HomeMy WebLinkAbout2-8-2011 P&Z MINUTES t •
CALDWELL PLANNING AND ZONING COMMISSION
1VIINUTES �`�� � � � �
� �:aL' a �
_�Y..._
February 8, 2011 �
I. Call to Order— Chairperson Scholz called the meeting to order for the public hearing at
7:U0 p.m.
II. Comments from Mayor Nanculas — Mayor Nancolas unexpectedly stopped by to visit
the Planning and Zoning Commission and give t13em a heartfelt welcome as members of
the Caldwell Planning a»d Zoning Commission. The Mayor expressed both ]�is and City
Council's gratitude to the Commissioners for performing this service and donating tl�eir
time to the community. He further eYpressed the importa.nce of the role of commissioners
and the commission in the planning and zoning process as establisl�ed by state cade. The �
Mayor relayed to the contmissioners that h.is door was ahuays open for questions and
asked that the »ext train.ing session with the commissioners be held jointly witli City
Council, Mark Hilty and Jerome Mapp. The Mayor left tl�e meeting at the conclusion of
his remarks.
III. Ro11 Calt —
Members Present: Ken Scholz, Ed Doty-Pomoransky, Dana Vance, David Clark and Arvid
Salisbuiy.
Disclosures: None
Members Absent: None
StaffPresent: Anne Marie Skinner (Senior Planner/Development Team Leader) and April
Cabello (Planning Technician).
Staff Absent: Brent Orton (Public Works Director), Brian Billingsley (Planning and Zoning
Director).
Review of Proceeding — Chairperson Scholz announced the procedures for the puUlic hearing.
IV. Oid Business
A. Approve minutes of December 14, 2010 meeting as signed by Chairperson Scholz on
December 22, 20I0.
MOTION: Commissioner Clark SECOND: Commissioner poty-Pomoransky.
V. New Business
1
P&Z Minutes
2/8/2011
� �
A. Elect Ken Scholz as chairperson and Ed Doty-Pomoransky as vice-chairperson for
2011.
1VIOTION: Commissioner Clark S�COND: Commissioner Vance Passed: Unanimous
roll call vote.
B. Con�rm appointment of April Cabello as clerk far the P& Z Commissian.
MOTION: Commissioner Vance SECOND: Commissioner poty-Pomoi•ansky Passed:
Unanimous roll call vote.
C. Case Number SUB/PUD-206-11 APP-09-11 a request by Steiner Development LLC
and Mason and Stanfield for the following: planned unit development approval of an
assisted living facility, a multi-family building complex and 100 single-family
residential lots; preliminary plat approval of Canyon Crest Subdivision consisting of
100 single-family residential lots (also being part of the aforementioned planned unit
development); and, amendment to an existing development agreement for the now-
expired Hamilton Estates. The subject property is zoned R-1, consists of approximately
40 acres, and is located on the southeast corner of Florida Avenue and Laster Street.
(THIS HAS BEEN CONTINUED TO MARCH 29, 2011)
D. Case Number OA-139-11 a request by the Caldwell Planning and Zonina Department
to amend the current Caldwell Zoning Map and Official Com.prehensive Plan Map.
Testimony:
1) Anne Marie Skinner, Senior Planner/Development Team Leader, presented
the staff report and submitted the amended Zoning map labeled as e�ibit PZ-
1000 and the Comprehensive Plan map labeled as exhibit PZ-1001. Ms.
Skinner stated the following changes and corrections were made:
ANNEXATIONS: The following zone boundary changes, occurring from annexations,
were approved during the calendar year 2010 and are included in the amended zoning
map:
Name Case Number Ordinance Zone Date of Acreage
Nu�nber Ordinance
Recordation
Mallard Park Annexation ANN-179-09 No. 2813 R-S-2 2/23/2010 29.55
(NE corner of 10�' and
Orchard
Hoover Annexation ANN-180-10 No. 2824 R-1 5/25/2010 0.26
3809 S. Montana Ave
Hard Estates Annexation ANN-181-10 No. 2826 M-1 7/8/2010 523
2
P&Z Minutes
2/8/2411
. .
(SW of Indian Creek NE of
tracks approx. 1,890 ft south
of Linden
TOTAL ACREAGE 35.04
ANNEXED
ZONE CHANGES: Four (4) zone changes were pursued and approved in 2010. The
following zones changes were approved:
Name Case Number Ordinance Zone Date of Acreage
Number Ordinance
Recordation
Sawgrass Village LLC ZON-67-10 No.2821 R-3 5/25/2010 1.1
Rezone (Lot 2, Block 1 of
Sawgrass Village No. 1 —
16350 Ke Lar o Ave
Chaffin Rezone (2920 E. ZON-68-10 No.2822 C-3 5/25/2010 0.82
Linden
Centennial Blvd Rezone ZON-69-10 No. 2832 C-4 8/04/2010 39.76
R-2 8/04/2010 8.03
Sim lot Blvd Rezone ZON-70-10 No. 2833 M-1 8/17/2010 24.10
DE-ANNEXATIONS: There were no zone boundary changes occurring from de-
annexations in 2010.
COMPREHENSIVE PLAN MAP CHANGES• One comprehensive plan map change
was pursued and approved in 2010. The following comprehensive plan map change was
approved:
Name Case Number Comp. Plan Map Acreage
Desi ation
Sawgrass Village LLC Rezone (Lot 2, ZON-67-10 High Density 1.1
Block 1 of Sawgrass Village No. 1— Residential
16350 Ke Lar o Ave)
TOTAL ACREAGE 1.57
ZONE CLASSIFICATION ERRORS: The following two parcels are currently shown
with a zoning classification of R-2 (Medium Density Residential) and instead should be
shown with a zoning classification of C-4 (Interchange or Freeway Commercial).
Address Tax Parcel Current Correct Zone Property Acreage
Number Zone Owner
0 East Galveston R02039 R-2 C-4 Gregory 0.449
Strikwerda
50 East Frontage R02039010 R-2 C-4 Gregory 0.338
Strikwerda
2) Commissioner Salisbury asked if the property tax biJ] reflects the zoni�ig of
the property.
3) Ms. Skinner responded that property ta�c is not based upon t11e zo�ie but is
based upon the use.
3
P&Z Minutes
2/8/2011
, . a
4) Chairn�an Scholz asked if a property has a specific use and the zone is
changed does the use become grandfathered and does the zoning go with the
land not the use.
5) Ms. Skinner stated that it depends on several factors. lt depends on what tl�e
zone was at the time the use came about, it depends how ]ong the building was
vacant and it depends on tl�e new zoning.
6) The commission held a discussion, regarding land use, which did not pertain
to the zoning map update.
MOTION TO CLOSE TESTIMONY: Commissioner Clark SECOND: Commissioner poty-
Pomorai�sky Passed: Unanimous roll call vote.
Findings of Fact on Case No. OA-139-11 — Accepted MOTION: C.ommissioner Clark
SECOND: Commissioner poty-Pomoransky Passed: Unanimous roll ca11 vote.
Conetusions of Law on Case No. OA-139-11—The conclusions of law were read and accepted.
MOTION: Convnissioner Vance SECOND: Commissioner poty-Pomoransky Passed:
Unanimous roll cali. vote.
Recommendation on Case No. OA-139-11— MOTION: Commissioner poty-Pon�oransky
SECOND: Commissioner Wance. Ths Commission voted unanimously to recommend Approvat .
VI. Additional Old Business
A. (continued from December 14, 2010) Case Number OA-133-10 a request by the City
of Caldwell Traffic Commission to revise those portions of the Zoning Ordinance
pertaining to Vision Triangles, specifically Chapter 10, Article 2, Section 6(signs) and
Chapter 10, Article 2, Section 7(fences) and Chapter 10, Article 7(landscaping).
(THIS HAS BEEN CONTINUED TO APRIL 12, 2011)
B. (continued from December 14, 2010) Case Number SUP-341-10 a request by the City
of Caldwell and Reach The Peak Foundation for special use permit approval to expand
Curtis Park uses to include vault rest rooms, 3 picnic shelters with kitchens and 26
camp sites with fire rings. Curtis Park is located north of the Boise River in Township
4 North, Range 3 West, Section 10 and has a Tax Parcel Number of R34669. (THIS
CASE HAS BEEN WITHDRAWN.)
VII. Planning Issues — None.
VIII:. Adjournment
4
P&Z Minutes
2/8/2011
.,�•
Adjourn public hearing MOT[ON: Commissioner Clark SECOND: Commissianer poty-
Pomoransky Passed: Unanimaus roll call vote. The meeting was adjoun�ed at approximately
7:50 pm.
MINUTES A�PROVED AND SIGNED BY CHAIRPERSON KEN SCHOLZ ON THE DATE
NOTED �LOW:
�'
r
� - �^� ! � // ��
Ken Sc olz D t
ATTEST:
Sen or anner / De e en der
P&Z Minutes
5
2/8l2011