot higher than Cleveland. ITD said it would not have mattered if there had been work shops held for Blaine/Cleveland Street residents. They pretty much do as they please. Brian B said he felt that we should appoint a member to act as a liaison to any future project meetings. VIII. Old Business l. Code Enforcement - Elaine C said maybe we should just roll this off the agenda, unless there is a specific issue. It was the consensus of opinion that the Enforcement Code needs help, - but that this was not our job. Brian B will contact Rick W regarding this. 2. The Hat (Jan B) Jan B has received a second bid on the structural repair of the Hat. This bid in the amount of $11,500.00 is higher than our other bid, which was in the amount of $9125.00. The contractor wants a$5000 down payment and the balance at completion. There is $2000.00 in the City funds earmarked for this project The $5000.00 from the Civic goup is , not on file. Brian B. will contact Chuck R. regarding this. The plan now is to square the roof � and replace any needed parts. After it is re-roofed, they will add the fascia. Jan B. will request an invoice for the down payment. Jan has, also, found a very nice photo (1912 era) of The Hat. Steve M. said the College might be talked into assisting with the signs. Elaine C. polled the members by e-mail regarding the CLG proposal to explore nominating the Hat for the National Register. We are now waiting for status on the grant. 3. Historic District Signs Elaine C. said we really need to get these signs installed. Jim Shore has volunteered to help. Also, we need to be checking for sites for additional signs. The Presidents house at the College and the corner where Mildred Graves lives were suggested. Elaine L said she thought we had one at the president's house. We don't have the perimeter of the District very well marked. Elaine C. suggested the PG Batt house. Elaine C. will talk to Chuck R. to get a date to install. 4. Statement to use for Commission in Advisory Roll: (Brian B/Mark Hilty) Brian B. is still waiting for a response from Mark Hilty, the City Attorney. 5. Draft letter to prospective home buyers (Gina L) Gina L is waiting for the new letterhead. Elaine C ask her to get a copy of her letter to each of us for review. Gina ask to have the letterhead moved from 8 to here. Anita S. passed around copies of the various letterheads she had designed. Elaine C is going to ask her son about more historically correct fonts. Gina L. will e-mail her letter to each of us. Brian B. thought the City might pickup the cost of doing the letterhead. Jan B. will work on the graphic of the Hayman house, so it can be done very faintly in the center of the page. . 6. Rezone of District to R-1 (Brian B/Rick W) Brian B has met with the Mayor. He felt we have the Mayor's support in a rezone. We will need to have at least one workshop and include anyone in the District. He would like a couple of our members to attend the workshop. 7. Reforestation Project - Brian B. Brian B. reported that the Mayor has agreed to replant the trees in the District on the right of way, which were damaged in the paving project. The City is looking for a new Forester and the Commission feels this would be a good project for him/her. Elaine C. would volunteer to head up the Tree Project, once she steps down from chairing the meetings. Steve M volunteered to help. We are talking hundreds of trees. 8. House Numbering on curbs - Chuck R. Rolled to next meeting. 9. Streetscape Committee - Eileen D. Eileen D. reported that the Streetscape Committee on Downtown Project has chosen several designs for the streets in the Downtown area. She passed around a pamphlet showing the different designs which has been given to the Mayor and Brian B. thought they would go to the Council November5. There was one design Eileen D was trying to discourage. The only street that has had a decision is Kimball. The others are open to any of the five designs. 10 Elaine C mentioned to Brian B. that the house at 1615 Fillmore has been resided. There was no C of A. Brian said that he would have a building inspector go out to take a look at it. IX. NEW BUSINESS 1 School Bond - Existing Historic School District Buildings. Set for Thursday October 25, 2007 In the event the bond passes the School Administration offices will move out of the Carnige Library, Van Bureen will be rehabbed and Wilson will probably be coming down. Van Buren and the Library are our main concerns. There is no way we can protect these buildings. -Brian B. said he knows Roger Quarles very well. He will speak to him to let him know of our concerns. Washington is not in the District. Brian said he thought the area of Washington School is zoned R-1. X For the Good of the Commission Jan B. mentioned that Ann Swanson has sent out a copy of "More Lessons Learned" to each of the Commissioners. Anita S. volunteered to print a copy. Eileen D has already printed a copy. Brian will mail them out. Channel4 Documentary Broadcast Date Unsure. The premier is set for November 7 at the Egyptian Theater in Boise. XI. Adjournment Motion to adjourn, Steve M. Seconded Jan B. Motion passed. Respectfully submitted by Anita Shore, Secretary