HomeMy WebLinkAbout12-14-1995 P&Z MINUTES �
PLANNING AND ZONING DEPARTMENT
� ��je �itp of t�CarbYneir
, , NANCY HUFF
Planning 8 Zoning Director
621 CLEVELAND BLVD.
CALDWELL ID 83605
TELEPHONE 455-3021
� FAX 455-3003
Minutes for the Planning and Zoning Commission
December 14,1995
ROLL CALL: Those present:
Madeline Buckendorf
Dorothy Davidson
Sonia Huyck
Terry McConnell
Bettie Pilote
Mike Nachtigall
Rick Wells
REVIEW OF MINUTES FOR DEC. 14, 1995:
The recording device did not work properly and the tape for the meeting was blank. A motion by
Commissioner Huyck was made to table the review of the minutes until the next meeting. T'his
would allow the members of the Planning and Zoning Commission time to submit their individual
changes. The motion was seconded by Commissioner Buckendorf and the suggestion was
unanimously passed.
ROLL CALL: Those for a yes: Buckendorf, Davidson, Huyck, McConnell, Pilote, Nachtigall
The Chairman, read procedures and purposes of public hearing meetings and then, he introduced the
Planning and Zoning Commissioners in attendance.
OLD BUSINESS:
1. G09PP-95: Request for a Special Use Permit/Planned Unit Development (PUD) and
Preliminary Subdivision Plat for Glenn Meadows Estates located on the East side of South
Indiana between Cherry and Beech streets. The applicant was Jim McCov.
Staff reviewed the project, and issues of the past and how they were resolved. Ms. Huff discussed
the findings of a site review done by Ed Christopher. Some questions were fielded:
a. concerns about a 6-foot fence enclosing the RV storage azea,
b the access and
c the drainage.
1
� I
- I
The waivers were addressed and passed by the City Council December 4, 1995. On site examination
and plan analysis, staff noted that the garages would be placed in the normal subdivision regulation
area of the 20ft front setback. Staff asked the Commission if they wanted to note this as an
additional waiver of deviation formally or was this included in the exceptions provided by
SUP/PUD. Staff suggested that setback requirements can be allowed under the Special Use
Permit/PUD as a final note. Ms. Huff also noted that the grass right-of-way would be modified to
be grass with CRETE supports to allow emergency vehicles access. In addition to these three
solutions submitted to Commission were two corrections to the documents. First, number five in
the condition: should read "south" instead of "north." Second a ot found in the early staff report
was supposed to be the word to. Ms. Huff sta.ted that Staff had corrected the master and file copies.
Applicant Jim McCoy residing at H.C. Box 79, Melba was then introduced to speak on the
application. He spoke about the design of the PUD and how the intent and design are based on
serving a senior citizen population rather than young, starter home markets. He discussed the added
common landscaping he would be providing at each homesite. A homeowner's association would
encourage a structure in which this would be maintained and assured through time. Mr. McCoy also
discussed that there would be no intemzption in the current irrigation drainage ditch and the
development would be serviced by city water, sewer and lights and utilize the ditch.
In response to questions from Commissioner Huyck, Mr. McCoy stated that all the manufactured
homes and installation would be provided through him. Once Alder street opened, the RV/storage
would be moved to the current emergency vehicle access since this area would no longer be needed
and drainage would be provided. These modifications would be shown on the final plat map.
Mr. McCoy then responded to Commissioner Buckendorf concerning the irrigation and landscaping.
McCoy stated that Lennie Freeman, of Pioneer Irrigation District and Ken Brush, a rancher and
appraiser, had been contacted and he was conf'ident that an agreement could be reached.
Commissioner Buckendorf responded that she would like to see the Engineering Department's
thirteen (13) concerns met prior to the final plat. Mr. McCoy also stated that the landscaping will
be low maintenance consisting of trees and shrubs.
Addressing the concerns of the Planning and Zoning Staff:
A. Th�emergency access would be paved with Crete blocks and then sodded as proposed
by the Fire Chief thus allowing the grass as well as providing support for emergency
vehicle passage.
B. Ms. Huff stated that the fence requirement must meet City standards and protect a
vision triangle at intersections. It may be included for special consideration under a
Special Use Permit (SUP), as a note. Mr. Christopher, verified that it would be
necessary to meet City standards and this would limit the available pazking in the RV
storage. Commissioner McConnell, stated that he would like to keep the fence for
the RV at the current 6-ft height. He suggested that the use of a chain link would
provide security as well as allowing the proper view.
2
`
C. The use of carports as Mr. McCoy described are optional but could possibly obstruct
vision of the street for drivers. Commissioner McConnell suggested that non-
enclosed carports would simply have a roof and would not obstruct the line of a site.
Commissioner Huyck suggested limiting landscaping and bushes to those that do not
bring about a vision problem.
Open Public Comment:
1. Testimony was given by Bob Allen, of 2209 Beech, concerning whether the azea and roads in the
area could handle the density of this project. The project seemed very dense. Staff responded after
acknowledgment from the Chairman, that the project complied with current zoning. Ms. Huff stated
that the proper zone was being used at the proper density. Mr. Allen further expressed concern for
the road width of Alder. With expanded use and development, as well as a new school in the area,
he felt the roads would not be adequate. Staff responded that the Department Heads of the
Engineering and the City Fire departments had approved the width of the street and reviewed for
emergency vehicle traffic flow. Commissioner Buckendorf noted that the traffic would be reduced
since this was to be a senior community. Mr. McCoy stated that it would be maintained through the
covenants.
2. Testimony was given by Joe Ison of 310 S. Indiana. He stated his concern with the width of the
road which had been addressed. He also voiced concem on the existing irrigation drain to users
down line. Commissioner Huyck clarified the concern was with the exiti.ng of water not the
servicing. Commissioner Buckendorf suggested not approving the plat until arrangements were
made with the Irrigation District. Commissioner Huyck agreed.
After fiirther discussion, Commissioner Huyck offered the motion to approve the Preliminary
Subdivision Plat subject to conditions amended as followed:
#5 Amended to say south ends of the easement.
#12 The 13 items raised by the city engineering office must be met before final
approval of the plat.
.
#13 Landscaping Requirements shall be part of this application and reviewed and
approved by the planning and zoning staff and installed before final occupancy.
#14 In the RV parking area a 6-ft fence shall be a chain link, see through, and no
shrubs planted in the RV area in order to preserve the vision triangle.
# 15 Optional carports shall be open carports for the safety of vision and pedestrian
and vehicular safety. This shall be enforced as part of the Planned Unit
Development/Special Use Pernut conditions.
Madeline Buckendorf seconded the motion.
-,
�
1
. , �
�
ROLL CALL VOTE: Those voting yes: Buckendorf, Davidson, Huyck, McConnell, Nachtigall,
Those voting no: Pilote. Chairman Wells not voting
MOTION CARRIED
The Chairman advised those present of their right of appeal to the City Council.
COMMENTS: Commissioner Nachtigall complimented the organization of the previous process
and the ability to compromise.
2: C22PP-95: Request for a Short Plat: Final Plat for Cleveland Subdivision lots one and
two are splits lot three is Subdivision Review. Applicant: Ann Fountain.
Applicant Ann Fountain residing at 2509 Spruce, Caldwell explained that the lot had been split three
separate times in the past, developed and occupied. To do this to lot three it must be subdivided first.
She noted the letter from the Lonnie Freeman of the irrigation district and compliance with Idaho
Power.
Commissioner McConnell stated that he saw no problem and that the increased tax revenue would
be good for the city. Commissioner Huyck and Buckendorf agreed.
Commissioner McConnell offered a motion to pass the Short Plat Preliminary and Final Plat known
as, Cleveland Subdivision.
Mike Nachtigall seconded the Motion.
ROLL CALL VOTE: Those voting yes: Buckendorf, Davidson, Huyck, McConnell, Pilote,
Nachtigall. Chairman Wells not voting
MOTION CARRIED
MISCELLANEOUS:
Report on City Council Action:
\
Commissioner Buckendorf asked about the security units in the industrial and commercial zone. Ms.
Huff stated that it was dropped by the council. They did not want this issue to shift to staff level.
The submittal needs some clarification, perhaps a definition to clarify what was meant by a caretaker.
This gap would create issues during implementation of security units that would go beyond staff
level processing. For example, How would the Comprehensive Plan be met by allowing families
including: children, pets, and traffic and trip generation of residential patterns into industrial areas?
Would this undermine the underlying zoning intent - which is to separate families from industrial
hazards on-site in industrial sites? The idea is good but was not developed for staff to implement.
Question such as, what constitutes cazetaker quarters' needs to be tight and defined. The council did
not know if constitutionally staff had a right to monitor numbers of residents and preferences to
composition and structure.
4
� M �
�
�
Tentative Agenda for January 18, 1996:
Ms. Huff discussed the procedures for nominations and elections for the Chairman.
Work Session Meeting Set:
Sign ordinance work session is to be held January 11, 1996 at 7:00 P.M. New new ordinance
combined past sign committee findings. The intent and stunmary and background will be presented
by staff. The Planning and Zoning Commission will discuss issues and gaps and suggest
improvements and wording revisions. The Planning and Zoning Commission will then create an
action plan for consensus building in the community and how the document will be forwarded by
public committee?
Thank You, said staff
Commissioners thanked Chairman Wells for his great work with the board in the past year.
There being no further business the meeting was adjourned at 9:30 p.m.
5