HomeMy WebLinkAbout1-8-2003 CHPC MINUTES r
HISTORIC PRESERVATION COMMISSION
� MINUTES
January 8, 2003
Caldwell Public Library
I. Call to Order:
Jan Boles, Chairman, called the meeting to order at 7:10 p.m.
II. Roll CaIL
Members Present: Jan Boles, Chairman; Elaine Carpenter, Elaine Leppert, Betty Jo
Keller, Tom Ensley, Anita Shore, Josephine & Joe Masar and Chuck Randolph
Members Absent: Ken Eytchison, and Steve Maughan
City Staff: Steve Hasson, Community Development Director, and Jacqueline Hernandez
Approval of Agenda
MOTION/Jan Boles, SECOND/Betty Jo Keller. Accept the agenda as presented.
Passed.
III. Approval of Minutes:
MOTION/Elaine Carpenter, SECOND/Josephine Masar. Accept the minutes of
November 13, 2002 as received. Passed.
IV. Old Business
• A. Annual CHPC Award (Exhibit A)
Elaine provided a nomination form for the historic district award. It was noted the
Josephine Masar would work on a format to present at the next meeting. Jan agreed
to take photos of the nominated homes. Elaine C. suggested the award to consist of
a newspaper article in and/or a plaque award. The committee requested ideas for a
name to include on the plaque.
VI. New Business
A. Certificate of Appropriateness Interview:
The applicants, Joe and Josephine Masar, presented their application for a �
Certificate of A ppropriateness r equest t o add a g arage a nd s ome a dditions t o t he
interior of the home.
The applicants would like to go forward with the building plans for a double garage at
this time and build the 2-story addition at a later time. The applicants voiced a
concern if there was a time limit on the building permit? If so, how long would the
plans be permitted? Steve Hasson, Community Development Director, commented
there is no time limit on building plans.
Community Development Staff will design a Certificate of Appropriateness form. This
form will be distributed to applicants receiving the C of A approval. Jacqueline will
bring ideas to the next meeting.
, MOTION: Commissioner Elaine Leppert. SECOND: Commissioner Anita Shore.
The Commission approved the Certificate of Appropriateness for Mr. & Mrs. Masar.
The Commission stated that appeals would the made to the City Council as per the
process stated in the Zoning Ordinance. Passed: Unanimous roll call vote.
• B. Notification Process for Certificate of Appropriateness:
Due to the absence of Debbie Geyer, Jacqueline Hernandez reported the Idaho
Status for Preservation of Historic Sites document states that a public hearing MAY
be conducted when Certificates of Appropriateness are considered before any
Historic Preservation Commission.
Jackie reported that in the recent case of the LDS Church parking lot located in the
Steunenberg Residential Historic D istrict, t he P&Z Commission h ad r ecommended
denial of the rezone and special use permit applications. Jackie reported that a
neighbor had brought in a petition to the public hearing and made the point that she
would have opposed this plan to the CHPC if she had been aware of their meeting on
this issue.
Discussion followed concerning how notification would be conducted.
MOTION: Commissioner Elaine Leppert. SECOND: Commissioner Tom Ensley.
Person(s) requesting a Certificate of Appropriateness with the CHPC would be
responsible for posting a notification form, supplied by the Community Development
Department, on their property seven (7) prior to hearing. Passed.
C. CLG Funding:
Due to the absence of Debbie Geyer, Jacqueline Hernandez gave an update
concerning the CLG Funding. The Commission was informed that CLG funds would
be delayed until approximately February 1, 2003. The total funding would be as
� follows: $3,000 dollars from CLG grants and Planning & Zoning would match with
$1,000 for a total spending of $4,000 dollars. In-kind match would equate to the
remaining $2,000 needed.
D. Irrigation Boxes Located Within the Local District:
It was suggested that the irrigation boxes be removed out of the Steunenberg
Residential Historic District. Discussion followed. It was determined that the
irrigation boxes were a visual nuisance and a safety hazard for the City of Caldwell.
Chuck Randolph suggested a letter be sent to the City concerning this issue.
MOTION: Commissioner Tom Ensley. SECOND: Commissioner Chuck Randolph
A letter be sent from Jan Boles, Chairman, in behalf of the CHPC concerning the
removal of the irrigation boxes in the Steunenberg Residential Historic District. The
letter should be addressed to Mayor Nancolas, City Council members, Caldwell
Lateral Irrigation District, and Gordon Law. Passed.
E. Date Conflict with 2003 Meetings
Due to the conflict of the Planning & Zoning pubic hearings being scheduled on the
same night as the CHPC meeting, it was determined that the current monthly
meeting date must be changed.
MOTION: Commissioner Elaine Leppert. SECOND: Commissioner Josephine Masar.
Reschedule the monthly meeting to the third Thursday of the month beginning
� February 20 at 6:OOpm. Passed.
F. Tree Determination in Backyards
Steve Hasson, Community Development Director, asked the members if there were
concerns if a resident within the Steunenberg Residential Historical District were to
• cut a tree in their back yard? In response to the question, the Commission
determined there was no concern as to tree removal in back yards within the District.
Discussion was held concerning restoration of the Cleveland and Blaine tree canopy.
It was determined that Jan Boles would write a letter to the Mayor and City Council
addressing the Commission's concerns regarding this issue.
Chuck Randolph stated his desire to have some guidance for sick trees.
G. Depot Update: '
Steve Hasson, Community Development Director, gave an update of Debbie Geyer's
efforts of obtaining grant monies for the Train Depot. It was reported that the Urban
Renewal Agency had approved the following requests: 1) $50,000 for immediate
repairs to the train depot roof; and 2) $55,000 matching funds regarding the
Transportation Department (T-21) grant. Appreciation was expressed to Debbie for
her outstanding efforts.
VIII Adjournment
The meeting was adjourned at 8:55 p.m.
Respectfully submitted,
• Jacqueline Hernandez
Recording Secretary
ATTEST .�D�O:
�� �
Sig�`ed: �
( Ja �Boles, Chairman
Date: J �/ � 3
.
!
t s ,,,, �+ �
CEQIiia VG��
� From: Elaine earpenter jdoretti t�e�r`chiink�teij
e�::. Satu� Decem�r 28, 2t3G2 8:bz's r�M
�o: ,1oey Masar
Su���ct: Nistar�c A.vvacd
Hi, JaeV,
b�1e have t3}�9i1 t�'12 wE2.: Gff 't,etween C:�'i2'1SLTi�S dIl�: NcW Yc"'d�5 dI7C1 li. L'id5 311G:nic :-� .� y���_�
t1TCL' tU ���3t�2�.
t19�2 1S a rough OLI� OFl a�.ominaticn tOr'ii'� tOZ' Oi1Z' i11a�Or1C dS�icerE''�., Y=c���% SiTef.�_2 �:s =.
open to ideas that you �a? have crn�.e up witn.
i3ominaticr� form �cr :r.ard
°�arsared b_y the Ca�cvaell Historic preserva�ion Cc.�LL.�issicn
iiOC^caL2.Ci2 Ci YZC`iii8:
11'v'vTiE� .^ y :
�hi., home has �CCil
� ; Niodiii�l :�estore� cz rezl•�zra�e:+ _:...entlsT yes --�
2) Aaiut�d recz��iy yes r�c
Ji '.'VCVd 1....:.r.'2SCGt;�L(yr� O�' �.?.f:Cib...��;.;' :::OC.'t1�1:.�� � ---„ T
iC;2i 1 � t0
brief G25CZ'1�7L10.^� Of VJ��'Ia t �IS t'iOL�2 SiGu�C2 t Jc CC �sidered iCT i..�15 c.V�a� :. ( �i.i :QS L�:c�
:aCal:�� =� �±� . • - � - ' - -- - = - - '
� .'._-iis'�LIL-�C< .i�E�': ����`a'�4att4.'k��jT i3�4:::1��:_i�'c�' ���4,FItc# <�Fi�Ft1CJt t�_i�'ri��ii'�� �Fi'r�r��t
attentiez: te c�re azicz r.:ai�itaiz�inc� t �e �;ro�:e� W�.� ?:em� ::ver t�..;. ,
nt�.ac�. Fh��c :
�
�
�Xh�b� /�