HomeMy WebLinkAbout9-10-1998 P&Z MINUTES � R
• �
CALDWELL PLANNING AND ZONING CONIlVIISSION
MINUTES OF SEPTEMBER 10,1998
L Call to Order - Chairman Bill Roos called the meeting to order at appro�cimately 7:00
p.m.
II. Roll Call
Members Present: William Roos, Charles Murphy, Reed Taylor
Staff Present: Linda James, Bud Knickerbocker, Mazci Perry
Legal Counsel: Terry Michaelson
III. Review of Proceedings - Chairman Roos reviewed the procedures for public hearings.
IV. Poll Members for Conflict of Interest - Chairman Roos polled members for conflicts of
interest: there were none.
V. Old Business —
A. Approve Minutes of August 13, 1998 - Motion: Commissioner Murphy. Second:
Commissioner Taylor. Approve as written. Passed: Unaniinous voice vote.
B. Approve Orders of Decision for the Following Cases: None.
C. Approve Recommendations on the Following Cases: Case No. SUB-39-98
(Freddie Lane); SUB-41-98 (Chris Duplex); VAR-11-98 & SUP-42-98 (Marilyn
Jordan). Motion: Commissioner Murphy. Second: Commissioner Taylor. Approve
the recommendations for the referenced cases as written. Passed: Unanimous voice
vote.
VI. New Business - Hearings
A. Case No. SUP-43-98, a request by the Caldwell Transportation Company for a
Group Day Care Facility to provide childcare services for company employees.
The childcare services will be incorporated within the company's new office
building and will occur between the hours of 7:OOa.m. to 4:OOp.m. during school
days and hours. The site is located within an R-1 zone and is more commonly
known as 3503 S. 10`� Avenue.
Testimony —
Bud Knickerbocker presented the staff report, and E�ibit PZ-1000 a copy of an
Assessor's map showi.ng the location of the site.
Patricia Uhl's testimony was as follows: wants to provide this service to drivers so they
could get good employees; day care would be provided during the time drivers aze on
their routes, normally 1.5 hours in the morning and 2 hours in the afternoon; the building
is 24 X 50 and includes one large conference room plus a drivers' area and these azeas
aze vacant while the drivers are out; the only other azea in use is a small office; the
restrooms are handicapped accessible; the office can communicate by two-way radio with
drivers while they are on their runs; drivers have had problems with daycare because of
their irregular work schedules, which in turn is a financial hardship to them; only children
of the drivers will be accepted for daycare.
Public Testimony Closed — Chairman Roos closed the public testimony.
Comprehensive Plan Analysis — Moved: Commissioner Murphy. Second:
Commissioner Taylor. The proposed project is in compliance with the Comprehensive
Plan as follows: Residential Categories — Policy 12. Passed: Unanimous roll call vote.
Findings of Fact — Motion: Commissioner Murphy. Second: Commissioner Taylor.
Approve the general facts as findings of fact as stated in the Staff Report. Passed:
Unanimous roll call vote.
Conclusions of Law — Motion: Commissioner Taylor. Second: Cono.missioner
Murphy. The Commission has the authority to hear this case and to approve or deny;
public notice requirements were met; and the hearing was conducted within the
guidelines of Idaho Codes and City ordinances. Passed: Unani.mous roll call vote.
Order of Decision — Motion: Commissioner Murphy. Second: Commissioner Taylor.
Approve the request with the standard conditions and include the conditions that the child
caze center will provide care for no more than 12 children at any time, and child care will
be provided for Company drivers only.
Public Hearing Closed — Chairman Roos closed the public heari.ng and stated that
anyone wishing to appeal the decision of the Commission is to contact the Community
Development Director.
B. Case No. ANN/ZON-1-98, a request by Lucille Grant to annex approxi.mately
5.6 acres, currently zoned County Agricultural, into the City of Caldwell as a C-
3, Service Commercial zone. The northem portion of the site abuts the southwest
side of Caldwell Boulevard; the southern portion of the site is bordered by Notus
Canal. The northern portion of the site is also approximately 1200 feet south of
the intersection of Ustick Road and Caldwell Boulevazd.
Testimony —
Bud Knickerbocker presented the staff report, and E��hibit PZ-1000, a copy of an
Assessor's map showing the location of the site.
George Grant, Applicant, testified that his mother owns the property, and that there is no
particular plans for the site as this time, but they want this property annexed into the '
city. This properiy is totally suirounded by the city; plans involve surveying and doing '
a lot line adjustrnent with adjoining properties in order to create a more uniform lot.
Public Testimony Closed — Chairman Roos closed the public testimony.
Comprehensive Plan Analysis — Moved: Commissioner Taylor. Second:
Commissioner Murphy. The request is in compliance with the following
Comprehensive Plan policies: Agricultural Land Use, policy 3; Industrial Catagories,
policy 2. Passed: Unanimous roll call vote.
Findings of Fact — Motion: Commissioner Taylor. Second: Commissioner Murphy.
Approve the general facts as the fact that the Applicant is in the process of surveying the
property for lot line adjustments. Passed: Unanimous roll call vote.
Conclusions of Law — Motion: Commissioner Taylor. Second: Commissioner
Murphy. The Commission has the authority to hear this case and to recommend
approval or denial to City Council; public notice requirements were met; and the hearing
was conducted within the guidelines of Idaho Codes and City ordinances. Passed:
Unanimous roll call vote.
Recommendation to City Council for Annezation as a C-3 Zone -- Motion:
Commissioner Murphy. Second: Commissioner Taylor. Planning and Zoning
Commission members unanimously recommend to the City Council that Case No.
ANN/ZON-1-98, a request by George M. Grant to annex approximately 5.6 acres into
the City as a C-3 zone be approved. Passed: Unanimous roll call vote.
Public Hearing Closed — Chairman Roos closed the public hearing.
C. Case No. SUP-44-98 a request by Yvonne Patrick to operate a child care center
in an existing building located in a C-2 zone. The buildi.ng is located at 606
Main. �
Testimony - i
�
Linda James presented the staff report and the following Earhibits: PZ1000, a copy of
the Assessor's map showing the site and proposed pazking area; A-5, a copy of a letter
from Rick Wells noting that he was working on a contract agreement with the
Applicant for an out-door play area; and A-6, a copy of a letter from Bob Bushnell
noting that he would lease the parking azea for employee pazking and drop-off/pick-up
of the children.
Yvonne Patrick, Applicant, testified that she is finalizing an agreement with Rick Wells
on leasing an adjacent pazcel for use as the outdoor play azea and the area will be
completely fenced; she has approval from Bob Bushnell to use a lot located behind the
building for employee parking and loading/unloading children; she will clean up the
parking lot and paint stall azeas for parking; she understands that if she loses either of
the leased lots that she will not be in compliance with the requirements for a Group
Day Caze Facility; parents of the children will be required to walk them across the alley
from the parking area to the building and will be required to sign them in each day; her
responsibility to the children will begin once they are inside the building; she has
liability insurance; she will be putting a sign in the pazking lot which will designate
parki.ng for the day care use only; and the play equipmendfencing will enhance the
currently vacant lot.
� —
PubLc Testimony Closed Chairman Roos closed public testimony.
Comprehensive Plan Analysis — Moved: Commissioner Murphy. Second:
Commissioner Taylor. The proposal is in compliance with the following
Comprehensive Plan policies: 1) Commercial Categories — Policies 1,3, and 4; Historic
Areas — Policy 2. Passed: Unanimous roll call vote.
F�ndings of Fact — Motion: Commissioner Murphy. Second: Commissioner Taylor.
Accept the general facts as findi.ngs of fact and include the testimony that the Applicant
will obtain written lease agreements for the playground lot and
pazking/loading/unloading lot. Passed: Unanimous roll call vote.
Conclusions of Law — Motion: Commissioner Taylor. Second: Commissioner
Murphy. The Commission has the authority to heaz this case and to approve or deny;
public notice requirements were met; and the hearing was conducted within the
guidelines of Idaho Code and City ordinances. Passed: Unanimous roll call vote.
Order of Decision — Motion: Comm.issioner Murphy. Second: Commissioner Taylor.
Approve the request with the standard conditions and to include the condition that the
Special Use Permit is valid for a maximum of 26 children at any one time..
Public Hearing Closed — Chairman Roos closed the public hearing and stated that
anyone wishing to appeal the decision of the Commission is to contact the Community
Development Director.
V. Discussion on Workshop — Linda. James informed Commission members of the public
workshop to be held September 23, 1998 at 6:OOpm, with City Council members and
Planning & Zoning.
VI. Rear Yard Set-Back Issues — Linda James proposed that a draft ordinance be written,
changing the current rear yazd set-back of 20 feet to 15 feet. Members concurred.
VII. Adjournment - Chairman Roos adjourned the meeting at approximately 8:10 p.m.
TI�SE MINUTES APPROVED AT A REGULARLY SCHEDULE MEETING HELD
SEPTEMBER 24, 1998.
I
ATTEST: ,
William Roos, Chairman I
Charles Murphy, Vice Cha.irnian Community Development Director