Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout12-12-2000 P&Z MINUTES � Y CALDWELL PLANNING AND ZONING COMMISSION MINUTES OF DECEMBER 12, 2000 I. Call to Order — Chairman Blacker called the meeting to order at 7:00 p.m. II. Roll Call Members Present: Chauman Jim Blacker, Janie Archuleta, Jack Teraberry Staff Present: Linda James, Joan Holmes Legal Counsel: Mark Hilty III. Review of Proceedings — Chairman Blacker reviewed the procedures for public hearings. IV. Poll Members for Conflict of Interest - Chairman Blacker polled members for conflicts of interest: there were none. V. Old Business — Approve Minutes of November 14, 2000. Morion: Commissioner Archuleta. Second: Comrnissioner Teraberry. Approve as written. Passed: Unanimous voice vote. VI. New Business — Hearings A. Case No. SUP-111-00 (Panda), a request by Michelle Snyder to operate a children's daycare center within a residential dwelling located in an R-1 (Single-Family Residential) zone. The dwelling is located at 722 N. Georgia. Testimony — Linda James presented the staff report. Michelle Snyder, Applicant, testified in favor. Public Testimony Closed — Chairman Blacker closed public testimony. Comprehensive Plan Analysis — Motion: Commissioner Teraberry. Second: Coxrunissioner Archuleta. The request was applicable to the following Comprehensive Plan components set forth in the staff report: Property Rights — Goal, Objective B, and Policy 1; School Facilities and Transportation — Goal, and Policy 1; Land Use — Goal; Public Services, Utilities and Facilities — Goal, Objective B, and Policies 1 and 5; Transportation — Goal and Objective A. Passed: Unanimous roll call vote. Findings of Fact — Motion: Commissioner Teraberry. Second: Commissioner Archuleta. Accept the general facts outlined in the staff report as Findings of Fact and include the following facts: the Applicant may purchase the home so the proposed Condition No. 8.2 should be reworded if the special use permit is approved; the state fire marshal set the occupancy load at 35 children; an additional parking area could be provided in the back yard if the proposed parking is not adequate; a new 6-foot cedar fence will be installed in the rear yard. Conclusions of Law — Motion: Commissioner Teraberry. Second: Cominissioner Archuleta. The Commission has the authority to hear this case and approve ar deny; public norice requirements were met; and the hearing was conducted within the guidelines of Idaho Code and City ardinances. Passed: Unanimous roll call vote. Order of Decision — Motion: Comxnissioner Archuleta. Second: Comrnissioner Teraberry. The Commission approved Case No. SUP-111-00 with the standard conditions outlined in the staff report as amended. Passed: Unanimous roll call vote. Public Hearing Closed — Chaiiman Blacker closed the public hearing and noted anyone wishing to appeal the Comrnission's decision should see the Director of Community Development. �*******�**********�************�**************�*�****�*********��*****�*************** B. Case No. SUP-113-00, a request by Oscar Guerrero for approval of a special use permit to operate a dance hall located within a bar known as Xelenzia Night Club located at 512 Frontage Road. The site is zoned C-3 (Service Commercial). Testimony — I� i Linda James presented the staff report and the following E�chibits: E�ibit PR-1, a written response from Ronald I ' E. Young stating opposition, and E�ibit PR-2, a written response from Maximo San Pedio stating opposition, and I E�ibit PR-3, a written response from Michael R. Clark stating his opposition. Oscar Guenero, Applicant, tesrified in favor. William E. Little, Applicant's legal counsel, Jesse Valenzuela, Shelly Brandt, and Wes Story, all tesrified in favor. Testifying in opposition were: Glen Hollis, Charles Couch, Jim Hollis. Tim Fleming, City's legal counsel, testified. Mark Hilty, City's legal counsel, noted that specific conditions have to be put on approval of the special use pernut, such as restrooms and types of noise abatement. These condirions have to be met before the business can continue. He suggested that the hearing be continued to a time and date certain, that being December 19 at 7:00 p.m. in the Courthouse. Public Hearing Continued — Chairman Blacker continued the public hearing to a date and time certain, that date being December 19, 2000 at 7:00 p.m, in the public meeting room at the County Courthouse if available. Continued Public Hearing — December 19, 2000 Testimony — Linda James noted the names and addresses of those testifying at the December 12, 2000 public hearing. She also submitted for the record the following Exhibits: PR-4, PR-5, PR-6, PR-7. Tim Fleming, City Prosecutor, read into the recard Exhibit PR-5, and stated his conversations with Mr. Little. William E. Little, Applicant's attorney, testified in favor. Testifying in opposition were: Terry Dye and Jack Winters. Steve Rupert testified as neutral. Police Chief Bob Sobba signed up to answer questions. William Little testified in rebuttal. Public Testimony Closed — Chairman Blacker closed public testimony. Comprehensive Plan Analysis — Motion: Commissioner Archuleta. Second: Commissioner Teraberry. The request was applicable to the following Comprehensive Plan components set forth in the staff report: Property Rights — Goal, Objective B, and Policy 1; School Facilities and Transportarion — Goal, and Policy 1; Land Use — Goai, Residential Policy 1; Public Services, Utilities and Facilities — Goal, Objective A, and Policy 2; Community Design — Goal and Objective A. Passed: Unanimous roll call vote. Findings of Fact — Motion: Commissioner Teraberry. Second: Commissioner Archuleta. Accept the general facts outlined in the staff report as Findings of Fact and include the following facts: there was lots of testimony in opposirion to the request and the difficulties were stated; the club currently has code violarions and is not taking care of the current violarions; there is a question regarding the term of the lease that may or may not be a difficulty to the Applicant; Chief Sobba offered testimony regarding the problems that have occurred since the club opened; the Applicant does have security on site and stated that he wants to accommodate the difficulties expressed by neighbars; Exhibits PR-1 through PR-10 were submitted into evidence. Passed: Unanimous roll call vote. P& Z Minutes of December 12, 2000 Conclusions of Law — Motion: Commissioner Archuleta. Second: Commissioner Teraberry. The Commission I has the authority to hear this case and approve or deny; public notice requirements were met; and the hearing was ' conducted within the guidelines of Idaho Code and City ordinances. Passed: Unanimous roll call vote. ' Order of Decision — Motion: Cominissioner Teraberry. Second: Commissioner Archuleta. The Commission denied Case No. SUP-113-00 because of the following: the club is not in compliance with existing violations; the responsibility of proving that this use can be made compatible with the residential neighborhood rested with Mr. Guerrero and he was not able to offer substantial evidence that it could be compatible with the residential neighborhood so there is no compelling reason for the pernut to be approved. It is recommended that if Mr. Guerrero appeals the Commission's decision to City Council that he prepares a more appropriate and adequate presentation with concrete remedies that would alleviate the neighborhood's concerns. Passed: Unanimous roll call vote. Public Hearing Closed — Chaiiman Blacker closed the public hearing and noted anyone wishing to appeal the Commission's decision should see the Director of Community Development. **************��****�*********************************************��*�*****�*****�**:�*****�* C. Case No. SUP-112-00, a request by Gemstar Properties, LLC for special use permit approval to locate a sales office on Lot 2, Block 1 of Creekside Subdivision. The sales office will be used only for a realtor to sell the platted lots within this subdivision. Creekside Subdivision is located in an M-1 (Light Industrial) zone and can be accessed from Chicago Street via Gosling Street. Testimony — Linda James presented the staff report. Rita Earl, ApplicanYs Representative, tesrified in favor. Public Testimony Closed — Chairman Blacker closed public testimony. Comprehensive Plan Analysis — Motion: Commissioner Teraberry. Second: Corrunissioner Archuleta. The request was applicable to the following Comprehensive Plan components set forth in the staff report: Property Rights — Goal, Objective B, and Policy 1; School Facilities and Transportation — Goal, and Policy 1. Passed: Unanimous roll call vote. Findings of Fact — Motion: Commissioner Teraberry. Second: Comxnissioner Archuleta. Accept the general facts outlined in the staff report as Findings of Fact and include the following facts from testimony: the Applicant requested that the hours of operation for the sales office be set 9:00 a.m. to 5:00 p.m., Sunday through Saturday, and during the months of June, July and August the hours be extended to 7:00 p.m.; the Applicant requested that landscaping of the lot be deferred until June, 2001. Passed: Unanimous roll call vote. Conclusions of Law — Motion: Commissioner Archuleta. Second: Corrunissioner Teraberry. The Commission has the authority to hear this case and approve or deny; public notice requirements were met; and the hearing was conducted within the guidelines of Idaho Code and City ordinances. Passed: Unanimous roll call vote. Order of Decision — Morion: Commissioner Teraberry. Second: Commissioner Archuleta. The Cominission approved Case No. SUP-112-00 with the standard condirions outlined in the staff report as amended. Passed: Unanimous roll call vote. Public Hearing Closed — Chairxnan Blacker closed the public hearing and noted anyone wishing to appeal the Commission's decision should see the Directar of Community Development. *******�**�********�***********�*******�*********************�**�****��********�******* D. Case No. SUB-56P-00, a request by Crestline Development, LC and Heartland Development, LLC for preliminary subdivision plat approval of Delaware Park No. 2 at the Colonies, a phased development consisting of 252 single-family residential lots and 4 common-area lots located within an R-1 zone. The site abuts a portion of the east side of KCID Road and the south side of Delaware Park Subdivision, P& Z Minutes of December 12, 2000 which is located approximately 500 feet south of the intersection of KCID Road and Highway 20/26. Testimony — Linda James presented the staff report. Rita Earl, Applicant's Representative, testified in favor. Also testifying in favor were Kevin Amar and Steve Solecki. Public Testimony Closed — Chairman Blacker closed public testimony. Comprehensive Plan Analysis — Motion: Commissioner Teraberry. Second: Commissioner Archuleta. The request was applicable to the following Comprehensive Plan components set forth in the staff report: Property Rights — Goal, Objective B, and Policy 1; School Facilities and Transportation — Goal, and Policy 1; Economic Development — Goal; Land Use — Goal, Objectives Applicable to all Land Uses — A and C, Policies for Residential Use - 3; Natural Resources — Objectives A and C, and Policy 1; Public Services, Utilities and Facilities — Goal, Objective B, and Policies 1, 5, 6, and 7; Transportation — Goal and Objective A; Housing — Goal, Objective C and Policy 3; Community Design — Goal, Objectives A and E, and Policy 2. Passed: Unanimous roll call vote. Findings of Fact — Motion: Commissioner Teraberry. Second: Commissioner Archuleta. Accept the general facts outlined in the staff report as Findings of Fact and include the following facts taken from testimony: the Applicant has hired a firm to conduct a traffic study of the area and the study will be submitted to the City at the '�, rime the fmal application for Delaware Park No. 1 is submitted to the City; E�ibits PZ-1000, PZ-1001 and PZ- ' 1002 were presented by the Applicant's representatives; the request was made by the Applicant's representatives ' to remove the City Engineer's requirement to improve Logan Street along the southern boundary of Delaware Park No. 2 and to remove the Fire Marshal's requirement for secondary accesses for each phase; the note on the preliminary plat stating there is a 10-foot public pedestrian ingress/egress easement is incorrect and will be removed from the notes. Passed: Unanimous roll call vote. Conclusions of Law — Morion: Comxnissioner Teraberry. Second: Comxnissioner Archuleta. The Coxrunission has the authority to hear this case and approve or deny; public norice requirements were met; and the hearing was conducted within the guidelines of Idaho Code and City ordinances. Passed: Unanimous roll call vote. Recommendation to City Council — Motion: Commissioner Teraberry. Second: Commissioner Archuleta Commission members recommended approval of Case No. SUB-56P-00, a request by Crestline Development, LC and Heartland Development, LLC for preliminary subdivision plat approval of Delaware Park No. 2 at the Colonies with the conditions outlined in the staff report. Passed: Unanimous roll call vote. Public Hearing Closed — Chairman Blacker closed the public hearing. ************************************************************�***�**************�******* E. Case No. SUB-57P-00, a request by Crestline Development, LC and Heartland Development, LLC for preliminary subdivision plat approval of Virginia Park at the Colonies, a phased development consisting of 650 single-family residenrial lots and 9 common area lots located within an R-1 zone. The site is approximately 157 acres and is located between the east side of KCID Road and the west side of Ward Lane. The west end of the subject site begins approximately 500 feet north of the intersection of Highway 20/26 and KCID Road and the east end begins approximately 350 feet north the intersection of Highway 20/26 and Ward Lane Testimony — Linda James presented the staff report. Rita Earl and Steve Solecki, Applicant's Representatives, testified in favor. Steve Jordan testified in opposition. Kevin Amar, Applicant's Representative, testified in rebuttal. P& Z Minutes of December 12, 2000 Public Testimony Closed — Chairman Blacker closed public testimony. Comprehensive Plan Analysis — Motion: Coxrunissioner Teraberry. Second: Commissioner Archuleta. The I, request was applicable to the following Comprehensive Plan components set forth in the staff report: Property �� Rights — Goal, Objective B, and Policy 1; School Facilities and Transportation — Goal, and Policy 1; Economic Development — Goal; Land Use — Goal, Objectives Applicable to all Land Uses — A and C, Policies for Residential Use - 3; Natural Resources — Objectives A and C, and Policy 1; Public Services, Utilities and Facilities — Goal, Objective B, and Policies 1, 5, 6, and 7; Transportation — Goal and Objective A; Housing — Goal, Objective C and Policy 3; Community Design — Goal, Objectives A and E, and Policy 2. Passed: Unanimous roll call vote. Findings of Fact — Motion: Commissioner Archuleta. Second: Commissioner Teraberry. Accept the general facts outlined in the staff report as Findings of Fact and include the following facts taken from testimony: a traffic study has been undertaken for this area and the study will be presented to the City at the time of fmal plat application for the first phase of Delaware Park No. 1; the Applicant has agreed to provide the right-of-way and improvements for Hillcrest Street as required by the City Engineer; fencing requirements that will provide uniformity will be included in the CC&R's; the Applicant's representarive requested that the condition for secondary accesses for each phase be removed and that this recommendation is made to the Mayor and City Council; the Applicant's representative requested Coxrunission members to recommend to the Mayor and City Council that the proposed phasing of 15 years is approved; the Applicant's representative stated that the small out lot of 0.7 acres would not be included in the plat but that street frontage improvements will be installed along the out lot frontage, but the larger out lot to the south is under ownership of another party and the Applicant has no authority to provide additional right-of-way or to be required to install street improvements along an out lot that is not under his ownership. Passed: Unanimous roll call vote. Conclusions of Law — Motion: Commissioner Teraberry. Second: Commissioner Archuleta. The Commission has the authority to hear this case and approve or deny; public notice requirements were met; and the hearing was conducted within the guidelines of Idaho Code and City ordinances. Passed: Unanimous roll call vote Recommendation to City Council — Motion: Comxnissioner Teraberry. Second: Commissioner Archuleta. Commission members recommended approval of Case No. SUB-57P-00, a request by Crestline Development, LC and Heartland Development, LLC for preliminary subdivision plat approval of Virginia Park at the Colonies with the conditions outlined in the staff report. Passed: Unanimous roll call vote. Public Hearing Closed — Chairman Blacker closed the public hearing. �****�**�*�******************�**�����***********************�*********�**************** F. To hear concurrently Case Nos. ANN-46-00 and SUB-58P-00, a request by Parkland Development to annex approximately 251.5 acres into the City of Caldwell and for preluninary plat approval of Monarch Subdivision, a planned unit development consisting of 809 residenrial lots, 1 commercial lot, and 25 common-area lots. Five parcels, consisting of approximately 65.278 acres, are requested to be annexed as C-3 (Service Commercial) zones, and three parcels, consisting of approximately 186.23 acres, is requested to be annexed as R-1 (Single-Family Residential) zones. Approximately 24 acres requested to be annexed as a C-3 zone lies within the southwest corner of the intersection of Usrick Road and Middleton Road. This parcel is currently zoned County Ag and is designated on the Caldwell Comprehensive Plan Land Use Map as M-1 (Light Industrial). Included in the request for this parcel is a development agreement regarding future annexation and development of an 8-acre out parcel. The remaining 228 acres (approximate) are located along the east side of Middleton Road beginning approximately one-half mile south of the intersection of Ustick Road and Middleton Road and going northward approximately one-half mile from this intersection. There are two out lots located along the east side of Middleton Road, one lies within the one-half mile boundary on the north side of Ustick Road and one lies within the one-half mile boundary on the south. Monarch Subdivision, a phased planned unit development is platted on approximately 172.97 acres requested as R-1 zoning and approximately 1.45 acres requested as C-3 zoning. As a part of this annexation request, the C-3 and R-1 zones will be included in the next available update of the Comprehensive Plan Land Use Map. Testimony — P& Z Minutes of December 12, 2000 Linda James presented the staff report. Kent Brown, Applicant's Representative, testified in favor. George Keller testified in opposition. Kent Brown testified in rebuttal. Public Testimony Closed — Chairman Blacker closed public testimony. Comprehensive Plan Analysis on ANN-46-00 — Motion: Commissioner Teraberry. Second: Commissioner Archuleta. The request was applicable to the following Comprehensive Plan components set forth in the staff I report: Property Rights — Goal, Objective B, and Policy 1; School Facilities and Transportation — Goal, and Policy , 1; Economic Development — Goal; Land Use — Goal, Objectives Applicable to all Land Uses — C; Objectives Applicable to Area of City Impact — Objective A. Passed: Unanimous roll call vote. Findings of Fact on ANN-46-00 — Motion: Commissioner Blacker. Second: Commissioner Teraberry. Accept the general facts outlined in the staff report as Findings of Fact and included the fact that the site is contiguous to I the City's boundaries. Passed: Unanimous roll call vote. Conclusions of Law on ANN-46-00 — Motion: Cominissioner Archuleta Second: Commissioner Teraberry. The Commission has the authority to hear this case and approve or deny; public notice requirements were met; and the hearing was conducted within the guidelines of Idaho Code and City ardinances. Passed: Unanimous roll call vote Recommendation to City Council on ANN-46-00 — Morion: Commissioner Teraberry. Second: Commissioner Archuleta. Commission members recommended approval of Case No. ANN-46-00 a request by Parkland Development to annex five parcels, consisting of approximately 65.278 acres as C-3 (Service Commercial) zones, and three parcels, consisting of approximately 186.23 acres, as R-1 (Single-Family Residenrial) zones. Passed: Unanimous roll call vote. Comprehensive Plan Analysis on SUB-58P-00 — Motion: Corrunissioner Archuleta. Second: Commissioner Teraberry. The request was applicable to the following Comprehensive Plan components set forth in the staff report: Property Rights — Goal, Objective B, and Policy l; School Facilities and Transportation — Goal, and Policy 1; Economic Development — Goal; Land Use — Goal, Objectives Applicable to all Land Uses — A and C, Objectives Applicable to Residential Land Use — D, Policies for Residential Use - 3; Objectives Applicable to Commercial and Industrial Land Use — A; Natural Resources — Objectives A and C, and Policy 1; Public Services, Utilities and Facilities — Goal, Objective B, and Policies 1, 5, 6, and 7; Transportarion — Goal, Objectives A and E; Recreation — Goal and Objective B; Housing — Goal, Objective C and Policy 3; Community Design — Goal, Objectives A and E, and Policies 1 and 2. Passed: Unanunous roll call vote. Findings of Fact on SUB-58P-00 — Motion: Commissioner Teraberry. Second: Comxnissioner Archuleta. Accept the general facts outlined in the staff report as Findings of Fact and include the following facts taken from testimony: the berm to be installed along Middleton, Ustick, Dry Lake and Laster Lane will be three feet in height and will be landscaped; the 133 Lateral will be piped in accordance with Pioneer's requirements; Gordon Law has agreed to a right-of-way width of 51 feet for the interior streets; there will be micro walking paths incorporated into the plat; common lots will be landscaped; the CC&R's will include requirements for uniform fencing. Passed: Unanimous roll call vote. Conclusions of Law on SUB-58P-00 — Motion: Commissioner Teraberry. Second: Cominissioner Archuleta. The Coxnmission has the authority to hear this case and approve or deny; public notice requirements were met; and the hearing was conducted within the guidelines of Idaho Code and City ordinances. Passed: Unanimous roll call vote Recommendation to City Council on SUB-58P-00 — Motion: Comxnissioner Teraberry. Second: Commissioner Archuleta. Commission members recommended approval of Case No. SUB-58P-00 a request by Parkland Development far preliminary subdivision plat approval of Monarch Subdivision with the conditions outlined in the staff report. Passed: Unanimous roll call vote. P& Z Minutes of December 12, 2000 OOOZ `ZI zaquza�aQ3o sa;nuty� Z a8 d zo��a.ziQ;uauzdolanaQ �TUnunu a�eQ za���ig uz? f u�uu?�u� �.I.S�.I,.I.d �BAO'I�g Q�.I.ON �.LdQ �H.I. I�IO 2I��I�`�'Ig N`�L�2IIdH� Ag Q�NJIS QNd Q�A02Iddd S�.Lf1i�IIY�t '�'d O��OI �ia;euzixozdd� �e �ut�aauz ac�� pauznofp� za���ig uzuuteq� —;uawu.�nofpd 'IIIA ��C.renu�r �o u�uouz au� ui painpau�s s�utzeau ou aze azaql, •zo;�a.z1Q �uauzdojanaQ �iununuo� s� uot��u�isaz zaq passn�stp sauzer �puiZ — sanssI �u►uu�Id 'IIA ��������������������������������������������������������������������������������������� •�uT.z�au �tiqnd au� pasoi� zax��ig u�uuT�u� — pasoi� �ui.�eag ailqnd h