HomeMy WebLinkAbout12-19-1996 P&Z MINUTES II
PLANNING AND ZONING DEPARTMENT
� � T�ie C'ity o� C'aldwe
. ,
,
Planning & Zoning Director
621 CLEVELAND BLVD.
CALDWELL ID 83605
• TELEPHONE 455-3021
FAX 455-3003
REVISED JANUARY 21, 1997
Meeting of December 19, 1996
11'IINUTES OF THE PLANNING AND ZOIVING COMNIISSION
ROLL CALL:
Present: Bettie Pilote, William Roos, Ron Reed, Bill Gilbert, Madeline Buckendorf, Sonia
Huyck, Daniel Ozuna
Absent: Mike Nachtigall
Staff: Ed Christopher, Ann Marie Reyes
The regular meeting of the Planning and Zoning Commission was called to order by Chairperson
Bettie Pilote, at 7:15 p.m., in the Caldwell City Hall Council Chambers.
MINUTES
The first item of business was approval of the minutes for the previous meeting November 21, 1996.
A motion was made that the November 21, 1996, minutes be approved as written.
All in favor: "Aye."
Opposed: None
Motion passed.
OLD BUSINESS: �
None
- NEW BUSINESS:
Chairperson Pilote explained the procedure for public hearings.
The first item was Case #96-26-SUP, a Special Use Permit far a Security/Caretaker unit at the
Terrace Drive-In located at 3717 Lake Avenue.
�
�:
12MIN. WPD - 1 �.
A�
; ••;.
�
� Ed Christopher presented the staff report. He stated that all legal requirements had been met. The
proposal has met the requirements of the Comprehensive Plan and Zoning Ordinance. City water
is available to the location. The Terrace Drive-In building is on a private septic tank and well.
Commissioner Huyck questioned if it had to have its own septic tank. Mr. Christopher stated that
in the recommended canditions they would have to get approval from Southwest District Health
Department to either connect to the existing septic or install a new septic system. ;
The first speaker was the applicant Alice Estrada, who resides at 2819 S. Georgia #44, Caldwell,
Idaho. She stated that the structure had already been built. Its size is 20 x 30. She felt that having
a security manager on that end of the property would be helpful to the business.
There being no further questions or speakers, Chairperson Pilote declared the public hearing closed.
Nlrs. Estrada had a question, but since the public hearing had been closed Commissioner Huyck
made a motion to reopen the public hearing for the applicant. The motion was seconded by
Commissioner Buckendorf.
All in favor: "Aye."
Opposed: None
Mrs. Estrada asked whether the Planning and Zoning Department required that the structure be
placed on a fou.ndation. Mr. Christopher responded that the matter would be addressed by the
building official, usually, for temporary structure, they ask that it be blocked and skirted for
protection. That would have to be clarified with the building department when a building permit is
requested.
There being no further questions, Chairperson Pilote declared the public hearing closed.
With regard to Findings of Facts, Commissioner Roos stated the proposal was in conformance with
the Comprehensive Plan, Land Use Component. The legal requirements had been met and the
applicant had applied for a Special Use Permit as outlined in the Municipal Code. The use requested
met the requirements of the Zoning Ordinance in this case.
A motion was made by Commissioner Reed that the Findings of Facts be approved as stated.
The motion was seconded by Commissioner Huyck.
All in favor: "Aye."
Opposed: None
Motion passed.
Commissioner Roos Concluded that the legal requirements for this Public Hearing were conducted
in accordance with the Idaho State Law. The proposal was in harmony with the Comprehensive
Plan. The proposed use did not pose a safety, health, or nuisance to the surrounding neighborhood.
� I�MiN.WPD- 2
r
�
' A motion was made by Commissioner Reed to accept the Conclusions of Law as stated. The
motion was seconded by Commissioner Buckendorf.
All in favor: "Aye."
Opposed: None
Vlotion passed.
A motion was made by Commissioner Reed that Case #96-26-SUP, a Special Use Permit for
a Security/Caretaker unit at the Terrace Drive-In located at 3717 Lake Avenue, be accepted
as presented including the conditions set forth by staff.
The motion was seconded by Commissioner Roos.
Rol1 Ca11 Vote: Yes: Ron Reed, William Roos, Madeline Buckendorf, Sonia Huyck, Bill Gilbert.
Daniel Ozuna
No: None
Motion passed.
Anyone interested in filing an appeal may contact the Planning and Zoning Department.
The next item was Case #96-25-SUP, a Special Use Permit to reduce the number of off-street
parking spaces to accommodate an addition to the Social Security Office at 1118 S. Kunball
Avenue.
Ed Christopher presented the staff report. All legal requirements have been met. He stated the facts
pertaining to this request. The applicant appears to have met the directives of the Comprehensive
Plan by providing a service which is recognized as an asset to the community.
The first speaker was the applicant's representative Renn Joseph, 1068 Frances, Walla Walla,
Washington. Commissioner Gilbert asked how many employees were employed by the Social
Security office and whether used the parking spaces. Mr. Joseph stated there were less than ten
employees employed by the Social Security O�ce and he wasn't sure exactly where all the
employees parked whether it would be in the Armory parking lot or in the spaces provided.
There being no further questions or speakers, Chairperson Pilote declared the public hearing closed.
Discussion within the Commission ensued.
With regard to Findings of Facts, Commissioner Roos stated the proposal was in conformance with
" the Comprehensive Plan, Land Use Component. The legal requirements had been met and the
- applicant had applied for a Special Use Permit as outlined in the Municipal Code. The use requested
would not create an undo situation related to parking in the area.
A motion was made by Commissioner Reed that the Findings of Facts be approved as stated.
The motion was seconded by Commissioner Buckendorf.
1?:�.fIti.WPD - 3
r :�11 in favor: '`Aye."
Opposed: tione
Vlotion passed.
Commissioner Roos Concluded that the legal requirements for this Public Hearing were conducted
in accordance with the Idaho State Law. The proposal was in harmony with the Comprehensive
Plan. The proposed use did not pose a safety, health, or nuisance to the surrounding residential
neiQhborhood.
A motion was made by Commissioner Reed to accept the Conclusions of Law as stated. The
motion was seconded by Commissioner Huyck.
All in favor: "Aye."
Opposed: None
Motion passed.
A motion was made by Commissioner Huyck that the Commission approve the Special Use
Permit application #96-25-SUP, for the Social Security Office for an addition and to reduce
the number of off-street parking spaces from 19 to 13 spaces. Based on the Findings of Facts
and Conclusions of Law with the conditions as set forth in the staff report.
The motion was seconded by Commissioner Reed.
Roll Call Vote: Yes: Sonia Huyck, Ron Reed, William Roos, Madeline Buckendorf, Bill Gilbert,
Daniel Ozuna
No: None
11�Iotion passed.
Anyone interested in filing an appeal may contact the Planning and Zoning Department.
The next item was Case #96-24-SUP, a Special Use Permit for a Child Care Center in the G2
zoning district, located at 715 Everett Street
Commissioner Huyck stated that she received a call from the owner of Orphan Annie's Restaurant.
Their concern was their liquor license. Commissioner Huyck recommended they speak with Ed
Christopher in the Planning and Zoning Department since they were unable to attend the meeting.
_ Commissioner Hu��ck also stated that they did not receive their notice.
Ed Christopher presented the staff report. Legal requirements have been met. He stated the facts
pertaininQ to this request. Mr. Christopher addressed the point that Commissioner Huyck brought
up regarding the o�rner of Orphan Annie's Restaurant. NIr. Yee did come into the Planning and
Zoning Office and eYpressed his concern regarding his liquor license. Mr. Christopher informed Mr.
Yee that anytime a business chose to locate within 300 feet of an establishment that served alcoholic
1'_�tI`.�4'PD - 4
beverages would be waiving their right to come back at a later date and contest the matter. The
applicant was fully aware of this and are willing to accept that condition. Commissioner Buckendorf
asked whether Mr. Yee mentioned anything about not being notified. Mr. Christopher stated that
the records were verified and that he was most definitely sent a notification.
Commissioner Roos inquired about the catering business the applicant was going to operate in the
kitchen. The Fire Marshal did not make any negative comment on the matter, since the children
were going to be in a separate area.
The first speaker was the applicant Karen Tom, 305 E. Pat Lane, Caldwell, Idaho. Mrs. Tom stated
that she had done child care for 18 years. She had also applied for her State License. Mrs. Tom said
there would be no more than 25 children at any one time. She felt there would be no problem with
Orphan Annie's liquor license and did not feel it would be a determent to their day care facility. The
actual square footaQe of the day care area would be 1,234 sq.ft. There would be a six-foot fence to
be located on the larger portion of the yard for the children's play area.
There being no further questions or speakers, Chairperson Pilote declared the public hearing closed.
With regard to Findings of Fact, Commissioner Roos stated the proposal was in conformance with
the Comprehensive Plan, Land Use Component. The legal requirements had been met and the
applicant had applied for a Special Use Permit as outlined in the Municipal Code. The use requested
would not create an undo situation in that zoning district.
A motion was made by Commissioner Reed that the Findings of Facts be approved as '
presented. The motion was seconded by Commissioner Huyck.
All in favor: "Aye."
Opposed: None
iVIotion passed.
Commissioner Roos Concluded that the legal requirements for this Public Hearing were conducted
in accordance with the Idaho State Law. The proposal was in harmony with the Comprehensive
Plan. The proposed use did not pose a safety, health, or nuisance to the surrounding neighborhood.
A motion was made by Commissioner Reed to accept the Conclusions of Law as presented.
The motion was seconded by Commissioner Gilbert.
All in favor: "Aye."
Opposed: None
� Motion passed.
A motion was made by Commissioner Roos that Case #96-24-SUP, a Special Use Permit for
a Child Care Center in the G2 zoning district, located at 715 Everett Street be approved with
the Recommended Conditions of Approval and the added Condition No. 7
12MIN. WPD - 5
� 7. A six-foot fence be constructed on the larger portion of the property to the
southeast.
The modon was seconded by Commissioner Reed.
Roll Call Vote: Yes: William Roos. Ron Reed, vladeline Buckendorf, Sonia Huyck, Bill Gilbert,
Daniel Ozuna
No: None
Motion carried.
Anyone interested in filing an appeal may contact the Planning and Zoning Department.
The next item was Case #96-06-ANN, a request for Annexation for a two hundred and fifty-three
unit Mobile Home Park to be known as "Country Village" located on the east side of S. Florida
Avenue�etween Apollo and Orion Street extended.
Commissioner Ozuna declared a conflict of interest and therefore, excused himself.
Ed Christopher presented the staff report. Lzgal notification requirements had been met. Based on 'I
the surrounding zoning, the Comprehensive Plan Designation, staff had recommended a ,
Comprehensive Plan redesignation to High Density Residential and a zoning classification to R-3
(Multi-Family High Density Residential). The subject property lies within the City's Area of Impact
and adequate city services are available.
The first speaker was Stuart Greene, the agent for Caldwell MHC, LLC, 2482 E. Springwood Dr.,
Meridian, Idaho. The original request was C-3 (Service Commercial) since it was adjacent on the
east to this parcel. After discussing it with staff. they agreed to go with R-3, to keep it residential.
MHC, LLC met the requirements of the government code section, for contiguous property adjacent
to the city. It also met the guidelines of the City of Caldwell Comprehensive Plan.
The next speaker was Terence L. McCue, 2307 Pisces Drive, Caldwell, Idaho. Mr. McCue felt that
there would not be enough access for traffic to go to and from the area. He said that increasing the
amount of traffic in this particular area would put the public at risk and would not be a good use for
this area.
The next speaker was W. Darcy Maag, 3611 S. Florida Avenue, Caldwell, Idaho. NIr. Maag's
biggest concern was how much water and sewer were available for a piece of property like this
parcei. Mr. Christopher clarified that the sewer that lies on Florida between Cherry and Cleveland
Blvd. currently is serviced by a pump station. This summer the Engineering Department have plans
to replace it with a�avity flow system which will allow the sewer to be extended to this property.
� Mr. Maag's concern for water directly impacts himself. He believes that his well would be in
jeopardy.
Chairperson Pilote stated that Staff s comment was based on the fact that there are adequate Cird
Services in that area.
l'_MIN-WPD - 6
� Mr. Maag also stated for the record that he has no objection to the Annexation of this property, but
objects to the Mobile Home Park. ,
The next speaker was Stan Peace, 3522 S. Florida Avenue, Caldwell, Idaho. As far as the objection I
to annexing the property into City Limits, he does not have any. He expressed his concern for the
purpose of the use, so that it remains the same as the existing residential area.
There being no further speakers or questions, Chairperson Pilote declared the public hearing closed.
Discussion within the Commission ensued.
With regard to Findings of Fact, Commissioner Roos and Buckendorf stated that the proposal is in
conformance with the annexation policy. The legal requirements have been met and the applicant
has applied for annexation as outlined in the Municipal Code. That the subject property is adjacent
to City Limits and that adequate City Services are available.
A motion was made by Commissioner Huyck that the Findings of Fact be approved as
presented. The motion was seconded by Commissioner Reed.
All in favor: "Aye."
Opposed: None
1Vlotion passed.
Commissioner Buckendorf Concluded that the legal requirement for this Public Hearing were
conducted in accordance with the Idaho State Law. It has met the annexation policy of the City.
The Annexation is in harmony with the Comprehensive Plan.
A motion was made by Commissioner Reed to accept the Conclusions of Law as presented.
The motion was seconded by Commissioner Huyck.
All in favor: "Aye."
Opposed: None
Motion passed.
A motion was made by Commissioner Roos that Case #96-06-A1VN, a request for Annegation
for a two hundred and fifty-three unit Mobile Home Park to be known as "County Village"
located on the east side of S. Florida Avenue between Apollo and Orion Street extended, be
recommended to City Council for approval based on the a fore mentioned Facts and
Conclusions.
The motion was seconded by Commissioner Reed.
Roll Call Vote: Yes: William Roos, Ron Reed, Sonia Huyck, Madeline Buckendorf, Bill Gilbert
Na: None
l2MIN.WPD - 7
' Motion carried.
Anyone inierested in filing an appeal may contact the Planning and Zoning Department.
The next item was Case #96-02-COMP and #96-06-ZON, a request for Comprehensive Plan Map
Amendment and Zone Change for a two hundred and fifty-three unit Mobile Home Park to be known
as "Country Village" located on the east side of S. Florida Avenue between Apollo and Orion Street
extended.
Ed Christopher presented the staff report. Legal notification requirements had been met. As the �
applicant mentioned earlier their original request was C-3 and a Comprehensive Plan Amendment
to Commercial. Staff had recommended that an R-3 and a Hi Density Residential be a better
�
buffer between the existing commercial uses to the east and the lower density uses to the west, the
applicant had agreed to this recommendation.
Commissioner Buckendorf asked the name of the drain that separated the commercial from the
property. Mr. Christopher stated that it was the Wilson Drain. Commissioner Buckendorf also
questioned the one parcel that had not be annexed and what was the zoning. Mr. Christopher stated
that there was an approximately ten acre parcel, that is located to the north and is zoned R-2.
Commissioner Buckendorf inquired whether there had been a traffic study done of Florida. Mr.
Christopher stated there had been a traffic study contracted by J.U.B. Engineers. They are currently
in phase three of their study. Specifically the intersection at Florida and Cleveland Blvd. is currently
rated "B" (Better than average) with "C" being (Average). Their projection for the year 2020 will
be that it will drop to a"C" rating.
The first speaker was the applicant's agent Stuart Greene, Caldwell MHC, LLC, 2482 E.
Springwood Drive, Meridian, Idaho. Although, the original application requested C-3, R-3 woul_d
be acceptable since it would be a transitional zone towards the R-2 to the west. Property in that area
is surrounded by higher uses than the Comprehensive Plan. Again, all city services are available to
the property.
Mr. Maag requested that he switch places to speak with Mr. Scott Smith, since he had to leave early.
The next speaker was Scott Smith, 2815 Pisces Drive, Caldwell, Idaho. Mr. Smith would like to
object to the changing of the Comprehensive Plan. He felt the Commission should abide by the
Comprehensive Plan and deny the developer's request. Mr. Smith thought that R-3 would
completely subverts the Comprehensive Plan that was drafted in 1994. ,
The next speaker was W. Darcy Maag, 3611 S. Florida Avenue, Caidwell, Idaho. Mr. Maag is owner
and operator of Highland Appraisal, 4412 Aviation Way, Caldwell, Idaho, for the last six years and
- with the Lloyd Company for 10 years prior to that, doing appraisals and contract work for different
� counties throughout the state. His first objection, would be that the surrounding properties would
be affected by a Zone Change or Comprehensive Plan of this magnitude. When he purchased his
property four years ago, he researched the Zoning in the area for specific reasons he wanted to buy
in a residential neighborhood. He recently had an appraisal done on his property, and doesn't feel
the transition from a neighborhood with values in this range is just not feasible.
12ML'�l. WPD - 3
- Commissioner Buckendorf questioned whether the adjacent land would affect the properties values
negatively or positively.
VIr. vlaag felt that it would have a negative affect on property values. He then questioned where Mr.
Greene stated that they had designated this area as High Density Residential. The current map that
the cirv has is R-1 not R-2 or R-3.
Chairperson Pilote stated that the Comprehensive Plan is a guideline only and does have a geat deal
of fleYibility.
The next speaker was Brian Finley 2716 E. Beech Street, Caldwell, Idaho. Mr. Finley felt that it is
not in harmony with the Comprehensive Plan. The current property is zoned 50% low density and
�0% medium density and the new request is to zone it 100% high density does not make any sense.
He feels this would disrupt the quality of the neighborhood. He was worried about the increased
traffic flow.
The next speaker was Thelma Carpenter, 2806 Gemini Place, Caldwell, Idaho. She questioned
whether the Wilson Drain served as a natural barrier between the commercial and residential. She
felt the Wilson Drain stopped the commercial from expanding or going any further servin� as a
sufficient buffer. She felt that changing the land use to higher intensity would create adverse impact !
to the values and living standards developed by all property owners in the surrounding neighborhood.
Sl:e stated that bringing in a large number of children and putting them beside a known present
hazard didn't make sense.
The next speaker was Terence McCue, 2807 Pisces Drive, Caldwell, Idaho. He stated that zoning
the area, other than R-1 or R-2, would be impractical and unadvisable. He also stated that it makes
no sense to him to change the Comprehensive Plan. If the development was changed to High
Density Residential there would have to be a center turn lane on Florida and a light on the Cleveland
Blvd.
The next speaker was Steve Pease, 3522 S. Florida, Caldwell, Idaho. He stated that he agreed on
everything the previous speakers had said.
Mr. Greene stated that he definitely did not see this particular project as urban sprawl. He had
spoken with the person who is currently farming the area and it is becoming more and more difficult
to do, especially since farming equipment is bigger and very costly. According to the previous
speakers, they have mentioned their property values decreasing when in reality it had just been
confirmed they have actually gone up in value. In regards to the Comprehensive Plan, it is a moving
pian and it is meant to change.
' There being no further speakers or questions, Chairperson Pilote declared the public hearing closed.
Commissioner Buckendorf said there are two issues to look at before a recommendation for a zone
change whether it be C-3 or R-3. The biggest issue is the question of buffering. I� is surrounded by
a�iculture, R-1, and R-2. In her opinion, commercial is not a consideration nor would it fit in with
the Comprehensive Plan, and it outweighs the need for a commercial buffer. She thought the buffer
12ML'� �vPD - 9
y already provided by both the road and the canal present enough of a bufFer. There are no roads
leading into the commercial, it is her opinion that R-3 should not be recommended either.
Commissioner Reed a�eed with Commissioner Buckendorf. It would not be consistent to change
it to R-3 and put that many units in that area.
Commissioner Roos said he understood the frustrations of everyone that attended the meeting. All
the Commissioners sit on the Commission on their own time and at their own expense. They try to
understand the various sights the people bring before the Commission. They do this because they
care about our City. There is a committee that looks at the Comprehensive Plan and revises it when
they feel it is necessary. There have been a number of ineetings, and not a single citizen has shown
up to give their input. I am a firm believer in managed growth, not controlled growth. Controlled
growth can be looked upon as detrimental. He also, is opposed to changing the Comprehensive Plan.
He believed that going from what our Comprehensive Plan shows as R-1 and R-2 to R-3 would be
disastrous.
There being no further discussion Findings of Facts were presented.
With regard to Findings of Fact, Commissioner Roos stated that the proposal is not in conformance
with the Comprehensive Land Use Map. The legal requirements have not been met.
A motion was made by Commissioner Reed that the Findings of Facts be approved as stated.
The motion was seconded by Commissioner Gilbert.
Roll Call Vote: Yes: Ron Reed, Bill Gilbert, Sonia Huyck, Madeline Buckendorf, William Roos.
No: None
Motion passed.
Commissioner Roos Concluded that the legal requirements for this Public Hearing was conducted
in accordance with the Idaho State Law. That the proposal was not in harmony with the
Comprehensive Plan. The proposal use would pose a nuisance to the surrounding residential
neighborhood.
A motion was made by Commissioner Huyck to accept the Conclusions of Law as stated by
Commissioner Roos. The motion was seconded by Commissioner Reed.
Roll Call Vote: Yes: Sonia Huyck, Ron Reed, Bill Gilbert, Madeline Buckendorf, William Roos.
No: None
Motion passed.
Commissioner Buckendorf questioned if the motion that is now being made has to do with the
Comprehensive Plan change and not the Zone Change.
A motion was made b�� Commissioner Reed and amended by Commissioner Buckendorf that
a recommendation be made to City Council that the request for the Comprehensive Plan Map
redesignation from Low Density and Medium Density Residential to High Density Residential
12MIN.WPD- 10
r or Commercial based on the a fore mentioned Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law be
clenied.
The motion was seconded by Commissioner Huyck.
Roll Call Vote: Yes: Madeline Buckendorf, Ron Reed, Sonia Huyck, Bill Gilbert William Roos.
No: None
A motion was made by Commissioner Roos that if this property is annexed into the City, that
a recommendation be made to the City Council that it be zoned as R-1 and R-2 as shown by
the Comprehensive Plan Land Use Map.
The motion was seconded by Commissioner Reed.
Roll Call Vote: Yes: William Roos, Ron Reed, Madeline Buckendorf, Sonia Huyck Bill Gilbert.
No: None
Motion passed.
The Chair advised any interested party their right to appeal this decision to the City Council within
fifteen days by checking with the Planning Department for any questions.
On a point of Order, the Chair recognized Rita Earl of Skinner, Earl and Associates, working for the
applicant, address is 314 Badiola Street, Caldwell. This is a quasi-judicial hearing not a legislative
matter but as a legal matter dealing with zoning. The State Code does specify that this must be
related back to Comprehensive Plan and how the zoning relates to the Comprehensive Plan in
making your designation. The Comprehensive Plan includes the portion which is written and so we
would ask for clarification on specifically what portions we have not met. Also, on the zoning
recommendation that the Commission just made, we would be interested in knowing what portion
the Commission have recommended to be annexed as R-1 and what portion as R-2, those have to
have legal boundaries. The Comprehensive Plan Map does not give legal boundaries for those that
are just, as you know, a paint-brush on a canvas. We need to know exactly what the Commission
is specifically recommending as going R-1 and what specifically is going R-2.
Commissioner Buckendorf said she thought the Commission could handle the Comprehensive Plan
Map change, but the zone change is another matter. She then questioned whether the public hearing
had to be reopened. In the Comprehensive Plan, on page twenty-two, number seven, it stated that
the City would achieve appropriate buffering and adequate transition between different
classifications and uses when considering applications for new tises, land development, zone changes
and annexations.
Chairperson Pilote clarified for the Commission that a specific Code section should be cited.
Commissioner Buckendorf felt that this request did not provide adequate transition because the
majority of the area is surrounded by R-1, R-2, and agricultural at this time. As for the buffering
issue, the commercial area was already buffered by the canal and the road. That was why the
I=MIN.WPD- ll
� Commission is not making a that recommendation to City Council for approval.
Commissioner Roos stated that Florida Avenue was the only buffer between a R-1 and a R-3, and
he doesn't consider a street as an adequate buffer between two diverse zones.
Commissioner Buckendorf stated the area that is C-3 is bounded by both the canal and street in
comparison to the amount of land that is surrounded by residential and agricultural land. You have
three and half sides that are residential with only approximately one-half of one side that is
commercial.
Chairperson Pilote asked if there were any further clarifications.
Commissioner Huyck stated the Commission can also go to the High Density Residential section on
page twenty-one, where it says suitable Hi� Density would be suitable primarily for multi-family
housing such as apartments, townhouses, condominiums, mobile home parks and other compact
residential developments but it would also be suitable for professional office development and
limited neighborhood commercial uses in selected locations as well as a variety of public and semi-
public uses and compatible institutional uses. The residential density would be from ten to thirty
dwelling units per net acre.
Chairperson Pilote reminded the Commission that they needed to cite specific sections of the code.
Commissioner Buckendorf stated that she had looked this up before hand.
Chairperson Pilote questioned if that was complete from the Commission. If so, they should move
to the second clarification.
Commissioner Huyck stated the reason she had trouble doing this was because she had not made up
her mind before she came to the meeting, so she had not picked out specific reasons to either back-up
one position or the other.
Chairperson Pilote told the Commission they would have to justify their vote to the applicant
because they have to show what they based their vote on.
Commissioner Roos stated that their decisions had to be based upon law and not on emotions. He
questioned staff, in relationship of establishment of zoning boundaries. He felt that the boundary
was originally placed on the Comprehensive Plan Land Use Map based on the decision made by
some previous Commission or the City Council. He questioned the determination to have the zoning
be based on the Comprehensive Land Use Map the boundaries wouid be set some place within City
statute.
• Mr. Christopher stated he thought that when you actually zone a piece of property you have to define
specifically what property is to be zoned what. You can't arbitral go down the middle of the
property and have one half be one zone and the other half another. You have to be consistent and
have some bases, whether that is defined as the first three hundred feet along Florida as beina R-1
and the remainder is going to be R-2, or however you define it. It has to be defined specifically.
12M1N. WPD - l2
' Commissioner Roos said he was laboring under the impression that these lines were drawn on the
Comprehensive Plan Map based on a previous determination.
Chairperson Pilote, confirmed her understanding that the Commission have chosen an explanation
as to their vote, on page twenty-two, of the Comprehensive Plan, number seven, and on page twenty-
one, the detinition of High Density Residential as their explanation of their vote.
R.ita Earl further explained that a Zone Change must be done by meets and bounds description. The
City Staff have to know exactly what is beina recommended for R-1 and what exactly is
recommended for R-2. v
Mr. Christopher explained that it needed to be specified. The description could be referenced as the
first two hundred feet along the centerline of Florida Avenue to the east for the length of the
property.
Rita Earl stated the applicant's application provided a legal description for what the applicant was
asking to do, so that it would be very specific for the Zone Change.
Commissioner Buckendorf questioned if there would have to be any public discussion for the R-1
or R-2, since R-3 or C-3 was discussed in the public hearing. I
i
Chairperson Pilote explained that when the motion was made it said deny the R-3 and C-3 and
recommend R-1 and the R-2. It had nothing to do with the public hearing .
Commissioner Huyck asked Commissioner Roos if the Comprehensive Plan Map gave any
indication as to whether it is the front part that faced Florida. Commissioner Roos said that it did.
In fact, that was the bases of his vote.
Chairperson Pilote explained that the Commission could not go forward without answering the
applicants request.
Commissioner Roos reiterated that he felt that someplace there was in writing exactly where the
boundary was between the Low Density and Medium Density.
Chairperson Pilote explained that there is not always specific boundaries on the map. We are
growing so quickly and are facing the impact area with the County. The applicant has asked the
Commission to verbalize what their opinion was based on. _
Commissioner Roos based his opinion and motion on the fact that he believed that was the boundary
he was talking about. That on the west was R-1 and the east was R-2 as designated on the
Comprehensive Plan Map. He was under the impression that there was a legally described line
established for that.
Commissioner Huyck stated the only legal des�ription that w�s �iven was the one in the application.
Chairperson Pilote stated that anyone interest in filing an appeal had the right to do so. She then
IZMIN WPD - 13
` questioned if the Special Use Permit would still be heard.
Rita Earl stated that if there could be a recominendation the Council would be able to make the
determination if the appeal is appropriate and either accept or reject the Commissions decision.
It was her opinion that a recommendation be made.
Chairperson Pilote asked staff if the S.U.P. for the mobile Home Park be heard and a
recommendation to City Council be made. However, the Commission felt that it is a mute point and
do not need to hear it.
Mr. Christopher stated if a recommendation is sent to City Council for the Annexation, confumation
of the Comprehensive Plan Designation and the Zone Change; they would probably prefer to receive
it as an entire package. It would be staffs recommendation that the S.U.P. be heard.
The next item was Case #96-27-SUP, a Special Use Permit for a two hundred and fifty-three unit
Mobile Home Park to be known as "Country Village" located on the east side of S. Florida Avenue
between Apollo and Orion Street extended.
Ed Christopher presented the staff report. He stated that all legal requirements had been met.
Stewart Greene, 2482 E. Springwood Drive, Meridian. Based on the Commission's previous
decision to send the annexation on with a zone recommendation of R-1 and R-2, we are requesting
a S.U.P. based on some difFerent zoning. In regards, he requested the Commission make a decision
tonight on the S.U.P. as they see fit and then let it move on to City Council.
Chairperson Pilote reiterated that Mr. Greene knew he couldn't have this development in a R-1 or
R-2 zone which the Commission have already recommended to City Council. The public hearing
could continue, testimonies could be heard or a vote could be taken and a recommendation be
forwarded to City Council based on the fact that it is an impossible situation. So theoretically, the
Commission would have to take a vote to deny it based on the fact that it would not be allowed by
the other two motions. Mr. Greene would be able to then take the whole package to City Council.
What he said was that he basically felt he knew the outcome of the vote and if the audience still
wished to speak against it in the public hearing they still have that right and the Commission would
still go through the list. You do have the right to go to the City Council meeting. You will be
notified again by the City that it is going to be heard. You have every right to be there and testify
to everything you testified to tonight, and more if you think of something else you want to add.
The first person to speak was Thelma Carpenter of 2806 Gemini Place. She would like to go on
record that she objected to this mobile home unit complex. She would like to reserve any right she
might be giving up to speak at any future time on this project.
� Chairperson Pilote said she had the right to testify anytime this issue is discussed in a public hearing.
The second speaker was Terrance McCue of 2807 Pisces Drive. He didn't have an objection to
taking the vote on this because it is not in conformance with the previous motions. He wanted it on
record, the points of order and that possible ex parte communication took place outside the meeting
l2tiIIN.WPD- 14
with the applicants representative Rita Earl, who also sits on the City Council, who does have a
direct interest in this. He would like it on record that this was a concern of his and at the time it
comes before the City Council it could be dealt with.
Chairperson Pilote explained that the ex parte communication was that Mrs. Earl did approach her '
.
as the Commission came back into the meeting and said that the applicant wanted to get this over
with because they knew the Commission had to deny it. That's when we started discussing it with
Mr. Maag. Then Sharon came forwazd and I tried to explain to them that we did not have any private
conversation. It was merely a point of order. Chairperson Pilote doesn't vote anyway. It was to say
please how could we get this done that we can still send it to City Council as a package without
taking two more hours to hash it back and forth because we all know our responsibility as the
Commission to deny it.
The next speaker was Paul Bull of 2805 Pisces Drive. He emphasized that this development would
affect the value of their property. They don't need anybody putting more mobile home parks or
things that don't help the community. If one of the concerns that he heard was to have more low
income housing. There is low income housing that runs from Linden all the way over to Ustick.
He would rather put them out there then right in the middle of the community, by their houses. The
traffic would increase tremendously. If there are two hundred and twenty-five units, and there are
only two drivers in each unit, that's four hundred and fifty cars a day coming and going. Right now,
in the last ten yeazs he noticed a lot more traffic than there used to be. In fact, he got in a wreck on
the corner of Florida and the Boulevard four weeks ago. The traffic is just horrible there. He does
oppose to this project. He questioned the adequate city services. In his house, he had fifty-six
pounds of water pressure, ten years ago. His water pressure is now down to twenty-three pounds.
At twenty-three pounds he can't run his sprinkler system. He felt that two hundred and twenty-five
more units is going to effect his water pressure and that there are not adequate city services. If this
weren't an enormous profit program, nobody would be talking about doing this, just because we're
trying to be nice and help the people who need housing in Caldwell.
Chairperson Pilote told Mr. Bull he should try and understand that when the Commission quoted and
stated that there were "adequate city services" that's what comes to the Commission from
Engineering and Water Department. The Commission doesn't just say there's enough sewer out
there.
Mr. Bull stated for the record that the Commission was wrong, and the findings were wrong. He
fought with the city water department for two years to get his sprinklers to more than just pop-up.
He said that it is very frustrating. There is J.U.B., who have done some of these reports, who live
in Nampa, where there is adequate pressure.
Chairperson Pilote stated the Commission relied on the staff people that send the Commission the
recommendation from Engineering and other departments. She reiterated that it is imperative that
a�oup or as individuals try to attend some of the transportation meetings. They need to hear some
of the things which are out of our parameter.
Mr. Bull agreed with one thing that was said by Mr. Roos, also being a Caldwell businessman for
a number of years would like to stay here. Many of the people here would like to stay here. There
12MIN.WPD- l5
� comes a point when we've been talking about Caldwell, what's happening to it and this is what's
happening to it. He won't stay here because he could make a living somewhere else as so many
hundreds of people could. He thought its something that needs addressed.
The next speaker �vas Barbra Filson of 3716 S. Florida. She would like to go on record to present
her lerter. Livina right there on Florida, the noise, the traffic and trying to get out onto Florida is
already immense. The traffic of Caldwell High School would be coming out onto Georgia and
across onto Florida. That is going to be more tra�c besides what we've got from Central Canyon
and Vallivue HiQh School traffic that comes ciown that road. She emphasized that she highly
objected to this development.
The next speaker was Bill Van Sickle of 3405 Starlight. He is opposed to this project. Take
mathematics and figure that two hundred and fifly some homes with a half inch water pipe going to
them. That's fifty square inches of water pipe. There's an eight inch riser coming out there. An
eight i.nch riser fi�ures out to just a little over fifty square inches of water. They can not justify
saying that all the homes that are already in there will be adequate with fifty square inches. Traffic
density, when he moved there were just corn fields in the backyard. There were only four homes in
the whole area. When he retired out of the Navy he wanted to go to a place that wasn't quite as busy.
So he came to Caldwell. He knew that the Commission was going to deny this, but he will come
back on City Council night to argue. He wanted it on record that he is highly opposed to this project.
The next speaker was Valerie Kelly of 2720 Beech. She stated that she is opposed to it. When the
adult trailer court was supposed to go in, Cherry Street was supposed to be paved, the storage
building was supposed to be landscaped, none of these things were done. She is not sure who is
supposed to follow-up on this stuff, but its never been done. There's always a beautiful picture
painted, but when it gets out there, that's not what it looks like. Nobody from the city has ever done
anything about making it look like what it was suppose to look like.
The next speaker was Brian Finley of 2716 Beech Street. There's going to be a lot of traffic going
down Beech. Then when you put in this little beauty, you've got hundreds maybe thousands cars
it going to be a major intersection on Cleveland. There is going to have to be at least a four lane road
up through Florida, and there's going to be many other dangers to that. So that's a major
consideration. There may need to be a tra�c light put in there. He brought up a point about
housing. He fumly believed his housing values are not going up as much as they would have if he
had a similar home across the street from his house. He doesn't want to live near that. He felt it
should go back to the continuity of the neighborhood. He thanked the Commission for dedicating
their time and energy to this effort. He hoped the Commission could stick to the Comprehensive
Plan and it would continue to be a very good tool for everyone to use so that very sound principles
are the bases of planning and zoning decisions. He also hoped t�ie City Council agrees with the
Commission.
The next speaker was Darcy Maag of 3611 S. Florida. He would like to go on record as opposing
the planned development. He presented to the Commission a petition that he had put together, and
questioned if it would go forward to the City Council.
�Ir. Christopher stated the Commission could direct staff to send the petition to City Council.
l2Mi� �VPD - ; 6
�
+ Mr. Maag would like to clear up some misconceptions about the traffic on Florida. He had done a
little research. It seems more than anyone had done and it was tough. He had to go across the hall
from the Planning Department. June 3, 1996, J.U.B. did a traffic count, there were sixteen hundred
and thiriy eight cars a day that traveled Florida Ave. He had J.U.B. fax him some information that
is on his petition that according to the estimates its going to put twelve hundred and fi$een more cars
a day on Florida havinQ a development of this size with a peak traffic count of three hundred. He
thanked the Commission for their time, and stated that he does object.
The next speaker was Steve Pease, 3522 S. Florida Avenue, who objected to the proposal.
Mr. Greene then gave his rebuttal. In regards to the rebuttal, he stated that when the Commission
moved on, they read the application throughly and their findings were with the application in mind.
Regarding the Comprehensive Plan and the Housing element with that in mind. He stated the
density for this project is no �eater than R-2. Take R-2 and look at the zoning, nine units per acre
net, and take the map its actually more than what the application proposed. Rental housing is
allowed in the R-2 zone. He defined that there is no difference between a manufactured home and
a mobile home other than being put down on a permanent foundation, hasn't been since 1976. It is
the only housing that comes under H.U.D. specifications. It is presently thirty-three percent of the
new housing in the United States.
Chairperson Pilote concluded the public hearing portion of the meeting.
Commissioner Roos stated in relationship to Special Use Permit procedures he read from City Code
10-03-04, paragraph l, every use which requires the granting of a Special Use Permit is declared to
poses characteristics which such as to require review and appraisal by the Commission to determine
whether the use would cause any damage, hazard, nuisance, or other determent to persons or property
in the vicinity. The Commission may require higher standards of site development than listed
specifically in this Chapter in order to correlate proposed use to other properry and uses. The
Commission may revoke or modify its approval of a Special Use Permit in accordance with
procedures as set forth in this section under specific conditions when it is not in conflict with the
Comprehensive Plan. He believed that even if this property were zoned as R-3 still requiring a
Special Use Permit for such a development that "other determent" to persons or property in the
vicinity would stand in this case. It would be detrimental to the neighborhood, in his opinion.
With regard to Findings of Fact, Commissioner Roos stated that the proposal is not in conformance
with the Comprehensive Plan Land Use Component in as much it is a use that is not allowable under
R-1 or R-2, which is our recommendation to the City Council and legal requirements have not been
met.
A motion was made by Commissioner Huyck to accept Commissioner Roos's Findings of
. Facts. It was seconded by Commissioner Buckendorf.
Roll Call Vote: Yes: Sonia Huyck, Madeline Buckendorf, William Roos, Bill Gilbert, Ron Reed.
No: None
Motion passed.
12M]N. WPD - 17
e
0
� Commissioner Roos concluded that this hearing was conducted in accordance with Idaho State Law.
That the proposal is not in harmony with the Comprehensive Plan and that it does pose a detrimental
effect of the residential neighborhood.
A motion was made by Commissioner Huyck to accept the Conclusion of Law as stated by
Commissioner Roos. It was seconded by Commissioner Buckendorf.
Roll Call Vote: Yes: Sonia Huyck, Madeline Buckendorf, William Roos, Bill Gilbert, Ron Reed
No: None
Motion passed.
A motion was made by Commissioner Roos to deny the S.U.P. 96-27 for Country Village based
on the Findings of Facts that it does not meet the requirements for a R-1 or R-2 neighborhood.
It was seconded by Commissioner Reed.
Roll Call Vote: Yes: William Roos, Ron Reed, Madeline Buckendorf, Sonia Huyck, Bill Gilbert
No: None
Motion passed.
Anyone interested in filing an appeal may contact the Planning and Zoning Department.
Chairperson Pilote stated that the Commission really appreciated the input. The Commission is
servants of the entire community and try to do so in everyone's best interest. Sometimes there are
no other choices when you don't know the feelings or concerns of everybody in the community. She
urged everyone to be as dedicated as other things come along, things that you read about that are not
necessarily going to impact you immediately but it will still impact you as the growth of Caldwell
continues. As the changes in Caldwell continue so we a11 can work together as a community to
come up with some really good answers here. The Commission did appreciate the audience's time
and Mr. Greene's time.
There being no further discussion, a motion was made by Commission Roos to adjourn. The motion
was seconded by Commissioner Reed. The meeting adjourned at 10:55 p.m.
l2MIN. WPD - 18