HomeMy WebLinkAbout5-16-1996 P&Z MINUTES � PLANNING AND ZONING DEPARTMENT
� The City of Caldwell
NANCY HUFF
Planning & Zoning Director
621 CLEVELAND BLVD.
CALDWELL ID 83605
TELEPHONE 456�3021
FAX 456-3003
Revised
MINUTES OF THE PLANNING AND ZONING COMMISSION
Meeting of May 16, 1996
ROLL CALL:
Present: Daniel Ozuna, Madeline Buckendorf, Sonia Huyck, Bettie Pilote, William Roos, Mike
Nachtigall, Bill Gilbert
Absent: Ron Reed
Staff: Nancy Huff, Ed Christopher, Dehra Meyer, and Richard Harris, City Attorney
The regular meeting of the Planning and Zoning Commission was called to order by Chairperson Bettie
Pilote, at 7:15 p.m., in the Galdwell City Ha11 Council Chambers.
MINUTES:
The first item of business was approval of the minutes for the previous meeting of April 18, 1996.
A motion was raade by Commissioner Huyck that the April 18, 199b, minutes be approved as
amended. The�rotion was seconded by Commissioner Buckendorf.
�
All in favoL`�ye."
Opposed: None
Motion passed.
ACCEPTANCE �F FACTS AND CONCLUSIONS:
The ne� item of business was the Acceptance of Facts and Conclusions for the following:
* 96-08-SUP, a Special Use Permit for a reader boaxd sign for Vallivue School at 1409
Homedale Road
* 96-OS-SUP, a Preliminary Plat approval for a Senior Assisted Living Facility on W.
Beech Street
* 96-03-ANN, a request for annexation and zone change to C4-AP for property located
at 1311 Andy Lane
MINUTES P&Z 5J16/96
Page 1
„ . ��
� A motion was made by Commissioner Huyck that the Facts and Conclusions for the above
referenced case numbers be approved. The motion was seconded by Commissioner Roos. I
. i
All in favor "Aye.”
Opposed: None
Motion passed. I
PUBLIC HEARINGS: I
The public hearing portion of the agenda then followed. Chairperson Pilote explained the procedure for
public hearings.
OLD BUSINESS
None
NEW BUSINESS
The first item was Case # 96-10-SUP, a Special Use Permit request for the construction of a ball
field and associated services located at the corner of Linden Street and S. 14th Avenue. The
applicant was the First Christian Church.
Ed Christopher presented the staff report. All legal requirements were met. The requested site for the
ball field is also a future site for a new church. In addition to the ball field, a concession building would
be built. The structure would be a modern type building that would consist of a kitchen, bathrooms,
storage area, and a covered patio. The building would meet all the requirements of the building
department and the American Disabilities Act.
The applicant was represented by Dan Roberts. He gave his address as 16358 Linden. He stated that
the church owned the property and that the field would not be leased. He further stated that it would be
sodded and maintained.
Commissioner Buckendorf asked whether or not there would be a buffer zone and/or fencing to separate
the azea from the other neighbors. Mr. Roberts stated that there were some neighbor complaints on that
issue. He was not sure if there would be adequate funding for a fence or netting at this time.
Commissioner Huyck asked about the gravel and dust problem. Mr. Roberts stated that they would
water the gravel down as necessary to keep the dust to a minimum. Commissioner Buckendorf asked
the applicant if he had read the conditions as set by staff and if he agreed with them. He stated that he
had read them and he did agree with them. Commissioner Gilbert expressed his concem over providing
bu�ering between the residerrts on Linden and the ba11 field. Mr. Roberts stated that there were none at
this time. The ba11 field would be 50' from the property line and approximately 40' from the base path
to the property line.
There being no further questions of the applicant, Chairperson Pilote excused the applicant and reminded
him that he would be able to give rebuttal after all of the speakers that were signed up were heard.
MINUTES P8Z 5/16/96
Page 2
�' }
The first speaker was Bev Larsen who resides at 2403 So. lOth Avenue. She stated that building a
church was okay, but was not pleased with a baseball field for the following reasons:
1. Traffic would greatly increase.
2. The noise would be increased. '
;. The gravel parking lot would stir up a lot of dust.
4. The concession stands and restrooms would be located off a very busy street.
5. There would be the problem of people loitering there and possible vandalism.
The second speaker was Stan Larsen who resides at 2403 S. l Oth Avenue. He stated that his reasons for
being against the ball field were the same as Bev's.
The third speaker was Barbara Precht who resides at 2417 S. l Oth Avenue. She was opposed to the ba11
field for the same reasons listed above.
The fourth speaker was Sara Denney who resides at 605 East Linden. She was also against the ball field.
She read a letter that she sent to the Planning and Zoning Department. Her main concerns were the
parking, the noise and the traffic.
The fifth speaker was Duane Darbin who passed.
The sixth speaker was Joe DuBose who resides at 506 E. Linden Avenue. He stated that he lives next
to the proposed pazking area.. He would like to see a fence between him and the parking lot. He stated
that it would be a bad place for kids to hang out there.
The seventh speaker was Dorothy DuBose who resides at 506 E. Linden Avenue. She stated that there
would need to be a fence and a buffer zone with a gate to keep the kids from congregating. She was also
concerned about the field being maintained and not to have a fire hazard.
The eighth speaker was Liz Madson who resides at 520 E. Linden Avenue. She was opposed to the ball
field for the same reasons as stated previously. She also stated that she felt that her property taxes would
go up with a ball field there. She felt that if she had to pay increased t�es, she would rather it be because
of a house going up there.
Chairperson Pilote asked the applicant to give rebuttal. Mr. Roberts responded to the various concerns.
He stated that the ball field would be watered regularly as would be the gravel parking lot. He stated that
he did not have any answers to the possibility of vandalism. He stated that traffic would not be a problem
as the activities at the field would take place at low traffic times (after 6 p.m. on week days or on
weekends). He stated that the field would be permanent, not temporary. He further stated that the
parking lot would have more than ample parlang area. for 30-40 cars at any one time. He also stated that
they would take care of the weeds. He said that they are not opposed to putting up a solid fence.
However, there was not enough money to do thax at this time. He stated that it would take up to maybe
five (5) years for the church to have the money to put up the fence. He stated that he did not know how
it would affect the taxes of the other neighbors. The Commission expressed concern over the gravel
parking lot. Mr. Roberts stated that the gravel parking lot would be paved when the new church was
built. Commissioner Buckendorf requested clarification of the intended use by church leagues.
MINUTES P&Z 5/16/96
Page 3
,' t
� Mr. Roberts stated that there were 18 church leagues, but thax they wouldn't be playing at this field all
of the time. There would be approxirriately 50 people at the field at one time. Commissioner Nachtigall
� inquired as to why they wanted to build the ball field and concession house before the new church. Mr.
Roberts replied that the church had owned the land for some time and that the church politics were
dictating that something should be done with the land now.
Chairperson Pilote then closed the public hearing and discussion from the Commission ensued.
The Commission was unanimously opposed to the idea. of the ball field before the new church being built.
There was also no money for fencing, the netting could not be in place for a year, and the parking lot
would not be paved for at least five (5) yeazs. The consensus of the Commission was that there needed
to be fencing and netting to protect the other residences. Commissioner Huyck stated that while she
could appreciate the applicant's position, he was not in a monetary position to be able to feasibly meet
the conditions that the Commission would impose at this time. Commissioner Gilbert concuned with
Commissioner Huyck and stated tha.t the Commission must consider the neighboring residences a.nd that
the project was not acceptable at this time.
A motion was made by Commissioner Nacbtigall that Case # 96-10-SUP, a request for the
construction of a ball field and associated services located at the corner of Lindea Street and S.
lOth be disapproved as per the Comprehensive Plan P.22, item 12, as it does not minimize
potential adverse impacts on a residential neighborhood. Commissioner Gilbert seconded the
Motion.
Roll Call Vote: Yes: Mike Nachtigall, Bill Gilbert, Daniel Ozuna, Madeline Buckendorf, Sonia Huyck,
William Roos
No: None
Motion passed.
Anyone interested in filing an appeal may contact the Planning and Zoning Department.
The ne� item was Case # 96-11-SUP, a request that an ezisting structure be ailowed to be
converted into a training facility. The applicant is the Lighthouse Developmental Agency, Inc.
Ed Christopher presented the staff report. He stated that all legal requirements had been met. The
applicant wishes to remodel the vacant building into a training center. He related that staff had received
many comments from adjacent property owners requesting bu�ering of the parlQng area and about paving
the pazking area to help control the dust.
Chauperson Pilote reminded the speakers that due to the many speakers signed up tonight, the time limits
for speaking would be strictly adhered to. Chairperson Pilote then recognized William Gigray III. Mr.
Gigray III related to the Chairperson and Commissioners that in order to move things quickly, he would
speak on behalf of the neighbors in attendance. Chairperson Pilote stated that his request would be a11
right. The Chairperson then asked that when she called the names of the speakers that they si� that
Mr. Gigray is responding on their behalf and then they may elect to pass.
MINUTES P8Z 5/16/9b
Page 4
, �
� The applicant was represented by Doug White, who resides at 414 Sunnyside in Caldwell. He stated that
this would be a development training center for disabled persons. There would be no weekend activity.
• He stated that he met with the Homeowner's Association last Thursday and addressed some of their
concerns. He stated that he would provide some landscapinQ, but that they would not be able to pave
the whole gravel parking area. He stated that they would be putting up fencing. He also stated that there
was increasing concern from the Neighborhood Association that they would become a commercial
enterprise in terms of possibly leasing the top floor of the building. He stated that they had no intention
of using the upper floor, with the exception of some staff offices. He reiterated that they would not be
manufacturing or selling anything. Commissioner Huyck inquired as to the number of students they would
have. Mr. White stated that they would be licensed for 24 students and have 2 teachers and 6 to 8
therapy techs or education aides.
The first speaker was Art Scovell Sr., another representative of the applicant, who resides at 2521 �
Norman Street in Caldwell. He asked if the Commission had any questions for him. Commissioner
Buckendorf inquired about the landscaping and buffering. Mr. Scovell replied that the large parking lot
would be cleaned up and many of the shrubs taken out. In place of the shrubs would be small trees.
There would be low shrubs placed among the trees with bark chips. He stated that they would asphalt
a portion of the paxking lot with proper drainage provided. He stated there would be a street light on
either side of the parking lot.
Commissioner Gilbert stated that he had done business with Art Scovell before and he excused himself
from this hearing as it presented a conflict of interest.
The first speaker was Steven Maughan. He sta.ted that he thought that Mr. Gigray III would present the
argument. Chairperson Pilote stated that she thought it would be in the best interest of all if NIr. Gigray
would speak first and then proceed down the list of names.
Mr. William Gigray III was then called to the podium. He gave his residence as 1523 Dearborn in
Caldwell. He stated thax he has owned and resided in that property since 1977. He opposed the granting
of the application on the basis that the subject property is located in a R-2 zone and as presented does
not qualify as a school or as other public or quasi public use as required in the § 10-02-02 Table 1 Land
Use Schedule.
The following items are attached to these Minutes as e�ibits in support of Mr. Gigray's testimony:
Exhibit A Opposition Statement Wm. F. Gigray, III
E�ibit B Uniform Building Code - Chapter 8- Requirements for Group E
Occupancies
E�ibit C IDAPA 16, Title 04, Chapter 11 - Rules and Minimum Standards
Governing Developmental Disabilities Centers
E�ibit D Signatures from neighborhood residences
Exhibit E § 10-02-02 Table 1 Land Use Schedule
Due to the length of the presentation by Mr. William Gigray, III, transcription of the tape will be made
available upon request
MINUTES P8Z 5/16/96
Page 5
�
Commissioner Roos stated that Mr. Gigray ha.d said that this use was not a school and inquired as to how
he would classify it. Mr. Gigray replied that he considered it a professional office. Mr. Gigray stated that
' they are providing a professional service for a fee.
The fourth speaker was Steve Maughan who resides at 1401 Cleveland Blvd. He stated that he
supported much of Mr. Gigray's testimony. He wanted to address the question of development along
Cleveland Boulevard. His concern was an increase in traffic and that the appearance along the boulevard.
He stated that if the Special Use Pernut was granted that a special performance requirement be very strict
in the kind of landscaping and overall general appearance of the project. He strongly opposed the project
unless the requirements that Mr. Gigray expressed were somehow guaranteed. He stated that he would
also require than the parking lot be paved prior to occupancy.
The fifth speaker was Elaine Hallstrom who passed.
The sixth speaker was Stephen Fisher who resides at 1615 Dearborn. He stated that he strongly opposed
the project. He stated that it did not qualify as a school. He further stated that according to the
Comprehensive Plan, H'istoric Neighborhoods should be enhanced, sustained and preserved. He related
specific statements from the Comprehensive Plan regarding commercial development within historic
neighborhoods. On Page 66, of the Comprehensive Plan, Housing Objective No. 5 stated that there is
need "to protect the integrity of residential neighbor hoods from intrusion of non-residential uses." On
Page 27 it states, " rehabilitation and improvement of the living environment should be encouraged in
older neighborhoods, thus retaining the residential character of areas that might otherwise be invaded
by commerciai development." He reiterated on the fact that the Comprehensive Plan specifically states
that it is important to the City of Caldwell to sustain the quality of life in its historic neighborhoods.
The seventh speaker was Bob Hallstrom who passed.
The eighth speaker was Jonathan Ball, who resides at 105 E. Homedale Road. He is a representative of
the applicant. He states that he has lived in Caldwell since 1949. He stated that they want to provide
better landscaping there. He stated that the building there now was in bad shape and that they want to
make a nice looking place there. He stated that they want to be good neighbors. They want to provide
a service for the handicapped individual. He stated that they are not a school. They are a training
facility. He stated that they are semi-public. They would provide a service to anyone needing it.
Commissioner Buckendorf asked if they were a profit making business. Mr. Ball stated that they were.
The ninth speaker was Tom Mallea who passed.
The tenth speaker was Pat Ma11ea, who resides at 1701 Dearborn. She stated that she was opposed to
the project. She stated that she did not want to see Cleveland Boulevard become commercial.
The eleventh speaker was Carole Munn who passed.
The twelth speaker was Monte Munn who resides at 1510 Dearborn. He opposed the project for the
same reasons as stated previously.
MINUTES P&Z 5/16/96
Page 6
. �
� The thirteenth speaker was Terry Mazurak who resides at 1602 E. Cleveland. He provided signatures
of 29 residents, all of whom opposed the project. The signatures are attached and made an Exhibit of
` these Minutes. He stated that they want to maintain the historic residential area of the City of Caldwell.
The fourteenth speaker was Maggie Shroud who passed.
The fifteenth speaker was Joy Bloch who resides at 1421 Dearborn. She stated that she opposed the
project. She reiterated the fact that maintaining the historic residential neighborhood was essential to the
history of the City of Caldwell.
The sixteenth speaker was Clark Brown who passed.
The seventeenth speaker was Buzz Beauchamp who resides at 1522 Dearborn. He opposed the project.
He wanted to keep the historical neighborhood. He stated that it would be a detriment to the
neighborhood.
The eighteenth speaker was Mike Stuits who passed.
There being no further speakers, Chairperson Pilote then asked the applicant for his rebuttal.
Mr. White stated tha.t they have a s� (6) month provisional license verbally from the state. He stated that
he would agree to widen the access driveway ne,�t to Mr. Gigray's property. He also stated that they do
not intend to place any more signs up than are all ready on the property.
Chaiiperson Pilote asked Mr. Christopher to please make the Commission some copies of his exhibits that
he provided in support of his testimony.
Commissioner Buckendorf asked Nancy Huff for clarification on whether or not the project consisted of
a school or a professional offce. Ms. Huff replied that is was semi-public according to what the applicant
represented to her in their application. If it was considered semi-public and a professional office, it would
need to be in an R-3 Zone.
Chairperson then closed the public hearing and discussion from the Commission ensued.
Commissioner Buckendorf stated that the primary issues were as follows:
a) Is this a professional office or a school?
and
b) How does this fit in with the Comprehensive Plan?
Commissioner Buckendorf stated that it is not a school and it does not fit in with the Comprehensive
Plan. She stated that it did not fit in the R-2 Zone. She opposed the project. ,
!
MINUTES P8Z S/1bi96
Page 7
Chairperson Pilote requested clarified with Mr. Harris, the City Attorney, on whether or not they should
� be concerned with the definition of the term school or professional o�ce. Mr. Harris responded that the
` whole thing evolves around the definition of the word school. He stated that he was surprised by the
applicant's stating that they aze not a school. He stated that his research that he had done so far indicated
that it could have gone both ways in terms of being a pernutted use in the area. He stated that the
applicarns have removed it from consideration themselves by admitting that they are not a school and they
are not treating themselves as a school. Since they were not pressing it as a school, it wasn't an issue any
longer. He stated that he thought that the whole application rested on whether or not they were
considering the project a school.
Commissioner Huyck stated that she opposed the project, based on information given by the City .
Attorney, Richard Harris.
A motion was made 6y Commissioner Buckendorf that Case # 96-11-SUP, a request to allow an
existing structure to be converted into a training facility, be denied. The reasons being that the
project is � professional facility which does not fit in the R-2 Zone and the Comprehensive Plan
specifically makes provisions for sustaining the historic residential areas of the City of Caldwell.
Commissioner Nachtigall seconded the Motion.
Roll Call Vote: Yes: Madeline Buckendor� Mike Nachtigall, Daniel Ozuna, Sonia Huyck, William Roos
Abstained: Bill Gilbert
No: None
Motion p�ssed.
Anyone interested in filing an appeal may contact the Planning and Zoning Department.
The ne� item was Case # 96-04-SUB, a r�uest for approval of the Preliminary Plat for High Point
Estates. The applicant is D.Duain and Shirley Ackerman.
Nancy Huff presented the staff report. She stated that all legal requirements had been met.
Commissioner Huyck stated that she thought that the Commission decided that they wanted these
applicaxions to be either a PUD or SUB, but not both. Ms. Huff stated that the application was a SUB
and that is what the Commission would hear tonight. Chairperson Pilote stated that it was a PUD. She
suggested that it be considered a PUD and that the Case Number be changed to reflect that.
Ted Hutchinson of Tealey's Land Surveying, represented the applicant. He resides at 109 S. 4th St. in
Boise. He stated that he wanted to make sure that the Commission had the new revised copy af the plat.
He stated that they were only gaing with 40 units, instead of 45 units. The other five units would be used
for common areas. He relayed that the development would be constructed in three (3) phases.
The next speaker was Dwain Ackerman who resides at 3616 So. Kimball Avenue. He stated that Mr.
Hutchinson had stated everything. He asked if there were any questions from the Commission.
Commissioner Huyck asked him if he had read and agreed to the conditions as set by staff. He stated that
he had and yes he agreed with them. Commissioner Huyck stated that she would like to add in Condition
#3 that it be a requirement. Mr. Ackerman said that would be fine with him.
MINUTES P&Z 5/16/96
Page 8
�
+� There being no further speakers, the Chairperson closed the public hearing and discussion from the
� Commission ensued.
A motion was made by Commissioner Roos that Case # 96-04-PUD, a request for approval of the
Preliminary Plat for High Point Estates be approved with Condition #3 to read Evidence of
Pioneer Irrigation a�Aroval shall be part of file and a requirement and that the title of the Case
# read 96-04-PUD. Commissioner Nachtigail seconded the Motion.
Roll Call Vote: Yes: William Roos, Mike Nachtigall, Bill Gilbert, Daniel Ozuna, Madeline Buckendorf,
Sonia Huyck
No: None
Motion passed.
Anyone interested in filing an appeal may contact the Planning and Zoning Department.
There being no further business Chairperson Pilote adjourned the meeting at 11:15 p.m.
i
MINUTES P&Z 5/16/96
Page 9