Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout8-22-2006 HE MINUTES . � CALDWELL HEARING EXAMINER • MINI�ITFS �PPROV�D August 22, 2006 �� I. Call to Order — Hearing Examiner, M. Jerome Mapp, opened the meeting for the public hearing at 7:02 p.m. II. Review of Proceedings — Mr. Jerome Mapp outlined the procedures for the public hearing. Members Present: Brian Billingsley (Senior Planner), David Richey (Associate Planner), Dee Fernandez (Secretary), Brent Orton (Engineering Department) and Mark Hilty (City Attorney). III. Old Business A. Mr. Mapp approved the minutes of the July 25, 2006 meeting. B. Case Number VAR-29-06, a request by Windsor Creek LLC, for a variance of ordinance 11-03-02, Street Location and Alignment. The site is located south of Homedale Road and east of Lake Avenue. Testimony: • Brian Billingsley, Senior Planner, informed Mr. Mapp that the applicant requested this case to be continued. Mr. Mapp approved the case to be continued. Mr. Mapp asked if anyone in the audience was in attendance for this case; there was no one. Case continued — Mr. Mapp continued case number VAR-29-06 to the September 26, 2006 Hearing Examiner public hearing. IV. New Business A. Case Number VAR-30-06, a request made by Vern and Judy Subia for variance approval regarding frontage requirement for 2205 College Avenue. Testimony: Brian Billingsley, Senior Ptanner, informed Mr. Mapp that this case is to be continued due to an error in the mailing notice (site address). Mr. Mapp approved the case to be continued. Mr. Mapp asked if anyone in the audience was in attendance for this case; there was no one. Case continued — Mr. Mapp continued case number VAR-30-06 to the September 26, 2006 Hearing Examiner public hearing. • ............................................................................... B. Case Number SUB-154PF-06, a request made by Tom Krause for short plat approval of Carrington Center, located on the southeast corner of Ustick Road and 10 Avenue. Caldwell Hearing Examiner Page 1 of 5 Minutes — August 22, 2006 � y � T��±� Ht � �1"1 V' .�. Brian Billingsley, Senior Planner, informed Mr. Mapp that the applicant requested this case to be continued. Mr. Mapp approved the case to be continued. Mr. Mapp asked if anyone in the audience was in attendance for this case; there was no one. Case continued — Mr. Mapp continued case number SUB-154PF-06 to the October 24, 2006 Hearing Examiner public hearing. ............................................................................... C. Case Number ANN-126-06, a request made by Brad & Jennifer Dugan for annexation of 0.661 acre parcel into the City with R-1 (Single Family Residential) zoning. The site is located at 3521 South Montana. Testimony: David Richey, Associate Planner, presented the staff report. Brent Orton, Engineering department, read additional conditions into the record that were not included in the staff report. This information was given to the applicant at the meeting, off the record. Mr. Mapp stressed the importance of the applicant being made aware of conditions prior • to public hearings. Brad Dugan, applicant, signed in favor and provided testimony. His reason for the annexation request is to have City services (sewer and water); Southwest Health District will not allow him to have a septic system. Public testimony closed — Mr. Mapp closed public testimony. Comprehensive Plan Analysis: Mr. Mapp found that the request was applicable to the Comprehensive Plan components listed in Sections 5.1 through 5.4 in the staff report. Findings of Fact: The Hearing Examiner accepted the general facts as outlined in the staff report and public testimony as a part of the Findings. Conclusions of Law: The Hearing Examiner accepted the Conclusions of Law as outlined in the staff report. Recommendation: The Hearing Examiner recommended approval of Case Number ANN-126-06, a request by Brad and Jennifer Dugan to annex a 0.661-acre parcel of land into the City of Caldwell with R-1 zoning, with the condition of ineeting the requirements of the Engineering department as stated by Brent Orton. Case closed. • NOTE: See Recommendation for complete testimony or contact Community Development Department for audio tapes of the hearing. Caldwell Hearing Examiner Page 2 of 5 Minutes — August 22, 2006 � � ............................................................................... • D. Case number ZON-47-06 & SUP-275-06, requests made by Gary McCallister for rezoning from R-1 Single Family Residential to R-3 Multi Family High Density Residential, and special use permit approval for professional medical offices. The site is located on 10' Street between Ash and Elm Streets. Testimony: David Richey, Associate Planner, presented the staff report. Exhibit SP-5 was submitted from the audience containing colored photos, map identifying the site and a petition in opposition. Mr. Richey announced that City Attorney Mark Hilty wished to address the Hearing Examiner. Mark Hilty, City Attorney, provided testimony about the history of development of the site, and a temporary parking allowance made by the previous Community Development Director, Gian Paolo Mammone. Brent Orton, Engineering Department, answered Mr. Mapp's question about a development agreement. Brian Billingsley, Senior Planner, testified about the surrounding land use of the property. Mr. Billingsley presented PZ-1000, a map submitted by the applicant. He stated that six letters were received from nearby property owners that objected to the applicant's request. He read the names and addresses of the letter writers into the • record. Mr. Mapp reviewed the letters for reasons of objection. Larry Knopp, applicant's representative and architect, signed in favor and gave testimony. Gary McAllister, applicant, signed in favor and provided testimony. He read a letter from Zions Bank into the record. The letter was marked as exhibit PZ-1001. John Blaisdell, applicant, signed in favor of the application and provided testimony. Travis Manning signed in opposed to the application and gave testimony. He is concerned about increased traffic on 10 Avenue, and wants the neighborhood to remain as R-1 zoning. Ken Stringfield signed in opposed to the application and gave testimony. He is concerned about the lighting, increased traffic, the parking lot where cars still park, and dust from the parking lot. He submitted exhibit PZ-1002 a letter from Melvin Landers, PZ-1003 a petition signed by 26 neighborhood residents, and PZ-1004 photographs and a letter from Melissa Stringfield. Katherine Kerrick signed in opposed to the application and gave testimony. She submitted P�-1005 a black binder. Ms. Kerrick wants to preserve the neighborhood integrity, and is opposed to 10 Avenue frontage. . David Kerrick signed in opposed to the application and gave testimony. He submitted PZ-1006 a notice of claim against the City of Caldwell regarding a parking facility in an R-1 zone. Caldwell Hearing Examiner Page 3 of 5 Minutes —August 22, 2006 � • �w y �A��!!;�±°r ::�w� rarallari fnr rghi_rf_tal tf?Gtimnnv_ Mark Hilty answered Mr. Mapp's question about the approval process of the rezone application separately from the special use application, since a portion of the site does not require a zone change. Public testimony closed — Mr. Mapp closed public testimony. Comprehensive Plan Analysis: Mr. Mapp found that the request was applicable to the Comprehensive Plan components listed in Sections 5.1 through 5.6 in the staff report. Findings of Fact: The Hearing Examiner accepted the general facts as outlined in the staff report and pub�ic testimony as a part of the Findings. Conclusions of Law: The Hearing Examiner accepted the Conclusions of Law as outlined in the staff report. Recommendation: The Hearing Examiner recommended approval of Case Number ANN-126-06, a request by Brad and Jennifer Dugan to annex a 0.661-acre parcel of land into the City of Caldwell with R-1 zoning, with the condition of ineeting the requirements of the Engineering department as stated by Brent Orton. Mr. Mapp stated the following conditions: 1. Applicant shall provide site plan showing all streets, existing and easements • including Fairview. 2. Development should show everything except R-1 zone. 3. There shall be 20 feet of landscaping along the public street. 4. There shall be landscaping in front and parking in the rear. 5. There shall be connectivity for sidewalks and interior driveways. 6. Landscaping: Mr. Mapp agrees that a detailed landscaping plan is not required, but it should be detailed enough. He does not want a"sea of asphalt." 7. Mr. Mapp wants to see elevation of the buildings. He needs more detail in order to make an informed decision. A development agreement will not provide the detail that is required. 8. Case is deferred to next hearing examiner meeting. These details shall be submitted to Brian Billingsley in Community Development at least two weeks prior to the next Hearing Examiner meeting on September 26, 2006, in order for the neighbors to have reasonable time to review the information. Zone change request is not approved. Both cases deferred to next meeting. Mr. Mapp has no problem with the special use permit application as a concept, but he does not have enough information to make a decision tonight. For any questions, Mr. Mapp instructed the audience to contact staff. Case deferred to September 26, 2006. NOTE: See Recommendation for complete testimony or contact Community Development Department for audio tapes of the hearing. ,� ............................................................................... V. Planning Issues Caldwell Hearing Examiner Page 4 of 5 Minutes — August 22, 2006 . \/1 Arli���rnrr�nn+ Y�. /'�M�VM������v��L The Hearing Examiner adjourned the meeting at approximately 10:00, and then reopened the hearing to state that he requires a large drawing, 18 x 24 or larger. The Hearing Examiner adjourned the meeting at approximately 10:15. MINUTES APPROVED AND SIGNED BY THE HEARING EXAMINER, M. JEROME MAPP, ON THE DATE NOTED BELOW: ATTEST: M. Jerome Mapp Date Community Development Director � i Caldwell Hearing Examiner Page 5 of 5 Minutes —August 22, 2006