HomeMy WebLinkAbout2-28-2002 P&Z MINUTES � .
I
T '
Caldwell Planning and Zoning Commission
MINUTES
February 28, 2002
I. Call to Order — Vice-Chairman Robison called the meeting to order at 7:00 p.m.
II. Roll Call —
Members Present: Vice-Chairman Sylvia Robison, Janie Archuleta, and Jack
Teraberry,
Members Absent: )im Blacker
Staff Present: Steve Hasson, Debbie Geyer, and Ben Weymouth
III. Review of Proceedings — Vice-Chairperson Robison reviewed the procedures for
public hearing.
Vice-Chairperson Robison announced that Case No. ZON-21-02 and SUB-67P-02 had
been withdrawn by the applicant and, therefore, would not be heard at the evening's
public hearing.
IV. Poll Members for Conflict of Interest — Vice-Chairperson Robison polled
members for conflicts of interest. There were none.
V. Old Business —
A. Approve Minutes of January 24, 2002 and April 23, 2001 meeting. Approve as
written. Passed by unanimous voice vote.
B. Case Nos. SUP-152-01 and VAR-23-01, a request by Judy Bistline for a planned
unit development to construct two rental units on two adjacent parcels of land
� zoned R-1 (Single-Family Residential). Additionally, a request for a 5-foot
variance on both land parcels. The site is legally described as lots 1A and 1B of
Block 1 Spear Subdivision and abuts the north side of Oak Street approximately
310 feet west of Airport Avenue.
Testimony — Steve Hasson, Community Development Director, presented the
staff report.
Judy Bistline, Applicant, testified in favor. Mrs. Bistline presented Exhibit PZ-
1001, showing the proposed design of the condominiums.
Greg Timinsky, Applicant's Representative, testified in favor.
Stefani Bistline testified in favor.
The following signed in as opposed but chose not to speak: Geoffrey Foreman
and Suzy Profitt.
NOTE: See Order of Decision for complete testimony or contact Community
Development Department for audio tapes of the hearing.
Public Testimony Closed — Vice-Chairperson Robison closed public testimony.
Variance Procedure — Commissioners found that the five criteria were true.
Comprehensive Plan Analysis -— MOTION: Commissioner Teraberry
` SECOND: Commissioner Archuleta. The request was applicable to the following
Comprehensive Plan Analysis as outlined in the staff report: Property Rights —
Goal, Objective B and Policy 1; School Facilities and Transportation — Goal and
Policy 1; Economic Development — Goal; Land Use — Goat; Objectives
Applicable to All Land Uses — C; Public Services, Utilities and Facilities — Goal,
Objective B and Policy 5; Transportation — Goal. Passed: Unanimous roll call
vote.
Findings of Fact — MOTION: Commissioner Archuleta. SECOND:
Commissioner Teraberry. Accept the general facts as outlined in the staff report,
all five criteria of the variance procedure, which were found to be true, testimony
and exhibits. Passed: Unanimous roll call vote.
Conclusions of Law — MOTION: Commissioner Archuleta. SECOND:
Commissioner Teraberry. The Commission has the authority to hear this case
and approve or deny; public notice requirements were met; and the hearing was
conducted within the guidelines of Idaho Code and City ordinances. Passed:
Unanimous roli call vote.
Order of Decision — MOTION: Commissioner Archuleta. SECOND:
Commissioner Teraberry. The Commission approved Case No. SUP-152-
01/VAR-23-01 with conditions as outlined in the staff report. Passed:
Unanimous roll call vote.
Public Hearing Closed — Vice-Chairperson Robison closed the public hearing
and noted anyone wishing to appeal the Commission's decision should see the
Director of Community Development.
VI. New Business — Hearings
A. Case No. SUB-66PF-02, a request by Fred Cornforth for preliminary and final
subdivision plat approval of KD's Landing Subdivision, which consists of 2
commercial lots on approximately 1.14 acres. The site is located on the
southeast corner of Ustick Road and Lake Avenue and is zoned C-3 (Service
Commercial).
Testimony
Steve Hasson, Community Development Director, presented the staff report.
Ben Weymouth, Assistant City Engineer, testified as staff.
Fred Cornforth, Applicant, testified in favor. Mr. Cornforth presented Exhibit PZ-
1000, a site plan of the proposed office building.
NOTE: See Order of Decision for complete testimony or contact Community
Development Department for audio tapes of the hearing.
Comprehensive Plan Analysis — MOTION: Commissioner Archuleta.
SECOND: Commissioner Teraberry. The request was applicable to the
following Comprehensive Plan Analysis as outlined in the staff report: Property
Rights — Goal, Objective B and Policy 1; School Facilities and Transportation —
Goal and Policy 1; Policies for Commercial/Industrial Use — Policies 3 and 4;
Natural Resources — Policy 1; Hazardous Areas Component — Objectives A and
B, and Policy 2; Public Services, Utilities and Facilities — Goal, Objectives A, B,
C, D and Policies 1, 2, 6, and 7; Transportation — Goal, Objectives A, B, D and
Policies 5, 7, and 8; Recreation — Goal, Policies 1 and 3; Community Design —
Goal, Objectives A, B, E, G, and Policies 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 8, 9, 10, and 11.
Planning & Zoning Commission
Minutes - February 28, 2002
Passed: Unanimous roll call vote.
Findings of Fact — MOTION: Commissioner Archuleta. SECOND:
Commissioner Teraberry. Accept the general facts as outlined in the staff report,
testimony and exhibits. Passed: Unanimous roll call vote.
Conclusions of Law — MOTION: Commissioner Archuleta. SECOND:
Commissioner Teraberry. The Commission has the authority to hear this case
and approve or deny; public notice requirements were met; and the hearing was
conducted within the guidelines of Idaho Code and City ordinances. Passed:
Unanimous roll call vote.
Recommendation — MOTION: Commissioner Archuleta.. SECOND:
Commissioner Teraberry. The Commission recommended approval on Case
No. SUB-66PF-02 with the standard conditions as outlined in the staff report.
Passed: Unanimous roll call vote.
Public Hearing Closed — Vice-Chairperson Robison closed the public hearing
and noted anyone wishing to appeal the Commission's decision should see the
Director of Community Development.
***�*****�**�************************************************,�********�******�**************
B. Case No. SUP-156-02 a request by Salvador Gallegos for approval of a
special use permit to establish an auto repair facility on two lots in a C-4
zone. The site is located at the intersection of Boise Avenue and Frontage
Road and is more commonly known as 103 Frontage Road.
Testimony — Steve Hasson, Community Development Director, presented the
staff report.
Salvador Gallegos, Applicant, testified in favor.
Ben Weymouth, Assistant City Engineer, testified in response to questions posed
by the Commissioners.
Ron Ames, testified in opposition.
Salvador Gallegos, testified in rebuttal.
NOTE: See Order of Decision for complete testimony or contact Community
Development Department for audio tapes of the hearing.
Public Testimony Closed — Vice-Chairperson Robison closed public testimony.
Comprehensive Plan Analysis - MOTION: Commissioner Archuleta.
SECOND: Commissioner Teraberry. The request was applicable to the
following Comprehensive Plan components set forth in the staff report: Property
Rights — Goal, Objective B and Policy 1; School Facilities and Transportation —
Goal and Policy 1; Land Use — Goal; Objectives Applicable To All Land Uses —
Objective A; Policies for Commercial Use — Policies 3, 4, and 5; Natural
Resources — Goal, Objectives A, C, and Policy 1; Public Services, Utilities and
Facilities — Goal, Objectives A, B, and Policies 1, 2, 6, and 7; Transportation —
Goal, Objectives A, B, and C; Community Design — Goal, Objectives A, E, and
Policies 1 and 6, Economic Development — Objective A.
Findings of Fact - MOTION: Commissioner Archuleta. SECOND:
Commissioner Terraberry. Accept the general facts outlined in the staff report as
well as the facts brought forward during public testimony as Findings of Fact to
Planning & Zoning Commission
Minutes — February 28, 2002
J include: 1) Remove the original special use permit, and 2) Control the noise
factor by establishing definite hours of operation. Passed: Unanimous roll call
vote.
Conclusions of Law — MOTION: Commissioner Archuleta. SECOND:
Commissioner Teraberry. The Commission has the authority to hear this case
and approve or deny; public notice requirements were met; and the hearing was
conducted within the guidelines of Idaho Code and City ordinances. Passed:
Unanimous roll call vote.
Order of Decision - MOTION: Commissioner Archuleta. SECOND:
Commissioner Teraberry. The Commission approved Case No. SUP-156-02
with the standard conditions outlined in the staff report with the addition of
condition 9.1 as outlined in the Order of Decision. Passed: Unanimous roll call
vote.
Public Hearing Closed — Chairperson Robison closed the public hearing and
noted anyone wishing to appeal the Commission's decision should see the
Director of Community Development.
*******************�**��*******�***********************************�**************�*********
C. To hear concurrently, Case Nos. ZON-20-02, SUB-68PF-02, and SUP-155-
02, requests by Boyer Caldwell Medical, LC for the following: 1) Approval to
rezone a portion of the vacated Block 41 of the Revised Plat of Dormans'
Lake View Addition from a R-3 (High Density Residential) to a C-2
(Community Commercial) zone. The site abuts the existing West Valley
Medical Center facility on the northeast corner of Arlington Avenue and Elm
Street; 2) preliminary subdivision plat approval of Boyer Caldwell Medical
Subdivision which consists of one commercial lot on approximately .59 acre;
and 3) special use permit approval for an off site parking lot facility located on
the southwest corner of Logan Street and Arlington Avenue. The parcel is
described as being a portion of Block 17 of the Plat of the Pioneer
Subdivision and is zoned R-3.
Testimony - Steve Hasson, Community Development Director, presented the
staff report and Exhibit PZ-1000.
Spencer Summerhays, Applicant, testified in favor.
Rita Earl, Applicant's Representative, testified in favor and presented Exhibits
PZ-1001 and PZ-1002 (drawings of the interior and exterior of the proposed
building) and PZ-1003 (vicinity map — designated at A-3 in the file).
Ben Weymouth, Assistant City Engineered, testified concerning water main
issues, the City's Infrastructure Improvement Policy and traffic flow in the area.
Mike Ward, West Valley Medical Center, testified in favor.
Rita Earl, testified in rebuttal.
NOTE: See Order of Decision for complete testimony or contact Community
Development Department for audio tapes of the hearing.
Comprehensive Plan Analysis - MOTION: Commissioner Archuleta.
SECOND: Commissioner Teraberry. The request was applicable to the
following Comprehensive Plan components set forth in the staff report: Property I
Rights — Goal, Objectives A, B and Policy 1; School Facilities and Transportation ,
— Goal and Policy 1; Economic Development — Goal and Objective A; Land Use ',
Planning & Zoning Commission '
Minutes — February 28, 2002
— Goal; Objectives Applicable to All Land Uses — A; Policies For Commercial Use
— 3, 4, and 5; Natural Resources — Policy 1; Public Services, Utilities and
Facilities — Goal, Objectives A, B, C, D, and Policies 2, 6, and 7; Transportation
— Goal and Objectives A, B, and C; Community Design — Goal, Objectives A, E,
Policies 1, 2, 6, 9, and 10.
Findings of Fact on Case ZON-20-02 - MOTION: Commissioner Teraberry.
SECOND: Commissioner Archuleta. Accept the general facts outlined in the
staff report, exhibits provided by the Applicant, as well as the facts brought
forward during public testimony as Findings of Fact. Passed: Unanimous roll
call vote.
Conclusions of Law on ZON-20-02 — MOTION: Commissioner Teraberry.
SECOND: Commissioner Archuleta. The Commission has the authority to hear
this case and recommend approval or denial; public notice requirements were
met; and the hearing was conducted within the guidelines of Idaho Code and City
ordinances. Passed: Unanimous roll call vote.
Recommendation on ZON-20-02 - MOTION: Commissioner Teraberry.
SECOND: Commissioner Archuleta. The Commission recommended approval
of ZON-20-02. Passed: Unanimous roll call vote.
Findings of Fact on SUB-68PF-02 — MOTION: Commissioner Teraberry.
SECOND: Commissioner Archuleta. Accept the general facts outlined in the
staff report, exhibits provided by the Applicant, facts brought forward during
public testimony, as well as the fact that the City, West Valley Medical Center
and Boyer Company will work through any differences concerning traffic study
requirements, water main issues, and irrigation prior to this matter being before
the Council. Passed: Unanimous roll call vote.
Conclusions of Law on SUB-68PF-02 — MOTION: Commissioner Teraberry.
SECOND: Commissioner Archuleta. The Commission has the authority to hear
this case and approve or deny the preliminary plan and recommend approval or
denial on the final plat; public notice requirements were met; and the hearing was
conducted within the guidelines of Idaho Code and City ordinances. Passed:
Unanimous roll call vote.
Order of Decision on Preliminary Plat and Recommendation on Final Plat —
SUB-68-PF-02 - MOTION: Commissioner Teraberry. SECOND: Commissioner
Archuleta. The Commission approved the preliminary plat and recommends
approval of the final plat of Case No. SUB-68-PF-02 with the standard conditions
outlined in the staff report. Passed: Unanimous roll call vote.
Findings of Fact on SUP-155-02 — MOTION: Commissioner Archuleta.
SECOND: Commissioner Teraberry. Accept the general facts outlined in the
staff report, exhibits provided by the Applicant, and facts brought forward during
public testimony. Passed: Unanimous roll call vote.
Conclusions of Law on SUP-155-02 — MOTION: Commissioner Teraberry.
SECOND: Commissioner Archuleta. The Commission has the authority to hear
this case and approve or deny; public notice requirements were met; and the
hearing was conducted within the guidelines of Idaho Code and City ordinances.
Passed: Unanimous roll call vote.
Order of Decision on SUP-155-02 — MOTION: Commissioner Archuleta.
SECOND: Commissioner Teraberry. The Commission approved Case No.
SUP-155-02 with the standard conditions outlined in the staff report contingent
on the City Council approving the rezone and final plat. Passed: Unanimous
roll call vote.
Planning & Zoning Commission
Minutes — February 28, 2002
° , ,
Public Hearing Closed — Vice-Chairperson Robison closed the public hearing
and noted anyone wishing to appeal the Commission's decision should see the
Director of Community Development.
****************�******************�**********���*****
VII. Planning Issues
A. Election of Officers
Chairman — MOTION: Janie Archuleta. SECOND: Jack Teraberry.
Commissioner Jim Blacker as Chairman. Passed: Members approved.
Vice-Chairperson — MOTION: Jack Teraberry. SECOND: Janie Archuleta.
Commissioner Sylvia Robison as Vice-Chairperson. Passed: Members approved.
Secretary — MOTION: Jack Teraberry. SECOND: )anie Archuleta. Debbie Geyer
as Secretary. Passed: Members approved.
B. Next Meeting Date — The next meeting date will be March 28, 2002.
, VIII. Adjournment — Vice-Chairperson Robison adjourned the meeting at approximately
9:30 p.m.
MINUTES APPROVED AND SIGNED BY VICE-CHAIRPERSON ROBISON AT A REGULARLY
SCHEDULED MEETING:
�
�,
. �
Attest: ��
Vic Chairperson, Sylvia Robison Date
Communi D elopment Directo
Planning & Zoning Commission
Minutes — February 28, 2002