HomeMy WebLinkAbout5-25-2000 P&Z MINUTES „ i
r �
•
CALDWELL PUBLIC HEARINGS BEFORE HEARING EXAMINER
MINUTES OF MAy 25, 2000
I• Call to Order — Heari.ng Examiner M. Jerome Mapp opened the meeting for the public hearings at 7:00 p.m, and
outlined the public hearing procedures. City staff in attendance were: Linda James, Community Development
Director, George DeFord, Jr., City Attomey, and Joan Holmes, Administrative Secretary.
II. Hearings
A. Case No. SUB-30E-99 (Quail Meadow Subdivision), a request by V.E. Graves & Sons, Inc., for final plat
approval of 39 residential lots developed on approximately 14.'71 acres located in an R-1 (Single-Family
Residential) zone. The site is located between a portion of the east side of Dorman Avenue and a portion
of the undeveloped right-of-way of Marshall Avenue, adjacent to the west side of Manchester Park
Subdivisian.
Testimony —
Linda James presented the staff report and E�ibit A-5, an estimate of construction costs for complerion.
Dennis King, Applicant's representative, tesrified in favor.
No one testified in apposition.
Public Testimony Closed — Mr. Mapp closed public testimony.
Findings of Fact — Mr. Mapp accepted the facts outlined in the staff report as Findings of Fact and included the
following facts taken from testimony: the Applicant submitted an estimate of costs dated April 25, 2000; the
Applicant's engineer stated that nearly all of the items listed on the estimate have been completed.
Conclusions of Law — Mr. Mapp accepted the Conclusions of Law outlined in the staff report.
Recommendation to City Council— Mr. Mapp recommends approval on Case No. SUB-30E-99.
Public Hearing Cl�ed — Mr. Mapp closed the public hearing.
****************�**********************�***************************************************
B. Case No. SUP-11(A)-97 (Bean Hopper), a request by Nichole Lewis and Roxanne Hansen to amend
condition off Approval No. 6.8 of SUP-11-97, as approved by City Council on August 26, 1997. The
Bean Hopper is located at the intersection of Cleveland Boulevard and 21 Avenue and is more
commonly known as 2021 Cleveland Boulevard.
Testimony —
Linda James presented the staff report and Exhibits PR-1 and PR-2, letters of support. She also stated that no
changes to the facility were being requested.
Testifying in favor: Roxanne Hansen, Applicant. Nichole Lewis, Applicant, was signed up in favor but did not
speak.
No one testified in opposition.
Public Testimony Clmsed — Mr. Mapp closed public testimony.
Findings of Fact — Mr. Mapp accepted the facts outlined in the staff report as Findings of Fact and included the
following facts: no changes to the facility were being requested, and there were two letters of support.
Conclusions of Law — Mr. Mapp accepted the Conclusions of Law outlined in the staff report.
Order of Decision —Case No. SUP-11(A)-97, a request to amend Condition No. 8 of the Order of Decision r
approved by City Council on August 26, 1997 is approved and all other conditions outlined in the August 26, 1997
order shall remain as stated.
*** � * � **** � ***** � *** �� * � **: � ******* *** * ��r�*�******�:�*�*********��*:�****** **************** � **
C. Case No. SUB-34(1&2)F-99 (Southern Heights Subdivision), a request by K& L Development, LLC for
final plat approval of Unit 1 and 2, consisting of 97 residenrial and 2 common-area lots located on
approximately 20 acres in an R-1 zone. The site abuts the north side of Homedale Road and the west side
of Indiana Avenue.
Testimony—
Linda James presented the staff report and outlined the facts in the report. She also presented the following:
Eachibit PA-4, Exhibit A-6, and Exhibit A-7.
Rita Earl, Applicant's Representative, testified in favor. '
No one testified in opposirion.
Public Tesfimony Closed — Mr. Mapp closed public testimony.
Findings of Fact Mr. Mapp accepted the general facts outlined in the staff report as Findings of Fact and
included the following from testimony; The Hearing Examiner stated that he did not believe it was the intent of the
City Council to place a fencing condition on this subdivision that would .essentially cage each individual lot and
the Applicant is requesting removal of Condition No. 12.10 regazding fencing the parameter of each lot; the
estimate of costs for construcrion completion should be greatly reduced by the time the recommendation goes to
Council; the City Engineer a eed to allow P •�
� hases I and II t
o connect to the Ci s otable water s ste
irrigation water season ends in October of this ear; the develo er will � p y m�� �e
Y p connect its irrigation system to Pioneer
; before the next irrigation season; the Applicant submitted a copy of the proposed CC&Rs and has agreed to
° change them as necess to com 1 with the ''
:
azY p y City s ordinances.
' Conclusions of Law— Mr. Mapp accepted the Conclusions of Law out�ined in the staff report.
Recommendation to City Council —Case No. SUB-34(1&2)F-99 is recommended for approval with the
recommendarion that the fencin
re uirement to totall
g q y enclose each lot is removed.
Public Hearing Closed — Mr. Mapp closed the public hearing.
***** � ************** � *** � r ***���****�*******�*�*****�**********�****:�****�**** ***********
D. Case No. ANN-31-00, a request by Jan M. Vinson to annex approximately 48 acres into the City as an M-
1(Light-Industrial) zone. The 48 acres is legally described as a part of the NE '/a of Secrion 36, Township
4 North, Range 3 W.B.M and is located at the southwest comer of the intersection of Linden Street and
KCID Road.
Testimony —
Linda James presented the staff report and Exhibit HE-1000, an assessor's map with the site outlined.
Testifying in favor: Herb Rettig, Applicant's Representative and John Blaye, ApplicanYs Representarive. Mr.
Blaye presented Exhibit HE-1001, an aerial map of the area.
No one tesrified in opposition.
Public Testimony Closed — Mr. Mapp closed public testimony.
Comprehensive Plan Analysis — Mr. Mapp found that the request is in compliance with the following
Hearing Examiner Minutes of May 25, 2000
� Comprehensive Plan components: Industrial — Policies 1, 2, 3, and 7; Airport — Policy 2.
Findings of Fact Mr. Mapp accepted the general facts outlined in the staff report as Findings of Fact and
included the following £acts taken from testimony: Exhibit HE-1000 showing the site, and Eachibit HE-1001, an
aerial photograph were presented; the Applicant is willing to consider moving the e�cisting homes rather than
tearing them down; sewer and water aze in close proximity to the site.
Conclusions of Law— Mr. Mapp accepted the Conclusions of Law outlined in the staff report.
Recommendation to City Council—Case No. ANN-31-00 is recommended for approval, with a recommendation
that the Applicant is encouraged by the City to move the existing homes and not tear them down.
�*�x*�**:�*****�****�***********�*****************�****�*�******�***********�********
E. Case No. SUB-49P/F-00, a request by Reed Taylor for preliminary and final plat approval of Caldwell
Commercial Park Subdivision #2, which is a replat of Lot 4, Block 1, Caldwell Commercial Pazk
Subdivision. The site abuts the west side, of Aviation Way approacimately 1161 feet south of the
southwest comer of the intersection of State Highway 20/26 and Aviation Way.
Testimony —
Linda James presented the staff report and Exhibit HE-1000, a revised plat.
Reed Taylor, Applicant, tesrified in favor.
No one testified in opposition.
a .
Public Testimony Ciosed — Mr. Mapp closed public testimony.
Findings of Fact — NIr. Mapp accepted the facts outlined in the staff report as Findings of Fact and included the
following from testimony: Exhibit HE-1000, a copy of the revised plat; the City Engineer removed the pressurized
, irrigation requirement from the list of improvements to the site; the Applicant stated that he understands the
° procedures that have to be followed before the final plat can be recorded.
; -
� Conclusions of Law — Mr. Mapp accepted the Conclusions of Law outlined in the staff report.
Decision- A rove the relimina lat for a -
C se No. SUB-4
PP , p ry p 9P/F 00 and recommend a roval on final lat
PP P
without the requirement of pressurized irrigarion, and with the condition that a financial guarantee is provided in
accordance with the subdivision ordinance prior to recordarion of the final plat unless all of the requirements
placed on the plat by the City Engineer have been sarisfied.
.
Public Hearing Ciosed — Mr. Mapp closed the public hearing.
************��**:�***�**�**�***********�*****�****************�*******�********:�*******�****�
F. Case No. SUP-84-00, a request by Robert P. Hurtt for a planned unit development to have two separate
dwelling structures on one lot for a total of 4-dwelling units. The lot is located in a C-2 (Community
Commercial) zone and is more commonly laiown as 1018 Albany Street.
Testimony —
Linda James presented the staff report.
Robert Hurtt, Applicant, testified in favor and stated the following: there is a tri-plex on the property as well as the
vacant structure he wants to rent; there is gas, water, and electricity to the structure; the unit was empty when he
purchased the property last year but it had been rented; and he wants to totally remodel the structure.
I .
No one testified in op osition.
P
Public Testimony Closed — Mr. Mapp closed public testimony.
Hearing Examiner Minutes of May 25, 2000
� Comprehensive Plan Analysis — Mr. Mapp found that none of the Comprehensive Plan components applied.
Findings of Fact — Mr. Mapp accepted the facts outlined in the staff report as Findings of Fact and included the
Hearing Examiner's following comments: the request does not comply with requirements of Section 10-03-07,
Planned Unit Developments, Subsections 1, 2, 4, 8 and 9; it does not conform to the City of Notus's proposed
definition of a Planned Unit Development; the Applicant can research the status of the structure and provide proof
to the City that it is a grandfathered non-conforming use, which would entitle it to be rented for dwelling purposes;
the Applicant could file an appeal to City Council.
Conclusions of Law — Mr. Mapp accepted the Conclusions of Law outlined in the staff report.
Order of Decision —Case No. SUP-84-00 is denied. The Applicant has the right to appeal the decision to City �
Council or to provide proof that the structure was rented for d�velling purposes within the last two years.
��**�*�***�******************************�:�*****�************��********************�*******�
G. Case No. SUP-83-00, Don and Cheryl Lane, was withdrawn by the Applicant's prior to the hearing.
�****�***********�********:�***********:���*****��**�*****�*�************************:�********
H. Case No. SUP-85-00, a request by Matterhom Ice Cream, Inc., for a special use permit to place a '
sectional manufactured home on a permanent foundation at the business site for use as an office.
Matterhorn Ice Cream, Inc., is located in an M-1 (Light Industrial) zone and is more commonly known as
115 E. Plymouth Street.
Testimony —
Linda James presented the staff report.
Todd Wilson, Applicant, testified in favor. �
,
No one testified in oppositaon.
.
' Public Testimony Closed — Mr. Mapp closed public testimony.
;
C,
Comprehensive Pian Analysis — Mr. Mapp found that the request is in compliance with the following
Comprehensive Plan components: Industrial — Policies 2 and 3.
Findings of Fact — Mr. Mapp accepted the facts outlined in the staff report as Finclings of Fact and included the
foliowing facts taken from testimony: the Applicant does not intend to remove any trees; landscaping will be
installed around the new office; all conditions placed on the building permit will be met by the Applicant.
Conclusions of Law — Mr. Mapp accepted the Conclusions of Law outlined in the staff report.
Order of Decision —Case No. SUP-85-00 is approved with the standard conditions outlined in the staff report and
include the following condirions: the office shall be placed on a permanent foundation and declared real property
and landscaping will be instailed around the office; the landscaping plan will be submitted at the time of applyi.ng
for a building permit and shall be approved by the Community Development Director.
�**�*****��*********�*********��***************�****��**************************************
VII. Planning Issues- There were no planning issues brought forward.
VIII. Adjournment — Mr. Mapp adjourned the meeting at approaciinately 8:50 p.m
MINUTES APPROVED AND SIGNED BY HEARING EXAMINER M. JEROME MAPP, ON THE DATE NOTED
BELOW.
ATTEST:
M. Jerome Mapp Date
Community Development Director
Hearing Examiner Minutes of May 25, 2000