Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout8-10-2010 P&Z MINUTES - 5 � CALDWELL PLANNING AND ZONING COMiVIISSION ��� �-��� ' �� o /D MINUTES August 10, 2010 I. Call to Orcier — Vice Chairperson Scholz called the meeting to order for the public hearing at approximately 7:05 p.m. II. Roll Call- 1VIembers Present: Ken Scholz, Ed Doty-Pomoransky and Dana Vance. Disclosures: None Members Absent: David Clark and Mike Jakobson Staff Present: Anne Marie Skinner (Senior Plann.er/Development Team Leader), Brent Orton (Public Works Director), Robb MacDon.ald (Assistant City Engineer), Brian Billingsley (Planning Director) and April Cabello (Planning Technician) Staff Absent: None Review of Proceeding — Vice-Cha.irperson Scholz announced the procedures for the public hearing. III. OLD BUSINESS A. Approve minutes of June 25, 2010 meeting as signed by Vice Chairperson Scholz on June 25, 2010. MOTION: Commissioner poty-Pomoransky SECOND: Commissioner Scholz. Unanimously approved. IV. NEW BUSINESS A. Case Number SUB-177E-07 a request by L&M Associates, LLC and Jim Mashburn for a time extension for the preliminary plat of Spruce Crossing Subdivision located east of Jefferson Park Subdivision and west of Washington Avenue between Cherry Street and approximately 600ft south of Spruce Street. '1 estimony: 1 P&Z Minutes 8/ 10/2010 , • 1) Anne Marie Skinner, Senior Planner/Development Team Leader, presented the staff report and submitted an aerial photo labeled as e�ibit PZ-1000. 2) Commissioner Vance asked if the comments from the police department about weeds on the subject property as noted in the staff report had been resolved. 3) Ms. Skinner stated the weeds have been taken care of per the police code enforcement. 4) Jim Mashburn, applicant's representative, signed in favor of the application and provided supporting testimony. Mr. Mashburn stated they will need more time to develop due to the economic slowdown and they plan to put cattle or horses on the property to control the weeds. 5) Commissioner poty-Pomoransky asked when the cattle or horses will be placed on the property. 6) Mr. Mashburn replied very soon. 7) Commission Doty-Pomoransky asked if this will keep the weeds down. 8) Mr. Mashburn replied yes. 9) Commissioner Vance asked if property will be fenced. 10) Mr. Mashburn responded yes with barbed wire fence. 11) Commissioner Vance asked if the fence would be adjacent to the school yard. 12) Mr. Mashburn replied the cyclone fencing is adjacent to the school yard. 13) Commissioner Vance asked staff if cyclone fencing is appropriate next to a school yard. 14) Ms. Skinner replied code allows it for purposes of enclosing animals and does not specify anything between zones. 15) Commission Vance asked if the code allows farm animals to be placed on property that previously did not have farm animals. ' 16) Ms. Skinner replied code does allow for 1 usual farm animal per acre and ! they would be allowed to have up to 38 farm animals since the subject � property comprises 3 8 acres. 17) Mr. Mashburn stated weeds have been an issue in the past and he feels cattle or some type of farm animal is the most consistent way to keep the weeds down and that is why fencing is needed. 18) Trula Carrow signed in favor of the application but did not wish to speak. 19) Matt LeBaron signed in favor of the application but did not wish to speak. 20) Randall Jensen signed in neutral of the application but did not wish to speak. 21) Michael Staton signed in neutral of the application but did not wish to speak. MOTION TO CLOSE TESTIMONY: Commissioner pory-Pomoransky SECOND: Commissioner Vance Passed: Unanimous roll call vote. Findings of Fact on Case Number SUB-177E-07 — Acce�ted MOTION: Commissioner poty- Pomoransky SECON.D: Commissioner Vance Passed: Uuanimous roll call vote. Conclusions of Law on Case Number SUB-177E-07 —The conclusions of ta�v were read and accepted. MOTION: Commissioner poty-Pomaransky SCCOND: Commissioner Vance Passed: Unanimous roll call vote. ORDER OF DECISION on Case Number SUB-177E-07 MOTION: Commissioner Vance SECOND: Coinmissioner poty-Pomoransky. The Commission voted unanimously to Approve with conditions 6.2 through 6 2 P&Z Minutes 8/10/2010 B. Case Number SUP-339-10 a request by Greg Poe and the City of Caldwell for a ' special use permit for a hangar in an M-1 Light Industrial zone located approximately 850 feet west of KCID Road and 280 feet south of Linden Street in Section 36, Township 4 North, Range 3 West, Boise Meridian, Canyon County, Idaho, known as Tax Parcel #R35851010. Testimony: 1) Anne Marie Skinner, Senior Planner/ Development Team Leader, presented the staff report and submitted an aerial photo labeled as eachibit PZ-1000. 2) Brent Orton, Public Works Director, stated he would like to make the following corrections to the Engineering comments listed on pages 3& 4 of ' the staff report: • Page 3 of 8, Right-of-WaX - no right-of-way dedication requirement. � Page 3 of 8, 1. Street — no street requirement. , • Page 4 of 8, 2. Irri ation — modify to be stated that irrigation will be in compliance with City Code. 3) Matt Huffield, applicant representative, signed in favor of the application and gave supporting testimony. Mr. Huffield stated the hangar will house , operations for Greg Poe Aviation, Corporate Offices, TI spaces and a , maintenance hangar for their operations. I 4) Commissioner poty-Pomoransky asked if there was a runway in that , area. ', 5) Mr. Orton stated that the new terminal building next to the proposed �' project has an apron parallel taxi way and the proposed project would '' have access through an extension to the existing apron taxi way. i 6) Commissioner Scholz asked staff about the density on the southwest side I of the airport and the intent of future development on the northeast side �I of the airport and is it consistent with master plan. j 7) Mr. Orton replied yes it is consistent with the Airport Master Plan and ! services will be extended to the small area on the west side of the airport i and the area around the terminal is primarily for commercial and fixed base operations. 8) Commissioner Scholz asked how the egress and ingress would be i facilitated for this project. 9) Mr. Orton stated the existing access to the terminal building would be I used. 10) Commissioner poty-Pomoransky asked about the airport terminal I parking and if the terminal is occupied. , 11) Ms. Skinner responded that the airport terminal has a certificate of ', occupancy and for parking they are only required to have one parking !, space far every aircraft space and they have four planes and would be I required to have four parking spaces. ', 12) Commissioner Scholz asked the applicant what his understanding was of ' the egress and ingress for the proposed building. 13) Mr. Huffield replied that the egress and ingress is the main entrance adjacent to the airport terminal parking from Linden Road. . 14) Ms. Skinner stated there are approx 30-40 parking spaces at the existing airport terminal. 3 P&Z Minutes 8/10/2010 i , � 15) Commissioner Vance asked if future development will need to provide � parking. 16) Ms. Skinner stated this project is phase one of a multiphase project and the remainder of the phases will include parking for this hangar. 17) Russ Poe signed in favor of the application but did not wish to speak. 18) Andrea Moyer signed in favor of the application but did not wish to speak. MOTION TO CLOSE TESTIMONY: Commissioner Vance SECOND: Commissioner poty- I'omoransky Passed: Unanimous roll call vote. Comprehensive Plan Analysis SUP-339-10 — Accepted MOTION: Commissioner Va»ce SECOND: Commissioner poty-Pomoransky Passed: Unanimous roll call vote. Findings of Fact on Case Number SUP-339-10 — Accepted MOTION: Commissioner poty- Pomoransky SECOND: Commissioner Vance Passed: Unanimous roll call vote. Conclusions of Law on Case Number SUP-339-10 —The conclusions of law were read and accepted. MOTION: Commissioner Vance SECOND: Commissioner poty-Pomoransky Passed: Unanimous roll call vote. ORDER OF DECISION on Case Number SUP-339-10- MOTION: Com.missioner poty- Pomora��sky SECOND: Commissioner Vance. The Commission voted unanimously to Approve with conditions 8.2 througtt 8.14. C. Case Number SUP-337-10 a request by Guadalupe Sarabia for a special use permit for a used car sales lot in an M-1 Light Industrial zone located on the north side of Simplot Boulevard and one hundred feet east of the corner of Rodeo Avenue and Simplot Boulevard. Testimony: 1) Anne Marie Skinner, Senior Planner/Development Team Leader, presented the staff report and submitted an aerial photo labeled as exhibit PZ-1000. Ms. Skinner stated for the record that she handed the Commissioners, rior to the P start of the hearing, a revised page 6 of the staff report adding conditions of approval based on a call from a neighbor directly to the west of the subject property. 2) Commissioner Vance asked about the hours of operation listed in the conditions. 3) Ms. Skinner replied she took the hours of operation directly from the application. 4) Commissioner Scholz confirmed with staff the property had sewer, water and a landscape buffer. 5) Ms. Skinner confirmed the property had water and sewer but the landscape buffer is condition 8.14 and must be installed before the C of O is issued. 6) Commissiot�er Scholz asked staff the location of the ingress and egress. 7) Ms. Skinner replied that the egress and ingress is from Simplot Blvd. and that ITD had no problerns with the application but will not grant any additional access ingress or egress other than the existing ingress and egress. 4 P&Z Minutes 8/10/2010 8) Commissioner Scholz asked about traffic flow and if there was a signaled intersection. 9) Ms. Skinner stated there would be no problem with the traffic flow. 10) Commissioner poty-Pomoransky confirmed with staff that there was one entrance and exit on this property. 11) Eommissioner Scholz asked staff if there are other car lots in the area. 12) Ms. Skinner replied no. 13) Commissioner Vance asked staff if a car lot is an allowed use with the special use. 14) Ms. Skinner responded yes a car lot is permitted with a special use. 15) Commissioner poty-Pomoransky confirmed with staffthat the fence and landscape buffer listed in the staff report condition 8.19 must be installed prior to the C of O is issued. 16) Ms. Skinner replied that the existing fencing must stay and it was listed in the conditions along with the landscape buffer that is to be installed. 17) Commissioner Scholz asked staff if auto repair was an allowed use. 18) Ms. Skinner replied yes it is allowed in an M-1 zone. 19) Armando Sarabia, applicant's representative, signed in favor of the application and gave supporting testimony. 20) Commissioner Scholz asked Mr. Sarabia how many cars they propose to have on the lot and what is the capacity. 21) Mr. Sarabia stated no more than 40 cars. � 22) Commissioner Scholz asked where repairs will be done. 23) Mr. Sarabia replied all repairs will be off site. 24) Ms. Skinner replied that in the letter of intent submitted by the applicant they stated that they do not plan on doing any mechanical or detail work at this location and this is a small operation and will not house more than 15 vehicles. Ms. Skinner said this lot will not hold more than 15 vehicles. 25) Mr. Sarabia stated they will abide by the rules and will hold no more than 15 cars. 26) Commissioner Scholz asked Mr. Sarabia what type of landscape was planned for the buffer. 27) Mr. Sarabia replied dry desert like landscaping. 28) Anne Marie stated that dry landscaping is permitted and per the conditions on � this special use the applicant is being directed to install dry landscaping as was previously approved with the new construction of the building. 29) Commissioner Scholz asked Mr. Sarabia if this was a permanent structure on a foundation. 30) Mr. Sarabia replied yes it is a permanent structure. 31) Lupita Sarabia, applicant, signed in favor of the application but did not wish to speak. 32) Rose Almonte signed in favor of the application but did not wish to speak. MOTION TO CLOS� T�STIMONY: Commissioner poty-Pomoransky SECOND: Commissioner Scholz:Passed: Unanimous roll call vote. Comprehensive Plan Analysis SUP-337-10 — Accepted MOTION: Commissioner Vance SECOND: Commissioner poty-Pomoransky Passed: Unanimous roll call vote. Findings of Fact on Case Number SUP-337-10 — Accepted MOTION: Commissioner poty- Pomoransky SCCOND: Com_missioner Scholz Passed: Unanimous roll call vote. 5 P&Z Minutes 8/10/2010 Conclusions of Law on Case Number SUP-337-1.0 —Tl�e conclusions of law were read and accepted. IVIOTION: Commissioner Vance SECOND: Commissioner poty-Pomoraiisky Passed: Unanimous roll call vote. ORDER OF llECISION on Case Number SUP-337-10- MOTION: Commissioner poty- Pomoransky SECOND: Commissioner Vance. Tl�e Commission voted unaniulously to Approve with conditions 8.2 through 8.19. D. Case Number SUP-310-10 a request by Community Council of Idaho, Inc. for a special use permit to operate a childcare center in a C-3 Service Commercial zone. The site is addressed as 317 Happy Day Blvd. Testimony: 1) Anne Marie Skinner, Senior Planner/ Development Team Leader, presented the staff report and submitted an aerial photo labeled as exhibit PZ-1000. 2) Commissioner Scholz asked staff if there was a signalized light at the intersection and what structures are around or located on the site. 3) Ms. Skinner responded that the childcare center would occupy only the portion of the building that was a Mexican restaurant and the rest of the building is being used as classrooms by TVCC. 4) Commissioner poty-Pomoransky asked if the classrooms will be used once TVCC opens their new facility. 5) Ms. Skinner replied no. 6) Ms. Vance stated per the staff report the applicant will need to dedicate more land to the right of way and wanted to know if the signature on the application is the property owner. 7) Ms. Skinner replied the properiy owner signed the application. 8) Mr. Scholz asked if there is a buffer between the playground and Happy Day Blvd. 9) Ms. Skinner replied it must be fenced with a 6 foot high fence. 10) Commissioner Vance asked if fencing would be required around the front door to keep the children from walking out. 11) Ms. Skinner replied that putting any kind of fence between the front door and any street violates emergency services building code but there are certain types of locking mechanisms that daycare centers use because you cannot fence in the entrances or exits. 12) Commissioner Scholz asked how many children will be at this location and wanted to know if it complies with the zoning code. 13) Ms. Skinner replied 30-40 children and it does comply with the zoning code. 14) Commissioner poty-Pomoransky asked if there is a fire wall between the TVCC Classrooms and the daycare. 15) Ms. Skinner replied a fire wall is not required if they have their architect do a reclassification as a non separated use. 16) Commissioner Scholz asked what the traffic count on Laster Lane is. 17) Brent Orton, Public Work Director said that traffic is considered to be light on Laster Lane and his best estimate would be 1,000 to 1,500 cars per day. 18) Commissioner Scholz asked what the surrounding land use is. 19) Ms. Skinner responded commercial. 6 P&Z Minutes 8/10/2010 20) Commission Scholz asked if there was any residential nearby. 21) Ms. Skinner responded it is surrounded by commerciaL 22) Elisha Sulden, applicant representative signed in favor of the application and gave supporting testimony. 23) Commissioner poty-Pomoransky confirmed with Ms. Sulden that the Community Council of Idaho offices are currently located in this building and will be separate from the daycare. 24) Ms. Sulden replied yes. 25) Commissioner Scholz asked Ms. Sulden if they were already operating a daycare at this location. 26) Ms. Sulden responded no daycare but currently the administrative offices are located in this building and the special use application it to open a child care facility at this location. 27) Commissioner Scholz asked what will the hours of operation be and type of clientele. 28) Ms. Sulden replied the hours will be 6am to 6pm and the clientele is low income and migrant / seasonal workers. 29) Commissioner Scholz asked if transportation will be provided. 30) Ms. Sulden replied not at this time. MOTION TO CLOSE TESTIMONl': C�mmissioner Vance SECOND: Commissioner poty- Fomoransky Passed: Unanimous roll call vote. Comprehensive Plan Analysis SUP-310-10 — Acce�ted MOTION: Commissioner Vance SCCOND: Commissioner poty-Pomoransky Passed: Unanimous roll call vote. Findings of Fact on Case Number SUP-310-10 — Accepted MOT10N: Commissioner Vance SECOND: Commissioner poty-Pomorausky 1'assed: Unanimous roll call vote. Conclusions of Law on Case Number SUP-310-10 —The co»clusions of law were read and accepted. MOT10N: Commissioner poty-Pomoransky SECOND: Conunissioi�er Vance Passed: Unanimous roll call vote. ORDER OF DECISION on Case Number SUP-310-10- MOT[ON: Commissioner Vznce SECOND: Commissioner poty-Pomoransky. The Commission voted unanimously to Approve with conditions 8.2 through 8.17. . E. Case Number SUP-338-10 a request by the City of Caldwell for a special use permit for an off-premise advertising sign to be located on property located in the NW '/4 of Section 36, Township 4 North, Range 3 West, on the southwesterly side of Aviation Way approximately 3,350 feet south and west of the intersection of Linden Street and Aviation Way. Testimony: 1) Anne Marie Skinner, Senior Planner/ Development Team Leader, presented the staff report and submitted an aerial photo labeled as e�ibit PZ-1000. 2) Commissioner Scholz asked if the sign would face east and west. 7 P&Z Minutes 8/10/2010 . • ' . i 3) Ms. Skinner replied it is a one-sided sign facing the traffic going west into Caldwell. 4) Commissioner Scholz asked what exit the sign is servicing. 5) Commissioner poty-Pomoransky responded the purpose of the sign is to encourage more traffic to go downtown via 10` Avenue. 6) Commissioner poty-Pomoransky asked staff about the objections and comments in the staff report made by the fire department. 7) Ms. Skinner responded in the past there have been several other advertisement agencies wanting to place billboards which are much larger in size in this area but the properly owner must sign the special use application and the city owns this property and the city would not sign previously-requested applications due to the size of the signs. 8) Commissioner Vance stated she was concerned that the sign will not be readable due to the high speed of traffic. 9) Ms. Skinner replied that the City Clerk worked with ITD and per ITD the maacimum size of a sign would be 150 sq ft. 10) Commissioner poty-Pomoransky stated the airport does not have a readable sign and another special use sign request migl�t come bef'ore the P&Z Commission. 11) Ms. Skinner responded that would be an on premise sign and would not need a special use pennit instead the airport would need to submit a sign permit application which does not �o before the P&Z Commission. l.2) Ms. Skinner explained to the P&Z Commission that a�iyone can apply for off premise signage through a special use pen.nit process if they are in C-2, C-3, C-4 or M-1 zone with the property owner's signature on the special use application ai�d tlle case would be hea� by eitl�er the Hearing Examiner or the P&Z Co�n�uission for approval. Ms. Skinner further explained in this articular instance the a licant ha ens to be the Cit of Caldwell a I inQ p PP PP Y pP Y b f o r o f f p r e m i s e s i g n a g e i n a n M- 1 z o n e s o t h e C i t y i s f o ll o w i n g t h e p r o c e d u r e outl.ined in the sign ordinance. 13) Commissioner Scholz asked if the P&Z Commission could approve the special use witl� conditions regarding the size of the sign because the current sign size is inadequate and would serve better if it was a larger sign. l4) Ms. Skimier re lied the Commission l�as the authori to a rove witl� a , P h' PP condition of approval tl�at the sign cannot exceed the maaimum allowed by ITD. 15) Ms. Skinner stated she will ask the City Clerk to verify the maximum allowed signage size with ITD. l 6) The P&Z Commission expressed their concerns that the size ]Zas iio room foc expansion. MOTION TO CLOSE TESTIMONY: Commissio»er Vance SECOND: Commissioner poty- Pomoransky Passed: Unanimous roll call vote. Comprehensive 1'lan Analysis SUP-338-10 — Accepted MOTION: Commissioner Vance SECOND: Commissioner poty-Pomoransky Passed: Unanimotts roll call vole. Findings of Fact on Case Number SUP-338-10 — Accepted MOTION: Commissioner Vance SECOND: Commissi.oner poty-Pomoransky Passed: Unanimous roll call vote. 8 P&Z Minutes 8/10/2010 � Conclusions of Law on Case Number SUP-338-10 —Tl�e conclusians of law were read and accepted. MOTI:ON: Commissioner poty-Pomoransky SL;COND: Commissioner Vance Passed: Unanimous roll call vote. �rder of Decision on Case Number SUP-338-10 - MOTION: Commissioner Vance SECOND: Commissioner poty-1'omoransky. The Commission voted unanimously to Approve with conditions 8.2 through 8.13 with the following addition of condition 8.14: • 8.14 The size of the sign shall be increased to the maximum size allowed by Idaho Transportation Department to enhance visibility and to provide more space for future downtown advertising. V. Planning Issues '� A. Updating Planning and Zoning Commission Sylaws: NIs. Skinner infonned the commission she will add wording to the Bylaws and the P&Z Ordina»ce so that the Chairperson can make motions, seconds and vote. VI. Adjournment Adjourn public hearing MOTION: Convnissioner Scholz SECOND: Commissioner poty- Pomoransky Passed: Unanimous roll call vote. The meeting was adjourned at approxim.ately 9:15 pm.. MINUTES A ROVED AND SIGNED BY ACTING CHAIRP�RSON KrN SCHOLZ, ON THC DAT `OTED BELOW: �.� � J f � G"" / e _..... i Ken Scholz D e ATTEST: Anne Ma ie inner, S»> lanne v lopment Team Leader 9 P&Z Minutes 8/10/2010