HomeMy WebLinkAbout12-9-1993 CHPC MINUTES t • �
= Historic Preservation Commission
.,
� � r' 621 CLEVELAND BLVD.
� CALDWF_LL, IDAHO 83605
TEL.: (208)455-3006
FAX 455-3003
Caldwell Depot Facing Seventh Ave. (1906)
1�IINUTES
Meeting of December 9, 1993
Present: Chair Madeline Buckendorf, Carol Burbank, Bill Gigray III, Elaine Leppert, Vivian
McKay, Steve Maughan. Absent: Elaine Carpenter, Tom Ensley; Staff: Dennis Crooks, Liz
Yeary
The December 9, 1993 meeting of the Historic Preservation Commission was called to order
in the City Council Conference Room at 7:05 p.m.
The Mi.nutes of the meeting of October 28, 1993 were approved as submitted with motion I I,
from Elaine Leppert, seconded by Steve Maughan. ',
I
The first item on the agenda was the selection of properties for the FY94 Site Survey Project �
of the Arlington Addition. After discussion concerning the criteria for selection, the
following sites were chosen: ,
Site # Str.# Street Owner Subdivision Blk Lot
1. 1224 Fairview Patricia Back, Rev Trust Arlington Addn OS 8/9
2. 1324 Fairview Gary D McC�me & Lawanda F McC�ne Arlington Addn OS 13
3. 1402 Fairview Charles L Lee & Margazet Lee Arlington Addn 06 1
4. 1404 Fairview Donna M Shines Arlington Addn 06 2 �
5. _ 1503 Fairview Ruth D Englehom Arlington Addn 03 i l/ 12
6. 1509 Fairview Louise Roedel Arlington Addn 03 10
7. 1604 Fairview Warren Taylor Arlington Addn 08 1/2
*8. 1608 Fairview Warren Taylor Arlington Addn 08 3
9. 1616 Fairview Robert M Trent & Patricia A Trent Arlington Addn 08 4/5
10. 1303 Arlington Kenneth L Baldwin Arlington Addn QS 17
i i. 1323 Arlington Vera A. Fazley Arlington Addn OS 14
12. 1423 Arlington George D Hershey Arlingtan Addn 06 7/8
13. 1501 Arlington Robert F. Payne Arlington Addn 07 11/12
14. 1515 Arlington Frances Mead Arlington Addn 07 9
15. 1521 Arlington Reah a Barker Arlington Addn 07 �
16. 223 Mead Margazet M Stanwood Arlington Addn 11 6
17. 1420 Arlington Ted L Teay &°6Kenneth D Roberts Arlington Addn 10 4
18. 1402 Arlington Lola Moore Arlington Addn 10 1
19. 1219 Kimball S Memorial Pazk Baptist Church Arlington Addn 09F
20. 1502 Ellis David G Ascuena & Shanna Ascuena Arlington Addn 12 1
21. 122 Mead Mary L Broadwell & Mary Miller Fairacres Add 1 17
*8 1608 Fairview is an "alternate" should any prove unfeasible.
HISTORIC PRESERVATION CObIIvIISSION
Minutes 12/09J93 - P.1
� �
Motion was made by Steve Maughan and seconded by Carol Burbank to send out a request
for proposals to historians as quickly as possible since we have been advised by the State
Historic Preservation Office that there are less historians available to cazry out research
projects and those that are submitted earliest will probably get first choice. The motion
passed nnanimously.
The next item for review was the Draft Report on the Downtown Historic District meetings.
The general consensus was the report should be more specific, highlighting the use of the
model block concept to illustrate how sidewalk and storefront renovation could work and
provide the unpetus for energy to expand downtown. Other areas include the need for
beautification, the importance of a Downtown Merchants' Association, the hiring of
professionals to provide publicity, and maintain coordination, which takes the burden off the
merchants. Bill Gigray cited Title 50, Page 26, Business Improvement Districts, as a code
worthy of examination, the use of BIDs to make a plan and the use of LIDs for physical
improvements. The Report should address what Pocatello and Nampa have done, with
energy, ingenuity and commitment and show that this can be done in Caldwell. The
Downtown Merchants' Association was able to coordinate events to attract people downtown.
Some used public money as seed money to get things started. Bill also cited the Boise
presentation which showed a physical identity of the community. Both Pocatello and Nampa
gave statistics that revealed an increase in the occupancy rate which were very striking.
In order to present a good report to Council, it was suggested that slides be used showing
how the historic theme has worked and helped in other cities. It is unportant to note that
Nampa felt Caldwell had more historic buildings. It appears that a historical azchitectival
theme has been successful when done tastefully. ;
It was agreed to compile everyone's comments and come back in Jan to et a final re rt I '
�Y g P�
together. There was a consensus that it would be profitable to meet with the Council in a I
workshop session to discuss the whole downtown issue. '
There was discussion concerning the need for a downtown Master Plan that would address a
variety of issues such as sidewalks, infra.structure improvements, traffic, circula�ion, parking,
landscaping, lighting, architecture, design etc. which the Commission felt they could support
as a means to help to revitalize the downtown.
Once a plan is developed a historic district can be fashioned very flexibly to ensure some
stability of the plan, once it is adopted. Having a plan in place shows commitment. The plan
provides security for people to invest in their properties. Major traffic patterns in Caldwell
have changed for the future since it was built. We need to look at those traffic patterns to
see that when we plan the downtown we need to point ourselves to the new patterns.
Physically downtown has not really changed since the couplet was developed.
Madeline Buckendorf announced she will not seek another term on the Commission, due to
potential conflicts of interest.
Bill Gigray then left the meeting due to another obligation.
HISTORIC PRESERVATION COM[vIISSION
Minutes 12J09/93 - P.2
, • •
�
The last item of discussion was potential use of budgeted monies for 1994 projects. It was
agreed that something should be done which would be visible and a positive addition to the
community. Some suggestions were: improvements to the Saratoga Pazking Lot, the
passageway in the former Cunarron Building azea, historic street lights, etc.
The highest visibility project seems to be the parking lot because of its location. The
sidewalk could be reconstructed along with the additional street trees and other design
features to complement the historic monument at the corner. It was agreed to encourage
other suggestions, and to discuss this item in more detail at a future meeting.
With no fiuther discussion, the meeting was adjourned at 8:45 p.m. The next regularly
scheduled meeting of the Comrnission will be January 27, 1994.
Respectfully bmitted,
, �
��
Liz Yeary, Administrative Secretary
Planning and Zoning
HISTORIC PRESERVATION COMIvIISSION
1�Twutes 12J09J93 - P.3