HomeMy WebLinkAbout9-19-1996 P&Z MINUTES ` I
PLANNING AND ZONING DEPARTMENT
' ' The City of Caldwell
. ,
NANCY HUFF
Planning 8 Zoning Oirector
621 CLEVELAND BLVD.
CALDWELL ID 83605
TELEPHONE 455-3021
� FAX 455-3003
MINUTES OF THE PLANl�TING AND ZOI�TING COMNIISSION
REi�ISED Meeting of September 19,1996
ROLL CALL:
Present: Madeline Buckendorf, Sonia Huyck, Bettie Pilote, William Roos, Bill Gilbert, Mike
Nachtigall
Absent: Ron Reed
Staff: Nancy Huff, Ed Christopher, and Debra Meyer
The regular meeting of the Planning and Zoni.ng Commission was called to order by Chairperson Bettie
Pilote, at 7:15 p.m., in the Caldwell City Hall Council Chambers.
MINUTES:
The first item of business was approval of the minutes for the previous meeting of August 22, 1996.
A motion was made by Commissioner Buckendorf that the August 22, 1996, Minutes be
approved as written. The motion was seconded by Commissioner Mike Nachtigall.
All in favor "Aye."
Opposed: None
Motion passed. _
�
The next item of business was the approval of the Facts and Conclusions. �
�4
�
�
A motion was made by Commissioner Roos that the Facts and Conclusions for Case #96-17-SUP, �
the Day Addition be approved as written. The motion was seconded by Commissioner NachtigalL �
All in favor "Aye."
_ Opposed: None
Motion passed.
MINUTES P&Z 9l19196
Page 1
PUBLIC HEARINGS:
The public hearing portion of the agenda then followed. Chairperson Pilote explained the procedure
for public hearings.
OLD BUSINESS
None
NEW BUSINESS
The first item was Case # 96-18-SUP, a Special Use Permit to construct a Church Multipurpose
Building at 903 N. Michigan Avenue.
Ed Christopher presented the staff report. The applicantlrepresentative for the Church of the Nazarene
was Randy Haverfield. All legal requirements were met. The application was for a Special Use Permit
to construct a multipurpose church building to be used for church related activities and functions. The
site plan contained a front yard set back reduction from twenty feet to eight feet. This deviation was to
facilitate a full-sized basketball court in the new building. The variables that the applicant had to work
with were an inegular lot and a sixteen foot high concrete retaining wall to the west. This created a
geographic hardship of topography.
Commissioner Buckendorf inquired about the landscaping. Mr. Christopher showed that the landscaping
consisted primarily of grass and low shrubs with some small trees. Commissioner Huyck inquired as
to the adequacy of the number of parking spaces available. Mr. Christopher stated that there would be
plenty of parking available. The new building would be occupied at different tunes and would utilize
the same parking lot as the church.
The representative of the church was Mr. Randy Haverfield. He resides at 1015 Heartland Drive in
Nampa. He stated that the new building would provide more indoor activities for the children in the
neighborhood. There would be more room for weddings and other church related functions.
Commissioner Buckendorf inquired as to the uses of the building. NIr. Haverfield stated that it would
be used for larger congregational worship services, particularly during the different holidays. It would
also provide indoor games for the children.
The next speaker was Mr. Don Mason, who resides at 1610 N. Ohio. He stated that the property would
not be leased out. He further stated that they had decided to keep the landscaping on a Iow level to
protect the view. ,
The third speaker was Lowell Rowley, who resides at 816 N. Middleton Rd., in Nampa. He stated that
he had been a member of the church for a number of years and was in favor of the project. He stated that
_ the new building would provide more fellowship area and provide more activities for the children.
The next speaker was Yvonne Stuart, who resides at 2216 Cari Circle. She stated that she was in favc�r
of the project. Mrs. Stuart wanted to have more room to have weddings and activities for the children.
MINUTES P&Z 9/19/96
Page 2
� i
' . i
- There being no further speakers, Chairperson Pilote closed the public hearing. Discussion from the
Commission ensued.
Commissioner Buckendorf stated she was in favor of the proposed project. She stated that it would
serve the neighborhood well. Commissioner Buckendorf also stated that Condition �=2 should be
deleted. She further stated that since the packets did not show the map as E�chibit A, it should be stated
in the motion.
It was the general consensus of the rest of the Commission that the plan was a good one. Chairperson
Pilote reminded the Commissioners that the motion should include the setback reductions.
A motion was made by Commissioner Huyck that Case # 96-18-SUP, a request for a Special Use
Permit to construct a multipurpose church building to be used for church related activiries and
functions be approved with the following change; replace Condition #2 to read as follows: The
Special Use Permit site plan includes a setback reduction from 20' to 8', as shown on Exhibit A.
The reasons for approval are:
1) The request meets the requirements of the Comprehensive Plan.
2) The proposal, as presented, will be compatible with the existing neighborhood.
3) The proposal meets the zoning ordinance requirements.
The motion was seconded by Commissioner Buckendorf.
Roll Call Vote: Yes: Sonia Huyck, Madeline Buckendorf, William Roos, Mike Nachtigall, Bill Gilbert
No: None
Motion passed.
Anyone interested in filing an appeal may contact the Planning and Zoning Department.
The next item was Case # 96-19-SUP, a Special Use Permit to construct and operate a Veterinary
Hospital at the southwest corner of Badiola Street and Chicago Street in the M-1 Zone.
Nancy Huff presented the staff report. All legal requirements had been met. The Caldwell Veterinary
Hospital had been in operation for 33 years. The current business had to be relocated and would
facilitate one partner, Gordon J. Cooper, D.V.M. The plot plan included a main building and future
addition, a paved parking area for customers, and a gravel parking area for employees. ,The parcel would
be accessible by two entrances ofF Badiola Street.
_ Chairperson Pilote declared a possible conflict of interest. She stated that she would chair the meeting
_ and restrain from any comment or discussion.
The applicant was Gordon Cooper, who resides at 920 W. Ash. He stated that he would have to re-
locate. His proposal includes landscaping with grass and shrubs and a nice looking building.
MINUTES P&Z 9/19/96
Page 3
There w�as much concem over whether or not Mr. Cooper would be housing large animals for an ��
' extended period of tune. vlx. Cooper assured the Commission that he very seldom housed large animals.
He normally sent larQer animals to the hospital in Nampa. Mr. Cooper also stated that he would make
proper provisions for the �-ray chemicals to be disposed of.
Commissioner Buc'::endorf inquired about the possible paving of the employee parking area. Mr. Cooper
replied that he �vould not do that at this time. He stated that the empioyees could park on the asphalt area
if thev v�
The first speaker v��as Rick Kushlan, who resides at 18397 Pride Lane. He provided a set of plans for
the Commission to � He clarified the landscaping for Commissioner Buckendorf.
There bein� no furthzr speakers, Chairperson Pilote declared the public hearing closed. Discussion from
the Commission ensued.
The consensus of the Commission was that it would improve the area.
A motion was made b� Commissioner Roos that Case # 96-19-SUP, a request for a Special Use
Permit to construct and operate a Veterinary Hospital be approved as presented, for the following
reasons:
1 j The request meets the requirements of the Comprehensive Plan.
2) The proposal, as presented, will be compatible with the ea�isting neighborhood.
3) The proposal meets fhe Zoning Ordinance requirements.
The morion was seconded by Commissioner Huyck
Roll Call Vote: Yes: William Roos, Sonia Huyck, Mike Nachtigall, Bill Gilbert
Ab�tain: Madeline Buckendorf
No: None
Morion passed.
Anyone interested i.n filing an appeal may contact the Planning and Zoning Department.
The neYt item was Case # 96-07-SUB, a request for the Commission to review a small change by the
applicant in the pro�ession of development to accomplish a systematic development pattern. Phase II
of the Sunridge Subdivision, formerly Phase III, is a 171ot portion of this project and included paved
streets, curbs, gutters, and sidewalks. -
Chairper�on Pilote declared a conflict of interest and the hearing was chaired by Vice-Chairperson
_ Huyck.
Ed Christophe: presented the staff report. He stated that all legal requirements had been met. The
Preliminary Plat application for the Sunridge Subdivision was approved by the Planning and Zoning
Commission on April 7. 1994. Phase I was finalized in April of 1995. The applicant has chosen *.o
MINUTES PB�Z: ?9l96
Page 4
' i
develo next to Phase I and call it Phase II rather than 'um in to the other side of the ro'ect. This
P
J P g
P J
• change is a systematic and logical development.
The applicant was represented bv Becky Bowcutt, of Briggs Engineering, 11 ll S. Orchard, Suite b00,
Boise, Idaho.
Ms. Bowcutt stated that this chanQe was systematic with the development of the subdivision. She further
stated that they would meet and comply with all standards and requirements set forth by jurisdictional
letters. She fiu stated that they acknowledged that an approval letter from Pioneer Irrigation District
would be required as well as approval from the City Engineer.
Commissioner Buckendorf questioned whether or not the applicant understood that the City Council
would have fmal approval. Ms. Bowcutt stated that she understood that the City Council would do that.
There being no further speakers, Vice-Chairperson Huyck closed the public hearing. Discussion from
the Commission ensued. It was the general consensus of the Commission that this change provided for
a systematic development pattern.
A motion was made by Commissioner Nachtigall that Case # 96-07-SUB, a request to change
Phase III to Phase II of the Sunridge Subdivision be recommended to City Council for approval
for the following reasons:
1) The request meets the requirements of the Comprehensive Plan.
2) The proposal, as presented, will provide a more systematic development plan.
3) The proposal meets the Zoning Ordinance requirements.
The motion was seconded by Commissioner Buckendorf.
Roll Call Vote: Yes: Mike Nachtigall, Madeline Buckendorf, Bill Gilbert, William Roos
No: None
Motion passed.
Anyone interested in filing an appeal may contact the Planning and Zoning Department.
The next item was Case # 96-01-DAN, a recommendation to the City Council for de-annexation and
zone classification for property located at 5411 E. Cleveland Blvd.
Nancy Huff presented the staff report. The property is located at 5411 Cleveland Bl�d., and known
as Farwell Auto Body, Inc. I`he rezone would de-annex from City C-3 and become County C-3. The
property consisted of a house, field and Parts, inc. The de-annexation would result in the property
reverting back to County C-3. The City has supported this process and an agreement has been entered
. into the by the apnlicant and the City for annexation to take place sometime after five (5) years.
All legal requirements had been met.
MINUTES P&Z 9/19/96
Pa;e �
- The applicant was Wayne Farwell, who resides at �014 E. Ustick Road.
There being no further speakers, Chairperson Pilote closed the public hearing. Discussion from the
Commission ensued. Commissioner Gilbert stated that this was just a formality.
A motion was made by Commissioner Nachtigall that Case # 96-01-DAN, a request for de-
annexation, be recommended to City Council for approval for the following reason:
1) The request meets the requirements of the Comprehensive Plan.
The motion was seconded by Commissioner Buckendorf. '
Roll Call Vote: Yes: Mike Nachtigall, Madeline Buckendorf, Bill Gilbert, William Roos, Sonia
Huyck
No: None
Motion passed.
Anyone interested in filing an appeal may contact the Plannina and Zoning Department.
Chairperson Pilote then closed the public hearings.
The next item of business was a video entitled "A Mock Commission Hearing", by the APA. The
Commission decided that they would not view the video at the meeting. It was agreed that each
Com.missioner would view the video in their home and then pass it on to the next commission member..
The next item of business concemed the fact that Commissioner Ron Reed had missed six consecutive
meetings. The Commission decided that they would send a letter to Mr. Reed advising him that if he
missed another meeting, the Commission would have no other recourse but to notify the Mayor to take
further action. Commissioner Buckendorf, as Secretary, would draft the letter to Mr. Reed.
Chairperson Pilote recognized Mr. Robert Vasquez, Assistant to the Mayor. Mr. Vasquez introduced
himself to the Commission. He stated that as of October 1, 1996, he would be the Department Head for
the Planning and Zoning Department and the Building Department, as well as others that had been
assigned to him. He stated that he would not have direct hands on operation of these departments.
However, he requested that any issues or concerns be brought to his attention. He further stated that he
would speak to the staff and hopefully this would facilitate quick resolutions to any issues or concerns
that may arise. Mr. Vasquez also informed the Commission that part of his oversight would be to offer
direction if it is needed or interpretation if it's required. He reminded the Commissior�that the Mayor
is the ultimate responsible party. If for any reason the Commission is not happy with a direction that he
may give or an interpretation that he might make, they may speak with the Mayor at any time.
_ Commissioner Buckendorf welcomed Mr. Vasquez. She stated that she would Iike to see better
communication between the Commission, the City Council and the staff. She stated that especially with
the survey results, she would like to see a meeting with the City Council and staffto discuss some of the
MIfvUTES P&Z 9/19/96
Page 6
• issues that the public brought up. iVlr. Vasquez stated that he appreciated the fact that Commissioner
' Buckendorf brought that to his attention. He stated that he would present her suggestion to the Mayor.
Chairperson Pilote inquired if this included legal issues. Mr. Vasquez stated yes it does. Chairperson
Pilote stated that they would present any legal questions to Mr. Vasquez and he would then provide the
Commission with the appropriate information.
The Commission thanked Mr. Vazquez.
There being no further discussion, Chairperson Pilote adjourned the meeting at 10:00p.m.
MINUTES P&Z 9/19/96
Page 7