HomeMy WebLinkAbout10-19-1995 P&Z MINUTES �
.
PLANNING AND ZONING DEPARTMENT
.
� � City of Caldwell
NANCY HUFF
Planning & Zoning Director
621 CLEVELAND BLVD.
CALDWELL ID 83605
� TELEPHONE 455-3021
FAX 455-3003
MINUTES OF THE PLANNING AND ZONING COMMISSION
Meeting of October 19, 1995
1. ADMINISTRATION:
The Commission were advised by Staff that a training meeting has been scheduled with the City
Attorney for October 26, 1995, at 7:00 p.m. in the City Council Chambers. The next regular meeting
of the Commission will be November 16, 1995. Ms. Huff explained that during the Director's
Report portion of the agenda, the intent is for Commission to notify Staff of training and business
items. Short and long term plans may also be discussed The Area of Impact is being worked on and
the Director has been communicating with representatives of the County. The Commission will be
advised of further developments. Copies of the Idaho Planning Act primer and a Manual on
Comprehensive Planning were distributed as supportive information by the Director.
In response to a question from the Chairman, Ms. Huff said that the City Engineer is working with
Canyon Highway District concerning road standards for the Area of City Impact. Commissioner
Wells said that there is some frustration since the Commission asked a month ago for some kind of
area dialog and the thought was that such a dialog would be in process. Ms. Huff explained that a
dialog between the Mayor, Council and the Commission was not yet scheduled. Ms. Huyck asked
how the Commission could be prepared if there is no dialog. Ms. Huff responded that a meeting
with the City Council will be arranged. Commissioner Pilote commented that the Commission has a
procedure and that is that subdivisions are evaluated under the Caldwell Subdivision Ordinance and
the Commission makes sure the ordinance is followed. If that is not what is supposed to be
happening the Commission should be so advised. Commissioner McConnell added that this is the
reason a meeting of the Commission with the Council is important. Ms. Huff suggested the
Commission draw up an agenda and she would present it to the Mayor and arrange a meeting.
Commissioner Wells said that an agenda was prepared for October 5 but that the Mayor preferred not
to have the joint meeting until a plan was in place so that when we met it would be more productive.
That decision was made in part with input from Gordon Law who felt that prior to the Mayor making
the decision he would prefer to see a proposed agreement in place between Canyon Highway
District, Canyon County and the City, that would be more productive. Further discussion was
deferred to the Director's Report section, after applicant review.
MINUTES P&Z 10-19-95
Page 1
r
2. ROLL CALL:
Present: Chairman: Rick Wells, Dorothy Davidson, Sonia Huyck, Terry McConnell, Mike
Nachtigall, Bettie Pilote
Absent: Madeline Buckendorf
Staff: Nancy Huff, Liz Yeary
The regular meeting of the Planning and Zoning Commission was called to order by Chairman, Rick
Wells, at 7:30 p.m. in the City Hall Council Chambers. It was noted that Commissioner Buckendorf
was absent.
3. MINUTES:
The first item of business was approval of the minutes for the meeting of September 21, 1995. The
Minutes were approved unanimously.
4. PUBLIC HEARINGS:
The public hearing portion of the agenda then followed. Chairman Wells explained the procedure
for public hearings.
4a. A request for a Special Use Permit to operate a church in a C-2 (Community Commercial)
zoning district. The subject property is located at 822 Arthur Street in Caldwell. Applicant:
Alpha & Omega Ministries/Rev. Freddie Lane.
Commissioner Pilote declared a conflict of interest on this item and stated that she would not be
participating in the discussion.
Ms. Huff explained the location of the property, the type of building and the background to the
request. She added that the issue of businesses selling or serving alcoholic beverages within 300' of
a church had been brought to the attention of the applicant who had waived her right to protection
from this provision. The applicant has made an effort to address the impact of parking by providing
off-site parking at First Interstate Bank.
In response to a question from the Chairman, Ms. Huff said that several people had made inquiries of
a general nature about the request. The building is an existing structure and other uses are not
required to provide parking, since it is located in the Parking Overlay zone. In response to a question
from Commissioner Huyck, Ms. Huff said that on-street parking is not taken into consideration. The
church only has one counselor, and that aspect of the use would not generate a large amount of
traffic.
The applicant, Rev. Freddie Lane, responded to the report, stating that the Fire Code allows a
maximum of 48 people and if the congregation does grow, then they would look for other
accommodation. Their ministry is a counseling and ministering service to the downtown people who
are not otherwise served. Currently there is no Sunday morning service but she hopes to begin one.
MINUTES P&Z 10-19-95
Page 2
In response to a question from the Chairman, Rev. Lane said that the church has been operating for
six months and no parking problem has arisen.
In response to a question from Commissioner Nachtigall, the applicant said that she was aware of the
businesses serving alcohol and had no problem with that. In response to a question from
Commissioner Wells, Rev. Lane said that she would not oppose having an annual review nor did she
have a problem with any of the suggested conditions.
Gary Vance spoke on behalf of the Eagles, asking for a copy of the waiver concerning alcoholic
beverages. He added that the Eagles have Sunday night bingo when they also use the Bank parking
lot and he hoped this would not create a problem. Rev. Lane declined to give further testimony.
After further discussion, Sonia Huyck offered a Motion to approve the Special Use Permit subject to
suggested conditions amended as follows, based on finding that the use is suitable for the building,
will not infringe on other commercial uses, and the applicant has waived her rights concerning the
sale and service of alcoholic beverages by neighboring businesses:
#9. The applicant shall meet existing requirements of the City Building and Fire Departments.
# 11. There will be an annual review of the Special Use Permit to ensure that the parking is
adequate.
Terry McConnell seconded the Motion.
ROLL CALL VOTE. Those voting yes: McConnell, Pilote, Nachtigall, Davidson, Huyck. Those
voting no: None. Absent and not voting: Buckendorf.
MOTION CARRIED
The Chairman advised those present of their right of appeal to the City Council.
5. MISCELLANEOUS:
l. Director's Report
The discussion resumed concerning a proposed meeting with the City Council. Commissioner Pilote
suggested compiling a list of priorities. The first priority should be amending the Subdivision
Ordinance to address the Area of City Impact, and how waivers will be handled, either by the
Planning and Zoning Commission, the City Council or the Canyon Highway District. Commissioner
Wells said that he had met with Gordon Law and Ms. Huff and Rita Earl and one of the things
discussed was a meeting Gordon Law had with the Highway District and his proposal was that
everything north of the river would be built to County standard and everything south of the river
would have curb, and gutter and that the City would offer their equipment to the County and provide
them with the names of six other private companies that provide that type of service. Mr. Law's
impression was that the Highway District would support such an agreement. The Highway District
and the County Planning and Zoning Department are currently reviewing the proposal.
MINUTES P&Z 10-19-95
Page 3
Mr. Wells went on to state that he understood from Rita Earl that there was some discussion in the
Council of bypassing the Planning and Zoning Commission altogether and altering things so that the
waivers hearing would go to the Council before the Planning and Zoning Commission. The plan that
was given to the County from the previous City Attorney indicated that there would be a joint
commission and it would be made up of County, City Council people, City Planning and Zoning
Commission members who would administer the Area of Impact.
Commissioner Pilote asserted that it sounded like a good idea and expressed frustration at the
Council's apparent lack of understanding of the Commission's role.
Commissioner Huyck asked Ms. Huff if Planning and Zoning Commission hearings are governed by
State Code. Ms. Huff replied that State Code gives the City planning responsibilities and the City
Council has authorized the Planning and Zoning Commission to carry those duties out. Ms. Pilote
said that the City Council does not give the Commission enough credit to do their job.
Commissioner McConnell agreed with everything said. The purpose of the Commission is to serve
the people that live within the community and protect their interests when individuals propose
development. What is the public interest? That should be of prime concern and nothing else. The
Planning and Zoning Commission as a volunteer body, can be more objective. The City Council, an
elected body, could not be as objective.
Ms. Huff said that the City Council appoints the Planning and Zoning Commission. The
Commission does many review tasks and processing that are valuable to the Council. The Planning
and Zoning Commission is very important to the Planning and Zoning Department as well as the
Council.
Commissioner Huyck said that she would like to see more public citizen participation from the
community in public hearings.
Commissioner Pilote made a request for a joint meeting with City Council and the Mayor and certain
issues would be addressed at that time. The Chairman said that he would like some time to be able
to formulate an agenda. The meeting should be an open meeting so that the public can attend and
part of the agenda should be discussion concerning the Area of Impact.
Commissioner Nachtigall asked if the primary hangup re the Area of Impact is with the Highway
District. Mr. Wells said that a response is requested even if it is a verbal response.
After some further discussion, the Chairman said that he would arrange a meeting and provide an
agenda.
2. Report on City Council Action
Ms. Huff commented on items acted on by Council. The Bushnell Center committee was given 30
days to figure the money to open the doors in the gym, then would go back to the public and see what
they want. The City will try and get the Center back under the control of the City. $270,000 is
required for some of the floor repair and this does not include fixtures and the ceiling. $500,000 will
be required to get that resolved. If the public does not support the project other ways will be sought.
MINUTES P&Z 10-19-95
Page 4
r
Ms. Huff gave an explanation of the new format of the Staff Report.
3. Tentative Agenda for November 16, 1995.
If there are no items for a meeting in November a work session will be held.
There being no further business the meeting adjourned at 9:15 p.m.
Respectfully Submitted,
1' a�
Liz Yeary, � Rick Wells
Recording Secretary Chairman
MINUTES P&Z 10-19-95
Page 5