Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout7-18-1996 P&Z MINUTES � PLANNING AND ZONING DEPARTMENT 4 � ' The City of Caldwell , � NANCY HUFF Planning 8 Zoning Director 621 CLEVELAND BLVD. CALDWELL ID 83605 TELEPHONE 455-3021 • FAX 455-3003 MINUTES OF THE PLAN1vING AND ZOIYING CONIlVIISSION Meeting of July 18, 1996 ROLL CALL: Present: Madeline Buckendorf, Sonia Huyck, Bettie Pilote, William Roos, Bill Gilbert, Ron Reed, Mike Nachtigall Absent: None Staff: Nancy Huff, Ed Christopher, and Debra Meyer The regular meeting of the Planning and Zoning Commission was called to order by Chairperson Bettie Pilote, at 7:15 p.m., in the Caldwell City Hall Council Chambers. MINUTES: The first item of business was approval of the minutes for the previous meeting of June 20, 1996. A motion was made by Commissioner Huyck that the June 20, 1996, minutes be approved as amended. The motion was seconded by Commissioner Roos. All in favor "Aye." Opposed: None Motion passed. PUBLIC HEARINGS: The public hearing portion of the agenda then followed. Chairperson Pilote explained the procedure for public hearings. OLD BUSINESS None MINUTES P&Z 7/18/96 Page i NEW BUSINESS � The first item was Case # 96-13-SUB, a Special Use Permit request for a Spanish Pentecostal Church � that would be located on the southeast corner of N. Third Avenue. ' Ed Clu presented the staff report. All legal requirements were met. The applicant is requesting to construct and operate a traditional church building. The structure is designed with a focal entry and simplified cross. The building has an open vaulted ceiling in the sanctuary and gabled in the classroom and nursery. The approximate capacity is 270 people. Comments were received from the DEQ, Caldwell City Engineering and the Caldwell Fire Department. The applicant was represented by Danny Ayala, who resides at 11834 Bonnie Lane in Caldwell. Commissioner Gilbert expressed concern over whether or not there would be adequate parking. The applicant stated that they would meet all necessary standards and requirements, including curbs and gutters. Corrunissioner Buckendorf asked the applicant if he had read the conditions of approval. The applicant stated that he had and that he agreed with them. The first speaker was Marvie Thomas who resides at 320 Joliet Street. He was in opposition of the project. He stated that there would be too much noise. There being no further speakers, Chairperson Pilote gave the applicant a chance to provide rebuttal. The applicant's representative, Daniel Ayala stated that the church would only be open approximately six (6) hours per week. He did not feel that the noise would be a big problem. Ed Christopher stated that the parking lot would be adequate for 140 people. Ms. Huff stated that she had verified the parking with the architect. Chairperson Pilote then declared the public hearing closed. Discussion from the Commission ensued. Commissioner Huyck stated that all comments had been received from the City Engineering Department ad the Fire Department. The applicant had agreed to the conditions as set forth by staff. Therefore, she thought it would be a good addition to the neighborhood. A motion was made by Commissioner Nachtigall that Special Use Permit #96-13-SUP be approved for the following reasons: 1) It meets the requirements as set forth in the Caldwell Comprehensive Plan. 2) The applicant has agreed with conditions as stipulated by staff. The motion was seconded by Commissioner Reed. Roll Call Vote: Yes: Mike Nachtigall, Ron Reed, Madeline Buckendorf, Sonia Huyck, William Roos, Bill Gilbert No: None MINUTES P&Z 7/18/96 Pa;e 2 Motion passed. � Anyone interested in filing an appeal may contact the Planning and Zoning Department. The next item was Case # 96-14-SUP, a Special Use Permit request to operate an Ex�resso Shon on the northeast corner of 21 st Avenue and Chicago Street. Commissioner declared a conflict of interest and requested that she be able to abstain from voting, but be able to ask questions. Chairperson Pilote stated as long as she was only asking questions and not participating in the discussion that it would be fine. Ed Christopher presented the staff report. All legals had been met. Commissioner Buckendorf asked staff about the three (3) feet of right-a-way. Mr. Christopher stated that Engineering had approved this. Commissioner Buckendorf also inquired about the setbacks in reference to the drive through. Mr. Christopher stated that the setbacks were 20' and that the applicant had made provisions for this. The applicant was Jeff Swanson, who resides at 2412 E. Chicago Street. He stated that he had a modular structure designed for the location. Commissioner Huyck asked if he agreed to the conditions as set forth by staff. Mr. Swanson stated that he did. Chairperson Pilote asked if he would agree to a review in a year's time. The applicant stated that he would. There being no speakers signed up to speak, Chairperson Pilote declared the public hearing closed. Discussion within the Commission ensued. Chairperson Pilote re-opened the public hearing to allow the applicant to respond to questions concerning the landscaping of the location. Mr. Swanson stated that there would be some landscaping. Chairperson Pilote then closed the public hearings and discussion continued within the Commission. Commissioner Huyck stated that landscaping should be added to the conditions of the Special Use Permit. Chairperson Pilote suggested that it be added to Condition #7 and that it read "it shall be maintained ". Commissioner Gilbert inquired about water and sewer. Chairperson Pilote stated that the applicant would hook into city water and would keep portable sewerage (self-contained) and would have to have it pumped monthly or sooner if necessary. A motion was made by Commissioner Reed that Case # 96-14-SUP, a request to operate an Expresso Shop on the northeast corner of 21st Avenue and Chicago Street be approved for the following reasons: 1) It meets the requirements as set forth in the Caldwell Comprehensive Plan. 2) The applicant has agreed with conditions as stipulated by staff. The motion was seconded by Commissioner Nachtigall. MINUTES P&Z 7/18/96 Page 3 Roll Call Vote: Yes: Ron Reed, Mike Nachtigall, Bill Gilbert, William Roos, Sonia Hu��ck . Abstain: Madeline Buckendorf No: None Motion passed. Anyone interested in filing an appeal may contact the Planning and Zoning Department. The next item was Case # 96-15-SUP, a Special Use Permit request to operate a Beau ,ty Sho� at 1�O 1 S. Kimball Avenue. Nancy Huffpresented the staff report. The applicant and one other stylist plan to operate form 8:30 a.m. to 5:00 p.m. weekdays and occasionally on Saturday. In addition to on-street parking, the applicant shall construct seven off-street parking spaces which include one handicapped parking space. All legals had been met. Commissioner Buckendorf stated concerns over the number of parking spaces. The applicant was represented by Kevin Doser, who resides at 420 7th Street in Nampa, Idaho. Mr. Doser stated that they had reviewed the criteria and conditions for the permit. He also stated that they agree to them. Mr. Doser further stated that he had read the opposition letter from Ms. Shanna Ascuena Liles ( a copy of which is hereby made an addendum to these Minutes.) and her �ave concern over the possible influ�c of traffic. Mr. Doser stated that there would be two (2) chairs in the shop. The hours of operation would be during the daytime. He related to the Commission that they plan on having a nice sign placed properly and within the Sign Ordinance allowances. He stated that there would be landscaping. Mr. Doser requested an extension of the asphalting of the parking lot until Mid-October, 1996. Commissioner Huyck inquired as to where the clients would park while everything was under construction. Commissioner Buckendorf expressed concern over the noise and dust. The Commission expressed concern over the parking anangements and the period of time requested for asphalting. NIr. Doser cited fmancial reasons for not obtaining the asphalt at this time. The second speaker was Linda Doser, who passed. Chairperson Pilote closed the public hearings and discussion from the Commission ensued. There were several concerns expressed over the parking spaces. Mr. Christopher stated that Condition #9 covered the parking spaces. Mr. Christopher also stated that the request to defer the asphalting could be made Condition #12. A motion was made by Commissioner Roos that Case # 96-15-SUP, a request to operate a Beau Shon at 1501 S. Kimball Avenue be approved with the addition of Condition #12, which states that the parking lot will be asphalted no later than November 1, 1996, for the following reasons: 1) It meets the requirements as set forth in the Caldwell Comprehensive Plan. 2) Low impact on area. , 3) The applicant has agreed with conditions as stipulated by staff. MINUTES P8Z 7/18/96 Page 4 The motion was seconded by Commissioner Gilbert. Roll Call Vote: Yes: William Roos, Bill Gilbert, Ron Reed, Mike Nachtigall, Sonia Huyck, Madeline Buckendorf No: None Motion passed. Anyone interested in filing an appeal may contact the Planning and Zoning Department. The next item was Case # 96-16-SUP, a Special Use Permit to operate a Bicycle Race Track on a small irregular portion of property owned by the City of Caldwell. Ed Christopher presented the staff report. The applicant requests to operate a bicycle (BNIX) race track on a small irregular portion of properry owned by the City . The activities occur from April to September. The track consists of a series of jumps and turns designed to challenge young bicyclists. A building would be placed on the site to house the concession stand, registration room and restrooms. The City had committed to providing an access road and parting lot. The track is watered prior to practices and races. A non-illuminated sign would be built on the southeast corner of the property and would be located six feet inside of the fences. All legal requirements had been met. The Fire Department and the City Engineer's office provided requirements and comments. The applicant was represented by Ken Crosby, who resides at 14823 Helen Lane. Mr. Crosby stated that he would provide storm drainage on-site and would make provisions for the requirements of the Fire Department. He further stated that he would provide a park-like setting. This would include grass, trees, fencing, etc. Chairperson Pilote then closed the public hearings and discussion from the Commission ensued. Commissioner Huyck inquired if this request had gone before the City Council. Nancy Huff responded the only the lease had ben heard at City Council. Commissioner Huyck requested that Condition #7 be made a part of the Conditions of Approval and should read as follows: Condition #7. Applicant shall landscape with grass and trees. A motion was made by Commissioner Huyck that Case # 96-16-SUP, a request to operate a bicycle (BMX) race track be approved with Condition #7 (as stated above) added for the following reasons: 1) It meets the requirements as set forth in the Caldwell Comprehensive Plan. 2) The applicant is all ready doing business there. 3) The applicant has agreed with conditions as stipulated by staff. The motion was seconded by Commissioner Nachtigall. MINUTES PB�Z 7/18/96 Page 5 Roll Call Vote: Yes: Sonia Huyck, Mike Nachtigall, William Roos, Bill Gilbert, Ron Reed, iVladeline Buckendorf No: None Motion passed. Anyone interested in filing an appeal may contact the Planning and Zoning Department. The next item was Case # 96-04-ANN, a request to annex property located at 3708 Idaho Avenue. This request is based on the applicant's desire to hook into Caldwell City sewer services due to failing leach lines. Chairperson Pilote declared a conflict of interest and Vice-Chairperson Huyck presided over the hearing. Nancy Huff presented the staff report. The applicants requested annexation of their properry to the City of Caldwell. This request was based on failing leach lines. All legal requirements had been met. The applicant was David Smith, who resides at 3708 S. Montana. Commissioner Roos asked if the applicant owned the easement. Mr. Smith replied that he owned it. Vice-Chairperson Huyck stated that there was much concern over the shallow irrigation and high water table. Vice-Chairperson Huyck closed the public hearings and discussion from the Commission ensued. It was agreed that the Commission saw the problem with the sewer as a health concern. A motion was made by Commissioner Roos that Case # 96-04-ANN , a request for annexation, be recommended to City Council for approval, for the following reasons: 1) The property meets the Comprehensive Plan of the City of Caldwell. 2) The property being in the Area of Impact and adjacent to the city limits is an orderly development of the City. 3) The request is to correct a public health concern. The motion was seconded by Commissioner Reed. Roll Call Vote: Yes: William Roos, Ron Reed, Mike Nachtigall, Bill Gilbert, Madeline Buckendorf No: None Motion passed. Anyone interested in filing an appeal may contact the Planning and Zoning Department. MINUTES P&Z 7/18l96 Page 6 , , Chairperson Pilote declared the public hearings closed. It was decided that the Commission would not meet on August 15, 1996. The date of the next meeting was changed to August 22, 1996. Chairperson Pilote adjourned the meeting at 9:30 p.m. i MINUTES P&Z 7/18/96 Page 7