Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout7-10-2007 P&Z MINUTES �' . t r � AP p� • CALllWELL PLANNING AND ZONIN� COMMISSION MINUTES July 10, 2007 I. Calt to Order — Commissioi�er Griffith called the meeting to order for the public hearing at 7:00 p.m. lt. Roll Call — Members Present: Joyce Griffith, Gene Shaffer, James Kunsvold,lVlichael Jakobson, Scott Wallace, Jack Teraberry. Diselosures: Michael Jakobson and Joyce Griffith recused themselves frorn agenda Item B. due to conflict of interest. ' Members Absent: none ' Staff Present: Brian Billingsley (Planning Director), Anne Marie Skinner (Senior Planner), Brent Orton (City Engineer), Savanna Davis (Secretary). April Cabello (Planning Technician) II L Revie�� of Proceeding — Commissioner Griffith announced tl�e procedures foi• the public � � l�earing. IV. New Susiness B. Case Number SUP-296-07, a request by Lindsay and lacob Hendricks a»d Cory Jakobson for special use permit approval of a four-plex unit located in an R-2 Combined. Medilun Density reside»tial zone. The site is located north of Beech Street on the east side of 1716 Beech Street. Testimony: a. Brian Billingsley, Plaiming Director, presented the staff repoi�l and subm_itted engineering comments that were labeled as exhibit PZ-1000. b. Cory Jakobson, applicant, signed in favor and provided supparting testimony and submitted an architectural rendering as PZ-10U1. c. Commissioner Griffth asked the applicant if his intention was to use tl�is property as a rental. d. Mr. Jakobson stated that the property is intended to be a rental. e. Commissioner Teraberry asked if the homes in the area are one or two story homes. f. Mr. J�kobson stated that the homes in the area were a mixture of one and two story homes. g. Commissioi�er Ciriffith asked about the E�rc�posed clevelopments landscaping. h. Mr. Jakobson stated ihat the City of Caldwell does not have any requirements for � landscaping. � i. Commissioner Tereaberry felt it would be appropriate to have a five minute recess for the a.pplicant to review engineeria�g comments. MOTION TO RECESS: Commissioner Shaffer SECOND: Commissioner Wallace Passed: Unanimous roll call vote. j. Commissioner Gi•iffith recused l�erself asid Co�iimissioner Jakobson from this item on the agenda due to conflict of interest. Commissioner Runsvold was tllen elected as the actiug chairman. Commissioner Teraberry SECOND: Commissioner Wallace Passed: Ui�animous roll call vote. k. Commissioner Runsvold asked tl�e a.pplicant if he had adequate time to review tl�e comments from the engineerin�; department. L 1VIr. Jakobson stated tha.t he did and the only amendment that he would ask for is to be permitted to use city water if irrigation was not available. m. Breut Orton, city engineer, stated that it would be fine to use city services as long as irrigation is not available. n. Tom Eastham signed in opposition to tl�e application and stated l�is concerns for building above the se�ver lines. o. IVIr: Orton stated that building on top of a sewer line is not permitted. If the sewer line runs tllrough the property it would have to be relocated. • p. Mr. Eastha�n stated that he doesn't want another four-plex to be built in the neigllborhood. q. Shelbi Luckhurst signed in opposition and stated tllat she did i�ot believe that the sewer easement was available and she also expressed her co»cerns for keeping her access to the irrigation open. r. Mr. Orton tllen stated that developers are required to preserve irrigation aud drainage riglits for tl�e surrounding properties. s. Commissioner Shaffer asked the applicant if he could provide a site plan sl�owing how the adjacent properties are impacted a.nd the elevations on tl�e properties at the next months hearing. t. This case was continued to the l�earing on August 14, 2007. MOTION TO CLOSE PUI3LIC TESTIMONY: Commissioner Shaffer S�COND: Commissioner Wallace Passed: Unanimous roll call vote. V. Old Business A. Approve miilutes of June 12, 2007. MOTION: Commissioner Wallace SECOND: I Commissioner Run.svold. Passed: Ui�animous roll call vote. • I � B. (continued) Case Number ANN-141-06 & ZON-50-06, a request by Oakwood Enterprises for annexation of 6.67 acres into the City of Caldwe(1 with a G2 Community Commercial zoi�e, rezone approval of 4.13 acres from an R-3 Multi-Family High Density Residential zoue to a C-2 Community Commercial zone, a Comprehensive plan map amendment fram A�riculture to Commercial and Development Agreement. The site is located at 5022 Highway 20/26. Testimony: a. Anne 1Vlarie Skinner, Senior Planner, presented the staff report, read a letter from Kent Brown into the record and read an E-mail from Breut Orton i»to the record. Ms. Skinner also stated that the biggest issue with tl�.is case is the easement. b. Kent Brown, applicant's representative, stateci that he would like a cl�ance to work with staff, ITD and the higl�way district regarding easements. MOTION TO CLOSE PUBLIC TESTIMONY: Commissioner Rimsvold SECOND: Conlmissioner Wallace Passed: Unanimous roll call vote. Comprehensive Plan Analysis — MOTION: Commissioner Wallace SECON.D: Comrnissioner TeraUerry. .Passed: Unanimous roll call vote. � Findings of Fact on Case Number ANN-141-06 — Accepted MOTION: Commissioner Runsvold SECOND: Cornmissioner Wa(lace Conclusions of Law on Case No. ANN-141-06 —The conclusions of law were read and acce�ted. MOTION: Commissioner Shaffer SECOND: Commissioner Teraberry. Recommendation on Case No. ANN-141-06 - MOT10N: Commissioner VVallace SECOND: Commissioner Shaffer. The Commission voted to recommend Approval with the following conditions: • 8.2 as written in tlie staff report. Findings of Fact on Case lYumber ZON-50-06 — Acceptecl MOTION: Commissioner Runsvold SECOND: Commissioner Wallace. Conclusions of Law on Case No. ZON-50-06 —The conclusions of 1aw were read and acceptea. iV10TlON: Commissiouer Sl�affer SECOND: Commissioner Teraberry. Recommendation on Case No. ZON-50-06 - MOTION: Commissioner Runsvold SECOND: Commissioner Wallace. T'he Commission voted to recoulinend App�•ova( . � Yassed: Unanimous roll call vote. � � C. (Continued ) Case Numbers ANN-156-06 & SUB/PUD-176-07, a request by Fran.klin Freeman Teleos Parteners and WRG Design for a�inexation of 35.71 acres into tl;e City of Caldwell wit1� an R-S-2 (Semi-Rural Residential 2) zone, a comprehensive plan map designation of low density reside»tial, a development agreement and a preliminary plat/pla»ned unit development for Cedar Crossing East consisting of 77 residential lots and 17 common lots. The site located at 15217 Lake Avenue. Testimony: a. Anne Marie Skinner, Senior Planner, presented tlie staff report and stated that exhibit PZ-]003 (an architectural rendering), PZ-1004 (setback delegations), and PZ-1005 (a large Cedar Crossing project outline) had been submitted. b. Asl.iley Ford, applicant's representative, signed in favor of the application and provided supporting testimony. c. Nancy Henty signed neutral to the app(ication and did not wish to speak. d. Kelly Miller signed in favor of the application and stated that this project has mixed • uses. e. Commissioner R.unsvold stated that condition 11.33 will be modified to read as follows: • Front yard setback from 25 feet to 15 feet for the following lots shall. only be granted: lots 5 of Block 7 and lots 1 of Block 10. MOTION TO CLOSE PUI3LIC TESTIMONY: Commissioner Wallace S�COND: Commi.ssioner Runsvold Passed: Unanimous roll cal.l. vote. 1VIOTION TO RE-OPEN PUBLIC TESTIMONY: Commissioner Shaffer SECOND: Commissioner Teraberry Passed: Unanimous roll call vote. M:OTION TO CLOSC PUBLIC TESTIMONY: Co�nmissioner Runsvold SECOND: Commissioner Shaffer Passed: Un�nirnous roll call vote. Comprehensive Ptan Anatysis — MOT(ON: Commissioner Wallace SECOND: Cammissioner Shaffer. Passed: Unanimous roll call vote. Findings of Fact on Case Number ANN-1_56-07 — Accepted NIOTION: Commissioner Kunsvold SECOND: Commissioner Wallace • � Conclusions of Law on Case No. ANN-156-07—The conclusions of law were read and accepted. MOTION: Commissioner Shaffer SECOND: Commissioner Runsvold. Recommendation on Case No. ANN-156-07- MOTION: Commissioner Rusvold SECOND: Commissioner Wallace. The Commission voted to recon�mend Approval with the following conditions: • 8.2 as written in the staff report. Findings of Fact on Case Number SUB/PUD-176I'-07 — Acce�ted MOTION: Commissioner Wallace SECOND: Commissioner Shaffer. Conclusions of Law on Case No. SUB/PUD-176P-07 —The conclusions of law were read and acceptecl. MOTION: Commissioner Runsvold SECOND: Comnlissioner Wallace. Recommendation on Case No. SUI3/PUD-176P-07 - 1VfOTION: Commissioner Runsvold SECOND: Commissioner Wallace. The Commission voted to recommend Approval with the following conditions: • 1 I.33 modified as stated above. � VI. New Business A. Case Number ANN-161-07, a request by Jol�n and Sallie Palleria for annexation of 2.5 acres into the City of Caldwell with an R-1 Single-Family Residential zone. Tl�e site is located at 2511 Dori�ian Avenue. Testimon : Y a. Anne Marie Skini�er, Senior Plaziner, presented the staff repot�t. � b. John Palleria, applieaut, signed in ,favor of tl�e applicatio�i a��d stated tl�.at he chose to apply to aunex into the city limits so that l�e could hook up to city services in the future because he is current(y having problems with his well. c. Commissioner Runsvold asked staff if tl�e applicant would have to pay additional fees if he does hook up to city services. d. Brent Orton, city engineer, stated tl�at yes an additional fee would be required at the time of liook up if tlie parcel is large enougli to be subdivided, but tl�e price would be reduced accordingly. MOTION TO CLOSE 1'UBLIC TESTIMONY: Cominissioner Runsvold SECOND: Commissioner Teraberry Passed: Unanimous roll call vote. � � Comprehensive Plan Analysis — MOTION: Commissioner Runsvold SECOND: Commissioner Shaffer. Passed: Unanimous roll ca11 vote. Findings of Fact—Accepted MOTION: Commissioner Walla.ce SECOND: Commissioner Shaffer. Conetusions of Law —The co�lclusions of law were read and accepted. MOT10N: Commissioner Shaffer SECOND: Commissioner Runsvold. Recommendation on Case No. ANN-161-07 - M.OTION: Commissio»er Kunsvold SECOND: Commissioner Shaffer. Tl�e Co�nmission voted to recoimnend Approval with the followiug conditions: • 8.2 as written in the staf'f report. C. Case Number OA-81-06, a request by the Planning Zoning Director to revise the City of Caldwell's landscaping ordinance. Testimony: a. Anne Marie Skin»er, Senior Planner, presented the staff report. b. Commi.ssioners discussed berii�, and fence eights and porous surfaces. . C. The commission decided to continue this case so staff could address tl�ose issues. MOTION TO CLOSE TESTI1V10NY: Commissioner Teraberiy SECOND: Commissioner Wallace Passed: Unanimous roll call vote. M T � - - - - O ION TO CONTINUE CAS� NO. ANN 156 07 & SUB/PUD 176P U7: Commissioner Runsvold SECOND: Shaffer Passed: Unanimous roll call vote VIT. Planning Issues V[[1. Adjournment � + � Adjourn public hearing MOTION: Coinmissioner Runsvold SECOND: Com.missioner Teraberry Passed: Unanimous roll call vote. The meeting was adjourned at 10:00 pm. MINUTES APPROVED AND SIGNED BY CHAIRPERSON JOYCE GRIFFI:TH ON THE DATE NOTED BELOW: ,� � � ,�� �� - � �� Joyce Griffitl� Illate AT.TEST: �- Planning and Zoning Director � •