HomeMy WebLinkAbout9-9-1999 P&Z MINUTES P
� CALDWELL PLANNING AND ZONING COMMISSION
;,
' MINUTES OF SEPTEMBER 9, 1999
I. Call to Order — Chairxnan Blacker called the meeting to order at 7:00 p.m.
II. Roll Call
Members Present: Janie Archuleta, Matt Beebe, Jim Blacker
Staff Present: Linda Jarnes, Joan Holmes
Legal Counsel: Mark Hilty
III. Review of Proceedings —Chairman Blacker reviewed the procedures for public hearings.
IV. Poll Members for Conflict of Interest - Chairxnan Blacker polled members for conflicts of interest: there were
none.
V. Old Business —
A. Approve Minutes of August 5,1999 meeting. Motion: Commissioner Beebe. Second: Commissioner
Archuleta. Approve as written. Passed: Unanimous voice vote.
B. Approve Orders of Decision on Case Nos. SUP-62-99 (City of Caldwell ball diamond), Case No. SUP-
59-99 (John Stan), and Case No. SUP-63-99 Enterprise Car Rental). Motion: Commissioner Beebe.
Second: Cominissioner Archuleta. Approve the Orders of Decision for the referenced cases as written.
Passed: Unanimous voice vote.
VI. New Business — Hearings I
� A. Case No. SUP-64-99, a request by Jesus and Minerva Moreno for approval of a special use permit to
place a Class "B" manufactured home on an individual lot in an R-3 zone. The site is more commonly
laiown as 1315 Belmont Street.
Testimony —
Linda James presented the staff report and Exhibit A-5, pictures of the manufactured home. Mrs. James stated that
the Applicants would have to hook up to City utilities. There is a large tree in the center of the lot and it is unclear
whether it will fit with the manufactured home and srill meet setback requirements.
Marce Barrera, Applicants' representative, testified in favor and stated the Applicants want to move to their own
lot where they can make improvements, and they are willing to cut down the large tree if the home cannot meet the
setback requirements.
Public Testimony Closed —Chairman Blacker closed public testimony.
Comprehensive Plan Analysis - Morion: Commissioner Beebe. Second: Commissioner Archuleta. The request
is in compliance with the following Comprehensive Plan Components: Residential- Policy 2; Housing- Policy SC.
Passed: Unanimous roll call vote.
Findings of Fact — Motion: Commissioner Beebe. Second: Commissioner Archuleta. Accept the general facts
outlined in the staff report as Findings of Fact and include the following: The Applicant's are willing to cut the
large tree if needed so the manufactured home will fit within City's setbacks. Passed: Unanimous roll call vote.
Conclusions of Law — Motion: Commissioner Beebe. Second: Commissioner Archuleta. The Commission has
the authority to hear this case and to approve or deny; public notice requirements were met; and the hearing was
conducted within the guidelines of Idaho Code and City ordinances. Passed: Unanixnous roll call vote.
.;
- Order of Decision — Motion: Commissioner Beebe. Second: Commissioner Archuleta. Approve Case No. SUP-
64-99 with the standard conditions of approval outlined in the staff report and include the fact brought out in
testimony that the Applicants will meet the City's setbacks. Passed: Unanimous roll call vote.
' Public Hearing Closed —Chairman Blacker closed the public hearing and noted that anyone wanting to appeal the
Commission's decision is to see the Director.
**�r���**�*****�*�**�******��*�********�******�*********��***�*******�*****�******�
B. Case No. SUB-25(6)F-99 (West Valley No. 6), a request by West Valley Development, LLC for final
subdivision plat approval of 79 residential and i common-area lot on approximately 18.82 acres located
within an R-1 zone. The site is adjacent to the southern boundary of West Va11ey Estates No. 5
Testimony —
Linda James presented the staff report and noted that Pioneer Irrigation District did not submit written approval of
the pressurized system.
Matt Munger, engineer for the Applicant, tesrified to the following: there have been some problems with the
project and the irrigation system being turned over to Pioneer; the developers had given some thought at one time
to tuming the system over to Caldwell Lateral Irrigation District but it has reverted back to Pioneer and the
developers are now working with the Disirict on the agreement; the developers want to turn Phases 1 through 5
over to Pioneer as soon as possible and then turn the rernaining phases over to Pioneer one year after the final
phase; the system is currently owned by the developers who have a contract with a private maintenance company
that acts as the clearing house on behalf of the Homeowners' Association; there have been problems with pumps
shutting down but the developers are trying to ensure that it doesn't continue; Pioneer will be taking over the entire
system at some point in time and the developers are working with Pioneer to reach agreement on when this will
happen; he doesn't really know how severe the problems are with the system; it appears that the biggest problem
has more to do with irrigation in the common areas; the biggest problem with Pioneer is a personality conflict but
he believes they have gotten past that; the original agreement was that the entire system would be turned over to
Pioneer one year after the final phase; the developers are now asking for a one-year extension on the remaining
phases so Pioneer would not be taking over the entire system until the year 2003.
Mark Clark, attorney representing the Applicant, testified to the following: the Commission should keep in mind
that the only issue at this hearing is the request for fmal plat approval of Phase 6; the developers have complied
with everything required by the City's engineering and planning departments; it is the right decision for West
Valley to be within Pioneer's jurisdicrion.
Denise McDermott, spokesperson for the Homeowners' Association, testified in opposition presented E�ibit PZ-
1, a packet of correspondence related to the irrigarion issues in West Valley. Her concerns included: the
Homeowners' Association was formed in June of this year with management of the common areas turned over to
the group at that same time; there is an outstanding bill for $1900 due this month but the Association has no
money; the pump for the irrigation system is running off of a battery pack, which has to be replaced every few
weeks and is expensive; the property management company and the maintenance man are unpaid; no monies were
turned over to the Associarion to pay bills; each homeowner buying a lot in West Valley was assessed $100 which
was understood to be for setting up the Association, but there are no monies; it was represented to many persons
buying a lot that there would be a neighborhood park but no park has been developed; there are drainage problems
in many areas of the development and some homeowners have taken care of the problem on their own because the
developers will not respond to complaints; homeowners in the subdivision have begun to panic because of
problems and quesrions going unresolved and unanswered; the Associarion has to have answers because bills are
coming due and they don't lrnow what to do.
Wendy Brown, West Valley homeowner, testified in opposition and presented a video showing problem areas
within the subdivision.
Ken Bru�h, Pioneer Imgation Board Director, testified that: there are problems in the subdivision; there is a
difference of opinion between the developers and the District; the system, through Phase 6 has never been
inspected by the District; the developers submitted specifications to Pioneer but never called for inspecrions of the
installation; the District is reluctant to take over the system; the District has been working with the developers for
over two years but there is still no agreement.
Naida Kelleher, Secretary/Treasurer for Pioneer Irrigation, testified that the District will not take over Phases 1
through 5 at this time; the District will not take over any part of the system until one year after the final phase.
Matt Munger testified in rebuttal that: the developers are responsible for the irrigation system but not the common �
`+ f areas; some landscaping has been replaced; the pump is operating adequately; the system far Phases 2 and 3 were
,� approved by the District.
' f � Public Testimony Closed —Chairman Blacker closed public testimony.
Findings of Fact — Motion: Commissioner Beebe. Second: Commissioner Archuleta. Accept eh general facts as
outlined in the staff report as findings of fact and include the following as facts: no letter of approval from Pioneer
Irrigation has been submitted; Pioneer's letter of August 27, 1999 states that they will not take over the well until
they are prepared to accept the entire irrigation system and the date for that to occur is unclear; Ken Brush and
Naida Kelleher of Pioneer both testified that it is highly unlikely that the District will be taking over the system
within the near future; Gordon Law's memorandum of September 1 included unresolved issues as outlined in No.
4 of the memo. Passed: Unanimous roll call vote.
Conclusions of Law — Morion: Commissioner Beebe. Second: Commissioner Archuleta. The Planning and
Zoning Commission has the authority to hear requests for final plat approval and to make a recommendarion to
City Council; the hearing was legally noriced and conducted within the guidelines of applicable codes and
ordinances. Passed: Unanunous roll call vote.
Recommendation to City Council — Motion: Commissioner Beebe. Second: Commissioner Archuleta. Based
upon the Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law, the Planning and Zoning Commission recommends to the
Mayor and City Council that Case No. SUB-25 (6)F-99, a request by West Valley Development, LLC for final plat
approval of West Valley Estates Phase 6 is denied until the irrigation issues have been resolved. Passed:
Unanimous roll call vote.
Public Hearing Closed —Chairman Blacker closed the public hearing.
VII. Planning Issues- No planning issues were discussed
VIII. Adjournment —Chairman Blacker adjourned the meeting at approximately 9:10 p.m.
MINUTES APPROVED BY COMMISSION MEMBERS, AND SIGNED BY CHAIRMAN BLACKER, AT A
REGULARLY SCHEDULED MEETING HELD SEPTEMBER 23, 1999.
w
��.,, ATTEST:
C mnan Jim Blacker �
V ,
Community D elo ment Director
. j _