Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout10-25-2000 P&Z MINUTES _ i �` CALDWELL PUBLIC HEARINGS BEFORE HEARING EXAMINER MINUTES OF OCTOBER 25, 2000 I. Call to Order — Hearing Examiner M. Jerome Mapp opened the meeting for the public hearings at 7:00 p.m. and outlined the public hearing procedures. City staff in attendance were: Linda James, Community Development Director, and Joan Holmes, Planning Technician. II. Hearings A. Case No. SUP-105-00 (Angel Wings), a request by Nancy Woolery for approval of a special use pernut � to operate a 24-hour group home for both male and female residents between the ages of 16 and 21. The subject site is an existing residential dwelling and is located at 703 Belmont and is zoned C-2 (Community Commercial). Testimony — Linda James presented the staff report and read E�ibit PR-1, a letter of opposition from Shirley Lee, 907 Belmont, into the record. Nancy Woolery, Applicant, testified in favor. Jann Ertl, owner of the subject property also testified in favar. Levetra Upshaw testified in opposition. Sandy King testified as neutral. Nancy Woolery testified in rebuttal. Public Testimony Closed — Mr. Mapp closed public testimony. Comprehensive Plan Analysis — Mr. Mapp found that the request was applicable to the following Comprehensive Plan components set forth in the staff report: Property Rights — Goal, Objective B, and Policy 1; School Facilities and Transportation — Goal, and Policy 1; Land Use — Goal; Public Services, Utilities and Facilities — Goal, Objective A, and Policies 1, 2, 5, and 7; Housing — Objective C; Community Design — Goal, Objectives A and E. Mr. Mapp also found that the request was not applicable to the following Comprehensive Plan components set forth in the staff report: Land Use — Objectives Applicable to All Land Uses — A; Residential — Policies 1 and 3; Transportation — Goal and Objective A; Housing — Goal. Findings of Fact — Mr. Mapp accepted the general facts outlined in the staff report as Findings of Fact and ' included the foilowing facts: the request is in compliance with the following Sections set forth by staff in the '', Comprehensive Plan Analysis: 5.1- Properiy Rights; 5.2 — School Facilities and Transportation; 5.4 — Public �', Services, Utilities and Facilities; and 5.7 — Community Design. The request is not in compliance with the i following Comprehensive Plan Components as set forth by staff in the Comprehensive Plan Analysis: 5.3 — Land Use, Objective A, because there were no facts given that would indicate that the safety and general welfare of the neighborhood would be protected. Under Residential, Policy 1 there is no way to know if 15 residents in this house is appropriate. 5.5 — Transportation Goal, because there were no facts presented on how many persons would be driving and parking at the house and no off-street parking plan was presented. 5.6 — Housing, Objective C, because there was no evidence presented that there is adequate space for 15 residents or how the residents will be separated. Further facts are: there is this type of need in many communities but there were no details offered by the Applicant on how this facility would be operated; if there are 7 bedrooms and 4 of the bedrooms had 2 occupants and the other 3 bedrooms had 3 occupants that would make a total of 17 residents; there is a concern with the statement that there would be 24-hour supervision because the residents will not be supervised unless they are actually on the house properiy; there was no information offered on how the residents would be interacring on the property; the Applicant did not present to plan up front on how many people, with cars, would be on site at any one time, and did not know the number of parking spaces that would actually be needed; the neighborhood has the need and the right to know what will be going on at this property but there was no clear testimony from the . y Applicant on how the facility will be operated or how the youth will be supervised; it is unknown how many ' residents, supervisors, foster grandparents, parents and counselars could be in the facility at any one time; it is unknown whether or not the alley can provide proper ingress/egress to off-street parking at the back of the property; a secondary off-street parking lot could only happen if a special use perxnit were requested and approved at a separate public hearing.. Conclusions of Law — Mr. Mapp accepted the Conclusions of Law outlined in the staff report. Order of Decision — Mr. Mapp denied SUP-105-00 and stated that the Applicant could undertake certain actions that might provide a more favorable review if the request is heard again. Such acrions could include having a complete, thorough proposal with written rules and regularions on how the facility will be operated; and, complete explanations on who will be the supervisors and the team make up, who will be hired, what criteria will a supervisor have to meet in arder to be considered qualified to these youth and, how the youth will actually be supervised Public Hearing Closed — Mr. Mapp closed the public hearing and noted anyone wishing to appeal his decision should see the Director of Community Development. ***************************************�*******************�********�******���x*******�***** B. To hear concurrently Case Nos. ANN-45-00 and SUP-106-00, a request by the City of Caldwell to annex approximately 35 acres into the City as an R-1 (Single-Family Residential) zone and for approval of a special use pernut to construct `Brothers Park." The park will consist of l youth soccer fields, 4 adult soccer fields, a beach volleyball court, a playground area, walking path, restroom facilities and 3 parking lots. The subject parcel is located on the east side of S. Indiana Avenue and abuts the south side of Caldwell High School. The site is currently zoned County R-1 and is designated on the City's Comprehensive Plan Land Use Map as R.-1. Testimony — Linda James presented the staff report. Gordon Law, representing the City, testified in favor. Karl Kincheloe, Caldwell Engineering Department, testified in favor. Public Testimony Closed — Mr. Mapp closed public testimony. Comprehensive Plan Analysis on ANN-45-00 — Mr. Mapp found that the request was applicable to the Comprehensive Plan components set forth in the staff report: Properiy Rights — Goal, Objective B, and Policy 1; School Facilities and Transportation — Goal and Policy 1; Land Use — Goal, Objectives Applicable to All Land Uses — C; Area of City Impact — Objective A and Policy 5. Findings of Fact on ANN-45-00 — Accept the general facts outlined in the staff report as Findings of Fact and include the following facts: the request is in compliance with the Comprehensive Plan analysis as set forth in the report; the site is contiguous to the City's boundaries and is within the Area of City Impact; the City owns the property and intends to use it as a public park. Conclusions of Law on ANN-45-00 — Mr. Mapp accepted the Conclusions of Law outlined in the staff report. Recommendation to City Council on ANN-45-00 — Mr. Mapp recommended approval on Case No. ANN-45-00. Comprehensive Plan Analysis on SUP-106-00 — Mr. Mapp found that the request was applicable to the Comprehensive Plan components set forth in the staff report: Properiy Rights — Goal, Objective B, and Policy 1; School Facilities and Transportation — Goal and Policy 1; Land Use — Goal, Objectives Applicable to All Land Uses — A and C; Natural Resources — Policy 1; Public Services, Urilities and Facilities — Goal, Policies 1, 2, 6, and 7; Transportation - Goal, Objective A, and Policy 8; Recreation — Goal, Objecrives A and B; Community Design — Goal, Objectives A and E, Policy 2. Findings of Fact on SUP-106-00 - Accept the general facts outlined in the staff report as Findings of Fact and Hearing Examiner Minutes of October 25, 2000 . i include the following facts: the request is in compliance with the Comprehensive Plan analysis as set forth in the � staff report; there is a lack of soccer fields in the Treasure Valley and this park will assist in meeting the City's needs; the park is adjacent to Caldwell High School; the use of the property as recreationaUpark land is maximized because the facility will be shared jointly with Caldwell High School and the public. Conclusions of Law SUP-106-00 — Mr. Mapp accepted the Conclusions of Law outlined in the staff report. Order of Decision on SUP-106-00 — Mr. Mapp approved SUP-106-00 and approved the conditions outlined in the staff report that will apply if City Council approves the annexation. Public Hearing Closed — Mr. Mapp closed the public hearing. ***�**********�*************************************************************�*�***********� III. Planning Issues - There were no planning issues brought forward. IV. Adjournment — Mr. Mapp adjourned the meeting at approximately 8:40 p.m. MINUTES APPROVED AND SIGNED BY HEARING EXAMINER M. JEROME MAPP ON THE DATE NOTED BELOW. ATTEST: M. Jerome Mapp Date Community Development Director Hearing Examiner Minutes of October 25, 2000