HomeMy WebLinkAbout11-27-2007 HE MINUTES � t
��:^ j�� :.
• �AI nW�LL HEARING EXAMINER ,,.. ' .. ( Q�� —
��.�..a w �+� �
MINUTES
November 27, 2007
I. Call to Order — Hearing Examiner, Mr. Jerome Mapp, opened the meeting for the
public hearing at 7:25 p.m.
II. Review of Proceedings — Mr. Jerome Mapp outiined the procedures for the pubiic '
hearing.
Members Present: Anne Marie Skinner (Senior Planner), Savanna Davis (Secretary),
Brent Orton (Engineering Department), Brian Billingsley (Director).
Iil.Oid Business I
Mr. Mapp approved the minutes of the October 23, 2007 meeting.
� IV.New Business
A. Case Number ANN-164-07 a request by the City of Caldwell for Category B annexation
of 26.91 acres into the City with R-1 Single-Family Residential zoning, C-1 Neighborhood
Commercial zoning, and C-2 Community Commercial zoning and designations on the
Caldwell Comprehensive Plan Map as Low Density Residential and Commercial. The
sites are located as follows:
4522 Lake Ave.
2808 Marble Front Rd.
2816 Marble Front Rd.
1120 W. Logan St.
1106 W. Logan St.
3904 S. Indiana Ave.
4024 S. Florida Ave.
3912 S. Florida Ave.
104 Amber St.
1409 E. Ustick Rd.
5023 Hwy 20-26
5205 Hwy 20-26
715 Borchers Ln.
723 Borchers Ln.
5017 Hwy 20-26
4114 Nelson Ln.
712 Borchers Ln.
2703 Marble Front Rd.
2702 Marble Front Rd.
• 2722 Marble Front Rd.
• Tagtimnnv:
a) Anne Marie Skinner, Senior Planner, presented the staff report and read into the
record the new parcels of land that were added to the annexations. Ms. Skinner
went on to explain that the publication and notice requirements were met.
b) Cheryl Scott signed in opposition to the application and read into the record PZ-
1002, a letter from Jeff & Cheryl Scott.
c) Mr. Mapp asked if Ms. Scott was aware that her property is in the city impact
area.
d) Ms. Scott stated that she is aware that her property is in the city impact area.
e) Larry Doser signed in opposition to the application and stated that the
engineering department had told him that after he connected to city services that
he would be rebated for that.
f� Mr. Mapp asked if Mr. Doser had something in writing that stated he was going to
get a rebate from the city.
g) Mr. Doser replied that he did at one time, but doesn't have it now. '!
h) Ruth Henderson signed in opposition to the application stating her concerns for
being annexed into the city limits.
i) Davy Henderson withdrew from wanting to speak.
j) Brent Orton stated that the main reason that the city is requesting annexation is
to be compensated for the tax dollars that are owed for the property owners use
� of city services. Mr. Orton stated that one benefit to annexing into the city is that
they wouidn't have to pay the application fees to annex into the city limits at a
later date.
k) Mr. Mapp asked Brian Billingsley to explain the job of the Hearing Examiner.
I) Mr. Billingsley explained the difference between the Planning & Zoning
Commission and the Hearing Examiner.
m) Mr. Mapp stated that under state law a Hearing Examiner must have a
background in Planning.
MR. MAPP CLOSED THE PUBLlC TESTIMONY.
Comprehensive Plan Analysis: Mr. Mapp found that the request was applicable to the
Comprehensive Plan components listed in Section 5.1.1 through 5.1.4 in the staff report.
Findings of Fact on Annexation: The Hearing Examiner accepted the general facts as
outlined in the staff report, public testimony, and the evidence list as a part of the
Findings.
Conclusions of Law for Annexation: The Hearing Examiner accepted the Conclusions of
Law as outlined in the staff report.
Order of Decision: The Hearing Examiner recommended that Case Number ANN-164-07
• be approved with the following conditions
• • R7
B. Case Number SUB/PUD-167PF-07 a request by Ron McConnell and Skinner Land
Survey for short plaUplanned unit development approval of Campus Townhome
Subdivision consisting of 5 residential lots and 1 common lot. The site is located at 2116
Wisconsin.
Testmony:
a) Anne Marie Skinner, Senior Planner, presented the staff report. Ms. Skinner stated a
correction to the site address to read: 2216 Wisconsin, not 2116 Wisconsin. Ms. Skinner
stated that staff has one request that condition 8.13 be added to read; "Lot 6, the
common lot, be a blanket utility drainage irrigation ingress egress easement."
b) Ron McConnell, Applicant, signed in favor of the application, provided supporting
testimony and submitted exhibit PZ-1001, colored rendition of the proposed homes and
PZ-1002, a neighborhood meeting notification.
c) Mr. Mapp expressed his concerns for the pantry being in the hailway of the proposed
floor pian of the homes.
d) Mr. Mapp stated his concerns for parking.
e) Mr. Mapp asked Mr. McConnell if he has reviewed the conditions in the staff report and if
he agreed with them.
� f) Mr. McConnell stated that he has reviewed the conditions and does agree.
g) Mr. Mapp expressed his concerns for the request to waive the amenities as well as his
concerns for the lack of amenities in the proposed project.
h) Mr. Mapp stated his concerns for the lot 6, the common lot, not matching the rest of the
subdivision and the rear 15' property line being part of the common lot.
i) Ms. Skinner stated that the proposed project is a PUD and in a PUD zero lot lines are
allowed.
j) Homer Poland signed in opposition to the application and stated his concerns for traffic
safety, noise and the college lifestyle.
k) Mr. McConnell stated that since he's cleaned up the neighborhood there haven't been
any more problems caused by the coliege lifestyle.
I) Brian Biilingsley explained the required amenities vs. the optional amenities.
MR. MAPP CLOSED THE PUBLIC TESTIMONY
Comprehensive Plan Analysis: Mr. Mapp found that the request was applicable to the
Comprehensive Plan components listed in Sections 5.1.1 through 5.1.2 in the staff report.
Findings of Fact on Annexation: The Hearing Examiner accepted the general facts as
� outlined in the staff report, public testimony, and the evidence list as a part of the
Findings.
rnnrl��cinnc nf I a�n� fnr AnnaYatinn. Thp Haarinn FxaminPr acrepted the Conclusions of '
• Law as outlined in the staff report. J
I
Order of Qecision: The Hearing Examiner recommended that Case Number SUB-184P- '
07 be approved with the following conditions: �
• 8.2 through 8.11
• 8.12
• 8.13 "Lot 6, the common lot, shall be a blanket utility, drainage, irrigation, ingress
and egress easement."
• 8.14 zero side yard setbacks shall be for lots 1 through 4 only and shall meet all
of fire department requirements.
C. Case Number SUP-301-07/SUB-168PF-07 a request by Keystone Custom Homes and
Roger Branom for a special use permit for an assisted living center in an R-2 Combined
Medium Density Residential zone and short plat approval of Keystone Village Subdivision
consisting of 4 residential lots and 1 common lot. The site is located at the southeast
corner of Florida Avenue and Mariah Court.
Testmony:
. a) Anne Marie Skinner, Senior Planner, presented the staff report and submitted
PZ-1000, an aerial photo of the project. Ms. Skinner went on to define the
parking requirements.
b) Mr. Branom applicant signed in favor of the application and submitted exhibits
PZ-1001: an 8% x 11 & 11x17 of a floor plan, PZ-1002: 11x17 a site pian, and
PZ-1003: a large colored site plan. Mr. Branom then pravided supporting
testimony.
c) Mr. Mapp stated his concerns for the number of employee's, lack of open space,
the amount of curb cuts, the amount of buiidings on the site, and the lack of patio
space.
d) Mr. Mapp asked who would be responsible for maintaining the project.
e) Mr. Branom stated that the homes would be sold and maintained by the owner of
the property.
� Mr. Mapp asked Mr. Branom what the size of the rooms are would be. �
g) Mr. Branom stated that the rooms are 14x14 and the bathrooms are 8x8.
h) Josh Baker, signed in favor of the application and acknowledged that Mr. Mapp's
concerns could be addressed.
i) Cory Castaqueto signed in favor of the application representing Bee Hive
Assisted Living Homes franchise. He then stated that the size of the rooms is
very industry standard.
j) Mr. Mapp asked what the difference is between assisted living homes and
. nursing homes.
• I�� nnr r M�±uMNio±� gtatcrl thA twlif{AYPnf`PC ar1rl St?FPfI tI'lat {I�IPCt �IaIIAV MPfllf'aI II
Center is the ciosest hospital.
I) Mc Branom requested a continuance in order to be able to supply Mr. Mapp with I,
the buiiding dimensions that he would like to see.
m} Mr. Mapp spoke of the dimensions that are lacking that he would like to see. Mr.
Mapp then stated that the current plat is lacking detaiL
Mr. Mapp continued this item to the hearing to be held on January 29, 2007.
V. Plar.ning Iss��es
VI. Adjaurnment
The Hearing Examiner adjourned the meeting at approximately 9:35 p.m.
MINUTES APPROVED AND SIGNED SY THE HEARING EXAMINER, M. JEROME MAPP, ON
THE Df�.. �ED - W:
� . r
� .
,�'' �
� 1 (,J� ATTEST:
l `
L? ` � ,
��
M. Jerome pp � Da#e
� �
Planning and Zoning Director
•