Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout10-11-2011 P&Z MINUTES CALDWELL PLANNING AND ZONTNG COMMISSION ' ' MINUTES :8'; q t � - October 11, 2011 =� � ,- I. Call to Order — Chairperson Scholz called the meeting to order for the public hearing at 7:00 p.m. II. Roll Cali — Members Present: Ken Scholz, Ed Doty-Pomoransky, Dat�a Va.nce, David C1ark and Arvid Salisbury Disclasures and Conflicts of Interest: None Members Absent: None Staff Present: Anne Marie Skinner (Seniar Planner/Development Team Leader); I Robb MacDonald (Assistant City Engineer); April Cabello (Planning Teclmician); Aaron Seable (City Attor»ey) StaffAbsent: Brian Billingsley (Planning and Zoning Director} Review of Proceeding — Chairperson Scholz anliounced the procedures for the public I�earing. III. Old .Business A. Approve minutes of August 9, 2011 regular meeting MOTION: Commissioner Clark SECOND: Commissioner poty-Pomoransky Passed: Unanimous roll call vote. IV. New Business A. Case Number VAR-3'7-11 a request by Darigold Inc. for a street side yard setback variance from the required setback of 20 feet on property located at the northwesterly corner of Albany Street and 6` Avenue identified as Tax Parcel #R05159 and addressed as 520 Albany Street. Testimony: 1) Anne Marie Skinner, 621 Cleveland Blvd., Caldwell, ID 83605, Senior Planner/Development Team Leader, presented the staff report and gave the name of the applicandowner, location of the project, zoning and comprehensive plan map designations of the project and surrounding uses and zones. 1 P&Z Minutes 10/11/2011 _ 2) Ms. Skinner read the five criteria, as listed in Section 5 of the staff report, which must be found to be true for the Commission to approve the variance. � ' Ms. Skinner stated that all applicable public agencies were notified and no comments were received with the exception of Police Code Enforcement who stated there were no open code violation cases against the site. 3) Ms. Skinner concluded that staff had reviewed the five criteria and found them to be true and recommended approval of the variance. 4) Chairperson Scholz asked Ms. Skinner to outline the location of the proposed new silo. 5) Ms. Skinner referred to pictures from the case file labeled as SP-12 to show Chairperson Scholz the location of the proposed silo. 6) Chairperson Scholz wondered about the existing silos. 7) Ms. Skinner explained that a variance was granted in 2008 for the two existing silos. , 8) Nathan Carlson, 1130 Rainier Ave. S., Seattle, WA, 98144, Applicant, '� reiterated that Darigold is asking for a variance from the street side yard ' setback to allow for placement of an additional silo to be able to increase � production of butter on the site. Given the size constraints of the boundaries of the site, there is no other location to place the silo. The utilities are already in place at the proposed location. Where the plant physically sits, there is no room left so this is the only logical place left to place the new silo. 9) Mr. Carlson referenced the drawing from the case file labeled as A-3 to point out to the Commissioners the location of the new silo. 10) Commissioner poty-Pomoransky wondered if the new silo would be like the other two silos. 11) Mr. Carlson responded it would be like the larger of the two existing silos. 12) Commissioner poty-Pomoransky wondered if the new silo would increase the traffic at the site. 13) Mr. Carlson responded there might be an additional truck or two more per day but nothing significant. 14) Public testimony was closed. MOTION TO C.LOSE TESTIMONY: Commissioner Vance SECOND: Commissioner poty- Pomoransky Passed: Unanimous roll call vote. Evidence List for Case Number VAR-37-11 - Consisted ofthe case file, the written and verbal staff reports, tl.i.e sign-up sheets and �xhibit FZ-1000 (aerial photo ofthe site submitted by Anne Marie Skinner). MOTION: Co�nmissioner Vance SECOND: Commissioner Clark Passed: Unanimous rolt call vote. Findings of Fact for Case Number VAR-37-11— All five variance criteria were found to be true. NIOTION: Commissio»er Vance SECOND: Commissioner Clark Passed: Unanimous roll call vote. Conclusions of Law for Case Number VAR-37-11-1VIOT10N: Commissioner Salisbury SECOND: Commissioner Vance Passed: Unanimous roll call vote. Order of Decision on Case Number VAR-37-1.1 — MOT10N: Commissioner Vance SECOND: Commissioner Clark. The Commissian voted unanimously to Approve the variance request with no conditions. 2 P&Z Minutes 10/11/2011 . B. Case Number ZON-75-11 a request by Your Real Estate Solutions LLC for a comprehensive plan map change from Commercial to Traditional Neighborhood and a � ' rezone from R-3 High Density Residential and G2 Community Commercial to T-N Traditional Neighborhood on 0.34 acres addressed as 90$ East Chicago identified as Tax Parcel #R04806 and a comprehensive plan map change from Commercial to Traditional Neighborhood and a rezone from R-3 High Density Residential to Traditional Neighborhood on 0.21 acres addressed as 904 East Chicago identified as Tax Parcel #R04807. Testimony: 1) Anne Marie Skinner, 621 Cleveland Blvd., Caldwell, ID 83605, Senior Planner/Development Team Leader, presented the staff report and gave the name of the applicandowner, location of the project, zoning and comprehensive plan map designations of the project and surrounding uses and zones, as well as explaining the request. 2) Ms. Skinner stated that all of the applicable agencies were notified of the request and no comments were received. Ms. Skinner stated she would stand for questions. 3) Commissioner Clark wondered why Ms. Skinner, in her verbal staff report, hadn't mentioned the proposed use of 908 East Chicago as a restaurant. 4) Ms. Skinner replied she did not mention the proposed use because the proposed use or uses are not pertinent to the rezone request. Proposed uses should not be used in consideration of approving or denying rezone requests. 5) Commissioner Clark wondered if a restaurant was allowed in an R-3 zone. 6) Ms. Skinner reiterated that the parcel addressed as 908 East Chicago has a split zoning. The bare half of the parcel is zoned C-2. The oth'er half of that same parcel is zoned R-3. The applicant is requesting to rezone the entire parcel to one zone — that zone being Traditional Neighborhood. At the same time, since the applicant owns the adjacent parcel, the applicant is also requesting rezone to Traditional Neighborhood of said adjacent parcel as well. The Traditional Neighborhood zone is a mix of neighborhood uses that one would want to see in a traditional neighborhood setting such as low, medium and high intensity residential and low-intensity commercial uses such as a gift shop or a restaurant or a bed and breakfast or a boutique or a hair salon. 7) Commissioner Clark wondered about staff's recommendation. 8) Ms. Skinner replied that staff recommends approval of this request based upon surrounding existing uses which are very mixed. Additionally, this is also part of the section of town that staff is looking at to rezone to Traditional Neighborhood anyway. 9) Commissioner Vance confirmed that staffls proposed rezone had not happened as of yet and wondered when that would potentially happen. 10) Ms. Skinner replied staff would be working on that potential rezone in the spring depending upon public workshops and property owner reactions. 11) Troy Ashworth, 6568 S. Federal Way, Ste. 168, Boise, ID 83716, Applicant, pointed out to the Commissioners the two surrounding restaurants and the overflow parking lot for one of those restaurants. He is hoping to obtain a zoning that gives flexibility to do something with the property. Right now the house is really run-down and is an eyesore. A rezone would allow the properiy owner to do something with the sight. A preliminary round table meeting has already been held with city staff regarding the use of the property as a restaurant with pertinent parking requirements. 3 P&Z Minutes 10/11/2011 _ 12) Chairperson Scholz wondered about the two vacant houses on 904 E. Chicago. � ' 13) Mr. Ashworth responded that there is an old Victorian on 908 E. Chicago to which nothing has been done as of yet. On 904 E. Chicago there is also an old Victorian which has been used as a triplex and they're in the process of renovating to continue its use as a triplex. The back building on 904 E. Chicago has had no renovations as of yet, but the plan is to convert that from a triplex to a duplex. 14) Chairperson Scholz wondered about the location of the buildings. 15) Mr. Ashworth pointed to the location of the buildings on Exhibit PZ-1000. They would like to have the option of using 908 E. Chicago as a restaurant or as residential. They're thinking the restaurant should work however. 16) Public testimony was closed. MOTION TO CLCISE TESTIIVIONY: Chairperson Salisbury SECOND: Commissioner Vance Passed: Unanimous roll call vote. Evidence List for Case Number ZON-75-11- Consisted of the case file, the written and verbal staff reports, the sign-up sheets and Exhibit PZ-1000 (aerial photo of the site submitted by Anne Marie Skinner). MQTION: Commissioner V�u�ce S�COND: Chairperson Clark Passed: Unanimous roll call vote. Comprehensive Plan Analysis — MOTION: Commissioner Vance SECOND: Commissioner Clark Passed: Unanimous roll call vate. Findings of Fact for Case Nunnber ZON-75-11— MOTION: Commissionec Vance SECOND: Comulissioner Clark Passed: Unanimous roll call vote. Conclusions of Law for Case Number ZON-75-11— MOTION: Commissioner Satisbury SECOND: Commissioner Clark 1'assed: Unanimous roll call vote. Recommendation on Case Number ZON-75-11 — IVIUTION: Commissioner poty-Pomoransky SECOND: Commissioner Clark. The Commission voted unaniitlously to recommend Approval with the foliawing conditions: • Items 8.2 through 8.3 C. Case Number ZON-77-11 a request by Jose Rojas, David Rojas and Mike Fairchild for a comprehensive plan map change from Industrial to Commercial and a rezone from M-1 Light Industrial to C-3 Service Commercial on 1.62 acres addressed as 623 Albany Street identified as Tax Parcel #R05060. Testimony: ]) Anne Marie Skinner, 621 Cleveland Blvd., Caldwell, ID 83605, Senior Planner/Development Team Leader, presented the staff report and gave the name of the applicant/owner and project architect, location of the project as identified on Exhibit PZ-1000 (aerial photo of the site submitted by Anne Marie Skinner), 4 P&Z Minutes 10/11/2011 _ zoning and comprehensive plan map designations of the project and surrounding uses and zones. ' 2) Ms. Skinner referred Commissioners to an e�ibit from the case file identified as SP-13, which is a map given to the Commissioners in their packets, to identify all , of the surrounding uses. Ms. Skinner further stated that the larger surrounding ' area of the subject property is an area that City staff is considering to rezone to , Traditional Neighborhood pending public workshops and responses from ', property owners. '' 3) Ms. Skinner stated that all applicable public agencies were notified. The Police Code Enforcement Department responded that there are no outstanding code violations on the site. The Mapping/Engineering Department responded with a request to require a sewer easement to the City of Caldwell to cover an existing sewer line. That request has been added as a condition of approval. 4) Ms. Skinner reminded the Commissioners that the request is a rezone request and the proposed use within that rezone is not relevant to the request. The Commissioners are looking at the proposed zone, the surrounding uses and the surrounding zones. The Commissioners give a recommendation only and that recommendation is forwarded to City Council for the final decision. 5) Chairperson Scholz wondered if this was the old lumberyard. 6) Ms. Skinner confirmed that it is the site of the former Irrigators Lumberyard and thought it had been vacant for about ten years. Ms. Skinner stated the present owners purchased the properly in 2007 from Steven Gregory. 7) Commissioner Clark wondered if the lumberyard was an industrial use. 8) Ms. Skinner confirtned that a lumberyard is an allowed use in an industrial zone and further explained the main difference between industrial and commercial is that retail is allowed in a commercial zone where it is not allowed in an industrial zone. Many of the uses permitted in an industrial zone overlap and are also permitted in a commercial zone and vice versa. However, retail is one of those that doesn't overlap and is only permitted in a commercial zone. Manufacturing, recycling plants, fabrication are examples of uses only permitted in an industrial zone. 9) Commissioner Vance stated that Irrigators Lumberyard was retail. 10) Ms. Skinner clarified that, while they sold lumber, they were actually classified as a lumberyard which is a different classification than retail sales. 1 1) Chairperson Scholz wondered what staff considered the classification of A-Gem Electronics across the street. 12} Ms. Skinner stated A-Gem falls under a retail classification. 13) Chairperson Scholz wondered about the nearest zone equivalent to tlie proposed use. 14) Ms. Skinner explained that immediately adjacent to the subject property across 7` Avenue to the east is all zoned C-2 Community Commercial which is where A-Gem is located. 15) In response to Chairperson Scholz's queiy on up- or down-zoning, Ms. Skiiiner stated that typically commercial uses are considered less intensive than industrial uses. 16) Commissioner Vance wondered about the eaisting parcels and tlieir existin� zones ai�d if tl�ey've achieved those zoning desi�nati.ons over time. 5 P&Z Minutes 10l11/2011 _ 17) Ms. S1<iru�er explained the zoni»g l�istory of the subject pr°operry and surrot�ndinb area as dating back to tl�e ariginal zoning inap af 1977. In respoa�se to a special ' use permit case a few months ago that was heard by the Hearing Faaminer, Ms. Skinner researched the zoning of the entire area. Even though the entire area is made up of a myriad of uses including l�ouses, duplexes, triple�es, and apartment buildings, as well as commercial and indlistrial uses, the area was giveu an M-1 Light Industrial zoning designation in 1977 and it's been that zone ever since. The division between M-1 Light Industrial and C-2 Community Commercial occurs at 7`�' Avenue which area has also been zoned commercial since 1977. Again, the G2 Community Comulercial zoned area has a myriad of uses including mixed residential, restaurants and retail. Ms. Skinner had no ki�owledge as ta �vhy M-I and G2 zoning designations were cl7osen for a�•eas that llad such a mixture of estaUlished uses, including residential. 18) Commissioner Clark felt this request could be considered a rem.edy uiltil the entire area is rezoned. l9) Ms. Skiuner responded, in staff's opinion, that is the case. Staf.f will probably recommend a portion of the surrounding area to be rezoned to R-3, but the area '' immediately surrounding the subject praperty wi(1 be recommended to be rezoned to Traditional Neighborhood to allow for the mixture of retail and residential uses already in exrstei�ce. 20) Commissioner Clark. wondered if the subject property would ever be considered for residential purposes. 21 } Ms. Skiimer responded t11at she didn't think so because of its proximity to Darigold. 22) Commissioner Salisbury felt this was probably the best "band aid" to be relative to all otl�er uses ii.� the area. 23) Ms. Skinner responded that, in staff's opinion, and Uased upon the comprehensive plan analysis and tl�e mix of surrounding uses, that a commercial zone was most appropriate for the site. However, other people could have differing opinions. 24) Commissioner Vance stated they ���ould have to hear the rest of the testimony. 25) Mike Faircl�ild, 13155 Gail-Alan Rd., Donnelly, ID 83615, Applicant's Representative, spoke in favor of the application as the applicant's represezitative. Mr. I'airchild stated the applicant/ownec is requesting a change in the comprehensive plan map from industrial to commercial and a rezone from M-1 Light Industrial to C-3 Service Commercial on 1.62 acres at tl�e cori�er of 7`�' and Albany. 26) Mr. Fairchild further stated tl�e desire is to open a retail business in the main building at the corner of 7`�' and Albany and tl.ie rest of the site will rernain as is for now. Additionally, he stated the requiremei�t for the easement is not a problem. 27) Commissioner Salisbury clari�ed that Mr. rairchild was refecring to the sewer � easement. 28) Mr. Fairchi(d stated he was. 29) Commissiouer poty-Pomoransky wondered whether or not the existing buildings on Belmont would stay. 30) Mr. T'airellild stated they would stay. 6 P&Z Minutes 10/11/2011 _ 31) Chairperson Scholz wondered about plans for the eaisting improvements. � 32) Conlmissio��ier Clark remit�ded the Cotnmission. that the decision tonight I�ad '�, ' i�othi��g to do with the use of t.he site, rather tonigtlt's dec�isio�n pei�tains to the � zone aiid that it doesn't really matter what they're proposing to do as Iong as it fits within the zone of the property. 3�) Kaye Angert, 704 F.,. Belmont, Caldwell, ID 836Q5, spoke in opposition ofthe req uest. 34) Ms. Angert referred to Exhibit P7.-1000 and pointed out the site of her residence. 35) Ms. Angert stated her first itern of concern was that it was zoned M-] Light Industrial when they purcl�ased tl}e propei so they must have a change in mind that they didn't have when they bought tl�e property. She stated it has been rented out, until recently, as a place to manufacture canvas coverings. 36} Ms. Angert is concerned about not having a plan to go forward. She stated the block to the east is a lot of residential and her house is well over 100 years old. 37) Ms. Angert stated she would like to have it t•emain a quiet neighborhood and not have it changed to a high-traffic pattern_ The property was purchased under an M-1 zon'►ng and she doesn't see any reason why it should c;hange as it was zoned that way for a particular reason and it tits in with the rest of the block. 38) Ms. Angert felt there are a lot of other properties i.n the City that are zoned for the purposes which the applicant/owner intends. 39) Commissioner Clark wondered if Ms. Angert was suggesting the site remaii�. empty and/or what would she do with the site if it were her property. 40) Ms. Angert stated the praperty has definitely gone downhill since the closure of the I�unberyard and she is not recommeilding that it stay empty but sl�e is recom:mending that it stay as something compatible with the people already there. 41) Ms. Angert stated it's a dead-end street, with relatively little traffic, except the Dari.gald trucks. She stated both 5'�' Avenue and Kimball are wel.l-traveled roads and the applicant/owner would get more benefit out of l�aving a convenience store on either 5'"' or Kimball rather than having it at a dead-end street surrounded by nothing. She stated it doesn' make sense to allow a comrnercial building to go i�nto the site and that manufacturiilg does not rely upoi�i traffic like a retail establishment. 42) Commissioner Clark stated he respected her opinion, that l�e's lived here since 1978 and, more specifically, was here when [rrigators Lumberyard was in full swing and Darigold was in full swing and there was a pretty good amount of traffic in the area as he used to shop there with his family. He remembers the neighbarhood working rather well together with the lumber store thece and Darigold and that Darigold did and does produce a considerable amount of traffic. He wondered wliat the difference is between then and now. 43) Ms. Angert responded that it was her understanding the applicant/owner is intending upoi� opening a store in the location. She stated a conven.ience store has a lot of in-and-out traffic. The trucks trom Darigold aren't doing any stopping, rather they are just in and oiit. Iri•igators did a lot of work witll contractors where they didn't have a whole lot of people coming in and shopping. 44) Ms. Angert further stated she was concerned about parking and her abi(ity to park. 7 P&Z Minutes 10/11/2011 _ 45) Commissioner Clark wondered how long Ms. Angert has i•esided at 704 E. Belmont. ' � 46) Ms. Angert respo►lded tl�at she has lived off and on at 704 E. Bel:mont since 1986. 47) Cammissioner SaIisbury stated that he, too, reinembers quite a bit of traffic when both Irrigator's and Darigold were in fiil] operation. He respects Ms. Angert's views, but feels that th.ece has been yuite a reduction in the amoi,u�t of traffic since the closure of Irrigator's and Ms. Angert has gotten used to the reduced amount of traftic. 48) Commissioner Salisbury further stated there are additional processes the applicant/owner has to go through when a use is actualiy determined and tonight's reconrmendation only pertains to the zone. 49) Ms. Angert asked the Commissioners why the applicant/owner purchased the property as aia M-1 zane and tl�en decided to rezone it. 50} Commissioner Salisbury answered Ms. Angert and told her that was a question ', the Commissioners couldn't answer. 51) Chairperson Scholz asked Ms. Skinner about tonight's hearing in that essentially ' it was two phases with the first phase Ueing the rezoning of the property and the '� second phase being the actual use of the property withi�� that new zone. 52) Ms. Skinner replied that the Commissioners really need to consider whether or I not the requested zone i.s an appropi�iate zone in this location based upon the ' surrounding zoi�es and the surrounding uses. 53) Chairperson Scholz thanked Ms. Skinner and stated that was exactly what he was trying to point out — tl}at the Commission's focus this evening was solely on the zoning. � 54) Ms. Skinner explaiued that anything permitted outriglit iu an M- t zone the applicant could currently undertake with just a Change in Use application and he would not have to seek a��y other approval beyond that. If the rezone is approved to Commercial, then the applicant can do anything that is permitted outright in a commercial zo�ie provided he obtains the appropriate Change in Use permit and rneet all of the requirements associated with that Change cn Use. The Change in Use process is the same for eitlaer zone. 55) Kei� Norris, 710 E. Belmo�it, Caldwell, ID 83605, spoke in opposition of the application. Ms. Norris ceferred to �xhibit PZ-] 000 and pointed out the location of her house and that she has resided there for 17 years. Ms. Norris further stated her house was built in 1880. 56) Ms. Norris stated she is opposed because they want to change it from industrial to commercial and she is concerued about pat•king. She does not want people parking in front of her l�ouse and stopping her from parking in front of her house. She is further opposed because, as Ms. Angert stated, where are they going to park? 57) Ms. Norris stated this is a dead-end street and no oi�e is going to �vant to drive down a dead-end sti•eet to buy a carton of milk when they can go to King's in the midd(e of town and get some other things around that area and do a one-stap shopping rather than l�aving to drive all over with the way the price of gas is now. 8 P&Z Minutes 10/11/2011 58) Conunissioner Va.nce said that, with the current zoning, the app(ic�nt could choose to place a mobile home park or sonlething less desirable ttlan a store ' accoss the street fcom Ms. Norris and would that be something Ms. Norris would desire? 59) Ms. Norris stated a mobile home park would be more residential with more homes and �nore families and inore nei�hbors that she would be able to visit with. Sl�e is concerned with tl�e traffic from Dai�ymen's, that the trucks do not stop. If a child or an older person is coming out of the convenience store and Dairymen's doesn't stop and the truck hits the chilcl or older person, that is going to cause a problem. If a child runs out from mom's hands and Dairymen's hits the child and the child jets killed that is going to cause a problem. 60) Comulissioner Vance said that with an industrial zone there could be ma»y uses that could be less desirable than. a convenience store. Additionally, the Commission is not addressing the use tanight, rather just the zone, and ���hen the use is decided, parking will l�ave to be addressed. 61) Ms. Norris was fucther concerned that making the site a convenience store or a �i retail store would lead to the applicai�t obtaining a license to sell beer and wine and tur»ing it i�ito a"h.00p-de-doo" place and a"ladies of flie evening" place and just stretching it a little bit more into a beer and wine joint. 62) Commissioner poty-Pomoransky stated that there were additiona) processes that the applica�lt would liave to go through before any of the aforementioned uses could take place. 63) Chairperson Scholz explained to Ms. Norris that lie liked tl�e request because this was an "up-zone" and the other option was for Darigold to eapand its operation. and pl.ace silos, trucks, noise and traf.fic at the site. He feels the change to co�nmercial is closer to resideiitial and feels that the request is a more favorable move for the surrounding resicients. He feels the applicant is lookiug to create more of a neighborhood environment and he is a bit confused by the opposition. 64} Ms. Norris responded that she doesn't feel that a commercial zone is upgrading. She stated she feels tl.1e applicant's intention is just to i►nprove the main building and what about all tlie other junky buitdings on the site. She feels all the other buildings should be torn down and made into a parking lot. 65) Ms. Norris's other thought is that tl�e site is at a dead-end street when there are empty buildings in to��n that are more feasible and more centrally located. 66} Commissiouer poty-Pomoransky stated the parking issue would be addressed in the additional process the applicant has to go through and that Ms. Norris could express her opinion again in that later process. 67) Chairperson Scl�olz wondered what Ms. Norris would propose to be located on the site. He stated the site has an empty building in a semi-blighted area that the applicant wants to beautiiy and use ta create joUs and, if not this, then what would she propose? 68) Ms. Norris suggested a dayeare center, a boutique, a trainiiig center, a school like CWI or a vocational scl�ool witli hands-on learning like how to fix small engines or Ilow to sl�oe a horse. 69) Ms. Skinner wai�ted to clarify a few items regarding peitinitted and special uses. Ms. Skinner stated that some of the uses suggested are allowed i.n both an industrial and a commercial zone. For instai.�ce, the daycare center is al[owed in 9 P&Z Minutes 10/11/2011 _ botl� and a vocational center or schooi is allo«�ed in both so the change in zone i does not affect any of tl�ose uses. Those uses would require approval of a special '�� ' use permit regardless af being zoned iiidustrial or commercial, which would require a public hearing. 70) Additionally, Ms. Skin.ner clarified beer and alcollol periYiitting processes. There are two differeilt types of beer and alcol�ol use. Stores that sell closed containers of beer and wir�e are an allowed use in ce� zones and tlaey have to obtain tlze appropriate licensure through the State of Idaho and the City Clerk. Ho�uever, establishments that sell liquor by the glass, such as bars, are permitted only with an approval special use permit that requires a public hearing — and bars are allowed ii} either an industrial or a commercial zone if special use permit is received; therefore, if the applicai�t wanted to open a bar, he wauld not have to rezone to commercial, rather he would have to obtain special use permit approval and then obtain the appropriate licensure through the State of Idaho and tlie City Clerk. 71) Ms. Skinner furtlier expl.ained that all uses have a requirement for off-street parking. Said off-street parking requirernent has to be met prior to issuance of a Certificate of Occupancy. Tl.le subject property will have to provide the required off-street parking which will have to be paved and striped with appropriate signage and ADA accessible parking — regardless of the use and regardless of the zone. 72) Chairperson Scholz assured Ms. Norris that the Coinmissioners alJ Iive here and we're all conceriied witl� tlie welfare of the City and the compi•ehensive plan. He stated this area af town is a"mish-mash" of uses and tl�e City is trying to create some consistency and semblance of order. He is concerned about the community and wl�ere it is going and we are currei.�tly experiencing a problem witl� growth and we are trying to brina jobs back to our community and make it vi.brant aiid a nicer place to live. We're all trying to do what's best for the coinmunity. 73) Jessica Perkiiis, 716 �. Belmont, Caldwell, ID 83605, signed in opposition of the request. Ms. Perkins stated this was the first time she had ever attended a meeting such as this one and, after heari.ng the previous testimony a��d discussion, she feels her concerns will be addressed in the second phase. She understands that toniglrt's hearing is just about zoning and her concerns are regarding the use, which will. be addressed in the second phase and she will be back for the second phase. 74) Commissioner Vance thanked her far attending. 75) Commissioiler poty-Pomoransky assured her she would receive notices of the second phase. 76) Ms. Skinner clarified to the Commission aud the audience that uses permitted outright do not require any public hearings, therefore there won't be any notices. Tl�.e only time tliere is a uotice se�1t out is if the use requires a special use pecmit approval because special use permit approvals require a public hearing. On the land use chart, if there is a"P" next to the use, then the use is permitted outrigllt and a public hearing is not required. All the a�plicant has to do is n�ieet the requirements of the building code, fee code, landscaping code, parking code, etc. if tl�e use is pennitted outright. 77} Chairperson Scholz wondered about an insurance office? 1Q P&Z Minutes 10/11/2011 7$} Ms. Sl<inner stated that anything tl�at is permitted outright, sucll as an office-, a. store, a gift shop, a hair salon - all that is needed is to obtain a buildii�g permit ' � ai�d ineet the requirements of the code. However, if the applicant wishes to opeu a daycare center ot• a scl�ool or a bar or a church, then the applica�rt would have to obtain 5pecial use permit approval. 79) Ms. Perkins, after hearing Ms. Skiiuier's clarifications, stated lier concern was with a bar or a nightclub a»d it souncied like property owners would receive notice of such a use. 80) Ms. Skinner confirmed tizat "yes", all property o�vners within 300 feet would receive notice of a public hearing if the applicaiit wislled to open a bar or nightclub. 8I ) Mr. Fairchild, ap�lrcanYs representative, ac(dressed the Commission with rebuttal comments. He stated the applicant plans on upgrading the entire site. There is a requirement for off-street parking ���hich the applrcai�t intends to meet. The applicant does intend to open a retail store, not a bar, and tlie applicant is not trying to fool anybody. 82) Mr. Fairchild further stated that properties next to a commercial zone tend to have a higher value than properties next to an industrial zone. He and tl�e applicant feel the rezone would be an upgrade to the area and the intent is to do ekactly that. 83} Public testi�nony closed. 84) Commissioners discussed the rezone request amongst themselves. Commissioner Clark Uegaii by stating this was a tough case because this particular area oftown is such a mixture of uses with bars, stores, homes, daycares and all sorts of things. At tl�e same time there are property owners w110 own the co�nmercial properties and some of the homes on Qelmont are preriy far away from the subject property. There was testimony regarding beer and wine sales; however, Commissioner Clark stated that four blocks away from the site is Paul's Market where one could obtain all the beer and wine one wants. Commissioner Clark further stated there will be jobs produced with this rezone and feels the request should be approved. 85) Commissioner Vance noted that Neighborhood Commercial is also a viable option for the subject property which would allow for retail — if anyone felt it was way out of line to go with the Service Commeccial. zone. Commissioner Vance did not think the Service Commercial zone request was out of line based upon tlle immediately-adjacent proximity to Community Commercial and Industrial and further reiterated that the Commission makes a recommei.idation only and City Council makes tlle final decision. 86) Commissioner Salisbury stated it was understandable for residen.ts ta not understand the different levels of zoning. He fi�rther stated that the City is not in the business of deciding what business should open on someone's property, that for a b��siness to open so�l�eone needs to have the mea,ns and impetus to open sucli busii�ess. 87) Chairperson Sclaolz stated it appeared to him that this area was the originally- zoned industrial area of Caldwell, but the indush�ial area is now moving to tlie southeast part of Caldwell. The existing buildin�s in this area are part of the "old Caldwell". Chairperson Scholz considers this request an upzone where a pcoblem 11 P&Z Minutes 10/11/2011 is being cori and getting away fi•om tl�e industrial and moving inore towards what a neighborhoad should like. Based upon that pei•spective, lie is in favar of ' � the zoning change. 88) Chairperson Doty-Pomoransky feels the rezone request is consistent with the uses a��d zones in the area. Furtiler, there have been changes in the ordinance tliat will require them to improve the site witll landscap:ing and off-street parking. 89) Commissioner Clark further pointed out that houses have co-existed with coinmercial and i:ndustrial uses in the area for the last 60 years. 90) Chairperson Scholz stated he felt a commercial use is much more appropriate than an industi•ial use right across the street from residential. i MOT10N TO CLOSE TESTIMONY: Commissioner poty-Pomoransl<y SECOND: Commissioner Clark Passed: Unanimous roll call vote. Evidence List for Case Number ZON-77-11 - Consisted of the case file, the written and verba) staff reports, the sign-up sheeis and Exllibit PZ-1000 (aerial �hoto of the site submitted by Anne Marie Skinner). MOTION: Commissioner Vance SECOND: Commissioner poty-Pomoransky Passed: Unanimous roll call vote. ComPrehensive Plan Analysis for Case Number ZON-77-11— MOTION: Commissianer Vance SECOND: Commissioner Clark Passed: Unanimous roll call vote. Findings of Fact for Case Number ZON-77-11 — MOTION: Commissioner Vance SECOND: Commissioner poty-Pomoransky 1'assed: Unanimous roll ca11 vote. Conciusions of Law for Case Number ZON-77-11— IVIUT'ION: Commissioner Salisbury SECOND: Commissioner Clark PassecL• Unanimous roll ca.11 vote. Recommendation on Case Number Z�N-77-11— MOT10N: Cammissioner poty-Pomoransky SECOND: Commissioner Clark. Tl�e Commission voted unanimously to recommend approval with the followiug conditions: � ltems 8.? through 8.4 D. Case Number OA-144-11 a request by the City Engineer/Public Works Director and the City Attorney to amend Chapter 13, Article 1, of Caldwell City Code, regarding storm water management and discharge control. Testimony: 1) Robb MacDonald, 621 Cleveland Bivd., Caldwell, [D 83605, Assistant City Engineer, stated he is representing tlie City Engineer/Public Works Director in this ordinance a�uendment request. Mr. MacDonald stated that Artic(e 1 of Chapter 13 is being replaced with what is before the Commission tonight. 2) Mr. MacDonald stated the reasons for the proposed ordinaiice amendinei�t are the mandates placed upon the City of Caldwell from the Environmental Protection Agency and the requirements the City must fulfil) to maintain the MS4 permit which is the Municipal Storm Sewer System Permit. 3) Mr. MacDonald stated the ardinance has to be codified by December 2l, 2011. This ordinance is the City of Caldwell's Storm Water Management and Discharge 12 P&Z Minutes 10/11/2011 Control Ordinance. Definitions and terms are listed at the beginning of the ordinance. Page 5 outlines the applicability of the ordinance �s being applicable to , ' all storm drain systems within the City of Caldwell boundaries. Page 6 lists general reyuirerl�e»ts and prohibitions. Essentiaily discussed are items that cannot be discharged into the stoi•na drain system, such as herbicides, pesticides, fertil.izers, and fluids fi�om automotive services sucli as car wasl�es and body shops. Also discussed are items of concern such as debris left in alleys or in areas where runoff could be polluting waterways. Leaking of garbage cans and sediment on sidewalks can also cause problems. 4) Mr. MacDonald eaplained there are alsa issues with car wasl�es in parking lots. On certain occasions, these car washes are drained into the sewer system rather than the storm water system. There are additional requirements for spilled contaii�ment systems on Page 7, such as gas stations and automotive repair statians, where a fabric or absorbe��t can be app(ied to keep the spillage from getting into the stonn drains system. Page & lists some exceptions due to flle unusual weather events or emergency discliarges to prevent irnmineni danger to human life which would not be subject to prosecution. Pzge 10 exp(ains liabiiity a�ld responsibility for tl�e discharge. The City is not responsible for discharges, but the City is responsible to police it. Section 13 reviews storm water management plans ai�d comprehensive drainage plans and refers to Caldwell's Stocm VVater Management and Design Manual which is the manual deve(opers are required to design their infrastructure to. 'I'his ordinance applies to any updates and revisions to the Design Manual. Page 13 discusses maintenance of approved storm water facilities as being the responsibility of the developer/property �wner. Page 14 discusses inspection and enforcement. The City inspects newly-constructed siorm water facilities to make sure it �vas constructed per City specifications, but the owner is responsible thereafter for annual inspections of the storm water system to make sure everything is functioning properly. 5) IVIr. MacDonald discussed the enforcement section of the ordinance. `l'his ordinance adds an authorized enforcement agent, who is either the Public VJorks Director or his assignee, who has authority to ask permission to enter a. property to do an inspection, if there is reasonable cause. Written notice cai� be provided to a property owner if the pi•ope� is in violation anci the violation timeline process is outlined. 6) Commissioner Salisbuiy wondered if there was something written into the ordinance to give the violator time to remedy the situation with an investigation. 7) 1VIr. lYlacDonald didn't think there was anything in tl�e ordinance limiting the len��th of an '►nvestigation. The only timing references the wi•itten correspondence. 8) Mr. MacDonald e�cplained the administrative enforce»ient pawers listed on Page 17 and the appeal options available on Page 18. This ordinance gives the City more authority to go after violators. The EPA has these requirements and is requiring the City to enact the same. The City has not added anything over and above what the EPA is requiring. . 9) Commissioner Clark wondered if the ordina»ce was modeled after another one. 10) Aaron Seable, City Attorney, responded that the framework of this ordivance was fi•om the City of Boise, but some of the City of Boise's requiremenis are not listed in the City of Caldwell's ordinance. The City of Caldwell has an interest in not over-regulati�.ig anything, but rather only requiring from th.e citizens what is being required from the City of Caldwell. ].1) Commissionec Clark woi�dered who was making the requirer��ents — if it was the Ef'A or DEQ? 1.2) Lee Van De Bogart, Storm Water Project Engineer, 621 Cleveland Blvd., Caldwell, ID 83E�05, responded that the City of Caldwell has an MS4 permit to discharge waters into the Waters of the United States. To keep tl�is permit and not have it 13 P&Z Minutes 10/11/2011 revoked, we are required to 11ave this ordinance in place. We I�ave written the minimum requirements to l:eep our permit. lf we dan'i pass this ordinance, then .. - EPA can revoke ou.r 1VIS4 permit. l3} Anne Marie Skin»er presented the evidence list as consisting of the written and verbal staff reports, the case file and the sign-up sheet. Comprehensive Plan Analysis on Case Number OA-144-11— MOTION: Commissioner Sa(isbury SECOND: Commissioner poty-I'omoransky 1'assed: Unanimous roll call vote. Recommendation on Case Number OA-144-11— MOTIUN: Comnlissioner Salisbury SECOND: Commissioner poty-Pomoransky. The motion to recommend Approval Passed, with a majority voting in favor: Vance; Doty-Pomoransky; Scholz•, and Salisbury; and, one voting opposed: Clark. -------------------...---- --__.._.-------------------------------._ .............------...--_.__.-----------------._.. I Vl. Planning Issues — A. The ne�t regularly scheduled Planning and Zoning Commission hearing is �� February 14, 2012. ! B. Should Cotnmissioner Clark be elected as a City Councilman, then tonight's hearing will be his last as a planning and zoning commissioner. The first alternate, who is Roger Paige, will become a regular member to serve out the remainder of Commissioner Clark's term. VII. Adjournment The meeting was adjourned at approximately 8:55 p.m. MINUTES A PROVED AND SIGNED BY Cl-[AIRPERSON KEN SCI-IOLZ ON THE DATE NOTED B O . �' _._ _ % � - � Ken Scholz D A1'TEST: Anne l�arie Skinne , nior an e . eanl Leader 14 P&Z Minutes 10/11/2011