HomeMy WebLinkAbout4-17-1997 P&Z MINUTES + �
e
• , �
, COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT DEPARTMENT
� • �'�� �� ����,����„C, 621 CLEVELAND BLVD.
� CALDWELL, ID 83605
LINDA JAMES TELEPHONE 455-3021
Community Development Director FAX 455-3003
MINUTES OF THE PLANNING AND ZONING COMMISSION
Meeting of April 17, 1997
The regular meeting of the Planning and Zoning Commission was called to order by
Chairman William Roos, at 7:00 p.m., in the Caldwell City Hall Council Chambers.
ROLL CALL:
Present: William Roos, Bill Gilbert, Sonia Huyck, Mike Nachtigall, Ron Reed
Absent: Bettie Pilote, Daniel Ozuna
Staff: Linda James, Ed Christopher, Ann Marie Reyes
MINUTES
The first item of business was approval of the minutes for the previous meeting February
20, 1997.
A motion was made by Commissioner Huyck that the February 20, 1997, minutes be
approved as written. The motion was seconded by Commissioner Reed.
All in favor: "Aye."
Opposed: None
Motion passed.
OLD BUSINESS:
None
NEW BUSINESS:
Chairman Roos explained the procedure for public hearings.
The first item was Case #SUP-04-97, a Special Use Permit to construct and operate a full-
service, 184-bed nursing home facility.
Apnl 17, 1997
Page 1
The first speaker was the appiicant Matt Zehnder, 401 South Fourth Ave., 9th Floor B&W
Tower, Louisville, Kentucky. He submitted a revised site plan. The only difference was the
number of beds in the facility. The first plan showed 150 beds, whereas the revised plan
showed 184 beds. Mr. Zehnder stated that this development would be a two phased
project. The first phase would be 150 beds and the second phase would be 34 beds.
Commissioner Huyck questioned if the landscaping would be completed with the first
phase. Mr. Zehnder stated that most of the landscaping would be completed. The
landscaping that would be positioned where the second phase is proposed, would not be
completed because then they would have to take it out. Commissioner Huyck asked
whether the retention/detention basin wouid be fenced. Mr. Zehnder stated that since
there is so much land there, they would like to make the basin larger and add a secondary
retention/detention basin. Each basin would be 10 inches deep and almost an acre in size.
It would be turf and irrigated and appear to be a depressed part of the lawn. Chairman
Roos questioned if the entire perimeter of the property could be fenced, with the exception
of the driveways. Mr. Zehnder stated that the entire perimeter would not be fenced. There
would be a fence on the south side of the property. Commissioner Reed questioned if the
sewer issue had been resolved with the City. Mr. Zehnder stated that there is not an
adequate sewer system that comes to the site. The applicant would have no objection to
providing an 18 inch sewer line. Commissioner Gilbert asked if irrigation matters been
covered. Mr. Zehnder stated that they would also be bringing in a 12 inch water main.
Commissioner Huyck asked if they were going to use City water to irrigate. Mr. Zehnder
stated that as far as he knew they would be using City water. Commissioner Huyck stated
that a pressurized irrigation system be set up, utilizing the irrigation water rather than City
water. Chairman Roos questioned what type of signage was going to be used. Mr.
Zehnder stated that there was going to be an entry sign on the corner South 10th and
Usticic. There would also be a service entry sign on 10th Avenue and an entry sign Ustick
Road. The sign would be lit from within.
There being no further questions or speakers, Chairman Roos decfared the public hearing
closed. Discussion within the Commission ensued.
Commissioner Huyck stated that the project does fit in with the area and the other assisted
living facility on Ustick Road. She referred to a letter from Chief Allcott, referencing to the
corner of South 10th and Ustick Road being designated Commercial and that the traffic
committee had stated a need to neighborhood commercial. This was just one potential site
that was designated as a possible commercial location.
The next speaker was Linda James, Community Development Director, 621 Cleveland
Blvd., Caldwell, Idaho. Mrs. James stated that all legal requirements had been met. She
presented exhibit S-1, ail property owners within 300 feet subject site were mailed notice
of this hearing. There are 20 property's within the 300 feet and one letter was returned as
non-deliverable. Other than that there was no response. She then presented exhibit S-3,
notice was published in the Idaho Press Tribune notifying the public hearing. Exhibit S-4,
notice of posting, Ed Christopher verified that the site was posted on April 7, 1997. The
applicant had indicated that there would be 54 positions created by this development and
the parking requirements have been met for not only bed usage, but also for the
April 17, 1997
Page 2
employees.
Matt Zehnder was asked to come back to the podium to clarify potential expansion areas
on the site plan. He briefly stated that they would not exceed the square footage or the
184-bed requirement that they are set with.
With regard to Findings of Facts, Commissioner Huyck made a motion that the general
facts outlined in the staff report be approved as Findings of Facts on this application.
Based on public testimony the inclusion of the following facts be included: The additional
facts would be that the applicant has agreed to install an 18 inch sewer line and a 12 inch
water line. The applicant would agres to work with the City Forester and the Community
Director for landscaping and meeting with the City Engineer for the approval of the
irrigation agreement. Construction and design plan must be approved within one year and
construction started within two years.
The motion was seconded by Commissioner Reed and was passed by a unanimous voice
vote.
Commissioner Huyck made a motion that the project has met the following residential
categories under item number "M" addresses limited commercial, it fits within neighborhood
commercial. Commercial category section "I" identifying that particular intersection as one
or for commercial activity. The project site is not within the near vicinity of the Boise River
or Indian Creek, and is not within a floodplain. The comprehensive plan designation is low
density residential. The project site is not within the Area of City Impact. Public agencies
and the Caldwell School District were notified. All applicable design and construction plans
were submitted to the City Engineer. The applicant design and construction plans were
submitted to the City Engineer prior to signing and recording the final plat. The request
meets applicable legal standards of Subdivision Ordinance No. 1758, Zoning Ordinance
No. 1451, and the Comprehensive Plan, and that conditions of approval placed on the
preliminary plat have been met. The motion was seconded by Commissioner Reed and
was passed by a unanimous voice vote.
Commissioner Huyck made a motion that based on the Findings of Fact and Concfusions
of Law, as stated, the Planning and Zoning Commission hereby approves the request by
Matt Zehnder for a Special Use Permit to construct and operate a full-service, 184-bed
nursing home facility and directs the Community Development Director to prepare the
Order of Decision.
The next item was Case No. SUP-03-97, a request by Scott Wendell of Lombard-Conrad
Architects and the L.D.S. Church, for a Special Use Permit to construct a 1,716 s.f.
classroom seminary. The subject site is within the City of Caldwell R-2 zoning district and
is located at the northeast corner of the intersection of South Indiana Avenue and Spruce
Street.
Ed Christopher presented the application report. Mr. Christopher reviewed the following
exhibits: PZ1000 (location map, showing zoning), PZ1001 (site plan), S-3 (notice of
April 17, 1997
Page 3
publication), S-4 (notice of mailing), and S-5 (notice of posting). Ten notices were sent to
adjoining owners. No written or verbal comments have been received.
There being no speakers or questions, the public hearing portion of the agenda was
closed.
The appiicant was not in attendance, therefore, it was the general consensus of the
Commission to continue this case until the next scheduled public hearing. Staff was
addressed to notify the applicant.
The next item was Case No. ZON-01-97, a request by Linda Stephens and Dick Van Slyke
to rezone 2021 Cleveland Boulevard from R-2 to C-2 in order to operate a walk-in/drive-in
espresso/pastry shop.
Ed Christopher presented the application report. Mr. Christopher reviewed the following
exhibits: PZ1000 (location map, showing zoning), S-1 (notice of publication), S-2 (notice
of mailing), S-3 (notice of posting), PR-3 (letter from Liz Yeary), and PR-4 (letter from
Historic Preservation Commission). Twenty-six notices were sent to adjoining owners.
Two letters were submitted as comment.
The next speaker was the applicant Linda Stephens, 26104 Don Lane, Parma, Idaho. Mrs.
Stephens stated the property that is directly behind the subject property is zoned C-2. The
subject property has been up for sale for quite some time, with no interested buyers. It is
on a corner of a very busy intersection, so many people do not want to purchase the
property as a residence. This is the only house on 21 st Street that is still residential. The
business would bring in a lot of foot traffic from the college, and give the faculty and ,
students a place for quiet meetings and study time. '
Commissioner Huyck questioned if the applicant would consider this project if they were
�not allowed to have a drive through, and that this property falls within the Historic
Preservation District of the City.
Mrs. Stephens stated that the drive through is an essential part of the business. There will
not be any structural changes to the house. There will be a deck on one side, there would
be no changes to the front yard. There will be no lighted signs. The business hours would
be from 6:00 a.m. to 7:00 p.m.
Chairman Roos asked if the trees or shrubs on the side property went all the way to the
alley.
Mrs. Stephens stated that the trees and shrubs went almost to the alley. There is a
storage shed in that area that is going to be removed.
Commissioner Huyck questioned if the alley was wide enough for finro cars to come and
go from the subject property.
Apnl 17, 1997
Page 4
Mrs. Stephens stated that there would be enough room for two cars to drive through at the
same time.
Commissioner Huyck asked staff if there was anything in the code or ordinances that deal
with using residential alleys for business tra�c.
Mrs. James stated the city engineer has reviewed it, and did not offer any comment either
. for or against Mrs. Stephens plan to use that alley.
The next person to speak was Betty Tollman, Realtor of Better Homes and Gardens,
25126 The Driving Lane, Caldwell, Idaho. Briefly discussed the surrounding area to the
subject property. Trying to sell property on Cleveland has been very difficult, very few
people are interested in property located on such a busy street. Mrs. Tollman feels that
it is a prime location for this type of business.
The next person signed up was Mary Ann Van Slyke. All of the comments have already
been addressed, declined to speak.
The next person to speak was Dick Van Slyke, 2021 Cleveland Boulevard, Caldwell, Idaho.
In favor of proposed application. Clarified that there is enough room for two vehicles in the
alley.
The next person signed up was Donna Van Slyke-Johnston, 1602 Marshall, Caldwell,
Idaho. Declined to speak.
The next person to speak was Gary Vezzoso, 2010 Blaine Street, Caldwell, Idaho.
Opposed to spot zoning. There is no buffer between the zones. Re-zoning the subject
property to C-2, would open the doors to anything. One of his biggest concerns was
keeping pecple from going through the alley.
The next person to speak was Madeline Buckendorf, 1402 Blaine Street, Caldwell, Idaho.
Re-zoning to C-2 would open doors to many of the unwanted businesses in that area.
Being in the historic area, changing it from R-2 to C-2, will change the integrity of that
neighborhood. The landscaping or concrete barrier will keep people from the alley way.
The next person to speak was Liz Yeary, 1801 Dearborn, Caldwell, Idaho. Mrs. Yeary
addressed her concern regarding traffic in that area. There is already commercial from
21 st Street to the Nampa border and beyond. The City did a very thorough assessment
of the area from Fillmore to Arthur and from 12th Street to 21 st Street, to look at the long
term desire zoning of those areas. The zoning stayed the same, at the request of the
people that attended the hearing. Mrs. Yeary supports all of the other oppositions stated.
The next person to speak was Leslie Beaucamp, 1522 Dearborn, Caldwell, Idaho. Mr.
Beaucamp wants to keep the area a historic district. He felt there are other appropriate
locations for the applicant to locate her business.
April 17, 1997
Page 5
� ' r
The next person to speak was Stephen Fisher, 1615 Dearborn, Caldwell, Idaho. Mr. Fisher
stated that there is not enough parking spaces. According to the appiication report the
applicant does not meet parking standards. There is limited access to the parking area
that the applicant is proposing.
The next person to speak was Steve Maughan, member of the Caldwell Historic
Preservation Commission (HPC), 1401 Cleveland Boulevard, Caldwell, Idaho. Changing
the R-2 zoning to a C-2 zoning would encourage erosion to the Historic Cleveland
Boulevard Corridor. The HPC was uncertain why the zoning change was requested
instead of a special use permit, which would have potentially allowed for special
requirements on the change that would have mitigated impact on the area and protected
the property.
The next person to speak was Charlotte Eldredge, 2119 Cleveland Boulevard, Caldwell,
Idaho. Mrs. Eldredge stated that although there are signs posted in the alley stating for
residence use only, people go flying through the alley anyhow. The school bus stops on
20th Street and that would be hazardous.
In regards to the rebuttal Mrs. Stephens stated that the subject property is a perFect
location for her business. When the stop lights are put in, on the corner of Cleveland and
21 st Street, it will help with traffic so that it is not so congested.
Commissioner Roos asked what was the total anticipated capacity for customers inside.
Mrs. Stephens stated that there would be four tables, a couch and easy chair, and a table
for study. There will not be any tables upstairs, other than maybe small tables to write on.
The total capacity at one time would be 25 people. Business would be open around July
of this year. The basement of the house would not be used.
Commissioner Nachtigall asked Mrs. Stephens if she was given any option other than the
zone change for this project. Mrs. Stephens stated that an option was given at the time
her appiication was submitted.
There being no further speakers or questions, the public hearing portion of the agenda was
closed. Discussion ensued within the Commission.
Commissioner Huyck expressed her concern regarding the drive through, the re-zoning of
the property, and the lack of parking spaces. Chairman Roos expressed his concerns
regarding waste and debris, transition and buffering, parking, egresslingress to the
properry, and spot zoning.
Moved by Commissioner Huyck, seconded by Commissioner Nachtigall, that the General
Facts outlined in the staff report be approved as the Findings of Fact on this application,
and that based on public testimony, the inclusion of the following facts be incorporated:
it does not meet the Caldwell Zoning Code for adequate number of parking spaces, re-
zoning it would allow a�l C-2 uses (spot zoning), and there's no buffer between R-2 and C-
April 17, 199�
Page 6
2. The motion was passed by unanimous voice vote.
Comprehensive Plan Analysis - Applicable components of the Plan were identified by
members as: 1) Residential Categories, Items F, G, and M; 2) Transportation, Items C, G
and J; 3) Historic Areas, Items C and D; 4) Community Design, Item F.
Moved by Commissioner Huyck, seconded by Commissioner Nachtigall that the Planning
and Zoning Commission hereby draws the following conclusions based on the approved
Findings of Fact as outlined in our previous discussion and review of the Comprehensive
Plan analysis. The motion passed by unanimous roll call vote.
Moved by Commissioner Nachtigall, seconded by Commissioner Reed, that based upon
these Findings of Facts and Concfusions of Law, the Planning and Zoning Commission
hereby recommends to the Caldwell City Council that #he request by Linda Stephens for
a zone change from R-2 to C-2 be denied.
Roll Call Vote: Yes: Mike Nachtigall, Ron Reed, Bill Gilbert, Sonia Huyck
No: None
Motion passed.
Linda James stated she had a discussion with the City Attorney, regarding a case that has
three requests. The requests being a text amendment, a SUP, and annexation. He
indicated that as long as it is being heard concurrently, at the request of the applicant, then
if one dies, they all die. The audience will not speak on each different case because it will
all be one case. The question was also asked if there is a Special Use Permit, and the
other finro issues are a recommendation issues, if one dies it all dies and no
recommendation goes forward to City Council. Since Chairman Roos has a conflict on the
dates of regular meetings, the by-laws state that variation from this schedule can be done
by a majority consent of the voting members present.
A motion was made by Commissioner Huyck that at the present time, until further notice,
the regular meetings held on the third Thursday be changed to the second and fourth
Thursday of the month. The motion was seconded by Commissioner Reed. The motion
passed by unanimous roll call vote.
Linda James stated that there are many amendments to the Zoning Ordinance that need
to be done soon. Mrs. James handed out list of those areas of possible amendments to
the Commissioners.
There being no further items, Chairman Roos adjourned the meeting at 10:05 p.m.
� � �C'�,�. �.�.�.�-- � � �,
Minutes prepared b � � Dat��. � � �
April 17, 199'1
Page 7