HomeMy WebLinkAbout6-22-2000 P&Z MINUTES �4
� CALDWELL PUBLIC HEARING BEFORE HEARING EXAMINER
MINUTES OF JLTNE 22, 2000
I. Call to Order — Hearing Examiner Lee Dillion opened the meeting for the public hearings at 7:00 p.m. and
outlined the public hearing procedures. City staff in attendance were: Linda James, Community Development
D'uector, and Joan Holmes, Adnunistrative Secretary. ,
i II. Hearings
A. Case No. SUP-86-00, a request by Tamarack Properties, Inc., for a special use pernut to construct a
planned unit development that consists of 6- four plex dwelling units located on approximately 1.1 acres
located in an R-3 (Multi-Family High Density Residential) zone. The site is described as Lots 23 and 24,
Torrens and Tucker Addition and fronts N. Michigan Avenue.
Testimony —
Linda James presented the staff report.
Patrick Byrne, Applicant's representative, tesrified in favor. Scott St�eld, ApplicanYs Engineer was available
for quesrions.
Gary Vance testified in opposition. Concerns were: wanting Applicant to install a 6- foot tall wooden fence along
his property line in order to keep people out; there is a 20 x 30 foot pond that is seven feet deep on the property;
his understanding is the site is zoned R-15 and can only have 15 dwelling units per acre.
Public Testimony Closed — Mr. Dillion closed public testimony.
Comprehensive Plan Analysis — Mr. Dillion found that the request is in compliance with the following
Comprehensive Plan components: Residenrial — Policies 3, 4, and 5.
� Findings of Fact — Mr. Dillion accepted the facts outlined in the staff report as Findings of Fact and included the
� fact that the City encourages multi-family developments and the proposed development meets the City's standards.
Conclusions of Law — Mr. Dillion accepted the Conclusions of Law outlined in the staff report.
Order of Decision — Mr. Dillion approved the request by Tamarack Properties, Inc for a planned unit development
consisting of 6- four plex dwelling units with the standard conditions outlined in the staff report.
Public Hearing Closed — Mr. Dillion closed the public hearing and noted anyone wishing to appeal his decision
should see the Director of Community Development.
**�����****�****�**�******:�*�**:�*��*��****���*****�*********�*******�*:�******�**�*
B. Case No. SUB-29F-99 (20/26 Commercial Park), a request by Jerry D. Trammel for fmal subdivision plat
approval of 13 commercial lots. This subdivision lies within the CaldwelUCanyon County Area of City
Impact and is zoned C-3. The site is located north of the Boise River at the northeast intersection of
Farmway Road and Highway 20/26.
�_
Testimony —
Linda James resented the staff re ort and Exhibit PA-3 a letter from the Can on Ditch Irrigation District. Mrs.
P P
, Y
James stated that because of the District's letter, Gordon Law agreed to remove the preliminary plat condition
regarding irrigation.
Jerry Trammel, Applicant, testified in favor and stated he has met the City's requirements.
No one tesrified in opposirion.
I
�
- Public Testimony Closed — Mr. Dillion closed public testimony.
Findings of Fact— Mr. Dillion accepted the general facts outlined in the staff report as Findings of Fact and
included Exhibit PA-3, the letter from the Irrigation District as well as Gordon Law's recommendarion to remove
the condition of approval from the preliminary plat regarding the DistricYs submittal of a letter.
Conclusions of Law— Mr. Dillion accepted the Conclusions of Law outlined in the staff report.
Recommendation to City Council— Mr. Dillion recommended approval on Case No. SUB-29F-99.
***�*****�*�***�*******��*****��**�������******�*******�*:���*****:�********:�**�****
C. Case No. ANN-34-00, a request by Westpark and Briggs Engineering, to annex approximately 10.58
acres into the City as a C-3 (Service Commercial) zone, and approximately 26.24 acres into the City as an
R-3 (Multi-Family High Density Residential) zone. The site is located at the southwest comer of the
intersection of Ustick Road and Middleton Road.
Testimony —
Linda James presented the staff report and outlined the facts in the report. She presented as an e�ibit the City's
zoning map and identified the site.
Kent Brown, Applicant's representative, testified in favor and presented Exhibit HE-1, a letter from the FAA.
Eileen Keffer signed up as neutral, but did not wish to speak.
No one testified in opposition.
Public Testimony Closed — Mr. Dillion closed public testimony.
Comprehensive Plan Analysis — Mr. Dillion found that the request for C-3 (Service Commercial) is in
compliance with the components: Airport — Policies 2 and 4; He found that the request for that portion of the
annexation as an R-3 zone does not meet the same Airport policies that the C-3 zone does.
, _ _.
Findings of Fact— Mr. Dillion accepted the general facts outlined in the staff report as Findings of Fact and
included the foilowing comments: the Airport area has had a lot of applications for annexation in the past few
months and the City is under tremendous pressure to plan for this area; it is an area that will undergo tremendous
development within the next 10 to 15 years, which provides planning opportunities for the City; residential uses
have not been encouraged to develop within the vicinity of the Airport in the past while commercial and light-
industrial development has been permitted.
Conclusions of Law— Mr. Dillion accepted the Conclusions of Law outlined in the staff report.
Recommendation to City Council— Mr. Dillion recommended that the 10.58 acres requested to be annexed as a
C-3 zone is approved and that the 26.24 acres requested to be annexed as an R-3 zone is denied.
�*���***+�,�***�**�***��**********�********���*�*:����******�*�******�****�****��*�**�*�***�
D. Case No. SUB-35F(1)-99, a request by�K & L Development, LLC for fmal subdivision plat approval of
Vallivue Heights Subdivision Unit No. 1(initially approved as Southpark Subdvision Unit No. 1) to
develop 56 residenrial and 2 common-area lots on approximately 13356 acres located in an R-1 zone.
The site is adjacent to a portion of the west side of South Indiana Avenue (approximately 612 feet south
of the intersection of Homedale Road and S. Indiana) and a portion of the south side of Homedale Road
(approxunately 520 feet west of the intersection of Homedale and Indiana).
Testimony —
Linda James presented the staff report and presented the following e�ibits: E�ibit PA-1, a memo from Doug
Brown; PA-2, an estimate of construction costs; and PA-3, a memo from Gordon Law.
Hearing Examiner Minutes of June 22, 2000
� Scott Stanf'ield, Applicant's Engineer, testified in favor.
Kevin Amar, ApplicanYs Representarive signed up in favor but did not speak.
No one testified in opposition.
Public Testimony Closed — Mr. Dillion closed public tgstimony.
Findings of Fact— Mr. Dillion accepted the general facts outlined in the staff report as Findings of Fact and
included the following statements: the Fire Marshal's request for a secondary access onto Indiana was made at a
late date; other access will be provided to the west of phase 1; it is not equitable to require the secondary access at
this stage; landscaping along Homedale will be installed in a 15-foot common area; the Applicant is proceeding to
get de-annexed from the Wilder Irrigation District.
Conclusions of Law— Mr. Dillion accepted the Conclusions of Law outlined in the staff report.
Recommendation to City Council— Mr. Dillion recommended approval of Case No. SUB-35F(1)-99.
**�*����*****�***�*:�***��*�****************��******�*�*�*�*�***�**�*********�***��***��**
E. Case No. SUP-69A-99, a request by Pastor Freddie Lane to amend the existing special use pernut that
was approved to operate a church out of a building lrnown as 2423 Georgia Avenue by expanding the
church area into Suite 700, which would add approximately 3490 square feet of space to the existing
church facility. The site is zoned C-3 (Service Commercial) and the building, which currently houses
Radio Shack and Premier Video, is located at the intersection of Cleveland Boulevard and Linden Street.
Testimony —
Linda James presented the staff report and outlined the facts in the report.
_ Pastor Freddie Lane, Applicant, testified in favor and presented Exhibit HE-1, parking perxnission from American
Music; HE-2, a parking plan. Also testifying in favor were: Roger Grove, Katie Grove, and Doug Dobson.
_
No one testified in opposition.
Public Testimony Closed — Mr. Dillion closed public testimony.
Findings of Fact— Mr. Dillion accepted the general facts outlined in the staff report as Findings of Fact.
Conclusions of Law— Mr. Dillion accepted the Conclusions of Law outlined in the staff report.
Order of Decision — Mr. Dillion approved Case No. SUP-69A-99 with the standard condirions outlined in the
staff report.
Public Hearing Closed — Mr. Dillion closed the public hearing and noted anyone wishing to appeal his decision
should see the Director of Community Development.
*�**��*�***�**���**��**�x���**��********�*****�*�*�*��***��*�*��******:�*�********�**�����*
F. Case No. SUP-87-00, a request by Theta Psi House Coiporation for special use permit approval to turn
the existing house located at 2113 S. Indiana Avenue into a fraternity house. The site is zoned R-3 (High
Density Residential).
Testimony —
Linda James presented the staff report and read into the record Exhibits PR-1, PR-2, PR-3, letters of opposirion.
Hearing Examiner Minutes of June 22, 2000
' Testifying in favor were: Ron Millick, Michael Erickson, Eric Garayoa, Joshua Browne, Ron Torres, Bennett
^ Smith. If approved the corporation would purchase the property from Mr. Garayoa and lease to fraternity
members. Also signed up in favor were: Conlyn McCain and Christopher Saunders.
In opposition were: Pat Staples; Misty Hill; Anna Jonesi; Brodie Hill; David Root; Doug Doelson; Clarence
Frerichs; Jerry Walters. Concerns were: parking; safety; property upkeep; noise; parties; rotating students.
Public Testimony Closed — Mr. Dillion closed public tgstimony.
Comprehensive Plan Analysis — Mr. Dillion stated the request is in compliance with Residential - Policy 2.
Findings of Fact— Mr. Dillion accepted the general facts outlined in the staff report as Findings of Fact and
included the following: Outside of requests for childcare, requests for fraternities normally raise opposirion
because of concerns with noise and parking. The Advisor to the fraternity is also a member of the Corporation and
has a vested interest in this fraternity succeeding. Assurances by the Corporation and fraternity have to be given
whereas the present occupants or owner of the property do not have to provide any assurances. Essentially, multi-
family housing is already in use at this property without any conditions or restricrions. Approving the fraternity
would provide for conditions that have to be met.
Conclusions of Law— Mr. Dillion accepted the Conclusions of Law outlined in the staff report.
Order of Decision — Mr. Dillion approved Case No. SUP-87-00 with the standard condirions outlined in the staff
report. ,
Pubiic Hearing Closed — Mr. Dillion closed the public hearing and noted anyone wishing to appeal his decision
should see the Director of Community Development.
**��*:�*�**����*****:���******�*��**������*����***:��*�**���*:�**�***�:�:�**���************�**
G. Case No. SUP-88-00, a request by L. James and Judith E. Kindelberger for special use pernut approval to
use the existing house located at 1822 Dearborn as an owner-occupied duplex. The site is zoned R-1
t (Single-Family Residenrial).
� Testimony —
Linda James presented the staff report and outlined the facts in the report.
James Kindelberger, Applicant, testified in favor.
Testifying in opposition were: Elizabeth Yeary; Madeline Buckendorf; Stephen Fisher; Lee Parsons; Marianne
Saunders. Concerns were: neighboring houses are single-family and duplexes are not allowed; a duplex is not
appropriate in a historical area.
In rebuttal, Mr. Kindelberger stated that they are not changing the structure in any way; prior use was a triplex;
rules for the renter will be strictly enforced.
Public Testimony Closed — Mr. Dillion closed public testimony.
Comprehensive Plan Analysis — Mr. Dillion stated the request is in compliance with Residential - Policy 2.
Findings of Fact— Mr. Dillion accepted the general facts outlined in the staff report as Findings of Fact and
included the following: Historic neighborhoods are precious assets for the community and can include different
types of housing. The house in question was converted to a duplex and tri-plex prior to adoption of the Zoning
Ordinance so the use of the house other than single-family was occurring for many years. The house is not being
physically converted to a duplex under this request for a special use permit because it was physically converted
many years aga
Conclusions of Law— Mr. Dillion accepted the Conclusions of Law outlined in the staff report.
Hearing Examiner Minutes of June 22, 2000
` Order of Decision — Mr. Dillion approved Case No. SUP-88-00 with the standard conditions outlined in the staff
report.
Public Hearing Closed — Mr. Dillion closed the public hearing and noted anyone wishing to appeal his decision
should see the Directar of Community Development.
*���**�**�*:��**�**�***�**���**���*����:�*�*��*�*******��***�**�**���***********�***�*�***
H. Case No. SUP-89-00, a request by Paul's Market for special use pernut approval of an off-street parking
facility used as a secondary lot to the Market. The secondary off-street parking lot site is zoned G2
(Community Commercial) and is located at the southeast corner of the intersection of Chicago Avenue
and 9"' Street (as you travel northwest on Chicago) and is directly behind Mr. V's Restaurant.
Testimony —
Linda James presented the staff report and outlined the facts in the report.
Dale Binning, Applicant's Engineer, testified in favor.
No one testified in opposition.
Public Testimony Closed — Mr. Dillion closed public testimony.
Comprehensive Plan Analysis — Mr. Dillion stated the request is in compliance with the Transportation
component — Policies 1 and 10.
Findings �of Fact— Mr. Dillion accepted the general facts outlined in the staff report as Findings of Fact.
Conclusions of Law— Mr. Dillion accepted the Conclusions of Law outlined in the staff report.
Order of Decision — Mr. Dillion approved Case No. SUP-89-00 with the standard condirions outlined in the staff
� report.
, __ _
, Public Hearing Closed — Mr. Dillion closed the public hearing and noted anyone wishing to appeal his decision
should see the Director of Community Development.
���***�*:�:�*�******�**************��********��******:�*��*****�*�:��******�*�:�***�***��**�*
I. Case No. OA-31-00, a request by the Community Development Director to amend Caldwell Zoning
Ordinance No. 1451, Secrion 10-02-02, Land Use Schedule, by adding "Mini Storage" to the list of
special uses in a C-3 (Service Commercial) zone.
Testimony —
Linda James presented the staff report. -
Public Testimony Closed — Mr. Dillion closed public testimony.
Findings of Fact— Mr. Dillion accepted the general facts outlined in the staff report as Findings of Fact.
Conclusions of Law— Mr. Dillion accepted the Conclusions of Law outlined in the staff report.
Recommendation to City Council—Mr. Dillion recommended approval of Case No. OA-31-00.
*******�*�***��**:�*�**�*****�*�,�*�*********�***�:�****�**��*******�*****�:�*************�*
J. Case No. OA-32-00, a request by the Community Development Director to amend Caldwell Subdivision
Ordinance No. 1758, Section 11-02-06, Final Plat, Subsecrions B, C, D, E, F by deleting certain wording
and adding certain wording that would enable the City Council to hold the public hearing on final
Hearing Examiner Minutes of June 22, 2000
subdivision plat requests instead of the Planning and Zoning Commission holding the public hearing and
' making a recommendation to Council. The intent is to eliminate an unnecessary step in the platting
process.
Testimony —
Linda James presented the staff report.
Public Testimony Closed — Mr. Dillion closed public testimony.
Findings of Fact— Mr. Dillion accepted the general facts outlined in the staff report as Findings of Fact.
Conclusions of Law— Mr. Dillion accepted the Conclusions of Law outlined in the staff report.
Recommendation to City Council— Mr. Dillion recommended approval of Case No. OA-32-00.
*******�**�**����:�*��**��*�*�*�****��:�******��*******��������***********��*�*�****��*���
VII. 1 nnin I ues- There were no lannin issues brou ht forward.
, P a g ss p g g
VIII. Adjournment — Mr. Dillion adjourned the meeting at approximately 10:05 p.m.
MINUTES APPROVED AND SIGNED BY HEARING EXAMINER LEE DILLION ON THE DATE NOTED BELOW.
Lee Dillion Date ATTEST:
Community Development Directar
, _.
�
Hearing Examiner Minutes of June 22, 2000