HomeMy WebLinkAbout6-9-2009 P&Z MINUTES �� ♦
CALDWELL 1'LANNING ANll ZONING COlVIiVIISSIOlY
�
NIIlYUTES � A° �"�
O
June 9, 2009 � 9dSF�
��
I. Call to Order —Cl�airpersoll Jal:obson called the �l�eeting to order for the public hearing
at 7:05 p.m.
II. Roll Call —
1VIembers Present: Mike Jakobson, Vincent Sanchez, Betty "I'ollman, James Kunsvolci, Gene
Sl�affer
Disclosures: None
Members Absent: Geoff OldenKamp
Staff Present: Anne Marie Skinner (Senior Planner/Community Development Coordinator),
Qrent Orton (Assistant City T'njineer), Brian Billingsley (Plannin.g and 7oning Director),
Savanna Davis (Administcative Secretary), April Cabello (Planning Techniciai�}
Review of Proceeding —Chairperson Jakobson annouuced the procedures for the public hearing.
III. OLD BUSIN�SS
A. Approve Minutes of ineeting as signed by Chairperson Jakobson on April 27, 2009.
MOTION: Commissioner Runsvold SECOND: Commissioner Sanchez.
IV. N�W BUSINESS
A. Case Number SUB-194PF-09 a request by the Carrington Company, Tom Kraus and
JUB Engineers for short plat approval of Carrington Center II consisting of five
buildable lots on 9.56 acres in a G2 Community Commercial zone. The site is located
south of Ustick Road and east of South 10�' Avenue.
Testiznony:
1) Anne Marie Skinner, Senior Planner/Community Development Coordinator,
presented the staff report with the following change: page 4 of 7; three items
under storm water shall be stricken and replaced with: "The development of the
property shall be in accordance with the most recently adopted storm water
manual."
2) Tom Kraus, applicant, signed in favor of the application and provided
supporting testimony.
3) �� :�missi�ner Shaffe: zske� ab�ut the road syster:i �ha* �,�il! be �as�d.
� �
4) Mr. Kraus stated that there would be an all weather surface used until such time
that all the lots are sold and developed which would ultimately result in the
entire site being a continuous parking lot with cross-access easements.
MOTION TO CLOSE TF.STIMONY: Commissioner Runsvold SI?COND: Commissioiler
Tollman Passed: tlnanimous col.l call vote.
Comprehensive Plan Anal,ysis SUB-194PF-09 — Acce�ted MOTION: Commissioner Runsvold
S�COND: Coinmissioner Sanchez Passed: Unanimous roll call vote.
Findings of' Fact on Case Number SUB-194PF-09 — Accepted MOT[ON: Commissioner
Runsvold SECOND: Commissioner Sanchez Passed: Unanimous roll call vote.
Conclusions of Law an Case No. SUB-194PF-09 —The conclusions of Iaw were read and
accepted. MOTION: Commissioner Sanchez SECOND: Commissio��er Runsvold Passed:
Unanimous roll call vote.
Recommendation on Case No. SUB-194PF-09 - MOT[ON: Co»>missioner Runsvold SECOND:
Com.missioner Tollrnan Approved with conditions as written in tlie staff report.
B. Case Number SUP-326-09 a request by Coleman Homes for a special use permit for
an off-premise sign to be located at the southeast corner of Ustick and Middleton Road.
Testimony:
1) Anne Marie Skinner, Senior Planner/Community Development Coordinator,
presented the staff report
2) Commissioner Runsvold asked what would trigger the sign to have to be taken
down.
3) Ms. Skinner stated that either the commission could put conditions on it, the
property owner could have a contract with the applicant or the applicant could
decide the sign was no longer necessary and remove it.
4) Runsvold asked about grandfather rights for any other company that would like
to take over this SUP for the off premise sign on this site.
5) Ms. Skinner stated that any other person that wanted to have an off premise
sign on this site after the applicant's sign was removed would have to submit a
new application.
6) Susan Stanley, applicant's representative, signed in favor of the application and
provided supporting testimony.
MOTION TO CLUSE TESTIMONY: Commissionec Runsvold. SCCOND: Commissioner
5ancliez Passed: Unanimous roll call vote.
(
ComPrehensive Plan Anaiysis SUP-326-09 — Accepted MOTION: Commissioner Shaffer
SECOND: Commissioner Runsvold Passed: Unanimous roll call vote.
Findings of Fact on Case Number SUP-326-09 — Accepted MOTInN: Commissioner Shaffer
SECOND: C 011l(TllSS10110C RUIISVOICI PdSSE(I tJnanimous roll call vote.
Conclusions of Law on Case No. SUP-326-09 —'I'l�e conc(usions of law were read ancl accepted.
MOTION: Comt��issioner "I'ollman SECOND: Commissioner Runsvold 1'assed: Unaninlous rol(
call vote.
Order of Decision on Case No. SUP-326-09 - MOT'ION: Commissioner Tollman SECOND:
Commissioner Runsvold. "l Commission voted unanimously to Approve with the conditions as
listed in tl�e sta.ff repart.
C. Case Number SUB- 159E-06 a request by Patra Properties, Bingo Investments and
Landmark Engineering & Planning for a one-year time extension for Aspen Falls
Subdivision. This site is located on the east side of Farmway and south side of Ustick.
Testimony:
1) Anne Marie Skinner, Senior Planner/Community Development Coordinator,
presented the staff report, read into the record a letter submitted by Harvey
Sauvageau which was labeled as PZ-1000 and stated that staff recommends
that this case be denied because of the amount of lots that are under the current
required 8,000 square foot minimum lot size and because the Planning &
Zoning Commission recommended to the City Council that the underlying
application for the preliminary plat be denied.
2) Jed Wyatt, applicant's representative, signed in favor of the application and
provided supporting testimony and submitted a large site plan that was labeled
as exhibit PZ-1001.
3) Cheryl Wiley signed in opposition to the app(ication and provided opposing
testimony.
4) Duane Evans signed in opposition to the application and provided opposing
testimony.
5) Mr. Wyatt rebutted stating that the reason the developer is asking for the time
extension is because they would like to develop the land in the future, not right
now in this market.
6) The Commission discussed the pros and cons to approving and denying the
request.
MOTION TO CLOSE TESTIMONY: Commissioner Rurasvolcl SrCOND: Commissioner
Sanchez Passed: Ui�animous roll call vote.
Findings of Fact on Case Number SUB- 159E-06 — Accepted MOT[ON: Commissioner
Runsvold SECOND: Commrssioner "I'ollman Passed: [lnanimous roll call vote.
Conclusions of Law an Case No. SUB- 159E-06 —The canclusions of I�w were read a�id
accepted. IVIOTION: Commissioner REinsvold SECOND: Cammissioner Shaffer Passed:
Unlnimous roll call vote.
Order of Decision on Case No. SUB- 159E-06 - MOT10N: Commissioner Runsvold SECOND:
Commissioner Tollm�n. The Commission vated una»imously to Deny the reyuest.
D. Case Number SUB-156E-06 a request by L-202-1 ID Peregrine Estates and Landmark
Engineering & Planning for a one-year time extension for Peregrine Estates
Subdivision. This site is located on the east side of Lake Avenue approximately '/4 mile
south of Karcher Road.
Testunony:
1) Anne Marie Skinner, Senior Planner/Community Development Coordinator,
presented the staff report.
2) Jed Wyatt, applicant's representative, signed in favor of the application and
provided supporting testimony.
3) The Commission had discussion with the applicant's representative and the
Commission discussed the pros and cons to approving and denying the request
MOTION TO CLOSE TESTIMONY: Commissioner Runsvold S�COND: Commissioner
Sazichez Passed: tlnanimous roll call vote.
Fincliags of Fact on Case Number SUB-156E-06 — Accepted MOT[ON: Comi��issioner
San,chez SECOND: Collimissioner Runsvold Passed: Unanimous roll call vote.
Conclusions af Law on Case No. SUB-156E-06 —Tlle conclusions of law were read and
acce�ted. MOT[ON: Commissioner Sanchez SECOND: Commissioner Runsvold Passed:
Unanimaus roll call vote.
Order of llecision Case No. SUB-156E-06 - MOTIUN: Commissioner Sa»chez SECOND:
Commissioner Tollman. I'he Commission voted with a split decision to Deny the request with
Saiichez, "I'ol(man and Shaffer voting u� favor of the motion and Ruusvold voting against tl�e
motion.
+
E. Case Number OA-112-09 a request by Caldwell Planning and Zoning Department for
an ordinance amendment to section 10-08-01 through 10-08-03 of city code,
concerning the tree ordinance.
Testiitior�y: � �
1) Anne Marie Skinner, Senior Planner/Community Development
Coordinator, presented the staff report.
2) Commissioner Runsvold asked if the new definition of caliper is a
standard definition.
3) Lynn Sorenson, City Forester, stated that it is a standard definition.
4) The Commission had discussion amongst themselves.
Comprehensive Plan Analysis . OA-112-09 — Accepted MOTION: Commissioner Runsvold
SECOND: Commissioner Sanchez Passed: U»animous roll call vote.
Recommendation an Case No. OA-112-09 - M:OT[ON: Commissioner Ru►isvold SECOND:
Commissio»er Sl�affer. The Commission voled u.nanimously to Recommend Approval.
F. Case Number OA-115-09 a request by Planning and Zoning Director to adopt a new
Appendix F, Communities in Motion, to Caldwell's Comprehensive Plan.
Testimony:
1) Brian Billingsley, Planning Director, presented the staff report.
2) Brent Orton, Assistant City Engineer, provided supporting testimony.
Comprehensive Plan Analysis . OA-115-09 — Accepted MOTION: Commissioner Runsvold
SECOND: Commissioner Sanchez Passed: Unanimous roll call vote.
Recommendation on Case No. OA-115-09 - MOTIUN: Commissioner Runsvotd SECOND:
Commissioner Shaffer. Tl�e Com►nission voted unanimously to Recommend Approval.
G. (continued public hearing from April 14, 2009)Case Number OA-113-09 a request
by Caldwell's Planning and Zoning Director for an ordinance amendment to add
section 10-03-13 to the Caldwell Zoning Ordinance for the Administrative Citation
Process.
Testimo�ly:
' ,
1) Brian Billingsley, Planning Director, presented the staff report
with the statement that the City Attorney had yet to forward his
comments for inclusion in the ordinance.
2) Commissioner Runsvold responded that he, himself, as an
attorney had carefully reviewed the ordinance and had some
redline comments that he would email to Mr. Billingsley.
3) The Commission felt it would be best to continue the hearing
until Commissioner Runsvold's comments and the City
Attorney's comments could be included in the document and
moved and unanimously voted accordingly.
NI(?TION TO CONTINUE to August 11, 2009 meeting: Comuiissioner Runsvold SECOND:
Commissioner Tallman Passed: Unanimous roll call vate.
V. Planning Issues
none
VI. Adjournment
Acljouru public hearing MOTION: Commissioner Runsvold SECOND: Com:missioner
Toll»�an �Passed: Unanimo�is roll call vote. The �neeting was acijourned at 9:20 pm.
MiNU"I'ES APPROVEU AND SIGNED BY CHAIRPE(ZSON MIKE JAKOBSUN ON "L HE
UA'TE NO"I�EU BELOW:
�
r ,m� ��
� � . ,,
' , ` f � - f' �� � ''� �`
� �s` �`` � r �
� ]Vlike JaJ�'obson Date
�
,
ATTI;ST:
Senior Planner / Community Development Coordinator