HomeMy WebLinkAbout3-26-1998 P&Z MINUTES . � � '
� �_ ` COMiVIUNITI( DEe/ELOPMENT DE�ARTME�13
� -�-=
� � • � 1 I '�� �� � ��� 621 CLEVELAND BLVD.
V � � CALDWELL, ID 83605
LINDA JAMES TELEPHONE 455-3021
Community Development Director FAX 455-3003
CALDWELL PLAN1vING AND ZO1vING COMIVIISSION
MINUTES OF MARCH 26,1998
I. Call to Order - Chauman Bill Roos called the meeting to order at approximately 7:00 p.m.
II. Roll Call
Members Present: William Roos, Ra.y McLaughlin, Reed Taylor
Members Absent: Charles Murphy
Staff Present: Linda James, Bud Knickerbocker, Charma Comer
III. Review of Proceedings - Chairman Roos reviewed the procedures for public hearings.
IV. Poll Members for Conflict of Interest - Chairman Roos polled members for any conflicts of
interest: there were none.
V. Old Business —
A. Approve Minutes of February 26, 1998 — The minutes were approved as written.
� B. Approve Order of Decision for the f ollowing case: Case No. OA-14-98 (Ordinance
Amendment/ Manufactured Homes on Individual Lots). Motion: Reed Taylor moved to
approve the order. Second: Ray McLaughlin. Approved: Unanimously.
VI. New Business — Public Hearings
1. Case No. SUB-08F-97 (West Valley Estates #3), a request by J.B. Farms for final plat
approval to develop 52 residential lots on approximately 10.57 acres located in the R-1 Zone. The
site is located on the east side of South 10�' Avenue, south of Ustick Road and adjacent to the
south side of West Valley Estates No. 2.
Linda James presented the staff report and Exhibit PZ-1000, a copy of the Assessor's map
showing the location of the site and surrounding zoning. James stated that there was a revision in
the number of lots from 52 to 51 for final plat approval, and noted concerns on irrigation under
section 2.11.5, and asked that members include a stipulation in their recommendation to Council
that the system will be operative in Phase's l, 2 and 3 by April 15.
Wayne Forrey, Applicant's representative, presented exhibit PZ-1001, a preliminary plat of West
Valley 1, 2& 3 showing the phases. Forrey agreed and accepted stipulations in the staff report,
for the completion of the irrigation system for Phases 1, 2& 3., by April 15�'.
P&Z Minutes — Mazch 26, 1997
Page 1
�
� Findings of Fact — Motion: Reed Taylor. Second: Ray McLaughlin. Adopt the general facts
outlined in the staff report and the testimony offered by Wayne Forrey to agree and accept the
following stipulations: Irrigation system tested and operational by April 15�', 1997 deadline, for
Phase 1, 2& 3, as Findings of Fact. Passed: Unanimously.
Conclusions of Law — Motion: Ray McLaughlin. Second: Reed Taylor. All legal requirements
were met and the request is in compliance with the Comprehensive Plan and Zoning Ordinance.
Passed: Unanimously.
Order of Decision — Motion: Reed Taylor. Second: Ray McLaughlin. To recommend to City
Council that Case No. SUB-08F-98, a request by J.B. Farms for final plat approval to develop 51
residential lots on approximately 10.57 acres located in the R-1 Zone be approved with the
following stipulation: Pressurized irrigation to be in operation to Phases 1, 2& 3 by April 15, or
the City will complete the installation and cash the security.
Chairman Roos stated that anyone wishing to appeal this Decision should contact the Community
Development Director.
2. Case No. SUB-11F-96 (Falcon Ridge Estates No. 1), a request by K& L Development for final
plat approval to develop 54 residential lots on approximately 11.795 acres located in the R-1 Zone
and SUB-11P-96 (Falcon Ridge Estates No. 2), and extension of preliminary plat approval to
develop 30 residential lots on approximately 7.29 acres located in the R-1 zone. The site is
located on the southwest comer of the intersection of Montana Avenue and Homedale Road, and
lies adjacent to the southern boundary of Silverbow Estates Subdivision.
Linda James presented the staff report.
Commissioner Taylor declared a conflict of interest, and due to a lack of quorum, Case No. SUB-
11F-96 was continued to the Apri19�' Commission meeting.
3. Case No. SUB-20P-98 (Subia Subdivision), a request by Vern and Judy Subia to develop 9
residential lots on approximately 2 acres located in an R-1 zone. The subject site is located on the
south side of Logan Street, and east of Marshall Avenue.
Bud Knickerbocker presented the Staff report and Exhibit PZ-1000, a copy of the Assessor's map
showing the site location and the surrounding zoning.
Art Schultz, Applicant's representative, presented exhibit PZ-1002, a written response to items
discussed under Public Facilities, Section 2.10 of the staff report. Questions regarding road
easement, curbing, barrow pit/shoulder, sidewalk right of way, and irrigation runoff into streets,
were raised that no one could respond to. Community Development Director Linda James made a
suggestion that this case be continued to the next meeting so that Gordon Law, City Engineer
could be present to answer Commissioner's concerns. Motion: Commissioner Taylor. Second:
Commissioner McLaughlin , to continue Case SUB-20P-98 to the next scheduled meeting.
Passed: Unanimously.
P&Z Minutes — March 26, 1997
Page 2 .
2. To hear concurrently Case Nos. ANN-07-98 and SUP-29-98, a request by Dion Zimmerman to
�� annex approximately five acres into the City of Caldwell as an R-1 zone and to construct a Church
y of Jesus Christ of Latter-Day Saints building on said property. The subject site is currently zoned
County Agricultural and is located at the corner of the southeast intersection of Palrang Drive and
Montana Avenue.
Bud Knickerbocker presented the staff report and E�ibit PZ-1000, a copy of the Assessor's map
showing the site location and the surrounding zoning.
Dion Zimmerman , Applicant's representative, answered questions regarding development, and
Noted they anticipate construction starting in the spring of 1999.
Findings of Fact — Motion: Reed Taylor. Second: Ray McLaughlin. Adopt the General Facts
outlined in the staff report and the testimony offered, as Findings of Fact. Passed: Unanimously.
Comprehensive Plan Analysis - Motion: Reed Taylor. Second: Ray McLaughlin. The project
is in compliance with, the following components; Agricultural Land 1 and 3; Residential
Categories 12; Utilities 1; Urban Storm Runoff 1; Community Design 1, 2& 9. Passed:
Unanimously.-
Conclusions of Law — Motion: Ray McLaughlin. Second: Reed Taylor. All legal requirements
were met and the request is in compliance with the Comprehensive Plan and Zoning Ordinance.
Passed: Unanimously.
Order of Decision — Motion: Reed Taylor. Second: Ray McLaughlin. Based on Finding of Fact
and Conclusions of Law, Case No. ANN-07-98, be recommended to City Council for approval ,
and to approve Case No. SUP-29-98 with the following conditions; that the project be declared
null and void if construction plans are not submitted for approval by April l, 1999; and that
construction start by Sept 1, 1999; the SUP is approved contingent upon Council approving the
annexation. Passed: Unanimously.
Chairman Roos stated that anyone wanting to appeal this Decision is to contact the Community
Development Director.
3. Case No. SUP-30-98 (Alpha Bears), a request by Tina Valdez and Rachel Verlander to use an
existing residential structure as a Group Day Care Center, with no more than 12 children in
attendance at any one time. The site is more commonly known as 1205 Cleveland Boulevard.
Linda James presented the staff report and Exhibit PZ-1000, a copy of the Assessor's map
showing the site location and the surrounding zoning.
Ra.chelle Verlander, Applicant, addressed questions on parki.ng, lighting and location of loading
and unloading children.
Findings of Fact — Motion: Reed Taylor. Second: Ray McLaughlin. Adopt the General Facts
outlined in the staff report, and the testimony offered. Passed: Unanimously.
Comprehensive Plan Analysis - Motion: Reed Taylor. Second: Ray McLaughlin. The project
is in compliance, with the following components: Residential Categories 12, & 13; Historic
Areas 1, 2, 3, & 4.
P&Z Minutes — March 26, 1997
Page 3 -
.
�• Conclusions of Law — Motion: Ray McLaughlin. Second: Reed Taylor. All legal requirements
• were met and the request is in compliance with the Comprehensive Plan and Zoning Ordinance.
Passed: Unanimously.
Order of Decision — Motion: Reed Taylor. Second: Ray McLaughlin. Based on Findings of
Fact and Conclusions of Law, Case No. SUP-30-98 be approved with the following conditions: a
detailed parking plan be submitted to Community Development Director; lighting be placed in the
a11ey area; a written agreement to be designed and brought before the Community Development
Director for approval and to be signed by all customers in regards to not loading or unloading on
Cleveland Blvd. Passed: Unanimously.
Chairman Roos stated that anyone wanting to appeal this Decision is to contact the Community
Development Director.
4. Case No. VAR-09-98, a request by Nextel Communication for approval to construct a wireless
communications facility which will require a 75-foot variance to install a 120-foot monopole. The
site is located at the northeast corner of the intersection of Albany and Ninth and is more
commonly known as 824 Albany Street.
Bud Knickerbocker presented the stafFreport and Exhibit PZ-1000, a copy of the Assessor's map
and the surrounding zoning. .
Pamela Noble, Applicant's representative, addressed questions.
Findings of Fact — Motion: Reed Taylor. Second: Ray McLaughlin. Adopt the General Facts
outlined in the staff report and the testimony offered as Findings of Fact. Passed: Unanimously.
Comprehensive Plan Analysis - Motion: Reed Taylor. Second: Ray McLaughlin. The project
is in compliance with the following components; Utilities, 2. '
Conclusions of Law — Motion: Ray McLaughlin. Second: Reed Taylor. All legal requirements
were met and the request is in compliance with the Comprehensive Plan and Zoning Ordinance.
Passed: Unanimously.
Order of Decision — Motion: Reed Taylor. Second: Ray McLaughlin. Based on Findings of
Fact and Conclusions of Law, Case No. VAR-09-98, be approved and to include the conditions
as noted in the sta.ff report. Motion: Reed Taylor. Second: Ray McLaughlin. Passed:
Unanimously.
Chairman Roos stated that anyone wanting to appeal this Decision is to contact the Community
Development Director.
VII. Discussion on Planning Issues — April 1� Workshop with Council on the Comprehensive Plan
and map.
VIII. Adjournment — The meeting was adjourned at approximately 9:20pm.
P&Z Minutes — March 26, 1997
Page 4 -
y i
�� MIl�TUTES APPROVED ON TT� v ' � y3 DAY OF APRIL, 1998.
�.;� � J , ,:
� �� � _
Chairman Roos
P&Z Minutes — March 26, 1997
Page 5 �