HomeMy WebLinkAbout5-16-2006 HE MINUTES ,x
CALDWELL PUBLIC HEARING BEFORE HEARING EXAMINER
� MINUTES
May 16, 2006
APPRO ED
I. Call to Order — Hearing Examiner, M. Jerome Mapp, opened the meeting for the public
hearing at 7:12 p.m.
II. Review of Proceedings — Mr. Jerome Mapp outlined the procedures for the public
hearing.
Members Present: Brian Billingsley (Senior Planner), David Richey (Associate Planner),
Dee Fernandez (Secretary) and Mike Piechowski (Engineering Department).
III. Old Business
1. Mr. Mapp approved the minutes of the April 16, 2006 meeting.
2. Case Number SUB-143P-06, a request by North Pole LLC for preliminary plat approval
of Caldwell Crossing Subdivision containing 7 commercial lots and one common lot on
approximately 5.86 acres in a C-2 (Community Commercial) zone. The site is located at
the northeast corner of Franklin Road (Highway 20/26) and Smeed Parkway.
Testimony:
• Brian Billingsley, Senior Planner, presented the staff report. Mr. Billingsley clarified that
the agenda was incorrect, and that the subdivision is actually 6 commercial lots and one
common lot. He also pointed out a discrepancy on the staff report, item 2.7.4 on page 2,
that the right-of-way should be listed as 70 feet and not 50 feet.
Dennis Montgomery, Applicant, of Treasure Valley Engineers, testified in favor of the
application. Plat maps were submitted by Mr. Montgomery as exhibits PZ-1000 (8.5" x
11") and PZ-1001 (11" x 17").
Bob Runyan, Applicant, of Treasure Valley Engineers, testified in favor of the
application. He addressed two issues in the staff report, regarding fire sprinklers, and
the traffic study. Mr. Runyan expects to have the first issue of fire sprinklers addressed
when he receives a letter from Doug Brown of the Fire Department in the future.
Mr. Runyan then addressed the issue of traffic mitigation, and asked for clarification of
the 29% figure used in the traffic report. Mike Piechowski of Engineering responded,
requesting that the issue be deferred so that the City Engineer Brent Orton could
respond. Mr. Mapp clarified if the concern could be made in writing in order to put into
the record, to be considered before City Council.
Public testimony closed — Mr. Mapp closed public testimony.
Findings of Fact: The Hearing Examiner accepted the general facts as outlined in the
• staff report, public testimony and Exhibits PZ-1000 and PZ-1001 as a part of the
Findings.
Caldwell Hearing Examiner
Minutes — May 16, 2006
.Y
Conclusions of Law: The Hearing Examiner accepted the Conclusions of Law as '�
• outlined in the staff report.
Comprehensive Plan Analysis: The Hearing Examiner accepted 5.1 — 5.9 of the staff
report.
Recommendation on Preliminary Plat: The Hearing Examiner recommended approval
of Case Number SUB-143P-06, North Pole LLC for preliminary plat approval of Caldwell
Crossing Subdivision containing 6 commercial lots and two common lots on
approximately 5.86 acres in a C-2 (Community Commercial) zone with the conditions
outlined in Sections 8.1 through 8.30 as written, and with changes in 2.7.4 in staff report
— should be 70 feet not 50 feet, plus the following conditions for City Council's
consideration:
1. Site plan for fire management emergency services and truck
access.
2. Structures to be considered for access.
3. Provide additional landscaping according to City code to relieve
pressure of asphalt and heat in the area.
Case closed.
NOTE: See order of Decision for complete testimony or contact Community
Development Department for audio tapes of the hearing.
• IV. New Business/Hearings —
A. Case Number SUP-270-06, a request by the City of Caldwell, for special use permit
approval to operate a public park in a C-2 (Community Commercial) zone. The site is
located at the corner of Kimball Avenue and Arthur Street.
Testimony:
Brian Billingsley, Senior Planner, stated that the City of Caldwell requested this case be
continued to the June 27, 2006 meeting.
Mr. Mapp stated for the record that this case shall be continued to June 27, 2006. There
were no comment sheets received from the audience for this case.
NOTE: See order of Decision for complete testimony or contact Community
Development Department for audio tapes of the hearing.
..............................................................................�
B. Case Number SUP-263-06, a request by Our Lady of the Valley Catholic Church &
Parish Center c/o Roman Catholic Diocese of Boise, for special use permit approval to
operate meeting rooms in an R-1 (Single Family Residential) zone. The site is located at
1122 West Linden.
• Testimony:
Caldwell Hearing Examiner
Minutes — May 16, 2006
i
David Richey, Associate Planner, testified to give the staff report. Before Mr. Richey
� gave the staff report, Mr. Mapp commented that he had heard this case about three
years ago, and that the request should read "expansion of SUP" since one of the
conditional use permit was to come back if an expansion was requested. Discussion
was also held concerning parking.
Greg Ugrin, applicant's representative and architect, testified in favor of the application
and gave some specific information. Mr. Ugrin stated this project was shelved due to
finances, and that he believed the prior SUP was approved with expansions. Mr. Mapp
stated he did not remember the approval with expansions.
Chuck McHugh, applicant's representative, testified in favor of the application. He stated
that there was a neighborhood meeting with those in the surrounding area, and that no
one in attendance was opposed.
Patsy Lodge signed in favor of the application and did not speak.
Public testimony closed — Mr. Mapp closed public testimony.
Comprehensive Plan Analysis: Mr. Mapp found that the request was applicable to the
Comprehensive Plan components listed in Sections 5.1 through 5.6 in the staff report.
Findings of Fact: The Hearing Examiner accepted the general facts as outlined in the
staff report and public testimony as a part of the Findings.
Conclusions of Law: The Hearing Examiner accepted the Conclusions of Law as
. outlined in the staff report.
Order of Decision: The Hearing Examiner ordered approval of Case Number SUP-263-
06, a request by Our Lady of the Valley Catholic Church & Parish Center c/o Roman
Catholic Diocese of Boise, for special use permit approval to operate meeting rooms in
an R-1 (Single Family Residential) zone, with conditions 8.2 — 8.11.
Case closed.
NOTE: See order of Decision for complete testimony or contact Community
Development Department for audio tapes of the hearing.
..............................................................................�
C. Case Number ANN-120-06, a request by West Valley Construction, to annex
approximately 23.07 acres into the City as an M-1 (Light Industrial) zone. The site is
located north of Linden Street and west of KCID Road.
Testimony:
Brian Billingsley, Senior Planner, presented the staff report. He stated that the name of
the applicant has changed since the agenda was printed. The applicant name is
Lemrick Properties, LLC. Mr. Billingsley asked to submit the development agreement
into the record concerning the realignment of Smeed Parkway. Mr. Billingsley asked to
• clarify that Mr. Mapp had received the revised copy of the staff report, dated May 15,
Caldwell Hearing Examiner
Minutes — May 16, 2006
2006. The revised staff report included the applicant name and minor revisions made by
• the Engineering Department.
Penelope Constantikes, applicant's representative, of Treasure Valley Engineering
testified in favor of the application.
Jim McGarvin, applicant's representative, signed in favor of the applicant and testified
about the project.
Mike Lemrick, applicant, signed in favor of the applicant and did not testify.
Findings of Fact: The Hearing Examiner accepted the general facts as outlined in the
staff report and public testimony as a part of the Findings, 5.1 — 5.3 of the
Comprehensive Plan Analysis.
Recommendation: The Hearing Examiner recommended approval of Case Number
ANN-120-06, a request by Lemrick Properties, LLC, to annex approximately 23.07 acres
into the City as an M-1 (Light Industrial) zone to include a development agreement.
Case closed.
NOTE: See order of Decision for complete testimony or contact Community
Development Department for audio tapes of the hearing.
..............................................................................�
• D. Case Number SUP-268-06, a request by Brian Donesley, for special use permit approval
to operate a saloon/nightclub in a C-3 (Service Commercial) zone. The site is located at
4498 Nampa-Caldwell Blvd.
Testimony:
Brian Billingsley, Senior Planner, presented the staff report. Mr. Billingsley provided
clarification on one point in the staff report, concerning a single family residence behind
the proposed site, and a proposed buffer between the site and the residence. Upon a
drive-by inspection, he stated that it appeared that the residence was being torn down.
Mr. Mapp commented about a prior case with a bar that required the building to be fire
sprinkled, per poug Brown of the Fire Department. According to Mr. Billingsley's notes
of a March 23, 2006 roundtable meeting, the Fire Department again required fire
sprinklers in this building.
Brian Donesley, applicant, signed in favor of the application and gave testimony. Mr.
Donesley sent a letter to adjacent land owners in April and received no response. In
reference to the 5,000 square foot usage of a 13,000 square foot building, he testified
that there are no current proposals for the remainder of the building. He further stated
that the application is for 4,999 square feet, specifically to avoid the fire suppression
system requirement of a building of 5,000 square feet.
Mr. Donesley addressed Mr. Mapp's questions about parking and landscaping issues.
�
Caldwell Hearing F�caminer
Minutes — May 16, 2006
Brad Evans and Sevina Evans signed in opposed to the application. Brad Evans
• provided testimony. Mr. Evans owns an independent car dealership next to the proposed
site, and he expressed his concerns about health issues, vandalism, theft, trash and
abandoned vehicles.
Mr. Donseley gave rebuttal testimony and addressed Mr. Evans' concerns.
Public testimony closed — Mr. Mapp closed public testimony.
Findings of Fact: The Hearing Examiner accepted the general facts as outlined in the
staff report and public testimony as a part of the Findings, sections 5.1 — 5.6.
Conclusions of Law: The Hearing Examiner accepted the Conclusions of Law as
outlined in the staff report.
Order of Decision: The Hearing Examiner ordered approval of Case Number SUP-268-
06, a request by Brian Donesley, for special use permit approval to operate a
saloon/nightclub in a C-3 (Service Commercial) zone, with conditions 8.2 — 8.11 as
written, and adding the following conditions:
1. Applicant shall install a 6-foot fence on the berm between the subject property
and Mr. Evans' property.
2. No expansion will be allowed unless a special use permit is approved.
3. If the Proposed development becomes a nuisance, the City may revoke said
permit.
4. Applicant should consider having external security during business hours. This is
i not a condition.
Mr. Mapp directed Mr. Donesely to speak with staff about the conditions. Public
testimon was not reo ened.
Y p
Case closed.
NOTE: See order of Decision for complete testimony or contact Community
Development Department for audio tapes of the hearing.
..............................................................................�
E. Case Numbers ANN-118-06 and SUB-146P-06 (Bear Ridge Subdivision), a request by
Landmark Engineering & Planning, to annex approximately 40.31 acres into the City as
an R-1 (Single-Family Residential) zone, and for preliminary plat approval to develop
124 residential lots and 24 common lots. The site is located at the northeast corner of
Bear and Laster Lanes.
Testimony:
Brian Billingsley, Senior Planner, presented the staff report. Mr. Billingsley clarified
2.7.4, to strike out paragraph 2 of the staff report, as these comments are covered by the
Engineering department's comments in the Streets section of the staff report.
Additionally, in 2.7.4 discussion was held regarding two cul-de-sacs earlier in the day
! and the request to join the two streets.
Caldwell Hearing Examiner
Minutes — May 16, 2006
Jed Wyatt, applicanYs representative, of Landmark Engineering & Planning, testified in
• favor of the application and addressed points in the staff report. Mr. Wyatt submitted '�
exhibit PZ-1000, an 11 x 17 map. I
TJ Angstman, applicant's representative, signed in favor of the application and provided
testimony about his focus of "move-up" market homes.
Zen Sugerwala signed in neutral of the application and gave testimony about his
preferences for lot size and fencing issues, and asked about street development.
Chuck McHugh signed in neutral of the application and gave testimony about the current
rural area and lot size, and the dangers of canals to children.
Duane Evans signed in opposition of the application. He spoke about his desire to
continue the current style of rural lots, such as hobby farms. He also asked for
clarification on how water would be supplied to the subdivision, since all current
homeowners have their own wells.
Dean M. Strange signed in opposition of the application. He spoke about his concerns
of canal debris or swimmers in the canal, and asked for a fence along the canal. He
also commented about his cattle, and his concerns about people throwing things at his
cattle.
Mr. Evans was called back by Mr. Mapp. He answered Mr. Mapp's questions about
when the land was developed and when it was purchased.
• Karen Jensen signed in opposition of the application. She gave testimony about her
agreement of previous testimony regarding lot size, and asked questions about fencing,
landscaping, parks, street disruption for utilities, and traffic control on 10 Avenue.
Louise Laduke signed in opposition of the application. She agreed with most of the last
speakers. She is concerned about increased traffic on a privately-maintained dead-end
road which would be an additional hardship. She also hopes there will be a stop-light at
10 Avenue and Ustick Road.
Jed Wyatt gave rebuttal testimony and addressed the questions and concerns made by
the previous speakers.
Brian Billingsley addressed Mr. Mapp's comments about bus stop locations.
Public testimony closed — Mr. Mapp closed public testimony.
Findings of Fact on Annexation: The Hearing Examiner accepted the general facts as
outlined in the staff report and public testimony as a part of the Findings, with the
following revisions:
' • deleted 4 sentence in paragraph 2— dedicated stub street
• paragraph 3— leave as written with addition "as approved by Fire Department"
• Page 5 street #2 — revise to be "applicant responsible for appropriate portion of
design improvements along Laster Street and Phyllis Canal" instead of putting
. requirement of %4 - that will be determined by Engineering department, without a
specific number.
Caldwell Hearing Examiner
Minutes — May 16, 2006
• Number 4 of same area street - last sentence, same thing.
� • Page 6 of 18 — sanitary sewer 3, revise to say Applicant shall work with City
regarding temporary 30' easement based upon City's master plan.
• Page 7 of 18 2.7.7 — meet requirements as related to pathways. Will need to
work out with staff before City Council.
Comprehensive Plan Analysis on Annexation: Mr. Mapp found that the request was
applicable to the Comprehensive Plan components listed in Sections 5. 1 through 5.10 in
the staff report. Comprehensive Plan amendments shall be added to each decision.
Findings of Fact on Annexation: The Hearing Examiner accepted the general facts as
outlined in the staff report and public testimony as a part of the Findings.
Conclusions of Law on Annexation: The Hearing Examiner accepted the Conclusions
of Law as outlined in the staff report.
Recommendation on Annexation to include a Development Agreement associated
with the rezone to Residential: The Hearing Examiner recommended approval of
annexation, development agreement, and modification of the Comprehensive Plan Map
to low density residential for Case Number ANN-118-06 with condition 8.2.
Findings of Fact on Preliminary Plat: The Hearing Examiner accepted the general
facts as outlined in the staff report and public testimony as a part of the Findings.
Recommendation: The Hearing Examiner recommends to the Mayor and City Council
• that Case Number SUB-146P-06, a request for preliminary plat approval of Bear Ridge
Subdivision, which will consist of 124 single-family residential lots and 24 common lots is
approved with conditions 11.2 — 11.3, and additionally as follows:
• 12.1 Fence along Laster and Bear Street to be placed on berm as a buffer.
• 12.2 Applicant will work with staff regarding placement of greenbelt.
• 12.3 Panda and Grizzly Gulch Street — cul-de-sacs will have thru-access, but will
leave to the Fire Department if they want a thru-street.
• 12.4 Ask applicant and staff to work on other locations for bus stops due to
possible traffic conditions. If the school district says they want them at those two
intersections, that will be their responsibility.
• 12.5 Roadway of Klondike Crossing Way — wants to leave stub road at that
location, not off Bear.
• 12.6 Pie-shaped lots measured at set backs for lot width compliance.
• 12.7 Engineering department recommendation about 1/16 road crossing.
Recommends to City Council that this issue be reviewed and that requirements
are considered applicable to all parties so that one is not paying more than
another — to be shared cost proportional. Bridge crossing to be fair to all parties
• 12.8 Road on 1/16 section line on north property, should continue north.
Remove section 11.33, recommends 11.33 be stricken from record. Identify to
Council that Hearing Examiner took out.
• 12.9 Fence — buffer along north side of 8C Lot 2 open space play area — so no
balls go into canal area. Should be fenced or bermed.
• Case closed.
Caldwell Hearing Examiner
Minutes — May 16, 2006
+ �
NOTE: See Recommendation for complete testimony or contact Community
� Development Department for audio tapes of the hearing.
..............................................................................�
V. Adjournment:
The Hearing Examiner adjourned the meeting at approximately 10:50 p.m.
MINUTES APPROVED AND SIGNED BY THE HEARING EXAMINER, M. JEROME MAPP,
ON THE DATE NOTED BELOW:
ATTEST:
M. Jerome Mapp Date
Community Development Director
�
�
Caldwell Hearing Examiner
Minutes — May 16, 2006