Loading...
The URL can be used to link to this page
Your browser does not support the video tag.
Home
My WebLink
About
9-25-1997 P&Z MINUTES
� � � , �` COMMUPJITY OEVELOPMENT OEPARTMENT - _�. ` �i{.� .�� �i�,����,�,�. 621 CLEVELAND BW�. � CAIDWELL, ID 83605 LINDA JAMES TELE?HONE 455-3021 Communify Development Diredor FAX 455-3003 NIINUTES OF THE PLANNING AND ZONING CONIlVIISSION Meeting of September 25, 1997 7:00 p.m. I CALL TO ORDER: Chairman William Roos called the regular meeting of the Planning and Zoning Commission to order at 7:00 p.m., in the Caldwell City Hall Chambers. II ROLL CALL: Present: William Roos, Sonia Huyck, Bill Gilbert Absent: Charles Murphy, Mike Nachtigall Staff: Linda James, Ann Marie Reyes III REVIEW OF PROCEEDINGS: Chairman Roos explained the procedures for public hearings. N POLL FOR CONFLICT OF INTEREST: � Members were polled for conflict of interest; none were expressed. V OLD BUSINESS: 1. Approval of the April 24, 1997 minutes. A motion was made by Commissioner Huyck, � seconded by Commissioner Gilbert, to approve the minutes as amended. Passed unanimously by voice vote. Approval of the May 14, 1997 minutes. A motion was made by Commission Huyck, seconded by Commissioner Gilbert, to approve the minutes. Passed by unanimous voice vote. Approval of the August 14, 1997 minutes. A motion was made by Commissioner Huyck, seconded by Commissioner Gilbert, to approve the minutes as amended. Passed by unanimous voice vote. Approval of the August 28, 1997 minutes. A motion was made by Commissioner Huyck, seconded by Commissioner Gilbert, to approve the minutes as amended. Passed by unanimous voice vote. VI NEW BUSINESS: 1. Case No. VAR-06-97, a request by Caldwell Inn/Best Western for a 20-foot variance from September 25, 1997, Minutes Page t c the 45-foot height limitation in order to construct a 6�-foot advertisement sign. The site is more commonly known as 908 Specht Street and is zoned C-3. Linda James presented the application report. She reviewed E�chibit PZ1000, a location map showing the site and the surrounding zoninQ. Todd Taylor, the applicant's representative, testified that Best Western originally wanted the si� at 80 feet. The location of the sign at Comfort Inn measure >j feet. There is a 10 foot difference in the �ade in property locations; the applicant wants to have a sign of similar height. At 6� feet the sign would be able to be seen from the freeway. An application has been submitted to the FAA for their response. Chairman Roos explained the procedures far variances. The Planning and Zoning Commission found that all five criteria required to be met, listed under Section 10-03-OS for a Variance, are true. Moved by Commissioner Huyck, seconded by Commissioner Gilbert, to approve the variance. Roll Call: Yes: Sonia Huyck, Bill Gilbert No: None MOTION CARRIED Comprehensive Plan Analysis - The applicable items were as follows: 1) Commercial Categories - Policy 8; and 2) Community Design - Policies 2, 4, and �. A motion was made by Commissioner Huyck, seconded by Commissioner Gilbert, to accept the Comprehensive Plan Analysis as stated. Passed by unanimous voice vote. Findings of Fact - Moved by Commissioner Huyck, seconded by Commissioner Gilbert, that the General Facts outlined in the staff report be approved as Findings of Fact on this application, and that based on the public testimony, the inclusion of the following be incorporated: 1) the City code limits height to 45 feet; 2) the sign will not exceed neighboring signs; 3) the request for approval to FAA has been submitted; and 4) the location of the site is zoned C-3. Roll Call: Yes: Sonia Huyck, Bill Gilbert, Chauman William Roos No: None MOTION CARRIED Conclusions of Law - Moved by Commissioner Huyck, seconded by Commissioner Gilbert, that the Planning and Zoning Commission hereby draw the followin; conclusions based on the approved Findings of Fact: That the request has met the intent of the law and all notifications and legal requirements have been met. Roll Ca1L• Yes: Sonia Huyck, Bill Gilbert, Chairman William Roos No: None MOTION CARRIED Nloved by Cominissioner Gilbert, seconded by Commissioner Huyck, that based on the Findings of Facts and Conclusions of Law, the Planning and Zoning Commission approve the request by September 25, 1997, Minutes Page Z f��d sam[c�y� `L661 'SZ �aq�ua�das soo� u�Tiit� uEUUrer�� `�aqliJ II?g `�I��ng �tuos :sa� :IT�� ii�2i •uoi��n.�suo� �o s�uauiannba.� io� p�o.�i� � a� pa��E�uo� sEu �u��Tidd� a� (9 pu� :pEO.�i� �3o s�uauzannbai a� o� anp si �uauiannbai ��iau ac� (s :pax�ol pu�J st ssau�snq a� (� :�aa� ct aql uE� ia�� aaE �ai� a� ui sarn��n.r�s .�at�o a�uis `a�altnud �i�ads E�ou si sn.� (£ :a�ia�uo��o .�aqu��� a� Luo.r� pania�az uaaq seu �uautuio� ou (Z :olts a��o uou�ru�suo� a� �inn m�uo� �oiduns (j :pa��iod.io�ut aq �utnnoiio� a��o uotsni�cn a� `�uoun�sa� �tiqnd uo pasEq ��i.J� puE `uoT�E�TiddE s� uo ���3 �o s�tnpui3 s� pano.zdd� aq vodal ��s ac� ut pacnJ�no s���,� I�iauarJ a� �Eq� `�aqii� iauotssTUZUZO� �q papuo�as `x��nH iauotssruzuzo� �q panoy� - ���3 �o s�urpui3 •alon a�ion snouzrueun �q passzd •pa���s sE panoidd� aq sis�i�u� u�jd anisuauazduio� a� ��� `�aqjirJ IauotssTUn.uo� �q papuo�as `x��inH iauotsstunuo� �q panoy� •£ puE `z `i sai�iJod - sauo�a��� �u�snpuI (j :s�oiio� s� aiann suza�r aiqE�tlddE au,I, - sis�i��' �Id anisuauaiduio� Q�2I2I�� I�IOI.LOY�I auoN : oN �.TaQIirJ ItTg `X��ng ETUOS :sa� �it�� ti�?I - panoidd� aq a�uer.�n a� �E� �,zaqiirJ zauotssnznzio� �q papuo�as `x��ng aauoisstuz�uo� �q panoy� •an.� a.� `a�uEU�n E io� SO uoT��as �apun pa�sii `�aui aq o� pa.nnba.� Eua�u� anz� IIE �Etp puno� IIOiSSiIIILIIO� autuoZ puE �uruu�jd at� •sa�u�uen zo3 sa.mpa�ozd a� paut�Idxa soo� u�uzn�u� •oiis aq��o uoi��n.z�suo� aq� �no.� aq pinonn �nq tn p�oi o� Lua� io� �i�nn �Iuo a� pu� ssautsnq pax�oT pu�1 � st �usdr�o� a� •s��q puE �nq ut �utp�oi ,Ci�ua.rm� si �rreduio� au,I, •mds a� asn �E� san.reduzo� ,iiuo a� a� sa�mosa� IEiatrry� o�ze� pue �oldurrs •oits ar���o uot��na�.suo� a� ui }auz aq ijcnn p�oz�teg � a� zo� s�uatua.nnbai a� •��npozd ac� �o a��.zo�s puE �uTpEOi ut �ueduzo� ar� zo� suzaiqoid i�ianas a��uTUZTia pinonn oiis E�uin�u ��� pa�t�sa� `ant���uasasda� s��u��Tidd� a� `aa�s�a� �ar •�utuoz �utpuno.Lms a� pu� a�is a� �utn�ous d�uz uot�E�o1 �`OOOIZd �14T�� pannaina.z aus •�odaz uot���tidd� at� pa�uasazd saurer �putZ • i-y� pauoz si pue anuan� �smbuzolg OZS sE �oux ��zounuo� a�oui st a�is a��o uoi�e�oj a� :anuan� zsmbuiolg �o �sann pu� �aa.Rs puo3 �7 �o �ou pa���oi x��.0 mds irei a� iano �TTt�E� nutp�oj puE oiis aaEZO�s �oo�-pg u� ��n.z�suo� o� zapio ut uoT���TUZTi ��`dtau �oo�-S�, au� uro.r� a�uEUen �oo3-Sc � io� `•�uI `sa�mosa� I�aauTy� o��� �q �sanbai � `L6 'o� as�� •z •�uauzy��daQ luauidoianaQ ,�tunuiuzo� a� ����uo� ,��uz i�eadd� u� �uri� ui pa�sa.za�ut auo�ud Q��� 1�IOI,LO�AI auoN : oN SOO� LIIL'IIIiM LIELLI.IIL'Li� `7I�AriH ETLIOS `�zaqi?� Itig :sa� �II�� I1�2I •papni�ui aq ienozdde �o suoi�ipuo� pa�pu��s IIE (z pu� :uania aq o� sEu ��uaa� �unuanop za�o �Cu� so �3�o iEno.�dd� (i :suot�ipuo� �ulnnoIl�3 ay1 y1Tn� `u�is �uauzast�zanp� �oo�-Sg ���n.usuo� o� a�u�uEn loo�-p� E.zo� u.ia�sa� �sag�uui IlannpJ�� � b'�d samu�y�r 'L66 T 'SZ �9maidas '2.I�E 32C� 6'� SI �T � asE�d io� puE az�e zad g•t si Z as�ud .�o� �tsuap aq,I, •anuan� �p i�uoiE �Ennapis �oo� an� E aq �m aia� pu� `s�aa.�s a��o apis u�sa uo s�Ennapis �oo� � aq i� a.�a� •sea.� padE�spusJ aq � Z� pus `�c, `j s�oZ •�uai x�oiq .�o� �uauiannbai s��i� a� paa�xa �ou iTinn pu� sasEud am�n� ui pau�isap aq II� sx�oJq a��o q�uai a� •azTS �oi umunutui ro� a�ueutpzp �uiuoZ a��o s�uauza.nnbai at� laatu ��id �unutiaid a� uo pannoqs s�oi a� ii� �E� pa�.�s iat�n� aH •uta�s�s uouE�r.ut pazunssaid a��o uoi��zado pu� a�uEUa�uTEUi a� aano ax�� o� auTO� sT ��u�siQ uoi��ar.uI iaauoid •��ru}suo� o� �uTOa SI �IIL'.IIEd L�ilOs �EL� t�L'lY1i�LC� 3L� O�III 1�EMi�L'CI SIL� 8T� O� IIEICI S� �u��ridd� a� si �I •�EM�Ed panEd E q�inn x.nd poo�.zoq�iau �uzs E s� pasn aq Iirn� pu� `�o-uru za�Enn uuo�s ao� uts�q uouua�ap pa�E�ms E aq iirm �oi a��u�ap a� ��q� pa�T�sa� `ant��uasaidaz s��u �tlddE aq� �aa�uny� ��y� •a�is ioou�s a� o� �8��8d u�u�sapad E se pasn aq Tj� pue �oi a��uTEip � aq II?� t�Z �07 •aa.z� pu� onn� sas��d io� �Eid �utuniazd�o �ido� E`IOOIZd �966I `8I ��f uo szaquiatu uoissnuuio� �uTUOZ puti �utuuEid a� �q panozdd� s�nn 1E� uEid I�da�uo� �`� �I� s�iqrqxg pamatnas aus •�odai uot���ridd� a� pa�uasazd sauz�r epur7 '�' c a�ue� °�oN � d�sumoZ `c uot��aS 3� t/I A11�I �/I �1(�S a� � Pa���ol P�I�o ja�.ied E s� paqu�sap st pu� `p�o� x�i�sn �o �nos pu� anuan� �p j�nos �o apTS �.sBa a� uo pa�E�oi si a�is a� •auoz I-g a� ur pa���oi sa.z�E �,g • � I�Ia��uzTxoidd� uo s�oJ IEi�uapisai �9 doianap oi I�noiddE ��id �uttutia.zd .�o� suu�3 •g•r �q �sanbai � `(c •oN uoisinipqns sa��sg �ai�� �saM) L6 P� �Z '�N uoTSinTpqns sa���sg �atl�A �Sat1c1) L6 'soN as�� •c Q��� I�IOI.LOIAI auoN : oN SOO� �ETIti� IILLLLITEii� `�zaql.TJ Iljg `x��nH �IUOs :sa� :ti�� II�2I •ojis a��o �uacua�Bid anoiddE It�uno� �T� pu� (£ °uoTl�n�.suo� aio�aq pania�as aq a�aaunuo��o zaqcu�c�� �an�p�� a� �q �noadd� (z pu� :�noidd��o suot�ipuo� p.�pu��s IIE (I :suot�ipuo� �t,nn�oIio3 a� �rnn x��.R mds IiE.� a� zano ��c��� �t.npEOj puE o�s a�ezols �003-08 u� ��n.�suo� o�.�ap.�o ut uoi���itutj ��ta� �oo�-S� a� uio.z� a�u�u�n E ao� �•�� `sa�mosa� i�zaury� o�.re� �q �sanba.� a� ano.�dd� uoTSSituLUO� �utuoZ pu� 8utuu�ld e� `nn�Z�o suoisni�uo� pu� ��E3 �o s�utpui3 at� uo pasBq ��t� ��aqlirJ zauoissnuuzo� �iq papuo�as `x��ng zauoisstuzuzo� �iq panoJ� Q��'� I�tOI.LONI auoN : oN soo� ui�TIItM uEUZZi�u� `�aqi?J Iiig `�i��nH Etuos :sa� �ti�� II�2I •�auz uaaq an�u s�uauza.�nba� i��at II� P� ^��I a��o �ua�cn a� s�aaw �sanbas a� �E� :��E33o s�utpuT3 panoiddE a� uo pas8q suotsnl�uo� �uinnoiio� a� nnerp �qa.za� uoissTtutuo� �utuoZ pu� �utuuEld at�l �E� `�.zaqiuJ .�auotssnuuzo� �iq papuo�as `�J��inH zauotssiunuo� �q panoy� - nn�Z�o suotsni�uo� Q�'b'J I�IOI,LOLII auoN : oN , Sa�d saina?Vh 'L66I 'SZ �aqmaidas •nn�� uopio� �o I�noiddE a� ol pa��ru�suo� aq ii�qs `Ioo��s apE.� aq� o� ssa��E io� `�z iaqumu �oI �no.� �En� ��n� pan�d a� (g puE :s1oi iau.�o� ii� io� �aa� az�nbs OOS`L P� s�oi ioua�ut .�o� �aa� a.�nbs 000`9 �o um� a� �aaui �snLU s�oj ije (� `uodai �s a� ui pauTJ�no suot�tpuo� p.�pu��s (g :�atu aq ij�us `�c,j iaqumu uia�t t�inn uoi�da�xa a� q�inn `iaau�u� �i� a� �q �as suot�ipuo� jIE (s :�aur aq iiEus i�us.�y� an,� a� �q �as suot�ipuo� II� (� :�aa3 L� �i II?^� a�E�ms p�oi ioua�uT a� (£ `anuand q�pi uo �nnapis �oo� S� puE �aa.�s aq��o sapts �oq uo s�nnapts �003 � aq � aiaq� (� :Ea.� uouzuzo� a� puE �oI �utpimq u�ea o� uoA��t.ut pazrmssaid ti� aia� (i :suoi�tpuoo �utnnotio� aq� apni�ut puE uotst�aQ �o iapip a� a.�da.�d o� io��anQ �uaLUdolanaQ �r�munuo� a� s��anp puE `auoz j-� a� ut pa�s�oi sai�E LS'OI �Ia��uzTxozddE uo s�o1 �i�uapisai Zc doianap o� i�noiddE �gid uoisinipqns �.Teunznjaid io3 S�3 'S'f �9 �sanbai a� anozddE �qa.�a� uoisstt.uuzo� �muoZ P� ���id a� `nn�Z�o suotsni�uo� puE ���3�0 snutput3 asa� uodn paseq ��� `�aq� .zauoissnu�uo� �q papuo�as `x��ng �auotssnzz�uo� �q pano� - �iddE �ou pinonn � j iaqumu uza�r `azo�aia� :papuoq aq �ouu�� pu� uE� ��t�m uo uo��jndus �uE aq �ouu�� azat� pu� �aLU st �uTpuoq ��t papao�ai aq uE� �Ejd IEUg �`asuodsai s�nn�7 uopao� �o £I saqumu iva}t o� p��az m pale�s sauz�r �pur7 Q�F�J l�TOLLOI�I auoN : oN SOO� LLILTiiim iIBLLLITLLI� `�aQi?rJ ilTg `x�,�nj.� �ruos :saA �II�� ti�2I •�auz uaaq aneu s�uauzazmba.z JE�aI puE suot�E�gr�ou iado�d IiE pu� nn�i a��o �ua�ut a� s�aauz �sanbai at� ��, :�E3�o s�uipu�3 pano.�dd� a� uo pas�q suoisni�uo� �u�oiio� a� n��.�p �qazau uoiss�zo� �uiuoZ P� ���id a� ��� �aqluJ zauoiss�uo� �q papuo�as �x��ng zauoissnuuzo� Fq panoy� - nnEZ�o suotsnj�uo� Q�2I?I�'� I�iOIZOIAi auoN : oN SOO� LLiL'iili� iIELU3TELj� `a.I2C�IT� Ilig `x��ng 8tuos :sa� �II�� II�2i •s�oi .zau�o� II� j�� OOS`L P� s�oi ioua�ui .�o� �aa� a.renbs 000`9 3o s�uauza.nnbaa umu�tnuz a�;aaLU s�oi �utpitnq IiE (s pus :sea.� uounuo� a� pu� �oj �utpimq ���a ol uotl��un pazunssa.�d aq Iiinn aza� (�, :�aa� �� o� a���.ms �utnup .zoua�ut a� as�a.��uT (c `anuan� �pj uo xiE�apis �oo� ang � pu� s�aaz�s aoua�ui a��o sapis �oq uo s�Ennapis �003 � 01 paa.r�� �ue�Tidd� a� (z °ioou�s a� o� �Enn ��nn au� io� uot�nlosaz �.�o� nn�7 uopio� u�inn �aur s�u lu��tldd� au� ( j:pa�E.zodzo�ui aq �uin�oiio� ac� �o uoisnj�uT ac� �,fuoun�sa� �iiqnd uo pas�q ��� puE `uot�E�tidd� sT� uo ���3�o s�uipuT3 s� pano.�dd� aq �zoda.��e�.s au� ui pautJ�no s���3 i�.�auarJ a� ��� ��aqltrJ iauoisstiuuio� �q papuo�as `x��nH aauotsstu,n.uo� Fq pano� -��E3 �o s�uipui3 '8 P� £ sat�tiod - u�1saQ �tuntuuio� (9 `•�'S P� `£ `Z - �uisnoH �S �OI Pu� `c `� sat�tiod - uotlE�odsu�.zZ �t `i ��tiod - �oun� uuo�S �aill �� `£ ��tiod - sat�Ti?�Il �� `i I Pu� `pi `6 `L `� `� `i sat�ijod - sauo�al�� I�tluapisa� (I :snnoiio� s� azann suia�T aIqE�Tidd� a� - sis�iEU� u�id anisuauaiduzo� •�01 u�Ea uo unnous a��;oo� a.�nbs �no�Tnn palda��� aq o; a.�� sd�uz 1Eid �.zeuiuitJazd ou �sase� a.zn�n� ii� ui �$y� sau�r epui-� o� �sanbaa � apew x��nH �auoissiuruio� . 9 �Ed samury� 'L661 `SZ la4�a�daS '�'d 00�6 �Ia}gunxoiddE �E �ut�aaui a� paumofpE soo� u�LUn��� :yu�OtQ�' IIIA •c�uocu E a�t� �sEai �e Lua� �uiinpa��s ur�aq o� puE sdo�sxaonn a� alnpa��s o� sa� aiqncag �souz a� io� uotssnuuzo� Iiod o� paa.�� sau�r �pui7 •sas�� .zEin�t�d uo uotssn�sTp io ap�aa suotst�ap ou ii� aia� •�noqE suoT�sanb an�u s.�aquiatu a� ��� sia�EUZ ssn�sip o� �tun�oddo uE siaquiauz uoissitutuo� a� �utn� `pua�� pjno� aidoad aa.� io onn� �seai �E aia�nn sdo�sxionn �o� �as aq aun� E�E� pa;sanbai x��ng zauoTSSnuLUO� : S�l1SSI �I�III�II�i�'Id I�IO I�IOISSl1�SIQ IIA •�ua�daQ �uauidoianaQ �iunLULUO� a�. ����uo� ��LU `I�addE ue �uii� ui pa�saia�ui auo,�u� Q�'b'� I�iOIS,Ob1I auoN : oN soo� uz�tiiim u�uutE�� `�aqitJ Iiig `x��nH stuos :sa� �iiE� il�2t •a�u�uutpzp �utuoZ ac� o� �uauipuau� �xa� � �o i�no.zdde io� �uau�daQ �uauzdolanaQ �nmuzuzo� a� �q �sanbai a� �B� IT�uno� �t� iian�pi�� a� o� J�noidd� puaunuo�a.z �qazau uoissTUZUZO� �uiuoZ P� ���Id a� `nn�Z�o suo�sni�uo� pu� s���,��o s�LnpuT,� asaq� uodn pas�q ��� `�zaqiuJ zauoiss�o� �q papuo�as `x��ng zauoissnuruo� �q panoy� •a�on a�ion snoturu�un �q passsd •�auz uaaq an�u uoi����t�ou iadoad puE sp.�pu�s ��al aiq��iTdd� aq� puE nn�i a�3o �ua�ut a� �aauz saop �sanbai a� �Eu,I, :��e3�o s�utpui� panoidd� aq� uo pas�q suotsni�uo� �utnnoiio� a� nn�ip �qaia� uoissimiuo� outuoZ P� ��T�id aq1 ��c� °�aq�rJ iauoissiunuo� �c{ papuo�as `x��CnH zauotss�o� �iq panoJ� - nnEZ�o suoisni�uo� •a�on a�TOn snoutrasun �q pass�d •saa� I�ru�E a� �inn ��T�.uo� ui sT ainpau�s aa3 a� ��� pa���s uaaq s�u �i (t :pa��iod�o�ut aq �uinnoijo� a��o uotsnj�ul aq� �uop��Tldd� s� uo �0�3 �o s�uTpui� sE pano.zdde aq uodaz ��s a� ut pauti�no s���3 I�sauarJ a� �.�qa �a.zaqji� aauotssTUZUZO� �q papuo�as `x��nH zauotssctuuzo� �iq panoy� - ��E3 �o s�mput,� •�odai uot���tidd� au� pa�uasa.�d saurer �pui-� •�j uoi;�asqns `£0-90-OI uot��aS `P� `•g9 uot��asqns `SO-SO-OI �ot��aS `j uot��asqns `£O-SO-OI uot��as `.� puE `Q pu� �j suor��asqns `�b0 uot��as :Z uot��asqns `OI-£0-OI uot�.�aS �L `9 `S `t� `£ `� `I suot��asqns `90 - £0 - OI uot��as `.� uoi��asqns `60-ZO-Oi uot��as (j :�u�nnoiio� a� ut t�o3las se s�unouz� aa� pa�uaia�a� �e axaiap o� 15�,1 •oN a�u�utp�p �u�uoZ�o �xa� a� o� �uauzpuau� uE�o i�noidde zo� luaur�daQ �uauido1anaQ �tunuruzo� jian�pi�� au� �q �sanbai � `L6-OI-F�O 'oN as�� •�, •�uaunzedaQ �uau.idoianaQ �tununuo� a� ����uo� �C�uz `uotst�ap sn� �t.niEadd�e t.n pa�sa.�a�ut auo�u� Q��'� I�IOIS,Ob1i auoN : oN soo� uretlitM u�uui�u� `uaqlirJ tllg `x��nH �tuos :saA �II�� ii�2I '� ' ' .