HomeMy WebLinkAbout1-16-1997 P&Z MINUTES V Pt.r1NNl^:G AND ZONING DEPARTMENT �
. ��
. ,
T�ie Cit�T o� Ca �
Planning & Zoning Director
621 CLEVELAND BLVD.
CALDWELL ID 83605
TELEPHONE 455-3021
FAX 455-3003
Meetin� of January 16, 1997
MINUTES OF THE PLA.VNING A�TD ZONING COMNIISSION
ROLL CALL:
Present: Bettie Pilote. William Roos, Bill Gilbert, Madeline Buckendorf, Daniel Ozuna, Mike
Nachtigall
Absent: Sonia Huyck, Ron Reed
Staff: Ed Christopher, Ann Vlarie Re}�es
The regular meeting of the PlanninQ and ZoninQ Commission was called to order by Chairperson
Bettie Pilote, at 7:20 p.m.. in the Caldwell City� Hall Council Chambers.
MINUTES
The first item of business �� approval of the minutes for the previous meeting December 19, 1996.
A motion was made by Commissioner Roos that the December 19, 1996, minutes be approved
as amended. The motion was seconded by Commissioner Gilbert.
All in favor: "Ave."
Opposed: None
Motion carried.
OLD BUSINESS: -
None
NEW BUSINESS:
ELECTION OF OFFICERS
Commissioner Buckendorf nominatzd Comr.lissioner Roos for Chairperson for 1997. The
nomination was seconded bv Commissioner NachtiQall. There were no other nominations.
JAN97.MIN - l
All in favor: '`Aye" �
Opposed: None �
��
�
Commissioner Gilbert norninated Commissioner Nachtigall for Vice-Chair for 1997. There were
no other nominations.
All in favor: "Aye"
Opposed: None
Commissioner Buckendorf nominated Commissioner Huyck for Secretary for 1997. There were no
other nominations.
All in favor: "Aye"
Opposed: None
PUBLIC HEARINGS:
The public hearing portion of the agenda then followed. Chairperson Pilote explained the procedure
for public hearings.
The first item was Case # 96-28-SUP, a Special Use Permit for a kitchen and restroom addition to
the multipurpose building for the Church of the Nazarene located at 903 N. Michigan Avenue.
Ed Christopher presented the staff report. Legal notification requirements had been met. The
applicant had met the directives of the Comprehensive Plan by providing a compatible church
facility with buffering. Churches and related buildings operate on a limited basis and historically
compliment a neighborhood environment. They utilize buildings during off peak hours and within
reasonable hours compatible to neighborhoods. The parking ordinance requires 114 off-street
parking spaces. The applicant provided 124 off-street parking spaces.
Commissioner Buckendorf questioned the Memorandum from the City Engineer, regarding item
number one. Chairperson .Pilote explained that the applicant needed to be aware that if there is
se�ver, there may be additional costs in the building permit.
i�1r. Christopher stated that since they are adding a restroom facility and kitchen there will be
additional plumbing that is going to dump into the sewer, so there would probably be an additional
charge, where the multipurpose room did not have those requirements.
The applicant was represented by Randy Haverfield, 1015 Heartland Drive, Nampa, Idaho. He stated
that the existing house building would be removed. The new addition would be added along the
• south wall of the new multipurpose building. There would be more access for the Fire Department
to Qet to the multipurpose building, whereas before they would have to go in between the two
buildinas. The new addition is a non-combustible structure. The existing structure is a wood frame
combustibie building. The addition would be compatible with the multipurpose building.
J.-.\9'.�11� - 2
��
Commissioner Buckendorf asked if the access that is put in for the Fire Department was ;oing to be
paved or unpaved. �vlr. Haverfield stated that the surface would be paved.
BeinQ no further questions or speakers, Chairperson Pilote closed the public hearing. Discussion
from the Commission ensued.
Commissioner Gilbert felt it would be good for the area.
With regard to Findinjs of Fact, Commissioner Roos stated the Zoning Ordinance policies number
10-0?-02. 10-02-OS-. 10-03-04 and the Comprehensive Plan Land Use Component page 21 dealing
with Low� Density Residential are met within this requested Special Use Permit. That the applicant
has applied for a Special Use Permit as outlined in Municipal Code. That the Commission has the
authority by Idaho State Code to hear and rule on this request.
� motion �vas made by Commissioner Gilbert that the Findings of Fact be approved as stated.
The motion was seconded by Commissioner Nachtigall.
Roll Call Vote: Yes: Bill Gilbert, Mike Nachtigall, Madeline Buckendorf, William Roos, Daniel '
Ozuna
No: None
Motion carried.
Commissioner Roos Concluded that this hearing was conducted in accordance with Idaho State Law.
That the proposal is in harmony with the Comprehensive Plan, Land Use Component, that is found
on page ? 1. That the proposed use does not pose a safety, health, or nuisance to the surrounding
residential neighborhood and that it is in compliance with City Zoning Ordinances.
� motion was made by Commissioner Gilbert to accept the Conclusions of Law as stated by
Commissioner Roos. The motion was seconded by Commissioner Nachtigall.
Roll Call Vote: Yes: Bill Gilbert, Mike Nachtigall, Madeline Buckendorf, William Roos, Daniel
Ozuna
No: None
Modon carried.
� motion �vas made by Commissioner Roos that Case #96-28-SUP, a Special Use Permit for
a Kitchen and Restroom Addition for the Nazarene Church located at 903 N. Michigan Ave.,
be appro��ed as presented.
The motion was seconded by Commissioner Nachtigall.
Roll Call ��ote: Yes: William Roos, Mike Nachtigall, Madeline 8uckendorf, Bill Gilbert, Daniel
Ozuna
No: None
�A�� �,�m - �
. �
Motion carried. �'� �
in and Zonina De artment.
Anyone interested in filing an appeal may contact the Plann g ,. P
The next item was Case #96-29-SUP, a Special Use Permit to construct a four-family dwelling in
the R-2 zoning district for Bradshaw Construction to be located in the 2000 block of E. Linden
Street.
Ed Christopher presented the staff report. Le�al notification requirements had been met. The
applicant had met the directives of the Comprehensive Plan by providina a compatible multi-family
dwelling with adequate landscaping, buffering, and parkina. The site plan provided an adequate
sized lot to accommodate a four-family dwelling.
The applicant, Sallie Bradshaw Palleria, 711 Kimberly Court, Caldwell, Idaho, stated that there
would be an onsite dumpster. She would also put in a five-foot sidewalk. Commissioner Gilbert
questioned about the storm drain plan. Mrs. Palleria responded that a plan had been set up. iVlr.
Christopher stated that the Engineering Department would have the final say as to whether it is going
to work. Commissioner Buckendorf inquired if the five-foot sidewalk would be along Linden. Mrs.
Palleria stated the five-foot sidewalk would be along Linden. Commissioner Buckendorf also asked
if there would be any type of fencing. Mrs. Palleria stated there would be a six-foot fence between
each apartment and along the back side.
There being no further questions or speakers signed up to speak, Chairperson Pilote declared the
public hearing closed. Discussion within the Commission ensued.
Commissioner Nachtigall thought this project would be a welcomed improvement. Commissioner
Buckendorf concurred with Commissioner Nachtigall, that this would be acceptable being
surrounded by R-3 and C-1, creating more of a buffer between R-2 and the Commercial.
Commissioner Roos felt that it was commendable that someone wanted to come in and develop a
piece of property that is completely within the City Limits and where city services are available.
With regard to the Findings of Fact, Commissioner Buckendorf stated that the Comprehensive Plan,
Land Use Component, Residential Categories, applied to this proposal. The legal requirements had
been met. The applicant had applied for a Special Use Perrr.it as outlined in Municipal Code. That
the Commission has the authority by Idaho State Code to hear and rule on this request.
That this is infill property that it is bounded by C-1 and R-3 and it met the Zoning Ordinance
Sections 10-02-02, 10-02-0�, 10-03-04. -
A motion was made by Commissioner Gilbert that the Findings of Fact be approved as stated
by Commissioner Buckendorf. The motion was seconded by Commissioner Roos.
Roll Call Vote: Yes: Bill Gilbert, William Roos, Madeline Buckendorf, Mike Nachtigall, Daniel
Ozuna
No: None
1VIotion carried.
1:�,v97 r��lti - �
, k �
, ��
Commissioner Buckendorf Concluded that this hearing was conducted in accordance with Idaho
State Law. That the proposal was in harmony with the Comprehensive Plan, Land Use Component.
That the proposed use does not pose a safety, health, or nuisance to the surrounding area. It has met
or exceeded all the Zoning Ordinance Requirements as mentioned in the Findings of Fact.
A motion was made by Commissioner Gilbert to accept the Conclusions of Law as stated by
Commissioner Buckendorf. The motion was seconded by Commissioner Nachtigall.
Roll Call Vote: Yes: Bill Gilbert, Mike Nachtigall, Madeline Buckendorf, William Roos, Daniel
Ozuna
No: None
Motion carried.
A motion was made by Commissioner Roos that Case #96-29-SUP, a Special Use Permit for
a four-family dwelling in the R-2 zone for Bradshaw Construction to be located in the 2000
block of E. Linden Street, be approved based on the Findings of Fact.
The motion was seconded by Commissioner Nachtigall.
Roll Call Vote: Yes: William Roos, Mike Nachtigall, Madeline Buckendorf, Bill Gilbert, Daniel
Ozuna
No: None
Motion carried.
Anyone interested in filing an appeal may contact the Planning and Zoning Department.
Chairperson Pilote declared a conflict of interest, therefore, the hearing was chaired by
Commissioner Buckendorf, since Vice-Chairperson Huyck was absent.
The next item was Case #96-07-ANN, a request for Annexation for South Palrang Subdivision to
be located immediately south of South Palrang Drive between S. Montana Avenue and Oregon
Avenue.
Ed Christopher presented the staff report. Legal notification requirements had been met. The
applicant is requesting annexation for approximately three acres. The subject property is adjacent.
to the City Limits of Caldwell on its west side. The subject property lies within the City's Area of
Impact. Adequate City services are available to this parceL
Commissioner Gilbert questioned who owned Palrang Drive. 1vlr. Christopher stated that Palrang
Drive is a dedicated public street. Normally, when an annexation description is written it goes to the
center line of the street for annexation purposes.
Mr. Christopher statzd that a letter was received from the Canyon Highway District stating their
opposition to this annexation. One issue they were concerned about was the City annexinQ half of
JAV97 �91N - 5
. ,�''���
��
the street. like what would typically be done, that «ould still leave half of a street in the County,
which would be in their jurisdiction. When the streets were developed, the developer did not meet
the standards of the Highway District. The High«�av District did not accept those streets. The
Highway District wants the streets to belonQ to the property owners and they will have to take care
of them. Sid Bright from the Highway District stated if it is going to be annexed, the whole
Subdivision should also be anneYed. One of the su�gestions that was brought forth by the City
Engineer would be to annex the entire street. It « have no effect on the adjacent property
owners. They would still be in the County. All the dedicated street known as ``Palrang Drive" would
be the responsibility of the City, which would be accepted by the City. The option the City Engineer
also discussed with the developer would be to not onl� curb his side of the street, but on the Montana
Avenue end, the developer has a�reed to pave half of the block on the North side going up to
Montana Avenue. That would help encourage people to use Palrang Drive as a more expedient route
to get out to the main streets.
Corrunissioner Buckendorf questioned if the applicant is the owner of the property. Mr. Christopher
stated that the applicant is the owner of the property. Commissioner Buckendorf inquired about one
of the letters that were received, bringing up the issue of zoning R-S. She felt this matter would have
to be discussed if it is part of the annexation. She questioned if there was a clear City Policy of that
on what has been the discussion. Mr. Christopher stated that nothing had been set in concrete, the
R-S zoning has been used to buffer the typical residential against some of the agriculture. It is
something the Commission could consider.
The next speaker was the applicant's representati� David Bailey, Pinnacle Engineers, 870 N.
Linder, Ste. B, Meridian, Idaho. He felt that this �ti�as an odd situation, the City doesn't own the
property that Palrang Drive is on, the County doesn't own it, and they don't own it. The State Law
requires someone to accept a riaht-of-way for it to become official right-of-way and gain a duty to
maintain it. The applicant would like to dedicate it at this point and the City will accept it. He felt
that if half of the street was anneYed and the improvements were provided, the improvements would
be in place for the City to maintain. If the City anneYed the whole street, the City would then own
the whole street and would maintain the whole street. The applicant was going to build their side
of the street, plus 7'/� feet of asphalt on the other side. There would be some more improvements
on the north side of the street toward Montana Avenue to help encourage the traffic flow in that
direction.
Commissioner Buckendorf asked if the applicant was only interested in it being zoned R-1. Mr.
Bailey stated that R-1 suits the needs of parcels 100 feet deep. Going to a higher zone would make
odd shaped lots that would be very wide and shallo« . The developer desired to do the R-1 zoning
on the property.
The next speaker was Bert Olsen, 4407 S. Oregon. Caldwell, Idaho. He stated that he had been
� fighting to keep as much traffic off of OreQon Avenue as possible. He felt that all the traffic would
be driving down OreQon since it was paved. The property owners are the one's who paid to have
Oregon paved. The road should have been moved 2� feet, but the developer did not choose to move
it. The wear and tear on the road will have to be paid out of the home owners gockets. He doesn't
want to see Oregon Avenue extended south of Pa1ranQ Drive. There is a water box and water line
in the middle of the street on OreQon Avenue south ot PalranQ Drive. If the street is extended, the
1,�\97.MI?�J - 6
water box will have to be torn out, he thou�ht the water box should be left alone. With the Fire
Substation, School and Park, Mr. Olsen didn't feel the City would want that much traffic in that area.
Acting Chair Buckendorf asked for a clarification from staff regarding whether the street would be
extended. NIr. Christopher stated the City Engineer spoke with the developer. The City Engineer
felt that allowances should be made if the street w�ere ever to be extended. It's the City's Policy at
the time of anneYation or time of subdividing, that allowances be made in case something is ever
planned. Nothing is planned at this point, they are not even joing to move the boxes or even pave
it. They just wanted to insure that a right-of-way is procured in case something develops further
south.
Acting Chair Buckendorf gave the applicant the opportunity to provide rebuttal. The applicant's
representative, David Bailey, 870 N. Linder Ste. B, Meridian, Idaho, stated the developer would
make a commitment and have it put into the Conditions of Approval, that he would keep all the
construction vehicles off of Oregon Avenue. Mr. Bailey stated that Mr. Christopher explained the
reason the right-of-way was shown on the Plat was in case Oregon Avenue needed to be extended
in the future.
There being no further questions or speakers, the public portion of the hearing was closed.
Discussion within the Commission ensued.
Acting Chairperson Buckendorf made a point of clarification. The Commission only makes a
recommendation to City Council. City Council makes the final decision.
With regard to the Findings of Fact, Commissioner Roos stated that the Comprehensive Plan, Land
Use Component, Residential Categories, and the Zoning Ordinances 10-01-07, 10-01-03 are
applicable in • this request. Legal notification requuements had been met. The applicant had applied
for an Annexation as outlined in Municipal Code. That the Commission has the authority by Idaho
State Code to hear and rule on this request. The stafF report is part of the Findings of Fact.
Commissioner Nachtigall clarified the Zoning Ordinance is 10-03-03 not 10-01-03.
A motion was made by Commissioner Roos that the Findings of Fact be approved as stated.
The motion was seconded by Commissioner Nachtigall.
Roll Call Vote: Yes: William Roos, Mike Nachtigall, Bill Gilbert, Daniel Ozuna
No: None
Motion carried.
� Commissioner Roos Concluded that this hearing was conducted in accordance with Idaho State Law.
That the proposal is in harmony with the Comprehensive Plan, Land Use Comnonent in the
Residential Cate�ories. The proposed use does not pose a safety, health, or nuisance to the
surrotulding residential neighbarhood. That this would be a positive addition to the City of Caldwell.
A motion was made by Commissioner Roos to accept the Conclusions of Law as stated. The
JAN9ZN1lN - 7
. �
motion �� as seconded by Commissioner Nachtigall. ;�
�. "�
�`.,
Roll Call Vote: Yes: William Roos, Mike Nachtigall, Bill Gilbert, Daniel Ozuna �
No: None
Motion carried.
A motion �vas made by Commissioner Gilbert that Case #96-07-Al�TN, a request for AnneYation
for South Palrang Subdivision south of Palrang Drive between S. Montana Avenue and
Oregon :�venue, be recommended to City Council, based on the a fore menrioned Findings of
Fact and Conclusions of Law be approved with the following change; that the entire street
known as "Palrang Drive" also be annexed.
The motion was seconded bv Commissioner Roos.
Roll Call Vote: Yes: Bill Gilbert, William Roos, Mike Nachti�all, Daniel Ozuna
No: None
Motion carried.
Anyone interested in filing an appeal may contact the PlanninQ and Zonina Department.
The next item was Case #96-07-ZON, a request for Zone ChanQe for South Palrang Subdivision to
be located immediately south of Palrang Drive between S. Montana Avenue and Oregon Avenue.
Ed Christopher presented the staff report. Legal notification requirements had been met. The
applicant is requestin; a Zone Change from County "A"(Agriculture) to City R-1(Single Family
Residential) for approYimately three acres. The subject property is adjacent to the R-1 zone on the
west side. The Comprehensive Plan Map designation is Low Density Residential.
The next speaker was the applicant's representative David Bailey, 870 N. Linder Ste. B., Meridian,
Idaho. He briefly stated the developer believed that this zone was in accordance with the
surroundin� area and the R-1 zoning is compatible with the surrounding zoning.
The next speaker was Carl Anderson, 1316 S. Idaho, Caldwell, Idaho. He stated that he had signed
up just in case anyone had any questions.
There being no further questions or speakers, the public portion of the hearing was closed.
Discussion within the Commission ensued.
� Commissioner Roos stated he understood the feelings of the neighbors directly to the north. They
would like to see larser lots in this subdivision, which would part of an R-S zone. The City uses the
R-S zone ��ery seldom. The R-S zone is there to protect the a�ricultural around and act as a buffer
between aoriculture and residential. However, he didn't feei that the past history of the City of
Caldwell and it's annexation of agricultt�ral land into the City and for development it's been
detrimental by not havinQ R-S and QoinQ right to R-l. He felt R-1 was satisfactory.
J.a�9� ��� - s
. � ' :� ��
� ;�„ ���
With regard to the Fuidings of Fact, Commissioner Roos stated that the Comprehensive Plan, Land
Use Component, Residential CateQories, and Zoning Ordinances 10-01-03, 10-01-07, and 10-03-03
all applied to this propo�al. That the leQal notification requirements had been met. The applicant
had applied for this Zone Change as outlined in Municipal Code. The Commission has the authority
by Idaho State Code to hear and rule on this request.
A motion was made bv Commissioner Gilbert to accept the Findings of Fact as stated. The
motion was seconded by Commissioner Nachtigall.
Roll Call Vote: Yes: Bill Gilbert. Mike Nachtigall, William Roos, Daniel Ozuna
No: tione
Motion carried.
Commissioner Roos Concluded that this hearing was conducted in accordance with Idaho State Law.
That the proposal was in harmony with the Comprehensive Plan, Land Use Component, and Zoning
Ordinances. The proposal does not pose a safety, health, or nuisance to the surrounding residential
neighborhood.
A motion was made b� Commissioner Gilbert to accept the Conclusions of Law as stated. The
motion was seconded by Commissioner NachtigaIl.
Roll Call Vote: Yes: Bill Gilbert. Mike Nachtigall, William Roos, Daniel Ozuna
No: \one
Motion carried.
A motion was made b�� Commissioner Roos that Case #96-07-ZON, a request for Zone Change
for South Palrang Subdivision to be located immediately south of Palrang Drive between S.
Montana Avenue and Oregon Avenue, be recommended to City Council for approval based
on the a fore mentioned Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law.
The motion was seconded by Commissioner Gilbert.
Roll Call Vote: Yes: �Villiam Roos, Bill Gilbert, Mike Nachtigall, Daniel Ozuna
No: \one
1Vlotion carried.
� Anyone interested in filinQ an appeal may contact the Planning and Zoning Department.
The next item was Case �96-14-SUB, a request for Preliminary Plat for South Palrang Subdivision
to be located immediatel�� south of Palrang Drive between S. Montana Avenue and Oregon Avenue.
Ed Christopher presentzd the staff report. Legal notitication requirements had been met. South
JAN97.;YII�I - 9
. �
Pali•anQ 5ubdivision is an eighteen-lot residential subdivision designed for single family residences.
The proposal met the requirements of the Subdivision Ordinance, related to procedures for
processinQ plats and for specifications for developing lots. The proposal, as presented, would be
compatible w�ith the existinQ neighborhood.
The neat speaker was the applicant's representative David Bailey, 370 N. Linder Ste. B, Meridian,
Idaho. He stated the developer has met with the City Enaineer and the issues that were brought up
have been resolved.
Commissioner Gilbert inquired as to where the developer proposed to discharge the predevelopment
drainaae flows into an existing ditch. i�/Ir. Bailey stated that the ditch comes from the south and
flow�s open ditch to the north. A portion of it would be tiled and there would be pretreatment of the
flows, � calculations and would be tiled through the properry. Commissioner Gilbert inquired
how the developer proposed to retain the storm water runoff. Iv1r. Bailey eYplained that there would
be several methods to doing that. One, being in a pipe or catch basin that would be underneath the
curb, aurter, and sidewalk within the street right-of-way. The desi� has not been complete.
Mr. Christopher stated that had been several letters in protest to this Subdivision. Two of the letters
were rec�ived todav.
There beinQ no further questions or speakers, the public portion of the hearing was closed.
With reQard to the Findings of Fact, Commissioner Roos stated the Comprehensive Plan, Land Use
Component, Residential Categories applied to this proposal, as well as, Subdivision Ordinances 11-
01-02, 11-02-04, 11-02-05, 11-03, and 11-04. That the legal notification requirements have been
met. That the applicant had applied for a Preliminary Plat for South Palrang Subdivision as outlined
in Municipal Code. That the Commission has the authoriry bv Idaho State Code to hear and rule an
this request. That the Staff Report shall be a part of the FindinQs of Fact.
A motion was made by Commissioner Nachtigall to accept the Findings of Fact as stated. The
motion ��•as seconded by Commissioner Gilbert.
Roll Call Vote: Yes: Mike Nachtigall, Bill Gilbert, William Roos, Daniel Ozuna
No: None
Motion carried.
Commis�ioner Roos Concluded that this hearing was conducted in accordance with Idaho State Law.
That the proposal is in harmony with the Comprehensive Plan, Land Use Component as outlined on
paae 21 dealing with Low Density Residential. That Subdivision Ordinances 11-01, 11-02, 11-03,
� and 11-0-� also apply. The proposal does not pose a safety, health, or nuisance to the surroundi.ng
residential nei�hborhood.
A motion was made by Commissioner Nachtigall to accept the Conclusions of Law as statEd.
The morion was seconded by Commissioner Ozuna.
'.1�;7 \II\ - I0
Roll Call Vote: Yes: Mike Nachtigall, Daniel Ozuna, William Roos, Bill Gilbert
No: None �
Motion carried.
A motion was made by Commissioner Gilbert that Case #96-14-SUB, a request for Preliminary
Plat for South Pairang Subdivision to be located immediately south of Palrang Drive between
S. Montana Avenue and Oregon Avenue, be approved based on the a fore mentioned Findings
of Fact and Conclusions of Law.
The motion was seconded by Commissioner Nachtigall.
Roll Call Vote: Yes: Bill Gilbert, Mike Nachti�all, William Roos, Daniel Ozuna
No: None
Motion carried.
Anyone interested in filing an appeal may contact the Plannin� and Zoning Department.
Acting Chairperson Buckendorf questioned if there were any Committee Reports.
Commissioner Roos stated the Comprehensive Plan Committee would be meeting two weeks from
today's date. Acting Chairperson Buckendorf stated that with the new director there would be a Si�
Ordinance.
Acting Chairperson Buckendorf stated that there would be a special meeting with Canyon County
Planning and Zoning on January 30, 1997. It would be held on the first floor meeting room at the
Canyon County Court House.
Acting Chairperson Buckendorf stated thai there had been several requests for further education and
training workshops for the Planning and Zoning Commission. Since there haven't been any in a long
time and would be very usefuL
Ed Christopher stated that there was money budgeted for that purpose, in fact, in the December
packets there was an invitation to any Commissioners that wanted to attend a class that would be
held on January 25.
Acting Chairperson Buckendorf felt that it has been very frustrating for everyone with the lack of
well-trained professional staff. She felt that it was very important the Commission attend workshops
on all the new issues that have come up that have not been considered'uefore.
There being no further items of discussion, Acting Chairperson Buckendorf adjourned the meeting
at 9:1 � p.m.
JAN97 MIN - I 1