HomeMy WebLinkAbout9-24-1998 P&Z MINUTES `-�
CALDWELL PLANNING AND ZONING COMIVIISSION
1VIINUTES OF SEPTEMBER 24,1998
I. Call to Order - Chairman Bill Roos called the meeting to order at 7:00 p.m.
II. Roll Call
Members Present: William Roos, Charles Murphy, Reed Taylor, Janie Archuleta
Staff Present: Linda James, Bud Knickerbocker, Marci Perry
Legal Counsel: Terry Michaelson
III. Review of Proceedings - Chairman Roos reviewed the procedures for public hearings.
IV. Poll Members for Conflict of Interest - Chairman Roos polled members for conflicts of
interest: there were none.
V. Old Business —
A. Approve Minntes of September 10, 1998 - Motion: Commissioner Murphy.
Second: Commissioner Taylor. Approve as written. Passed: Unanimous voice
vote.
B. Approve Orders of Decision for the Following Cases: Case No. SUP-43-98 (CA
Transportation/Child Caze); SUP-44-98 (Yvonne Patxick). Motion: Commissioner
Murphy. Second: Commissioner Taylor. Approve as written. Passed: Unaninious
voice vote.
C. Approve Recommendation on the Following Case: Case No. ANN/ZON-1-98
(Lucille Grant). Motion: Commissioner Taylor. Second: Commissioner Murphy. �
Approve the recommendation for the referenced case as written. Passed: Unanimous
voice vote.
VI. New Business - Hearings
A. Case No. SUP-45-98, a request by Karla Bull to operate a Child Care Center in
an existing building located in a C-2 zone. The building is located at the
southwest comer of the intersection of Elgin and 9`� Street and is more
commonly known as 522 N. 9�` Street.
Testimony -
Bud Knickerbocker presented the sta.ff report, and Exhibit PZ-1000 a copy of an
Assessor's map, showi.ng the location of the site with surrounding zoni.ng.
;�,, Larry Bu11, Applicant's representative, testified in support and noted that the facility was
- in compliance with ADA requirements.
Public Testimony Closed — Chairman Roos closed the public testimony.
Comprehensive Plan Analysis — Moved: Commissioner Taylor. Second:
Commissioner Murphy. The request is in compliance with the Comprehensive Plan as
follows: Commercial Categories, Policies 1, 3 and 4; Historic Areas, Goal and Policies 1
through 4; Community Design, Policy 2. Passed: Unanimous roll ca11 vote.
Findings of Fact — Motion: Commissioner Murphy. Second: Commissioner Taylor.
Accept the general facts outlined in the staff report and include the testimony as fmdings
of facts. Passed: Unanimous roll call vote.
Conclusions of Law — Motion: Commissioner Murphy. Second: Commissioner Taylor.
The Commission has the authority to hear this case and to approve or deny; public
notice requirements were met; and the heari.ng was conducted within the guidelines of
Idaho Codes and City ordinances. Passed: Unanimous roll call vote.
Order of Decision — Motion: Commissioner Murphy. Second: Commissioner
Archuleta. Approve the request with the standard conditions and include the condition
that the maximum number of children permitted in the facility at any one time shall be
85. Passed: Unanimous roll call vote.
Public Hearing Closed — Chairman Roos closed the public hearing and noted that
anyone wishing to appeal the decision of the Commission should contact the
Community Development Director.
*�*����*��**�����������������*������*��**������������*�������*�����r��***�r*���*
B. Case No. SUP-46-98, a request by Thomas R. Ensley & Associates, representing
the Canyon County Board of Commissioners, to construct a two-story 25,626-
foot addition on the north side of the eausting Juvenile Detention Center located
in a C-2 zone. The addition will house a total of 104 beds and will include a
meeting room and space for 22 additional County offices. The Juvenile
Detention Center is located at the northwest corner of the intersection of 13�'
Avenue and Albany Street.
Testimony —
Bud Knickerbocker presented the staff report, and E�ibit PZ-1000, a copy of an
Assessor's map,showing the location of the site with surrounding zoni.ng.
Tom Ensley, ApplicanYs representative, testified in favor of the project and noted the
following: the existing center was built in 1990-91 and is across the street from the court
house and jail; the existing center is one level and the addition will be 2 levels; there will
be 90 beds and not 104 as originally intended; the parki.ng area is a vacant gravel lot; the
new addition will be an extension on the north side of the existing center and will be
similar in character; there will be a 10 foot high fence installed around the facility.
Stephen Jett, Coordinator of Juvenile State Corrections, testified in favor of the project
;., and noted the following: the 18 bed facility is housing 27 juveniles at this time; there is a
waiting list of 80 juveniles; the facility serves 5 counties but only 28% are admitted
� because of the lack of space; occupancy is always full; the addition is designed to be a
functional facility and will be more efficient than others he has seen.
Public Testimony Closed — Chairman Roos closed the public testimony.
Comprehensive Plan Analysis — Moved: Commissioner Murphy. Second:
Commissioner Taylor. The proposed project is in compliance with the Comprehensive
Plan as follows: Public Facilities Plan, Policies 1 and 2; Essential Services, Policy 1.
Passed: Unanimous roll call vote.
Findings of Fact — Motion: Commissioner Taylor. Second: Commissioner Murphy.
Approve the general facts and testimony as fmdings of fact and include the facts that the
facility is at 150% of its capacity, and a vacant lot will be used for the expansion and
will not be taking parking spaces from other uses. Passed: Unanimous roll call vote.
Conclusions of Law — Motion: Commissioner Murphy. Second: Commissioner Taylor.
The Commission has the authority to hear this case and to approve or deny; public
notice requirements were met; and the hearing was conducted within the guidelines of
Idaho Codes and City ordinances. Passed: Unanimous roll call vote.
Order of Decision — Motion: Commissioner Taylor. Second: Commissioner Murphy.
Approve the request with the standard conditions. Passed: Unanimous roll call vote.
Public Hearing Closed — Chairman Roos closed the public hearing and stated that
anyone wishing to appeal the decision of the Commission is to contact the Community
� Development Director.
**********************************�*******************************************
C. Case No. SUP-47-98, a request by Treasure Valley Christian Center, Inc., to
locate a church and conduct church services in an e�usting building located in a
C-2 zone. The building is located at the northwest corner of 7`� Avenue and
Arthur and is more commonly known as 214 South 7�' Avenue.
Testimony -
Linda James presented the staff report and Exhibit PZ 1000, a copy of the BID map
showing the location of the site and its relationship to the depot; Exhibit PZ 1001,
architectural renderi.ngs prepared by Tom Ensley and Associates. The renderings depict a
central, out-door area that is intended to be an open area with landscaping, benches and
period lighting that will be the focal point of drawing the downtown businesses and depot
together.
Reverend Royce Wright, Treasure Valley Christian Center, testified that the building has
been vacant for over a yeaz and is in disarray; the intent is to restore the building and
parking lot; there are currently 60 members; the parking lot that belongs to the buildi.ng
could accommodate 400 members.
Vince Wright testified that the proposed use as a church is in the central core of the
.., downtown; the Townsite Committee has been trying to get a BID in place in order to
have a taa� base that would be used for upgradi.ng the downtown area; churches don't pay
taxes so they would not be participants in the BID.
Reverend Wright testified that the building in still on the tax rolls and that the owner
approached the Church regarding relocating to the site. Services are Saturday nights,
Sunday mornings, and Wednesday nights.
In response to Commissioner Archuleta's question regarding the affect this type of use
would have on the BID, Linda James noted the following: The BID is intended to be able
to function through taxation. It is understood at this time that the building housing the
church will remain on the tax rolls; however, will it be taken off the rolls at some future
time? Another thing that the Commission members need to understand is that existing
restaurants and establishments serving alcoholic beverages that are within 300 feet of a
church may continue to serve alcohol; if the church is existing, then newly locating
establishments within 300 feet of the church could not serve beer or wi.ne, or alcoholic
beverages. The BID doesn't actually function until 51% of the required signatures have
been obtained; there are 49% of the signatures in place at this time and the Townsite
Committee is having a struggle to obtain the remaining 2%. Presently the City is moving
away from pressing for the remaining 2% and is working toward an LID to get the
downtown up and running and to get some enthusiasm in the downtown area for
commercial uses. The City is prepari.ng to apply for grant monies to revitalize the
downtown area and as a part of the funding request the BID should be in place.
Public Testimony Closed — Chairman Roos closed public testimony.
Comprehensive Plan Analysis — Moved: Commissioner Taylor. Second: Commissioner
Murphy. The proposed project is in compliance with the Comprehensive Plan as follows:
Commercial Categories, Policies 1 and 3; Historic Areas, Goal; Downtown, Policies 2, 4
and 5 Passed: Unanimous roll call vote.
Findings of Fact — Motion: Commissioner Murphy. Second: Commissioner Taylor.
Accept the general facts as outlined in the staff report and include the testimony as
findings of fact. Passed: Unanimous roll call vote.
Conclusions of Law — Motion: Commissioner Taylor. Second: Commissioner Murphy.
The Commission has the authority to hear this case and to approve or deny; public notice
requirements were met; and the hearing was conducted within the guidelines of Idaho
Code and City ordinances. Passed: Unanimous roll call vote.
Order of Decision — Motion: Commissioner Murphy. Second: Commissioner
Archuleta. Deny the request because it is important to get the business development and
to beautify the area around the train station because it could do a great deal for Caldwell.
Passed: By a two to one roll call vote.
Public Hearing Closed — Chairman Roos closed the public hearing and stated that
anyone wishing to appeal the decision of the Commission is to contact the Community
Development Director.
�*����*���*����r�������*��*��*�*�*����*****��*�****������*���**�*�����*�*����**
, ,�,
� D. Case No. SUP-48-98, a request by Carolyn Devlin to use an e�usting building and
grounds located within an R-1 zone for the purpose of providing a setting for business
meetings, social gatherings, weddings and receptions; and to place a manufactured home
on the site for use as security guard living quarters. The site consists of approximately 5
acres and is more commonly known as 701 N. Indiana Avenue.
Testimony -
Linda James presented the staff report and E�ibit PZ 1000, a copy of the Assessor's map
showing the project site and surrounding zoning, and Exhibit A-5, photographs taken by
the Applicant that show the existing house and grounds.
Carolyn Devlin, Applicant, testified that the project would bring a lot to the community;
people attending weddings would rent motel rooms, and business meetings would bri.ng
people into the city; if the special use permit is approved she would purchase the
property; the manufactured home to be used for security guard quarters would be behind
the eausting house and hidden from view; she would personally be living in the security
guard quarters.
Linda Gepner signed up in favor but did not speak.
Tim Hogg spoke in opposition and testified that his home is across the street from the
subject site and that the view would be directly toward the parking azea; the site is within
a unique corner that has large acreage and homes; traffic might be a hazard; the site is not
suitable for this type of business in this area.
Bill Uhl spoke in opposition and testified that he lives just down the street; the entry off
of Indiana is right at the crest of a hill, which would be dangerous for a large volume of
traffic; residential districts need to be kept residential and use the downtown for
businesses.
Carolyn Devlin spoke in rebuttal and testified that the property has been on the market
for some time and is priced to high for it to continue to be used as a residence; the
gardens, trees and shrubs will be kept in place.
Public Testimony Closed — Chairman Roos closed the public testimony.
Comprehensive Plan Analysis — Moved: Commissioner Murphy. Second:
Commissioner Taylor. The proposed request is in compliance with the Comprehensive
Plan as follows: Residential Categories, Policy 7. Passed: Unanimous roll call vote.
Findings of Fact — Motion: Commissioner Murphy. Second: Commissioner Taylor.
Accept the general facts as outlined in the staff report as findings of fact and include the
following: the properly below the subject site is used for commercial business; neighbors
across the street would be able to look across into the parking lot; the owner of the
property intends to live on-site; the property has been on the mazket for some time and
the sale price is quite high; Indiana is a collector street; the entrance to the site is on a
steep hill. Passed: Unanimous roll call vote.
�, Conclusions of Law — Motion: Commissioner Taylor. Second: Commissioner Murphy.
The Commission has the authority to hear this case and to approve or deny; public notice
� requirements were met; and the hearing was conducted within the guidelines of Idaho
Code and City ordinances. Passed: Unanimous roll call vote.
Order of Decision — Motion: Commissioner Taylor. Second: Commissioner Archuleta.
Approve Case No. SUP-48-98 with the standard conditions and include the following
conditions: a berm or tight-screen of plantings sha11 be installed to shield the parking area
from the neighbors and the street. If the use is discontinued, the parking and bermed area
will be returned to its present state; the only other residence placed on the properly sha11
be a single-family dwelling on a separate lot. Passed: By a two to one roll call vote.
Public Hearing Closed — Chairman Roos closed the public hearing and stated that
anyone wishing to appeal the decision of the Commission is to contact the Community
Development Director.
��**����*����������*�***��*��*�*�r��r���*���*����****�����r�������*����**��
E. To hear concurrently Case Nos. ZON-Ol-098 and SUB-25P-98 (West Valley
Estates, Phases 6, 7, and 8), a request by West Valley Development, LLC, to rezone -
approa�imately 57.32 acres from R-S and R-S2 (Semi-Rural Residential) to R-1 (Single-
Family Residential), and preliminary subdivision plat approval to develop 220 residential
and 6 common-azea lots on the aforementioned acreage. The site is located south of West
Valley Estates Subdivision, Phase 5 and lies along the northem boundary of Homedale
Road approximately one-eighth mile east of South 10`� Avenue.
Testimony — Case No. ZON-Ol-98
Linda James presented the staff report and PZ1000, the City's zoning map, which shows
the subject site.
Wayne Forrey, ApplicanYs representative, testified that the reason the area was initially
zoned R-S and R-S2 was the lack of the City's sewage capacity to serve this area as an R-
1 zone in 1994 and that lots at that time would have had to be large in order to provide
adequate area for septic systems; the City now has the capacity to connect this area with
the public sewage system.
Sonia Huyck testified in opposition and stated that the zoning approved in 1994 was
because of the lazger lots that would be created by the R-S and R-S2 zones and that it
created a common meeting ground between the developer and the residents in the area;
there is no compelling reason to change what was worked so hard by residents in 1994 to
accomplish; the larger lots were intended to provide a buffer between small lots in the
subdivision and the larger parcels abutting the western and southern boundaries of the
project; the entire West Va11ey Estates before annexation and zoni.ng was all farmland
with one dwelling; financial hardship claimed by the developer should not be the over-
riding factor for the rezone.
Bob Torrey testified in opposition and stated that he build his home in 1976, which
provided a view toward the northeast (rezone site) and that the larger lots under the
current zoning help in keeping this view open.
,, Di�e Parker testified in opposition and stated that at the time the zoning was created it
was meant to help buffer and provide a transition to the 3+ acre parcels across the Canal;
homes on these lots are $250,000 and up and to now have them surrounded by $70,000
homes on small lots in West Valley is not appropriate; the University of Moscow
extension, which is an agricultural setting is directly south of West Valley and across
Homedale Road.
Byron Parker testified in opposition and stated that they had fought hard to get the R-S
and R-S2 zoning in this area and could not understand why they were coming back in
four years to change it.
Melissa Huyck signed up in opposition but did not speak.
Wayne Forrey testified in rebuttal that the proposed rezone area could now be provided
with a full range of City services, which would support smaller lots; there have been
many changes in Caldwell since 1994.
Sonia Huyck, on sur-rebuttal and speaking on behalf of those opposing the rezone,
testified that sewer availability was not the issue in 1994 when the zoni.ng was
established, and that lot sizes were the issue and a compromise between the neighborhood
and the developer was reached with the creation of the R-S and R-S2 zones.
Public Testimony Closed — Chairman Roos closed public testimony.
Comprehensive Plan Analysis — Moved: Commissioner Murphy. Second:
Commissioner Taylor. The following Comprehensive Plan components and policies
apply to the rezone as follows: Land Use Goal; Agricultural Land Use, Policy 1;
Residential Categories, Policies 2 and 7; Housing Goa1, Policy l. Passed: Unanimous
roll call vote.
Findings of Fact — Motion: Commissioner Taylor. Second: Commissioner Murphy.
Accept the general facts outlined in the staff report as findings of fact and include: the
subdivision has developed as initially planned through Phase 5; the subject site was R-S
and R-S2 under the 1996 Master Plan; sewer capacity is now in place but it wasn't there
in 1994. Passed: Unanimous roll call vote.
Conclusions of Law — Motion: Commissioner Murphy. Second: Commissioner Taylor.
The Commission has the authority to hear this case and to make a recommendation to the
Mayor and City Council for approval or denial; public notice requirements were met; and
the hearing was conducted within the guidelines of Idaho Code and City ordinances.
Passed: Unanimous roll call vote.
Recommendation — Motion: Commissioner Murphy. Second: Commissioner
Archuleta. Recommend to the Mayor and City Council that the request for the rezone be
denied because there is no compelling reason for it to be approved. Passed: Un�nimous
roll call vote.
Public Hearing Closed — Chairman Roos closed the public hearing.
*���*��**���������������***�**�*�**�����***����������**�*�����**��****�*���*��
.,
� E. Case No. SUB-25P-98 (West Valley Estates, Phases 6, 7 and 8)
Testimony —
Linda James presented the stafFreport.
Wayne Forrey, Applicant's representative, testified that nice homes have been
constructed in West Valley Estates and the developer wants to continue building; West
Va11ey is beginning to look good and there is a good mix of lot sizes; the plat is in
compliance with the requirements of the Fire Marshal and City Engineer; Pioneer
Irrigation and the developer have come to an agreement on Pioneer being a part of the
subdivision and will operate the system.
Sonia Huyck spoke in opposition and testified that the additional lots will add an extra
burden on traffic already generated by the subdivision.
Bob Torrey spoke in opposition and testified to the high volume of traffic on Homedale
Road, and noted that his property elevation is higher tha.n the proposed development.
Byron Parker spoke in opposition to the plat.
Wayne Forrey testified in rebuttal that there would be landscaping installed to screen
portions of the proposed phases.
Public Testimony Closed — Chairman Roos closed the public testimony.
Comprehensive Plan Analysis — Moved: Commissioner Murphy. Second:
Commissioner Taylor. The same Comprehensive Plan Analysis as found in Case No.
ZON-01-98 applies to this Case. Passed: Unanimous roll call vote.
Findings of Fact — Moved: Commissioner Taylor. Second: Commissioner Murphy.
Accept the general facts as outlined in the staff report as the Findings of Fact. Passed:
Unanimous roll call vote.
Conclusions of Law — Moved: Commissioner Murphy. Second: Commissioner
Archuleta. The Commission has the authority to hear this case and to make a
recommendation of approval of denial to the Mayor and City Council; public notice
requirements were met; and the hearing was conducted within the guidelines of Idaho
Code and City Ordinances. Passed: Unanimous roll call vote.
Recommendation - Moved: Commissioner Murphy. Second: Commissioner Taylor.
Recommend to the Mayor and City Council that the subdivision proposal should be
denies because the proposed plat does not conform to the required lot sizes in an R-S and
R-S2 zone. Passed: Unanimous roll call vote.
Public Hearing Closed — Chairman Roos closed the public hearing.
��**�****�r***��������*�**�*����**��**�**���*���*�**���r����**���*��*��*���**���
.,
�- VI Discussion on Planning Issues
1. Manufactured Home Ordinance — Members reviewed proposed changes to OA-18-98
and approved the changes (a copy of the proposed changes in a part of case file OA-
18A-98). Linda James noted that the hearing on the ordinance would be set for
October 22, 1998.
VII Adjournment - Chairman Roos adjourned the meeting at approximately 11:20 p.m.
THESE MIr]UTES APPROVED AT A REGULARLY SCHEDULED MEETING HELD
OCTOBER 22, 1998.
i�� �
__ �_---
ATTEST:
William Roos, Chairman
� �
�-' ""r�
ed T r, S cretary Community Devel m t Director
,..�