HomeMy WebLinkAbout8-14-2007 P&Z MINUTES ' t
, .
• C_ALDWELL 1'LANNING AND ZON.[NG CCl1VIMISSION
iVI1NLJTES ' AP� C�v�a
� r I IU
August 14, 2007
l�. Call to Order — Comiilissioner Griffith cal led the rneetin� to order for the public hearing
at 7:00 p.m.
11. I2olt Call —
Members Present: Joyce Griffith, Gene Sliatfer, James Ru»svold, Scott Wallace, Jack
Teraberry, Geoff Oldenkamp.
Disclosures:
Members Absent: Mic.hael Jakobson
Staff Present: Brian Billingsley (Planning Director), Anne Marie Skinner (Senior Planner), Brent
Orton (City Fngineer), Savanna Davis (Secretary).
Review of Proceeding — Commissioner Griftith announced the procedures for the public
l�earing. �
• New Business Item B, Case Nuinber SUP-298-07, a request by Matt Brown, Terry Cox
and T-Mobile for a special use permit for roof top cell antennas was continued
indefinitely.
III. Olci Business
A. Approve minutes of June 12, 20Q7. NIOTION: Commissioner Wallace S:ECOND:
Commissioner Runsvold. l'assed: Unanimous roll call vote.
B. (continued) Case Number OA-81-06, a request by the Planning & Loning Director to
revise the City of Caldwell's landscaping ordinance.
a. A»ne 1Vlarie Skinner presented the staffreport and stated all the changes.
Comprehensive Plan Analysis — MOT'ION: Commissior�er Shaffer SECOND: Commissioner
Runsvold. 1'assed: Unanimous roll call vote.
Recommenclation on Case No. OA-81-06 - MOTION: Commissioner Runsvold SECOND:
Commissioner Shaffer. The Commission voted to recommeud Approval with the conditions
stated in the staff report.
�
� I V. New Business
A. Case Number SUB-182P-07 & VAR-31-07, a reyuest by Dom�a Caskey, Parl< Avenue
LLC and Toothman Orton Engineei�in� for preliminary plat app�•oval of Park Avenue
Subdivision consisting of 8 residentia] lots and 5 common lots iu an R-1 Single Family
Residential zone and a variance for cul-de-sac design requirements. The site is located at
2310 10"' Avenue.
Testimony:
a. Anne iVlarie Skim�er, Senior Planner, presented the staff report and read a letter into
the record that was labeled PZ-1001 ai�d another tetter that was labeled as PZ-1002.
b. Troy Behunin, applieant's representative, siibmittcd a large exhibit that was labeled
PL-1004 and provided supporting testirnony. Mr. Behtu�in stated that it is tlle
applicant's every intention to target the homes to a certain age group and stated that
the lots would be rented out, keepin� Ms. Caskey as the owner of the parcels. NIr.
Behunin also stated that the lots will be open lots with no fences and will be
maintained for the tenants. 1VIr. Behuriiri stated that the current drainage ��-ill remain
as it is - historical draivage. 1VIr. Buhuniil stated tt�at tllere are two existing l�omes
on the site that will remain but the dilapidated sheds will be removed.
c. Commissioner Teraberry stated his coi�cerns for a gate being needed for the
emergency access.
• d. Mr. Behunin stated that if tl�e conmlission wanted the applicant to tlley would be
willing to i�stall a crash �ate.
e. Brent Orton spoke of the turf block and sidewalk.
£ Commissioner Teraberry stated liis concerns for drainage.
g. Mr. Bel�unin stated fhat the applicaut has historic drainage rights.
h. Mr. Orton stated that siibject would be something that the applicant would l�ave to
worl< out with tl�e City's engineering department before the cievelopment of the
]and.
i. iVlr. Behu»in statecl that it is the intention of the applicant to use
detention/retention ponds.
j. Mr. 'I'ereberry stated his concerns for tl�e pressurized irrigation system.
k. Mr. Bel�unin stated fhat the issue with irrigation 11as not been resolved at tl�is time.
1. Anne Marie Skinner stated that the City requires a pressurized irrigation system be
installed.
m. Mr. Behunin stated that the applicaut would install a pressurized irrigation system.
n. Mr. Kunsvold stated his concerns for fencing surro�ulding the property.
o. Mr. Behunin stated tl�at the applicant would be willing to install a four foot vinyl
fence.
p. Tlle following people signed in favor of tl�e application b�rt �iid not wish to speak:
Doiina Caskey, Marjorie Bratton, and Eric Sl�annon.
•
� c�. Davi� Wl�itney si��ed in op,position to tlie app'lication and stated tl�at he agreed
with Gina Lti�jak's submitted. letter and w�itll com�Y�issioner Teraberry�s concenls.
Mr. Whitney stated his coi�cerns for the ty�e of l�omes that would be built on these
Iots and who would manage the property after the applicant is no longer able to.
r. Beverly Larson, signed in opposition, and stated tl�at at this time she :feels that a
neighborhood meeting is needed to answer fencing and irrigation c�uestions.
s. Amy Gipson si�ned in opposi�tion and provided op�posing testimony stating �that tliis
project would be a detriment to the c�mmunity.
t. Marylyn Purcell si;ned in opposition of the application and stated that she is
completely opposed to this snbdivision and expresses her concerns for her pr�perty
rights as a neighbor.
u. Carolyn Scl�ramm signed in opposition ta tlie application and stated her concerns
for irrigation and drainage proble►ns.
v. Kathy Gipson signed in opposition to the application and stated her ccxncerns for
irrigation and drainabe problems.
w. Mr. Orton stated that a pressure irrigation system will be required so that will
alleviate some of the problems caused by the overilow of irrigation water down the
street.
x. C�rolynn Schramm si�ned in opposition to the application and stated lier concerns
fot� the conditions of the ir pipes.
y. Mr. Orton stated that tlie applicant is required to instal( �1ew irrigation pipes that are
capable of withstanding the pressure of the irribation water.
• z. David Whitney stated thai the nei�hbors hzve one right uncler the v�riance statute.
aa. Commissioner Runsvold asked Mr. Whitney how the cul-de-sac variance is going
to aFfect the surroi�t�ding neighbors.
bb. Mr. Whitney stated that granting the variance is fhe only way tl�e commission lias
control over this application.
cc. Th� following peaple signed in o�position of the application but did n�t wish to
speak: Glen Nielson and Marie Neilson.
dd. The following people signed Neutral to the application but did not �-vish to speak:
Stacey Dye and Randy Dye.
ee. Greg Lovan, applicant's representative, signed in favor of the application and
provided stipporting testimony stating the applicant's intentions and that tl�e
applicani is going to live among the homes and has a very �ested interest in tl�e
planning of tl�e homes.
ff. Troy Behlmin stated tl�at tllere was no e�Pfort to dihite the �krtrtb �n a.ny way.
MOTION TO CLOSE TESTIMONY: Commissioner Wailace SECOND: Commissioner Runsvold
Passed: Unanimous roll call vote.
�
. nn C;ommissinner Shaffer stated that he wouid like to see this case tabled to #he next
hearing date. Commissioner Shaffer then stated that he would like the engineer for
this project to provide the sizes of the lots on a vicinity map.
hh. Commissioner OldenKamp stated that he would like to see a vinyl fence installed
surrounding the property and that if the irrigation ditch does belong to the applicant
it needs to be tiled or covered.
ii. Commissioner Shaffer stated that he would like to see the pipe and ditch shown on
the plans.
jj. Commissioner Shaffer stipulated that a neighborhood meeting be held so that the
developer can answer questions by neighbors before the next meeting of the
Pianning and Zoning Commission.
MOTION TO CONTINUE: Commissioner Wallace SECOND: Commissioner Runsvold Passed:
Unanimous roll call vote.
D. Case Number ANN-1.62-07 & SUB-180-07, a request by Nlorgail DeveLopment,lVlatt
Morgan, Legacy Falls LLC and 'I'odd Meyers far anncxation of 21.56 acres with C-l.
Neighborhood Comrnercial zoning, a developmeiit agrec-ment and preliminaiy plat
approval of Legacy Falls SLibdivision consisting of 10 comrllercial lots. The site is
located at the southeast corner of Karcher Road anci Florida Avenue.
�
Testimony:
a. Anne Nlarie Skinner, Senior Planner, presented tlie staff report.
b. 'I'odd Meyers, �pplicant's representative, signed in favoi• of the application and
submitted a large overall site plan that was labeled as PZ-1000.
a Commissio�ner Sl�after aslced if anything had been dor�e to make the development
more aesthetically pleasing to tlie surrounding properties.
d. IVIr. Meyers stated that landscaping, fencing aud lighting would be used.
e. Brent Orton, city en;;ineer, stated that a traffic study lias not been completed and
will have to be completed before this case can inove forward to a City Council
hearing.
f. Keith Jacobs, applicaut's engineer, signed in favor of the applicatio►i but did not
wish to speak.
MOTION TO CLOSE TESTIMONY: Commissioner Runsvold SECOND: Commissioner
O1denKamp Passecl: Unanimous roll call vote.
Comprehensive Plan Analysis — MOTION: Commissioner Wallace SECOND: Commissioner
OldenKamp . Passed: Unanimous roll call vote.
• Findings af Fact on Case Number ANN-162-07 — Accepted MOTION: Commissioner Runsvold
SECOND: Commissioner Wallace
Conclusions of Law on Case No. ANN-162-07 —The conclusions of law were read and
. accepted. MOTION: Commissioner Teraberry SECOND: Commissioner OldenKamp
Recommendation on Case No. ANN-162-07- MOTION: Commissioner Runsvold SECOND:
Commissioner Teraberry. The Commission voted to recommend Approval with the following
conditions:
• 8.2 as written in the staff report.
MOTION TO RESCIND THE MOTION TO RECOMMEND APPROVAL: Commissioner Shaffer
SECOND: Commissioner Wallace Passed: Unanimous roll call vote.
Recommendation on Case No. ANN-162-07- MOTION: Commissioner Shaffer SECOND:
Commissioner Runsvold. The Commission voted to recommend Approval with the following
conditions:
• 8.2 as written in the staff report.
• 8.3 the development agreement shali also include the requirement that all building plans
for buiidings abutting Highway 55 and any residential shall have to be reviewed and
approved by the Design Review Commission prior to building permit application.
Findings of Fact on Case Number SUB-180-07 — Accepted MOTION: Commissioner Runsvold
• SECOND: Commissioner Shaffer
Conclusions of Law on Case No. SUB-180-07 —The conclusions of law were read and
accepted. MOTION: Commissioner Runsvold SECOND: Commiss+oner Teraberry .
Recommendation on Case Na. SUB-180-07 - MOTION: Commissioner Wallace SECOND:
Commissioner Runsvold. The Commission voted to recommend Approval with the following
conditions:
• 11.1-11.30
D. Case Number OA-88-07, a request by the Planning and Zoning Director for an ordinance
amendment creating a new zoning classification called the College Distric (C-D) and
amending the Caldwell zaning map to identify the location of this new zone.
a. Brian Billingsley presented the staff report and explained the area where the new
College zoning district would be. Mr.Billingsley also stated that the current zoning
of this area is R-2 (Combined-Medium Density Residential) which requires the
college to obtain a special use permit for most land use development.
• b. Mr. Billingsley then read a letter in favor into the record that was labeled PZ-
1001. Mr. Billingsley stated that a bed and breakfast will not be permitted in the
• rnilann rli�fri�t anYl that lhoro !S !?0 f'O:.�nularv orrnr Tho �nlloryo O::in� � r,�r�ol nf
�" � y ., r ..,
land in the historic district and will be required to follow the regulations set forth
by the Historic Preservation Committee for that parcel.
c. Commissioner Runsvold asked if a dance hali or a bar was considered.
d. Mr. Billingsley stated that neither would be permitted.
e. Chris Anton signed in favor of the appiication and provided supporting testimony.
f. Commissioner Runsvoid asked Mr. Anton how much of a burden the Special Use
Permit process has been on the college.
g. Mr. Anton stated that there hasn't been very much expansion for the process to
become a burden, but because of the plan for future expansions this would make
it much easier.
h. Andy Erstat signed in favor of the application and provided supporting testimony.
Comprehensive Plan Analysis — MOTION: Commissioner SECOND: Commissioner Teraberry.
Passed: Unanimous roll call vote.
i. Commissioner OldenKamp asked if properties surrounding the college district
could change their zoning to college district zoning
j. Brian Billingsley stated that yes they wouid be able to change their zoning to
College District if it was applied for.
Findings af Fact on Case Number OA-88-07 — Accepted MOTION: Commissioner Runsvold
. SECOND: Commissioner Wallace
Conclusions of Law on Case No. OA-88-07 —The conclusions of law were read and accepted.
MOTION: Commissioner Shaffer SECOND: Commissioner Teraberry.
Recommendation on Case No. OA-88-07 - MOTION: Commissioner Wallce SECOND:
Commissioner Shaffer. The Commission voted to recommend Approval with the following
conditions:
• 8.2 as written in the staff report.
V. Planning Issues
Brian informed the commission about the Sept. 13 open house for the Comprehensive Plan
1VIap.
VI. Adjournment
Adjourn public hearing MOTION: Commissioner Runsvold SECOND: Commissioner Wallace
• Passeci: Unanimous roll call vote. The n.ieeting was adjourned at 10:00 pm.
• MiT�ITTTF< APPR(IVFn AT�1Tl CI(;T�I�TI T2V (�i[ATRPFRC(l�l 1(lV(''F rRIG'FiT1-I flTl TT-1R
Df1TE NOTED BELOW:
1? v� '
Joyce Griffith Date ,
�� . �,�..-
AT'I'ES1': �
Planniilg ai�d Loning Director
�
r
�