HomeMy WebLinkAbout10-9-1995 CHPC MINUTES Historic Preservation Commission
. ,
621 CLEVELAND BLVD.
CALDWELL, IDAHO 83605
� TEL: (208) 455-3021
FAX 455-3003
Caldwell Depot Facing Seventh Ave. (1906)
MEMORANDUM
TO: Historic Preservation Commission
FROM: Planning and Zoning Department
SUBJECT: FY95 Grant - Final Report
DATE: October 9, 1995
The City of Caldwell Historic Preservation Commission and the Caldwell City Council
submitted a grant proposal to the Idaho State Historical Society in September 1994
seeking a Certified Local Government grant to fund two projects:
(a) Nomination to the National Historic Register of the Caldwell UPRR Depot; and
(b) Sponsorship of a Community Workshop on the maintenance and restoration of
older, historic residences.
It is important to note that while a grant is provided, the City provides matching funds in
the form of in-kind contributions such as clerical support, Commission volunteers, and
other necessary administrative assistance.
The City were notified of the successful acquisition of the grant in the amount of
$2,850.00 and proceeded to recruit consultants for both components. The State ,
Historic office supplied a list of historic consultants for the Nomination and from that list, ��
Madeline Buckendorf, a historic consultant, and local resident was selected. On the
recommendation of the State Historic office, Fred Walters of Oregon was approached
to conduct the community workshop and subsequently was contracted.
The Nomination to the Depot was accomplished and a copy of the final report is
attached. The consultant was commended by the Historic office for the quality of the
nomination. The UPRR, who own the building, and lease it to the City, notified the City
and the State Historic Office that they would oppose the nomination. However, such a
recommendation does not deter from the eligibility of the building for nomination. Since
1
the study, Ms. Buckendorf has given several presentations to civic groups on the history
of the Depot.
The Community Workshop was presented by Fred Walters, an architectural
conservator from Oregon. The workshop was hosted at the Public Library on April 29,
1995, and included a tour of a local historic residential neighborhood, which gave Mr.
Walters an opportunity to demonstrate practical maintenance applications and potential
problems. The workshop was comparatively well attended, according to the State
Historic Preservation O�ce, and the information literature provided will continue to be
available to the public. Staff have been contacted by other communities interested in
sponsoring similar workshops.
Prepared by
` �
Liz eary, Adm nistrative Secretary
Planning and Zoning Department
2
NPS Fo�m 10�800 OMB Ne. l070-Op7tl
(Rsv. IOiB01
United States Department of the Interior
National Park Service
National Register of Historic Places
Registration Form
This form is for use in nominetinQ or requs�tinQ detsrminations tor individual propertiea and districts. See instructions in How to Complers ths Nsriona!
Rsgistsi o/ Historic Plscss Rspiavation Form INetionel Reyistsr Bulletin 18A►. Complete eech itsm by merkinq "x" in the appropriate box or by entering the
information rsquestsd. If eny itsm doe� not epply to ths property beinp documentsd, e�ter 'N/A" for 'not applicable." For functiona; architectural
classification, materials, end ersas of aiqnificancs, entsr only catsqoris� end eubcategories from the inetructions. Place edditional entries and narrotive iteme
on continuatian aheeu (NPS Form 10-900e1. Use e typewritsr, word processor, or computsr, to complste ell items.
��:::�::���:�;:.:5:::.;:.;..::.:.;••::�•:�:.,:.:.:;;.;r.<.;. �.�:>.::::.::�::::'::%�;;::::z:;:::::'::;::'::::'r'';:::;;s:::::3i:�:::;i::::::::::i:;::�::::::::�::::::::`::::::::i:::�:::;;`:;:;i:::::f:::��?ii�:::;':::`;:i;.;:::'':�:;::;3;::>::i::c:?;::::2t::>i::�;:'�:�i£::;:<�:�:�::i;:::::::::';::::::::;:::;:;�;::i?::::::;;::::::::;::::::::z:::::::::;;;::;:;:i::i:::
'�. ��• n� �d�� ... ... . . ...
...............::......
histo�ic name Calduelt Ore9on Short line Railroad Deoot
other names/site nunber Caldwelt Union Pacific Deaot
2���:::Ci�ce�+o��:`:::':::::::'<;::;.:::�:><':::»::::»'::�?<::`:::<:`:>::>`:?:?<:<:'»::::`:�:'�::`:�:�:::::»::><>:�::�:<>::`:::;:<::::>:>;«:«:::>::�<>`::?::#:::'::;:':<::>:?::`<:>::>::::::::';`>;�`>:::':;:>::>::>�::::::::>:::::::<:::::::::>:::<;;:!'<:::>:::<:>::::>::»»::>:<�:»::::::>::':':;>:':>::;.::.?:`>:::>:�:::':::::>::>::`:�`';::::::::::;::<;::;:<:::::>::>::;>:::>` �
street & nunber 701 S. 7th Street X not for oublication
citv or town Caldwelt X vicinitv
state Idaho code ID countv Canvon code zia code 83605
: �.>;; .: .::..:. .. ...::>��:.>;:.>::.::..;....;::.;;�.;:::::;::>• ... . :.... � .. ::: .. . .. ... .::::::�:::.:::;::r::;::i:.;;:.;;:.;:.:.:;.;:.:. .. ._<.i•:�;:<::;::;::i>:: _ . ...;:.;::::.>::>;:.>;;
�:<�:�e€e�eElBCeI?Aq�t�y':£+�rtif�at�0� ... . _ . .............. ""
As the designated authority under the National Nistoric Preservation Act of 1986, as amended, I hereby certify that
this X nomination _request for determination of eligibitity meets the docunentation standards for registering
properties in the National Register of Historic Places and meets the procedural and professional requirements set
forth in 36 CfR Part 60. In my opinion, the property X meets does not meet the National Register criteria.
I recomnend that this property be considered significant _nationally _statewide _locally. (_ See continuation
sheet for additional cam�ents.)
Signature of certifying official Date
John R. Hill State Historic Preservation Officer
State or Federal agency and bureau
In my opinion, the property _meets _does not meet the National Register criteria. C_ See continuation sheet
for additional comnents.) ,
Signature of commenting or other official Date
State or Federal agency and bureau
:' '<i: ":ii.:.:1t>iii»:C•:i': +ii :•i'.i:<:i"�.i:�iiii";_i:[ii/ ".:!n; ;.:�.:: .ai>J: :: ::'fiiiJ:�iii:.iiiiiiiiiii :.iiiiii::4:ii:4:i:�iiiiiiiii:iiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiii:�i:iiii+T:iii:ii:�iiiiii:�:iiiiiiii:�i:_ii:ii:_:_i}:�:> :•i :.:?:.::�:.>ii::4iiiJ>::.ii:.::vv4i:::oi:�iiii:i�
♦::.. . .. ... n . .. ... . ... ...t.... .: . .:... \ : ..... J: ......:�::::: :.::::::::n::�:::::::::::::.�:::::.:�::::: :..�::::::::::::.::�::::::::::.�::::::::: :.:: :.:::.:�::.�:.:� ..�:::::::::.�::::::n�n::�:::.�::::::::::::::::::: :.:..�
� :::�$'EiFyE`t�>:�Bf�C?:�ElL �:..� ; <>::>::>::>:;:<>::>s>;::s:>::;::::>:;::»:x»::»»;:::::»>::::::>:;>;::s:<::. :: '<
tc+� �er�'c�hQe�. . ... .. .. ::::: •::.�:.::::: •:::.�.:::::::.�::::::::.� ::::::::::::::.:::::.
I, hereby, certify that this property is:
_ entered in the National Register. ,
See continuation sheet
_ determined eligible for the National
Register. _ See continuation sheet
_ determined not eligible for the
National Register.
_ removed from the National Register.
_ other, (explain:)
Signature of Keeper Date of Action
USD!/NPS NRHP Registration form
Property Name Caldwell Railroad Deoot
County and State Canyon Countv, [daho Page 2
.:::.,.:..
�l....C`►��SE�i�@'�1�l1::::<E;;::>:r?'::::?>'.» ,..,,._ ,.,.. . ,. ,:,.. ..:.. . ......:. .... ...::. . ::< >:. :.
Ownership of Property Category of Property No. of Resources within Property
_ private x building(s) contributing noncontributing
x public-local _ district _ _ buildings
_ public-State _ site _ _ sites
_ public-Federal _ structure _ _ structures
_ object _ _ objects
_ _ Total
No. of contributing resources previously
Name of related multiple property listing: tisted in the National Register:
.:::...................�::::::::::.;•::: �: ..�.�::.�::::;.�::::::::::.�:::::::::::::::: :.::<: ::::::::::. .:�:.:: :::.:::::::::::::.:�:: :.. ::.�::::::::::::::::::. :::::,. :,::<:::: :.::.�::. ::::::::::::. ::::::::.::�::::::::::::.: ::::::::::::::.�::: ::..�::::. :.
�:'•:::'�� �fli..,,... ..:, : ...: � �::>:i»:::>:i:>::::<::::::�>::::::::>::>i::>::>::>::>:::::;i::::>:z::<:::::>:<:::>s<:>.:;<;:>«::»::v;::><:::>::»:!>;:>::>::>:<:v:::<:�:<:::::::::>::[�>::>::>::>:<:::::>:<=>::::::::::>::::::<i::::<:::>::::>::::>:�::>::;i::iE::>::>::>::>:::<:�>::r;:>:
� S. � �� ......................................................>.......................................... .. .
Historic Functions (Enter categories from instructions.)
Cat: Transt�ortation Sub: _rait-related. combined freicht and oassenaer
Current Functions (Enter categories from instructions.)
Cat: Social Sub: civic
w/� <:i�<:::F:L::iR::Y:: �::r::::i::i::>;i:::;:iiii:.ii: iii :;i:;v: �.ii>: iiii :.: i :ai:� i: � i:5^i.iiiiiiiii:.iii :.ii�.;ii :<.i:o>:a:v: _ i: � iiiiii: _ ii:.: �: �: � iii.>: ::.::::::::::::::::. �... _:.....::. _:::. �::::::::::::::..:::::.::.: �.:::::....:.. _::::::::::::..::
:'F:::�i:::::..+...'• : .
. � Q�.::�:::;:�:�:�:::;;:;�i�::�:::::�::F:;:�:�:::�;::•':�:�:ti:�i::�:�::�:�::�;:::':::�:t�;>f:2�:S3::::�::�i::;:i:��:::::::ir:�:�:�:�::�::''>::::�::c:�::�::�:;:i::::�i:�i::::i:�:::i:;::';Gi::::�i:�:�i�:�3::�:�::�i:;::::::::�:�i::%:�i:�>:�i::::�:;;�:i::�:�i:�:�i:�i:�:�:�::�i:�:�i:�::::�i:i:�r:::>::::i;::�:�:�::;�:�i:�:;:i:;::?
� ....... .. .......... .............. . . .. .
. :,,., :.............:,.,.. ;........: :... :,,,...,.......; ...........,..; ;..... ;..,.....:: ... . _ .•.::.
. ... ........_ . .. .....,.. _..... ...
Architectural Classification Materials
(Enter categories fram instructions.) (Enter categories fran instructions.)
Richardsonian Romanesaue foundation concrete
walls brick
roof canposition shinale over ori9inal uood shinale
other
Narrative Description (Describe the historic and current condition of the praperty on one or more continuation
sheets.)
USDI/NPS NRHP Registration Form
Property Name Caldwetl Railroad Deaot
County and State CanYOn CountY, idaho Page 3
:: ...............: ....: ..::::::: ............................: ............... :.:::::::. . :.:::: ;::;::: ..::: ::::::. :.: . _:::::::. :::.: :: ::.:.:::,.:::::::::::::.: :::;:::: :;.::.: ::: :;;::::,:::::. :.;:.: ::. :::;:::,:::.: :::.;:.: .: ::::::,.;::::::. : :.::.
6:>:::�tete��E::�:::5 ::: ::. . �in�e>::>'::>:;>;::»:'::>::>::>::::::>::::>::;::>::>:<:»>:<:;:>::>::>_»»>::>�:::::::::::>:s>::::::>`:»? :`::::>;>:<:;:»::::<:::>[:::::>::::>::>::::::>::>:::<;:<:::_::::>::>:<::: »>::>:>;:':::>s:::>::>:::«:»::::>:<:>::::;:>::::::»:::::::::<:::::»»»:<:::>::>::>[::::::;:<:::>
�
Applicable National Register C�iteria (Mark '�x" in one or more boxes for the criteria qualifying the property for
National Register listing.)
x A Property is associated with events that have mede a significant contribution to the broad patterns of
our history.
_ e Property is associated with the tives of persons significant in our past.
x C Prope�ty e��wdies the distinctive characteristics of a type, period, or method of construction
or represents the work of a master, or possesses high artistic vatues, or represents a significant
and distinguishable entity whose componenis lack individual distinction.
_ D Property has yielded, or is likely to yield, information important in prehistory or history.
Criteria Considerations (Mark "x" in atl the boxes that apply.)
_ A owned by a religious institution or used for retigious purposes.
_ B removed from its original location.
_ C a birthplace or a grave.
_ D a cemetery.
_ E a reconstructed building, object, or structure.
_ F a corm�emorative property.
_ G less than 50 years of age or achieved significance within the past 50 years.
Areas of Significance
(Enter categories from instructions.) Period af Significance Significant Dates
Architecture
Transportation. Conmerce 1907-1945 1907
Cultural Affiliation
Significant Person Architect/Builder
Union Pacific/Ore9on Short Line Raitroad
Narrative Statement of Significance (Explain the significance of the property on one or mo�e continuation sheets.)
USD[/NPS NRHP Registration Form
Property Name Caldwell Railroad Depot
County a� State Canvon Countv. Idaho Page 4
:.: .. . ,..;..:.;.;.::, .. .:: � .•:.:�::::<::: ; •:;;:;:.:•;:• ::.:::...;.:.:;.:.:•:.;:.:;�:.;::.::<:.<:»::>:zx:<:::>:::>:<:::>�:<:>:::«::::::;y::::>:::«;:::>:;:::<:::::>���:;:::;;::::>�::.:.:. , . , ..
. .:' ....:.:.::::.:...:..:::+:�>'�:'�: �
�ii;y:
�.. Ikllaijar:.>�6��grsp�ael>:A���er�c�s:<:;><>:<::::<::>:::::>::>s»:::»::»::::>:::.;»<::::>::::>::::>:::;::;:;»>.::::»>:;:>::.:..... _ : .:.. :... ; : .
(Cite the books, articles, and other sources used in preparing this form on one or more continuation sheets.)
Previous documentation on file (NPS): Primary location of additional data:
_ preliminary determination of individual listing _ State Historic Preservation Office
(36 CFR 67) has been requested _ Other State agency
_ previousty listed in the National Register _ Federal agency
_ previously determined eligible by the Nationat Registe� _ Lacat goverrnient
_ designated a Nationat Historic Landmark _ University
_ recorded by Historic American Buitdings _ Other
Survey # Specify repository:
_ recorded by Historic American Engineering
Record #
... . : . . . _ ,
it�,.: {�e�ilgFapl'NC81'.�7@tH �.. ' ` '' " _ _ _ ...... _ _ ,
Acreage of property less than 1 acre
UTM References
1 1/1 5/2/5/2/6/0 4/8/3/4/7/8/0 3 � / / / / / / / / / / /
Zone Easting Northing 2one Easting Northing
2� ///// ////// 4_L ///// //////
See continuation sheet
Verbal Boundary Description (Describe the boundaries of the property on a continuation sheet.)
Boundary Justification (Exptain why the boundaries were selected on a continuation sheet.)
•:.:. :.� . �.��i': :::::::::::::;:�:�::� �::;::::�;::::::;;:::;:::::�:;:::::::'�;::::::'::::::2:::i:;::`:�;::::;:;:; :;::::::::::::;::::::;Y::Y: �:;:;:;:��::� �;:::�:::::::::::;::{:;;�:::::::;:;::::
7:>'t?:�»::::�:�>:Pr�iai�ed.. yc . . .:..
name/titte Madetine KelleY Buckendorf
organization tndependent contractor date
street & nunber 1402 E. Blaine telephone C208) 454-3435
city or town Caldwelt state ID zip code 83605
�Itl �':�:E:::'::::;::;`:•`.:::s<:>::;::�:::<::;<::;::i:;:<z:;:::::':<:>#`:>:::;:::::::;:::>:<3<:>::::<:;<:;>;:::``:�:`::�;:::>:<:<::::
�
Submit the following items with the completed form:
Continuation Sheets
Maps
A USGS map (7.5 or 15 minute series) indicating the property's location.
A sketch map for historic districts and properties having large acreage or numerous resources.
Photographs
Representative black and white photographs of the property.
Additional items (Check with the SHPO or FPO for any additional items.)
.. �; :•.;::•: •> •>�>;� • � »��>:i:»:�>:�»:�;<: ,
,. ,
pKO�3f:�>�1lIffIET' ' : . _ . ; :;?«E>;;:::>:;: < _ �: i . _. .. . _
(Complete this item at the request of the SHPO or FPO.)
name Union Pacific Railroad
street & nunber Contracts 8 Renewals Dept., 1416 Dodae Street telephone
city or town Omaha state NB zip code 68179
N1'S f-o�m IU�ODU�e �
OMtl No /Q10W79
18�H9)
United States Department of the Interior
National Park Service
National Register of Historic Places
Continuation Sheet
Section number 7 Page 1 Name of Property Caldwell Railroad Deaot
County and State Canvon Countv. Idaho
Description:
The Caldwell Oregon Short Line Depot is a one and one-half story building composed of a concrete
foundation, double brick walls, sandstone and concrete trim, and a composition shingle roof. Its
gross building area equals 3,020 square feet. The depot dimensions are 98 feet by 28 feet on the
west addition and 30 feet on the east facade. Its design is based on standard plans drawn up by the
Oregon Short Line's engineering department for the Weiser, Payette, Ontario, and Caldwell depots.
Each depot differs slightly in detailing and building materials.
Caldwell's depot reflects both classical styles of more prominent railroad stations and transitional
styles en vogue at the turn of the century. Its asymmetrical massing, keystone arched doorway,
large rusticated sandstone quoins and trim, tower-like entry, crenelated brick cornices, and rounded
columns in the south dormer reflect the Richardsonian Romanesque style. H. H. Richardson
designed several Massachusetts and Connecticut railroad stations in the 1880s. He also combined
elements of French Renaissance Revival element with Romanesque styles, such as steep-pitched
hipped roofs with flaring eaves. Though on a much more modest and restrained scale, Caldwell's
station includes some of the same stylistic elements of Richardson's small South Easton and larger
New London starions (see attached photos).
The south facade, which faces Caldwell's downtown core, contains the most stylistic details. Two
offset flared hipped roofs swoop down to the eaves of the combination passenger and freight station.
Decorative milleri-wood brackets support the eaves. A two-story, cross-gabled entryway dominates
the center of the depot portion's facade. Its square massing suggests a tower, a common element in
late nineteenth-century railroad architecture. A concrete voussoir tops a palladian window over the
central single doorway; sandstone quoins run up the doorway to meet the voussoir at the base of the
palladian window. Milled wood covers what were probably single-paned glass lights on each side
and a transom above the door. A single-paned sash door covers the entryway; concrete steps lead to
it. Paired single-light, fixed windows with plain trim and concrete lintels are located on each side
of the transom area. A sandstone belt course runs approximately four feet from the bottom of the
entryway's foundation. Crenelated brick cornices are located underneath the ea.ves in the second
half story. Sandstone trim runs between the cornices and sandstone quoins decorate the corners of
the half-story. A hipped roof dormer protrudes from the center of the entryway's roof. Paired
windows are inset into rounded wood shingle walls, and are separated by a matching colurnn.
Originally two smaller dormers flanked each side of the two-story entryway, but they have since
been removed.
Two three-sided bay windows flank each side of the entryway. Concrete lintels and supports are
Ni5 form 10 000 e OM9 No. �024-OO/B
(B-H61
United States Department of the Interior
National Park Service
National Register of Historic Places
Continuation Sheet
Section number 7 Page 2 Name of Property Caldwell Railroad Depot
County and State Canvon Countv. Idaho
under each bay. The central window consists of one large pane with a single overhead light. A
double-hung sash window with single panes forms each side of the bay. The windows are all
trimmed with plain milled wood. Rusticated sandstone quoins trim the corners, the bay windows,
and their supports. On the western bay window, a swamp cooler has been attached to the west sash
window. Sandstone belt courses run about four feet above the foundation at the base of the window,
three to four feet higher at the juncture of the window sashes, and at the top of the windows.
On the west freight station section, a single door is located at the section's juncture with the
passenger portion. It is a six-panel door with three vertical lights at the top. A similar double door
with four vertical lights is centered in the middle of the freight section. Two double-hung sash
windows with plain wood trim and concrete lintels and sills flank each side of the double doors.
Sandstone belt courses are located at the top, middle, and bottom of the windows.
The east and west building facades match each other, except for alterations to the west facade's
windows. Both originally had three double-sashed windows with single lights. The three windows
are joined by sandstone belt courses and quoins similar to the south facade, and have concrete lintels
and sills. On the west facade, the bottom halves of the sash windows no longer contain glass and
have been infilled with brick. Original photos of the depot also show a hipped-roof dormer in the
center of the west facade and another in the same Iocation on the east facade. These were removed
by the Union Pacific sometime prior to 1970.
The north facade follows a similar pattern to the rest of the building, with repetition of double-hung
sash windows, rusticated sandstone quoins and belt courses, and panel doors with vertical lights at
the top. No bay windows are located on this facade, but the pentagonal, cross-gabled tower
presents a three-bayed front. Two of the doors are slightly different from the south facade's doors.
The eastern door into the passenger section is a three-panel door with a single fixed light and a four-
light transom. The west side of the passenger station has an extra solid wood panel door; the other
two are six-panel wood doors with vertical lights at the top. A decorative brick chimney protrudes
east of the tower's roof. Some alterations have occurred to this side. A metal plate with iron bolts
has replaced the cement lintel above the paired sashed windows in the front of the tower. An
electric outdoor light is located above these windows. The western-most sash window on the freight
station section, the bottom half has been infilled with brick. Two smaller dormers flanked each side
of this entryway, but they also have been removed.
Despite some alterations, Caldwell's railroad depot retains its integrity and remains one of the most
intact historic buildings in the downtown core. The building is in good condition, and the City
continues to maintain it. It is used for various civic activities, including meetings, art shows, and
NPS fo�m 10.800-� OMB No. l01f-0018
18�881
United States Department of the Inte�ior
National Park Service
National Register of Historic Places
Continuation Sheet
Section number 7 Page 3 Name of Property Caldwell Railroad Deoot
County and State Canvon Countv, Idaho
recreational classes:
NPS Fo�m f0-BUtl�s JMH �YO 1074 /JO�A
Itl-tl81
United States Department of the Interior
National Park Service
National Register of Historic Places
Continuation Sheet
Section number 8 Page 1 Name of Property Caldwell Railroad Depot
County and State Canvon Countv. Idaho
Statement of Significance:
Caldwell's Oregon Short Line Railroad station is eligible for the National Register under Criteria A
and C. It represents the impact of the Oregon Short Line Railroad (a branch of the Union Pacific)
on southwest Idaho, and specifically on Caldwell's settlement and development. The depot's size,
brick construction and sandstone trim reflect Caldwell's economic importance as a railhead to the
Oregon Short Line. Though developed from standard plans, its ornate design represents elements of
transitional railroad architecture at the turn of the century.
The Oregon Short Line (hereafter OSL) Railroad linked the transcontinental Union Pacific Railroad
to the Pacific Northwest. The link was forged between Salt Lake, Utah, and Huntington, Oregon,
from 1881 and 1884. The tracks reached the new Caldwell townsite by September of 1883. Robert
Strahorn, who served as the Union Pacific's publicist from 1887 to 1885, seized the opportunity to
develop townsites along the new line. He and Senator H. H. Caldwell of Kansas, Hugh B. Wallace
and S. B. Jones formed the Idaho and Oregon Land Improvement Company, which sold town lots in
Hailey, Shoshone, Mountain Home, Caldwell, and Payette. The company also owned the water
rights to Caldwell city's only canal, called the Strahorn Ditch.'
Caldwell was virtually a tent city when the OSL Railroad laid its tracks there. When the railroad
tracks reached town in 1883,the Idaho Tri-Weekly Statesman in Boise described the scene tongue-in-
cheek: "The new town of Caldwell has eleven saloons and one pump in successful operation. With
water and good society there is no reason why the city should not prosper. " Boise had been
bypassed by the railroad, and its Board of Trade (precursor of the Chamber of Commerce) grew
exceedingly jealous of Caldwell's status as a railhead. Tri-Weekly Statesman editorials attacked
Strahorn and Caldwell for their "fraudulent" promotion of Caldwell, and Boise's businessmen fought
hard for a branch line. In the meantime Caldwell boomed; by 1884 Caldwell had 600 people, 40
businesses, 150 other structures, a telephone system, and a public school. Boiseans waited for their
own branch line until 1925.
Like many early railroad towns, a small shanty served as Caldwell's first depot. Caldwell's freight
and passenger receipts grew to nearly $15,000 a month in 1889, and its leading citizens petitioned
the railroad for a new depot with a waiting room. An 1889 Caldwell Tribune editorial
sarcastically refereed to OSL executives' foot dragging. It said that the wood depot, which was
"worth all of $7.60, " was a"valuable property that should not be disposed of in haste. " A larger
but still modest wood frame depot replaced the shanty in 1890, but city leaders were unsatisfied.
Caldwell had become a major shipping point for the sheep and wool industries, and its citizens
wanted a depot commensurate with its importance. A national bank panic and subsequent OSL
NPS Foim IO�BW-a UMd No lO7a.001d
IB-88)
United States Department of the interior
National Park Service
National Register of Historic Places
Continuation Sheet
Section number 8 Page 2 Name of Property Caldwell Railroad DeQOt
County and State Canvon Countv, Idaho
bankruptcy in 1893 delayed the possibility of a more substantial building. Railroad magnates E. H.
Harriman and Jacob Shiff reorganized the Union Pacific and the Oregon Short Line in 1897, and
pulled them out of debt by 1900. As part of his acquisition of the Oregon Short Line subsidiary,
Harriman planned improvements along the railway.'
In the late 1890s, irrigated farming radically altered the landscape along the OSL tracks. Canal
systems formed an intricate capillary system over the southwest Idaho, bringing plentiful water to
Caldwell's sagebrush plain. As agriculture thrived, the OSL's railroad receipts boomed. Nampa,
Caldwell, Ontario, Weiser, and Payette provideti ample profit for the OSL. Traditionally, railroad
companies rewarded those towns that serve� as county seats or provided large receipts with more
ornate and substantial brick stations. When the OSL constructed Nampa's brick-and-stone station
first in 1903, Caldwell business leaders felt that their city, as the county seat, was slighted. They
complained long and mightily to railroad executives. In 1904, business leaders petitioned City
Council to work with the Oregon Short Line in finding a suitable site for a new depot. They
recognized the symbolic value of an attractive brick station to their economy. OSL representatives
finally agreed to build one if City Council closed up lst Street West. The Caldwell Tribune urged
the council to acquiesce, stating: "The construction of an appropriate depot in Caldwell will greatly
add to the appearance of the town, and more favorably impress prospective settlers who may visit
this section. "`
By 1906 the old depot had handled over 61,980,000 pounds of freight and its ticket sales equaled
$48,8b0. That year Union Pacific's general superintendent W.H. Bancroft and his chief engineer
William Ashton met with Caldwell leaders. Bancroft informed the group that they intended to build
"large and ornate" depot buildings at Weiser, Payette, Ontario, and Caldwell. The newspaper later
reported that the new Caldwell depot and associated renovations would cost around $40,000. The
council planned to build its new city hall at the other end of what is now Seventh Street. A double-
lane bridge was also plannetl across Indian Creek, improving the entire downtown area. The
Tribune described the planned streetscape in glowing terms: "The scene will present itself to a
person as he steps off the train will be the most beautiful in the city. City Hall will remind George
Dew [a Caldwell bookkeeper originally from Massachusetts] of Trinity Hall, Boston. "
The OSL's engineering firm drew up standard plans for all the new Idaho and eastern Oregon
depots, but each one was adapted for local needs and the railhead's economic status. The Weiser
and Payette stations matched Caldwell's in size and design. Weiser's depot was constructed of dark
red brick and concrete block, and did not include improvements. It cost $20,000. Payette's depot
nearly matched Weiser's, and was torn down in 1983. [The Ontario, Oregon, railroad station looks
larger; its dimensions are not known.] Newspaper editorials from early 1907 described the Caldwell
NPS Fom+ 10�NOO�a OMtl No. l02d�OOIB
�e-ee�
United States Department of the Interior
National Park Service
National Register of Historic Piaces
Continuation Sheet
Section number 8 Page 3 Name of Property Caldwell Railroad Deoot
County and State Canvon Countv, Idaho
Depot's finished construction: "The new building is a beauty, being constructed with light-colored
brick, trimmed with cement blocks [it is sandstone, with some concrete block]...The building is
finished throughout in white fir, with 3 coats of oil and is most complete in every particular." The
structure contained both ladies and gentleman's waiting rooms and lavatories. It was initially
lighted by kerosene lamps, due to a disagreement between the railroad and the local electric
company. b ,
Though more modest in scale, the new depots reflected both classical styles of more prominent
railroad stations and transitional styles en vogue at the turn of the century. Their asymmetrical
massing, keystone arched doorway, lazge rusticated sandstone quoins, tower-like entry, and
crenelated brick trim reflected Richardsonian Romanesque style. H. H. Richardson, a prominent
American architect, designed several Massachusetts and Connecticut railroad stations in the 1880s.
He also combined elements of French Renaissance Revival and Victorian Gothic with Romanesque
styles, such as steep-pitched hipped roofs with flaring eaves, towers, bays, and brackets. Caldwell
and the other stations include some of the same stylistic elements of Richardson's small South
Easton, Massachusetts, and larger New London, Connecticut, stations. Richardson used similar,
slightly refined designs for later stations he designed for the Canadian Pacific.'
Richardson's design elements came from classical architecture, which dominated railroad
architecture throughout its history. The idea was to create a triumphal entrance to the city, no
matter how large or small. Such designs were incorporated in standard engineering plans of the
Union Pacific, and the more profitable railheads received this symbolic recognition with a brick and
stone station. Caldwell's depot reflected this style in its own small and restrained way. Varied
combinations of French Rennaissance, Richardsonian Romanesque, and Victorian styles already
dominated Caldwell's downtown commercial architecture and the new College of Idaho campus.
The most substantial downtown buildings were constructed between 1903 to 1910. This eclectic
mixture of styles served as the basis for later Prairie styles of architecture, which dominated
Caldwell residential architecture in the 1910s and 1920s.e
The incorporation of the railroad station with a downtown city plan reflected the "City Beautiful"
movement of the late 19th century. The City Beautiful movement marked the beginning of
concerted efforts towards city planning in the United States. The idea of planning cities fit well
within this Progressive era of social reform and application of scientific principle to various human
activities. In cities, this movement led towards more public parks and gardens, European-style
boulevards, and town squares surrounded by well-constructed city institutions. The Chicago Worlds
Fair in 1893 promoted this "city beautiful" design. Architects and city boosters got together to
develop an ideal city--based on neoclassical designs, with fountains, massive buildings, paved roads,
NPS Foim t0�8W�e OMB No. 102d-00/8
�e-ae�
United States Department of the Interior
National Park Service
National Register of Historic Places
Continuation Sheet
Section number � Page 4 Name of Property Caldwell Railroad DeQOt
County and State Canvon Countv, Idaho
and electrification. The designers and boosters both believed that beauty was an important element
in selling new communities, or revitalizing old ones.'
Thousands from all over the United States attended the fair. Many who attended went back home
with ideas with which to rebuild--or in the West's case, build--new cities. Caldwell's early city
leaders followed that basic plan, with their substantial railroad station on one end of Seventh street,
with a well-designed City Hall at the other end. A large fountain dominated the front entry of City
Hall, and impressive brick-and-stone buildings (many architect-designed) lined Main Street. City
fathers quickly established public schools, churches, libraries and parks. Blaine and Cleveland
Boulevards matcheri European streets lined with trees and electric lights. The boulevards tied the
downtown core to the College of Idaho, and to early suburbs such as Dorman's. Convenient public
transportation was also a hallmark of progressive cities, and Caldwell soon was linked to other area
towns by the electric interurban railroad. Town boosters followed this city beautiful pattern for a
strong economic reason: many prospective settlers came from established towns and communities in
the Midwest and East, and expected the same in prosperous Idaho towns. �^
Like many small towns, Caldwell would experience dramatic change with the introduction of the
automobile. Autos became more convenient for travel, and trucks eventually provided cheaper
freight rates than railroads. Changing economic patterns and the development of large corporate
enterprises in retail sales undercut independent merchants in small towns. Railroad traffic began to
decrease, and many small railheads lost their status. Passenger service continued until the 1960s,
then Amtrak provided the service. Amtrak stopped in Nampa, rather than Caldwell. Freight
service continued until the mid-1980s, then the Caldwell depot was closed completely. The city
government and Caldwell Economic Development worked a 99-year lease with Union Pacific in
1989, where the depot itself could be used for community events. The Caldwell depot has since
served that function in the downtown, remaining an important part of city civic and social life. It
serves as a visible reminder of Caldwell's ties to railroad history and its pioneer founders' dreams of
a "city beautiful. "
NPS Fortn 10-BOO�� OMBNe. l024-00/B
IB•891
U�ited States Depertment of the Interior
Nationai Pa�k Service
National Register of Historic Places
Continuation Sheet
Section number 8 Page 5 Name of Property Caldwell Railroad Depot
County and State Canvon Countv, Idaho
END NOTES
l. For background information on Strahorn, see Carlos Schwantes, Railroad signatures across
The Pacific Northwest (Seattle: University of Washington Press, 1993), 81-82. For
information about Caldwell's settlement, see Annie Laurie Bird, Boise. the Peace Vallev
(Caldwell, Idaho: Caxton Printers, 1934), 279-313.
2. The Idaho Tri-Weekl�Statesman, 8 September 1883, 3(quotation); See ITS editorials
throughout September of 1883. For statistics, see Caldwell Centennial Calendar (Caldwell,
Idaho: Caldwell Public Library, 1983) and Bird's Boise. the Peace Vallev. 249-278; 279-313.
3. The Caldwell Tribune, 23 March 1889, 4(quotation); see also Merrill Beal, Intermountain
Railroads. Standard and Narrow Gauge (Caldwell, Idaho: Caxton Printers, 1962), 177-195,
214-218.
4. Ibid., 13 August 1904, 4; 27 August 1904, 1(quotation); 3 September 1904, 2. See also Bird.
5. Elaine Leppert and Lorene Thurston, Early Caldwell Throu�h Photo�phs (Caldwell, Idaho:
Caxton Printers, 1990), 80; The Caldwell Tribune, 5 May 1906, 1; 16 June 1906, 1
(quotatiort). The information on George Dew was found in the 1910 U. S. Census.
6. The description of the depot and quote came from the article "Moving into New Depot," The
Caldwell Tribune, 26 January 1907, 5. For information about the Weiser station, see
Washington County, Survey #163 (State no. 016074), Idaho State Historic Preservation Office,
210 Main, Boise.
7. Carroll L. V. Meeks, The Railroad Sta.tion: An Architectural Historv (New Haven,
Connecticut: Yale University Press, 1956), 104-110.
8. Ibid. See also H. Roger Grant and Charles W. Bohi, The Country Railroad Station in
America (Boulder, Colorado: Pruett Publishing Company, 1978), 56, 66, 128-129.
9. John L. Hancock, "Planners in the Changing American City, 1900-1940," in American Urban
HistorX , ed. Alexander B. Callow, Jr. (New York: Oxford University Press, 1973), 596-600.
NPS Fo�m 10-Y00-� OM9 No. /OSO�OO/8
IB-891
United Statea Department of the Interior
Nationai Park Service
National Register of Historic Places
Continuation Sheet
Section number � Page 6 Name of Property Caldwell Railroad DeQOt
County and State Canvon Countv, Idaho
10. Ibid. See also Jennifer Eastman Attebery, introduction to Building Idaho: An Architectural
Histor� (Boise: Idaho State Historical Society, 1991), 3-5.
NPS Fwm 10-WO�• OMB No. l02�-0018
�e-ee�
United States Department of the Inte�ior
National Park Service
National Register of Historic Piaces
Continuation Sheet
Section number 9 Page 1 Name of Property Caldwell Railroad Deoot
County and State Canvon Countv. Idaho
BIBLIOGRAPHY:
Attebery, Jennifer Eastman. Building Idaho: An Architectural Historv. Boise: Idaho State
Historical Society, 1991.
Beal, Merrill D. Intermountain Railroads. Standard and Narrow Gauge. Caldwell, Caxton Printers,
1962.
Bird, Annie Laurie. Boise, the Peace Vallev. Caldwell, Idaho: Caxton Press, 1934.
Caldwell Centennial Calendar. Caldwell, Idaho: 1983. On file at the Caldwell Public Library.
The Caldwell Tribune. Caldwell, Idaho: March, 1889, through January, 1907.
Callow, Alexander B. American Urban Histon!. New York: Oxford University Press, 1973.
Culp, Edwin D. Stations West, the Story of the Oregon Railways. Caldwell, Ca�cton Printers,
1972.
Grant, H: Roger, and Charles W. Bohi. The Countr}! Railroad Station In America. Boulder, Co:
Pruett Publishing Co. , 1978.
The Idaho Tri-Weekly Statesman. Boise, Idaho: August-October, 1883.
Leppert, Elaine, and Lorene Thurston. Early Caldwell throu�h Photo�raphs. Caldwell, Idaho:
Ca�cton Printers, 1990.
Meeks, Carroll L. V. The Railroad Station: An Architectural Historv. New Haven, Connecticut:
Yale University Press, 1956.
Schwantes, Carlos A. Railroad S�natures across the Pacific Northwest. Seattle: University of
Washington Press, 1993.
r`
NM Fenw 10-Y00•�
aws ne. rouoo��
�wei
U�ited States Department of the interior
Nationai Park Service
Nationai Register of Historic Places
Continuation Sheet
Section number 10 Page 1 Name of Property Caldwell Railroad Deaot
County and State Canvon Countv. Idaho
Verbal Boundary Description:
Intersection of South Seventh Street and Railroad Avenue (701 S. 7th)
[Note: It is not part of the Lot and Block grid; it is in the railroad's right-of-way.]
Boundary Jusification:
Only sta.tion and structure still extant in Caldwell that is associated with the Oregon Short Line
Railroad.
�_�.,; � A .
�� .'
; �:
' '.�.
lt
J �_
F � t
�� :f'� - � . . . . � � Y ., _ i� ,��!
. � � . P?4:7` "�''. .. � RV'y,. � � � � .
� .. . . t�� 3 �'�ta' . , .
��
. . °�....--.+_
!1! 5
1 ''!`. _ _. . - � �?'f ^`� _ . . , -.
� r . �,,.,,r._+4:�: :t
� . . . . + ;` � c:: ' _ - :� �
, .,..� - ..r. � i. .s►
. �..._.. .-. : .
.. . �"K ''�Y ` t^'s ,,,.i�„r:^t"""`'.."^".' '„""� "�
Y - - , y� ...� �i�
_ - . �� : :V , 'V
_ - .�. ���3 .i�� �
' f. f ./ � 4 ,`� ` �^+��� � :�
�. � - i �- i 1 . � y .T .. �i��, 4 :-,�i
. � � �+ � � itiP! 2. Y`!i[!, � � 'n"�. � . .4
� ,{,.� fn �:t+.. MN��..., ,$.�*,�., . �3 q x�_, `°"�'�"
_ :��l1. t�N' �'.. �. �. ��5..�
��
r
�� �
.J. .w { _
� � � .
4 .
�
�iif`'
.AG'��.nV...� ..
$� ' _ r
� �.. : .
��; �>. ;�.,��
` .-» � � s.�,`.4•-
' i»s.
��. ' Y .��� : ""...
$' ���"i : , 4 � � �t i d � M ,; •
�..�b � 1 1�..4�.u_�s L p 5
=�y \. • 1 •�'�i.f�' "��'� �� .
s�� _ ;'45 �.� " _ . �.. 3 -..
�a�t �'' Y ry l��fti —. ..
,�'" '� .�,. � =��
,�, .- , , �
_ ._ � . _ __.___
_ ` � __ _ . . _ . -
_ , .,
, . -,� . i ,� . � . ,. . . � .. -. ; � .
.;ar . .. :. ,
.. _-- . ,,,. .t, ��. . . ' . . , . . .. - .^w-.sr� -
;� � _ .,�
� - �'•.r _
, . _�,.�- �. �. . . ., .
� � ..,::-.' >
.�:�.. . _-..>__-�_
` _ _ ' -
'-- ::s
r � � . f �.
�_,,/''' .e
-y �'�� ` +�" � r �� �y'�._�, c� ��a �- _--- � i� � /+
_ � � � s' ' . . . _ - - - � � - •
� + �� �i.i....���� L � � = �. �.i�.� -,.
•��• _ s% __ - K �— -_ - $; _ �`�
� � .. s � � .. -- � 1
i.��'i � � 3 ' _- = - � � :
Ga ,� z..� � '�. �v _ _ —�� , _T '���
�'�„�"'_�� , ' '�` `x- � �'�'�8i - — -- - _ - �`� ' `
�'" . �� ' r �._. �� �. . f;: w+,i - ..:.�a �, i + '- • - -- � t� - �-'�'_ _
=-��� ''� � e
^ � • �t,�•,
s- �_ . �
�"� � =7i� _ wr ..x : � . �-..�_--.,,- �r � r
� � '( � g � ��r
P
� �¢ s , ; ;� � ■ � , t
� , a .h"� � = .,.=� � �r ��; � �
� i - ai. - � , �.
_ . ...;,�. - ...:�,K -
�. � �
_ _ �,
_ ' ... "'"" :�.�--.� .J'-' ' `N.'y�t,� .. .
_ , � . � ti . .. ...�.Nir��'�
�� � �
�
Q� � �
oc � `� �'
\— � Z .
�.� �T O
� �
� � 3 � C �
� d�� v O� �;K� iZ !'�._,e�:� 3_ c_S� 3S�GE � m
U + � \ fN t7G nl� ' .
J •,-,,, _ J . �. --.— .
_ � , � �� � �- m j � � . j . RP � ' � �� ^ ,�
i . � Z n� , / / � �S6 r+� �' �
'. i � k _ �-�^. �-/, � � � ...;,�- ,.
' � i. a �,�,�tif / !, � 12°Z • �¢P�� � ' .Q ry �� -
— /-�� � ' / .� • J . W - �''Y
- ��� ,; o � .. ..� =----� - -� �- • .. . �
,�
;� °� i • ' � o ? i° P� i
'" � � j �� p� �� ( � ��� �
,
�>� � — ,�✓ ��' ; � • i O `,P '
; � :' i a Vi ' " ?�. � �-. �
- _ - _ = � F -��� U ! . � �' � ��'� y � — �'. ' I
_ , , / � � �� �
, _
1 � h �� � i ' � /� W - • Y�
' � P �� , i �_ _' - � �.�� F� . ` _ -_ 2r.�0- i - v ... JP�'b II
� 'pi � ' % � � .. / � � � . - � ' _
N ; .''�I % 3 � ." _ :
�� � fl ��
_ � �, . .._� / . . y Q , -- -\�\�'
/ ' ' _% i � • � 02 ^,�— ' f , QP G
' � i . i !�� � . �� i � "\;•�.
ir i E � ' i �� • ..
- --- /, j j i . � - - - / � ,I — .
A �-- I "
/ ;. zj i �'� /�- —' I - `� ��� � � . � .
���, i � � � . �- ' ^ \ rn ' �
��f' � I �— l .. M I � _ �7' ��l .. � �i l � . � .
� �� - '; f �.e� 3 = T / g � ��.
� � i,,� '�. �. .. `" � " •�%�'_" m.: � . /
�� .�� _ \ �; • . - / _ �
� � � oo , �/�� � . j -
' ,. `_- -�.- ` -' / ; - 1;"� ., !
R -� --�:� -t ,- i� . i ;
, $ I, d � � ` � �.�i ;, _ �
_ " / I ry � • �� : �,,,., . . . n 0 /� �' ' � � � - %�� I :� � • . � � • I .
s' � .� • �/ ' .
A iv .�//� -•.� � � 2� . --� " .��. � � � r�.���% � .
• � • / �-� � ' 4 i� �/ 5�% oi ,�V •I �.
=�� / .. .I . T �� . � , � j � if " �W � , J ' I
_ _ _ ,\ - __ . _ \ y ,�PG E � . -/�- + �'� �
-�' ::: .��� ., o`s, /` '� �.
= : � �„ , •1' --,, !� �^' s � _ ' ; =,�_1
� ..� � �1 � ' � _ -` , . J i
J I�. � ��. 1 '� � �/ _ j � .: � i � y w �
� � .a:—� �-+'; . p � �. � I �± • /� �` �• �J �� i � �� 3;`:
i k I:. . � R A � � /j� � • '. . • '� i
a � ' g , � i �' � :�'; ,� i
• 1• � '�f -�"i f � � . � • � •�.., I��� /� � i� � i. � e II •I!� •,;+� � '' � V '
� • ' �_ r •"' � ._ . •• � _ / � v :_1' • " �
. � : . . -�_-_
�: �'� :I _ - a:dl• .. ... ,v `'�Ci � � � I i '� � 3q�►anr : I
��- -�� '- 1 '' : ti �� i � .
� '� Y = � ��-� , '� � � � ,�� ��,:1, �r ' • � .... : = ' , —
' - oo� = v ^ �: o�,t � ��� � J\ �:y� _ �
_ .�.�rONn�i ,v ✓` �, / ,� ♦ , � .. .,.. . : �
- `^._ ^ '� a0 v � \ --- _; � =_— ��;�� _8"- 1.-
^; ; ..��� �� ' � J - � � � � �. ..
' - '`, a ���✓'''�. / /r G a .� � t �r ,��..��� _ � ....
• 1 . ' i � •�'/, � � �` % 7 J y �' ;, N 's' %�, • � " ': , . , , , A � .. ...
. � � . -�• •�. /� �•'.%.� v� `� 4 � l �' �, � . .... . `�
, , ' % �; �;� : � � � r � `- ---- �. , .
• � �' : � � , _ ~� �' � ' � : . �L•_ _ � - -r--' � '
� . . . � ,, /� / ` l. �( - `�J I �; 3 ^ 3Ar' �� ^ •
��•. i � f �� : : j •
:1- : .' , t / ,� d ` O _ , � 6� c --�' �=� � J � �\\
����'. `��;%f J ,. r ti "� . :�.-. �. _.. �.._..%_ , c �� ' , . '
- I . . •� . �� / _ � ~ � �' �`. -a� ' ` �: � ..••• �" "�v�rar _ �--'�.)�xf0 -' � �.
; Z s��( T � 1 I W � I �I 9 �i__ /.
Z 70 r L `� '
�.<? 5...-' -
TO: MAYOR WINDER AND CITY COUNCIL DATE: 9-25-94
FROM: CHIEF ALLCOTT ���'
SUBJECT: PROPOSED FEES
During the budget process, I was instructed to look into possible
fees for service that the City may want to consider implementing.
Attached are some proposed fees and the appropriate ordinance
language and resolutions for those fees. I plan on attending the
council meetinq to discuss any of these in more detail as needed.
i
i