HomeMy WebLinkAbout2-20-2003 CHPC MINUTES , "
r
HISTORIC PRESERVATION COMMISSION
MINUTES
• February 20, 2003
Caldwell City Hall
I. Call to Order:
Jan Boles, Chairman, called the meeting to order at 6:00 p.m.
II. Roll Call:
Members Present: Jan Boles, Chairman; Elaine Carpenter, Tom Ensley, Elaine Leppert,
Jose hine Masar, Ken Eytchison, Rick Wells, and Betty Jo Keiler.
Anita Shore, p
Members Absent: Steve Maughan and Chuck Randolph
City Staff: Jacqueline Hernandez
Approval of Agenda:
The Agenda was approved as written by general consensus.
III. Approval of Minutes: I
The minutes for January 8, 2003 were not approved. This item will be forwarded to
March 20, 2003 as old business.
VI. New Business
� A. Certificate of Appropriateness Interview:
The applicant, Mrs. Buffy Hake, presented her application for a Certificate of
Appropriateness to remodel and repair the rear portion of the existing structure. The
remodel included changes in the garage, an addition to the exterior of the home, and
interior.
Discussion was held concerning the request, mainly addressing the location of the
property and keeping the integrity of the front of the home to the originality.
Jan Boles recommended Mrs. Hake to read through the Step-by-Step booklet, and to
provide professional architectural blue prints when re-submitting her request. Mrs.
Hake explained she was not given the Step-by-Step booklet at time of application. A
copy was provided shortly after. Chairman Boles also informed Mrs. Hake of the
appeal process with the Mayor and City Council. The Commission agreed to assist
the applicant with information including Architectural pro bono references.
MOTION: Commissioner Elaine Carpenter. SECOND: Commissioner Ken Feaster-
Eytchison. The Commission tabled their decision recommending Mrs. Hake review
all materials and resubmit her application with professional architectural plans.
Chairman Boles agreed to send a letter to explain the Commission's decision,
accompanied by a copy of the City Zoning Ordinance Section 10-02-12 (Steunenberg
Residential Historic District), with the condition of a 30-day response by the applicant
or the application would be withdrawn. Elaine Carpenter will provide resources from
State Historical Preservation Office (SHPO) with architectural pro bono references.
The Commission stated that appeals would be made to the City Council as per the
. process stated in the Zoning Ordinance.
B. Step-by-Step HPC Booklet / HPC Certificate of Appropriateness Application
Discussion followed concerning materials the appiicants will need prior to submitting
a request before the HP Commission. City staff will supply the applicant with Step-
by-Step booklet, HPC Certificate of Appropriateness application, portion of the zoning
� ordinance pertaining to the Steunenberg Historic district and the Steunenberg
Residential Historic District Design Guidelines.
Chairman Boles suggested that the application and the Step-by-Step HP booklet
include: information concerning the applicant of posting their site, and the applicant
supplying exterior photos of the site upon submittal the application. Attachments to
the application must include a professional architectural blueprint including graphic
explanation and building elevation.
MOTION: Commissioner Elaine Leppert. SECOND: Commissioner Anita Shore.
Jan Boles to condense the ordnance to one sheet. Jacqueline to update changes to
be updated to reflect in the Step-by-Step booklet and HP C of A application.
C. Walla Walla Oregon Trail Trip
Jacqueline reported concerning the Walla Walla trip, which is being organized by the
Chamber of Commerce in the month of May. It was determined that the members to
check their availability and report back in the March meeting.
D. 2003 CLG Workshop
Discussion followed who would be attending the CLG workshop to be held in Boise.
The dates of the workshop are April 4& 5. It was stated that Chairman Boles would
not be able to attend. It was suggested that Vice' Chairman Carpenter represent the
City of Caldwell.
E. Anita Shore re-appointment
Chairman Jan Boles addressed Anita Shores' term has been expired.
• MOTION: Commissioner Elaine Carpenter. SECOND: Commissioner Tom Ensley.
Re-appoint Anita Shore to the Commission to 3 a year term. Chairman Boles to write
letter to the Mayor concerning this reappointment.
IV. Old Business
A. Annual CHPC Award:
Elaine presented a nomination form for the historic district award submittal.
(Exhibit A)
Josephine Masar provided an example of a framed award. Josephine presented
various examples of scanned photos taken from the homes located in the HP district
and faded them out in the background of the award.
The Commission agreed that the award would be named "Steunenberg Preservation
Award." The nomination form will reflect the same name and/or logo.
B. Certificate of Appropriateness:
Jacqueline presented an example of a Certificate of Appropriateness form. Elaine
Leppert will supply historical picture. It was determined that after the picture is
included on the form, the form may be utilized. (Exhibit B)
� C. Irrigation Boxes Located Within the Local District:
Chairman Boles presented a letter sent by Gordon Law, City Engineer. (Exhibit C)
�
D. Future Historical Preservation Meetings
MOTION: Commissioner Tom Ensley. SECOND: Commissioner Ken Feaster-
� Eytchison. Future meetings will be held at City Hall at 6:00 p.m.
VIII. Adjournment
The meeting was adjourned at 8:00 p.m.
Respectfully submitted,
Jacqueline Hernandez
Recording Secretary
ATTESTED T.
. t !� /�• >�,/
Sign , �
6
� Ja�`Boles, Chairman
�.__-
Date: � �-- � D ��
�
•
r
• Friend of Preservation Award Nomination Applicatian
for the year of
Sponsored by the Caldwell H'istoric Preservatian Comu�ission
Nominee:
Site Address:
CATEGORY
Sustained Preservation
Partial or Total Renovation or Companble Addition
Ctizrb Appeal
Please include a brief description of why this home should be considered for a
prsservation
award.
�
If known, pl.ease mclude a brief ]vstory of this
property.
Naminated
by:
i
�xti�b��- A
F �� ����s�'��������!������1�!������J�;��ig�� ��'���������s�i � ����o�►��'Q� �i'ii�► 0 �� ����e'► ��°��'►J�e����i � ��et �'�
� � ��������n�Pn�ln��n�lnl�nl9n!ln1En1►nlPn�an1ln�lnf � �6
��� ��� � � � ���'� �� �'P� ���'�? ���'�� (� �'�� �z� �'>� ��� 9'�? ��� �'�� ��� �'>� <<0'>� (� 4'>? ��1 '�> �� �'>� E�` �'�� � �� 1 '>> ��� 1 'r? , � ���
�'�� �� ��, ` �� ' tk. -. �� E► I1 !! �! ' E! 1► � I► I! ' �E /► _ I! �
� � � � �
� \� _ _ __ _ _. __ � ._ _ _ _._____ _. .._ _._ _
_ _ _
�C` ��.-0 e �� �
��� � o
�� f��� i • � _>>�e
� � `�� ��' — � �
��i�� , �� '��°
�� �� � � — 01
� • ^
��c-� � � � � ���/
� . . �
� � `'� v o0
� � � � �
��</ �� • • �� ����
�� � v A
� ' �
4���< j�? t � °>�
�� � �
�� v � m
� s
� < �x • �� >>�/
�� '✓ " ��
� ; �
������ � 0 >>_ -,o
� . � � , v ��
�,-� ��� � '^ °—�
6�< �'.� � � �>��
� � �-:� � � ' � 0 °
� ` ° �, s,
� • C 0 � >>��
��� �� � .�.^ � � � ^ �a �
�����. � �e t' � >>��
� ��'"� � x �� � a
� .�* /� �',� � �
��✓ �`w� 1 � ;<`,� „a �' °� `
' < � i • �' '' �� �"" ` � >1��
'� % �� � � �� : � � , �.-n_ � s _
� m -�»� - � ' ; ;-`,�.� "a ^ ��
'..�,✓`= �ai 1 '�.�,"�, , ` `t � » �
�� / �,o � � g si1'� v`r a � �
�:�V\�� • • • � ` ��1�e
��_ �"`P , • \oi o �
��<< �� ' C � >���
�` m.� /�°� � • � t,r ° � �
� • � v
� �
A- 1 �� �
����� � � � s ���
�� � ' � ' °' �'
� � - �
�� ��
� �^ ��
�. << ��� � � � '>��
i � .
�� - � . \ �`- m
�" -� � ' � A � �
�,� � . -^
�_ <<��� � • � �>��
�� ' � ' • ' ''' �
� � � � � � v ° �
�. �`� �.� . � � =>�€
�� :� . ► ' �` m��
Po � � ' � ' � ^
�� �� � � � �>��
� � , � • . .� �
� �, • s �
� � � • A
, -� .
�� ��� ' � ����
� d- �� � �
� �' � ' ^ a �
�� �`�
��� � � ����
�—�y'�-��' � ay��
F ��
�e -�-�
� -�- �
-� � �, _ _ ---- ._ _ _ _ - _ _ _ . � �
_ _ _ --_ _ _ _. _�
& �-. �� � �� . �� ; FA � s � �� FI �I , �� �A � �f !� �P �I : �� �f ��' , �
� � � � ��.� � � �e,�� � ��� � ������� �E-���� �f-���> t���>> t�-�=> �=-o, ��,�,�> � e�-���� t�-���> ��-��>� �f����� �f-o�>> tf-�,,> �� � ��1
� � t�
� � � �� " � �i � /�` �u� � ° v � �v� v �v ° v �v ° v � � ° v v � �v
��,./'S� � a 4 m ti F' !d � � V k� F V V V V V � � V V V g V V ��
� � `�� ����� �,�'.�����, ;�������'� ,`��F���' '�������� :'���P�@ �� ������1 '������� �g�l�� �d�Ei� ������ ���e�� ���0�� ����5��, '������!.' ,���� � °�,��
�� �k j ����.���,�, [��, f� �� ���h ���,�� �� �I�I ������I �o��� �� 11�1���� �!.� � �� c������������ v
� y
�
Steve Hasson
From: Gordon Law
� Sent: Monday, February 03, 2003 9:49 AM
To: Steve Hasson
Cc: Garret Nancolas; Gordon Law; Todd Binford �
Subject: Abandoned Water Boxes ��
�
Dear Steve;
I am in receipt of a letter from Jan Boles (Historic Preservation Commission) asking government agencies to cooperate in
the removal of abandoned irrigation boxes. You had forewarned me the letter was coming. Please convey to Jan our
appreciation for the commission taking a positive position on this issue. The City Engineer agrees with the commission's
conclusions the boxes are "blighted" and "hazardous eyesores".
Let me make a couple of observations concerning the boxes. The boxes were, and are, owned by the Caldwell Lateral
Irrigation District. At the time the district converted to a pressure system, the city placed a condition on them to remove the
abandoned boxes as a condition for working in public right-of-way. The district has not yet fulfilled the condition. The city
has no plans to take the district to court to force compliance nor does the city intend to "assume" ownership of the boxes.
We presume the district will honorably fulfill their earlier promises to the city.
Whenever the city conducts a project adjacent to one of these boxes, the city will remove the box as part of the project.
For instance, the city has a concrete replacement LID in which city residents may elect to enroll. If a property owner
adjacent to an intersection, with a box, joins the LID, the city will remove the box at city expense. In this way the residents
of the Historic District can control the timing of box removal. Additionally, the city will pay 25% of the concrete replacement
cost. Any residents with interest in this program may enroll or obtain further information by contacting Todd Binford at 455-
3006.
Sincerely,
• Gordon Law (City Engineer)
.
�
F'�rti�l�;�- l