HomeMy WebLinkAbout8-28-2007 CHPC MINUTES ` �
CALDWELL HISTORIC PRESERVATION COMMISSION
Monday, August 28. 2007 - 6 P.M.
CALDWELL PUBLIC LIBRARY - Idaho Room
-==. ,
AP��G�4'��:� '
C��`....��.� F
I... Call to Order 6 P.M. by Chair Elaine C.
II. Roll Call Present: Elaine Carpenter Chairman, Jan Boles, Eileen Davidson,
Elaine Leppert, Gina Lujack, Lorene Oates, Chuck Randolph, Anita Shore, and City Staff Brian
Billingsley & David Richey and City Council Liaison, Rick Wells.
Absent: Ron Blakley and Steve Maughan. ,
III Approval of Agenda One addition under Old Business #2 Jan B wanted to add '
an extra item, Building Permit far the Hat, under Paragraph 2 under Old Business. Motion to
approve as amended Anita S. Second Chuck R. Motion passed.
IV. Approval of Minutes July 23, 2007 Correction Page one "Rice house" to be
changed to read "�ZicelCravvley house" and page two Jon Roeder should be John Roeder. Motion -
to approve as corrected, Jan B. Second Gina L. Motion passed
V. Certificate of Appropriateness Interview Roeder Addition - CA-101-07
John Roeder, after being sworn, explained his application. He explained that the project
would need to be done in two phases. The front of the house would be phase one and the rear
would be phase two. He wanted to know if this would mean he needed two Certificates of
Appropriateness. It was explained that it could be approved on one certificate, but there was a
year deadline on the certificate. Phase one would be the addition of a front porch and a new
exterior door. The porch, which would be four foot, would extend slightly into the set back area.
However, Brian said the design as presented appears to fall within the requirements of the City
Code. This house is considered a"contributing structure", if it is altered, does this change it's
designation? Chuck R questioned why this was considered a contributing structure, since the
siding has been changed and other changes have been made. He felt the proposed entry change
would be an improvement on the appearance of the house. The roof change on Phase two was
discussed. Chuck R moved to approve the application as presented with the understanding that if
the second phase was not started within a year, Mr. Roeder would need to come back for an
extension on his application. Gina L seconded. Motion passed.
VI. Audience Participation None.
VIL Actions Since Last Meeting Chuck R reported he has approved the change of the
exteriar door in a house in the 1800 block of Everett St. The old door was warped. The new
door is a Craftsman style door. Rick W ask about a house near 16th and Blaine that has had a
roof change. Did we approve this? It is the "Whittenberger house" Chuck said he was sure it
had been approved.
'uiau� o� ��o .�a��al � �a� pu� ��u�siQ au� ut s�ui�sti �ue .zo� S-�y�
au� q���m uau� iii�n �ui� •p�au.za��ai .zno uo �nd o� � aui�Ig o� �i �a� pue stu� au�a� jitm �ui�
•suoi�sanb �ue an�u �au� �t �uauz�.z�daQ �uipitng au� ����uo� o� �uauiuzo� e pp� an� �eq� pa�sa��ns
ueug •poo� �.zan spunos �I •�no pau�no.z s�u aus ��um3o �do� e p�a.� aus •ai�s �o� ��.zado.zd.ztau�
�ui�stj azann oune s.zaumo pu� s�a�o�q a.zn�n� o� puas pjno� am u�tunn .za��at e�e.�p o� u�uouz �s�i
pa.zaa�unjon � eut� -��u�siQ �.zaquauna�s ut s.za�nq auzou ani��adso�d o� .za��a-� �
•p��nn.zo�
stu � �.z.ie � jji n� � x�i � •passe d uoi�o y� •papuo�a s -� eui� • j � o � pauoza .z ��u�siQ au � �a�
o� �� o� p.z�nn.zo� o� ann panouz � x�nu� •��u�siQ au� o� u�auz pjnonn j� ��unn uo uoissn�sip �
sem a.zauZ •it�uno� ��t� ar�� �no.zq� o� o� paau pjnonn ann pres ueug •jg o� ��i.z�stp ��aquauna�s
au� auoza.z o� ��t� au� �uixse .zapisuo� ann pa�sa��ns ueug •��j1H xrey� `�auzo��d ��t� au�
�o spueu au� ui si stuZ •uoi�i�ad �zno� s,a�i� .zy� pue ��i� au� o� .za��ai au� �o satdo� puno.z� passed
ueug •uotsi�ap s,��t� au� pai�add� seu a�t� .zy� - a�epdn a�ueutpzo�I�addd a�t� g
•dous �.zonn �xau au� o� a�e� o� ueug .zo� suoi�sa��ns pue sa�n��id .zau�a�o� �nd o� paau arn •stu�
�uip.z��a.z ��i� au� uto.z� auoauzos u�inn �auz s�u g u�ug - a�u�uip.zo �o� o�ut a�ua3 S
•siu� �uip.ze�a.z aitau� u�im �aaui jiim au ptes m x�i� �,apo�
��u� a�u�u� o� suot�sa��ns axeuz o� sn zo� a��udo.zdde �i sI •s.za���o �uauia�.zo�ug apo� au� o�
puas o� suoi�sa��ns an�u o� axit pinonn aurejg •�uauza��o�ug apo� u�inn dlau o� .�a�g�o j�uot�ippe
u� a.ziu o� �uto� azann �au� ��nou� au pies g uei.zg �a�ai �uauza�.�o�ug apoa �
•.zau o� puas
o� sa.zn��id seu g ue f pu� ani�e.rr�u e seu -� aurejg •a�is qan� .zno o� auop �u�m ann sa�ueu� �ue
u�im a���o siu ui ollaq�a Iud� ����uo� o� paau ann pt�s g ueug a�iS Qat1c� £
•auxi� auo �e sduz�I �q`dia a.zann azau� ��nou� aus pres auS �stu� �o a��nn� auo�u� si •�u�ql�
.__,, , tro u�mu� ueua�qsa.�d Ieu�uo au� �o �.z�n��ues aq� ui �unq p�e� pres aus u�tunn durej
�iq � u�im �pe1 � q�tm p�u au �ut�aauz E ssn�sip o� pa�uenn au `osj� •�eH au� .zieda.z o� �tuuad
�uipiing au� ssn�sip o� �ui�aauz au� .za�� aneQ pue uer.zg u�inn �aauz o� xse aH •Ii�� ueq.znra�ui
a� uo aj�i�z�e a�iu � seu u�iunn `auize�euz ��uno� uo�iue� �Z au��o ansst �sa�ei au��o �ido� e p�u
osi� aH •�eH au� �o �epsmq,I, �s�j ua�� a.�n��1d puno.z� passed g uer -��H au,I, Z
•y� �na�s �Iqissod P� g �f `2I �I�nq� Pue uz� uaann�aq �ut�aauz
e a�u�� o� ueQ ��e�uo� ijin� ueug •auzop pa�e�u.zn� au� pue q�n� au� pue xi�nnapis au� uaan�aq
a�u�u� au� �noq� �p.zeu.�ang u�Q ��e�uo� ann pa�sa��ns ��nu� •pr�au aq �ou pino� s�uaunuo�
�ijqnd os `s�uu�au �iiqnd �o ���i au� �noqe pa�uaLUUZO� x�t� •Q,�I u�im si uoist�ap izu� au�
`.zanamoq `.s�uaunuo� .zo suoi�sa��ns a�uz ue� �i�i� au,I, •��afo�d Q,I,I ue si siu,I, •siu� ��ar.zo� o�
spun� ou a.z� a�au� s�es a���s auZ •passn�sip s�nn ss�.z� aq� o� qzn� au� uzo.z� a�ueu� uoi�enaia auZ
•panouza� uaunn `x��.0 a��o sa�atd au� dn x�td o� x�n.z� ��ta � a�ue.�.z� o� �u� st aH •uot�en��xa
�uunp a.zouz pug o� adoq �auZ •pa.z�addesip seu uoi��as ,pZ �iq �•autj stu� �o a�aid ,�
e seu aH •auij za�znn pio au��o uot��as � pa�e�oi `osi� `an�r� �auZ •a�aid ,pZ .zaq�oue anes o� adou
pu� x�e� �o a�aid ,g u� panes an�u �aqZ •pa�n��o sx��.z� au� �o uoi��a.zip au� ut �ijds au� azaunn
aas ue� no� '�S u�OZ uo pa���oj uaaq an�u sx��.z� auZ '�ze�s itinn �I�udse au��o jenouiaz au� �eu�
sa��p onn� uan� uaaq se�j aH •a�ep �uin�d au� o� �oud pueianaj� ustu� o� �ut�e.z are �au1, •qzn�
-az au� �utop nnaa� aq� o� ua�ods seu au �eu� pa�.zociaz m x�� - puejanai��aut�ig ' i
ssauisng pi0 'IIIA
1 , .
•passed uoi�oy� •papuo�as � x�nu� •u.znofpe o� panouz Q uaallg -�uauivanofp� •IX
I
•ssaua��udo.zdd��o a���gt�.za� ��a� o� paau Iii�s pinon� �au�
�uipjinq au� �o .zoua�xa au� a�u�u� o� �u�nn o� azann �iau� �I •��u�siQ a�aiio� au� ut osie sEn� �eu�
���s1Q ��aquauna�s au� ut s�m �eu� �uipitnq auo �iuo senn a.�au� pt�s ueug •��u�siQ a�aiio� au�
uo uoisi�ap e s�n� a.zau� p.z�au p�u aus pres Z�ut� uoissnuuioa aq� 3o poo� aq� .�03 X
•I�ni�sa3 xaaz� ueipui si u�iunn
.zaquia�daS �� u�S I au� �iq uado aq �,uonn xaa.z� auZ •a.zo�S u�ue� u�no� ouepi .zauz�o� au� �o �a.re
�oj �uix.zed au� ui puno� uot��puno� � s�m a.zau�, •pa�sixa maux auo ou �eu� ii�� � Pue s�uauzas�q
aa.z�� puno� anzu �fau� ��afo.zd �aa�� u�ipul au� �uunp �eu� pa�zoda.z rn x�i� i
SS�I�IISflg AA�I�i 'XI
�stu� op o� �ut�uem uzo.z� s�u��tldde �sou� a�e�no�sip �Iqeqo.�d
pjnonn pu� anisuadxa �.zan a.z� asau,l, •uza�s�fs .zaixuuds a.z� e sa.zmba.z apo� izuot��u�a�ui
au ��eu ��n o pa�uto d g u�u g•a��d s pu � azi s.ztau �`s�o i�ui�.z� d�utp.ze�a .z apo ���i � e senn
a.zaq� pres � x�nu� •a�u�utp�p �uiuoZ IIa�Pi�� au� P� aP�� P��3 �u�PI au� `apo� �utptTng
i�uoi��u�a�ui au� o�ut pa��au� seu Q uaajtg -�s��x�a.zg a8 pag uo uoi�euuo�uI T i
•�u��iidde ani��adsozd
� u�im uoissn�stp �ue o� .�oud �auzi�j�sip e pea� pue a.zeda�d ann pa�sa��ns senn �I •uotuido Ie�aj
e ure�qo o� ��j1H xxey� o� x�ads jjtnn g ueug •��s ann ��unn jn�a.z�� aq o� paau �snf ann `�utu� peq
��,usem �t pres ueug •stu� op o� anui�uo� o� �u�m pu� aa��iuzuio� �osinp� u� aze arn •�ue�tjdd�
a.zn�n� ssaua��udozddd �o a����i�za� � u�im uoissn�sip .zno u�inn u�uoux �s�i uxoz� uza�uo� s,g uo�
�-- ° �uip.re�a.z st siq,I, - jio.z��:zosinp� uo uoi��� uoissiuiuzo� a.zo�aq �uauza�e;s uo uotssn�siQ- � Oi
-. . . ,., . •passed uoi�oy� •pa�uo�as
S e�tu� •dn���q e s� jieg ueq�nza�ui au� a�e� ann panouz � x�nu� - passed uoi�o� •papuo�as
s��iud '�-�� au� .zo� xx�d si�zn� asodznd ann panouz -� aut�jg •uo�ue� au� o�ui x�onn o� uiooz
aq ��tuz azau� x.zed si�n� u�im •xz�d st�.zn� uo u�xeasa.� auzos auop peu aus pies Q uaai.T� '0£
.�aquza�das �q ut aq o� spaau Iesodo�d .znp •slie� ueq.zn.za�uI a�� �o suot���oj au� �ejdsip o� deu.i �
pa�sa��ns rn x�i� •a�is �uo�s1H I�uoi�eN �.z�a s��an� pa�sa��ns ���nu� •�a�s�a� ar�� uo
�,ua.zaen pue a.zam ��u� sasnou �utp.re�a.z uoissn�stp � s�n�z a.za�Z �.r�a� �xau �duieN ut �ui�aauz aq
Ii?� dno�� jtezZ uo�azp au� pres ��nu� •a�is qan� ar�� x�au� o� �uann - Z aurejg •�,z�s�a� au� uo
si ��qm nnou� o� paau arn •�ua�i.z� au� �aauz pinonn u�tum sasnou �o sa.zn��td azann a.zau� pres u� f
•su�is ani�a.zdza�uI it��,i, uo�azp au� o� az��ssey� pzz� e pa�sa��ns ueug •Iliu au� uo dn auzoH
snnoija,� ppp au� pa�sa��ns uer •a��uiuzou o� sazn��ru�s �au�o .zo� �se � aureig •�.z�s�a� �uo�siH
j�uoi�eN au� uo �uiplmq sir�� aas o� axtj pinonn am •�uipimg „uot�e�uzl .zapttrn„ au� �o sa.zn��id
punoze passed g ue f•uot���s do�s �iaijo� jeu�r.io au� uzo.z� azn��n.us au� o� sa�ueu� au� �o
asne�aq `�tj�nb pinon� �t �eu� a.zns �,us�nn a���o OdHS auZ •�,z�s�a.z au� .zo� ��H au� �ui�euiuzou
�noqe paxle� �jsnoina.zd p�u uotsstuzuzo� auZ •jrezs au� �uoie �.zo�siu ie.znz au� uo x�onn sn aas
o� a�ti pinonn a�e�s au� pauoi�uauz � auteig .rea�i �utuzo�dn �o� ��afo.zd �Z� uo uotst�aQ 6
•�i��a.ztp �e.z� aj�Q �ut����uo� are �au,I, •a.zoda� it�.z,I, uo�azp au� uo uoi��uuo�ui a.zouz
pa�u�nn a���s au� �eu� pa�zoda.z � auiei� - 0£/6 a��p �ui�oda.z ��afo.zd �-�� uo a�epdn g
� .