Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout3-28-1995 P&Z MINUTES . , ' � + � PLANNING AND ZONING COMMISSION MINUTES Special Meeting of March 28, 1995 Present: Chairman: Rick Wells, Madeline Buckendorf, Dorothy Davidson, Sonia Huyck, Reed Taylor Absent: Terry McConnell, Bettie Pilote Staff: Ed Christopher, Liz YearX The special meeting of the Planning and Zoning Commission was called to order by Chairman, Rick Wells, at 12:00 noon in the City Hall Council Chambers. The only item on the agenda was a request for a Variance to allow a reduction in the street side setback from twenty (20) feet to zero (0) feet, and a reduction in the front setback from twenty (20) feet to eighteen (18) feet, for property at the southeast corner of Cleveland Blvd. and 12th Avenue, located in the C-2 (Community Commercial) zoning district. The applicant is XChange Services (Quick Lube). Ed Christopher explained the location of the property and nature of the request. He stated that the applicant had purchased the property in order to construct arid operate a lube shop, after ascertaining from Staff that there would be zero setbacks due to the commercial zoning. The applicant was later notified that this was an error on the part of Staff and the applicant elected to pursue a Variance. The request asks for a two foot setback reduction on Cleveland Boulevard and a twenty foot setback reduction on 12th Avenue. Part of the reasoning for placing the building closer to 12th Avenue is to reduce nuisance and intrusion on the neighboring property to the east. Ed added that the State Transportation Department was requesting that the drive approach on Cleveland Blvd. be restricted to a width of 45' rather than the proposed 60'. The Engineering Dept. has requested a return curb on the southern boundary line to separate the 12th Avenue drive approach from the a11ey approach. A 5' separation appears reasonable. Madeline Buckendorf asked Ed to describe the site hardships. He said that it is difficult to put a commercial use on this commercially zoned property because of the limited size of the site and the setback restrictions. Madeline also asked why there is not more green landscape area between the eastern property and the drive approach. Ed said that this could be addressed by the Commission. Madeline asked how many parking spaces are required according to Code. Ed stated that while a lube shop is not specifically addressed, retail or service establishments would be used as a guideline. The Code requires one space for every 250 sq.ft. of building, in this case 5.52 spaces. The revised site plan shows 8 spaces. In response to a question from Madeline, Ed stated that the fencing at the southern end of the property along the alley is required by Code to screen only the parking spaces, and not the whole property. MINUTES P8Z 03-2&95 Page 1 . 1 Ed stated, in response to a question from Madeline, that the Historic Areas Component of the Comprehensive Plan was not referred to when evaluating the request. Madeline commented that on page 63, policy number 5 reads "The City shall require harmony and compatibility of new development and renovation within designated areas of historic significance" and this property is within that designated area, and in addition the house on the southern side of the alley is a historic home. Mr. Fred Wiegand, on behalf of the applicant, said that they had approached the Planning Department prior to purchase of the property, to ascertain that the business could be operated at that location and that the proposed building would fit on the site. On receiving the information that this was possible, they had purchased the property and begun preliminary site work. Subsequently, they were informed that residential setbacks would apply. Therefore, the building would not fit on the site without a reduction in setbacks. The problem with moving the building to accommodate setbacks would make the turning radius too short and the site simply would not work. They are agreeable to maintaining the greenscape. Mr. Wiegand said that the current business in Ontario is a very clean, quiet, professional business that contributes to the community. In response to a question from Rick, Mr. Wiegand said that they plan to install a sign in the northwestern corner of the property in the landscape area. He further stated that the hardship is the fact that the property would not be wide enough to give a big enough turning radius for vehicles to operate the business economically. Rick questioned the two foot reduction request on Cleveland. The applicant responded that the business needs as much car stacking space as possible without encroaching on the sidewalk. In response to questions from Reed, the applicant said that the only fencing will be on the southern alley boundary and that �he resident to the east has expressed no opposition to anything they have done or proposed. Answering a question from Madeline, Mr. Wiegand said that if they adhere to a 20' setback on 12th Avenue, cars would have to drive around the block to get into the parking area which would not be good for business. Sonia expressed concern about pedestrian trai�ic in the area. Mr. Wiegand stated that in their present location in Ontario there is a lot of heavy pedestrian traffic which poses no problem to either pedestrians or the business. In response to a question from Madeline, Mr. Wiegand said that the property has been purchased and architectural work has been completed. Three trees have been removed. Responding to Rick, Mr. Wiegand said that they have never contemplated putting the building in the middle of the lot because it would not work. Madeline asked Ed why they were told the commercial setbacks would apply. Ed explained that the residential requirements were overlooked. For the same reason, the Comprehensive Plan Historic Areas segment was also overlooked. Ed told Reed that the remaining property could be developed commercially and would have to meet residential setbacks. MINUTES P8Z 032&95 Page 2 � . � There being no further testimony the public hearing was then closed. Madeline commented that while she sympathized with the property owner that he received the wrong information the setbacks are a serious matter. One of the reasons there is a Commission is as a way to provide checks and balance but the job of the Commission is to make sure that what is done conforms with the Comprehensive Plan and the City and State Codes. If an error is made, it is unfortunate. She did not find that it conforms with the Comprehensive Plan. The area has been mishandled for many years, and approval of this request compounds a problem. Rick Wells commented that he was not convinced of the need for a setback reduction on Cleveland Boulevard but felt the 12th Avenue request was warranted. Madeline said that she would like to see plans addressing setbacks as they exist. Sonia stated that because of the old street design of grass sidewalk area the effect is reduced. Rick asked Madeline if she did not feel the setback was in harmony with the historic areas segment of the Plan. Madeline agreed. She felt that by allowing the variance they would simply be adding to the mistake. Reed said that he was having difficulty imposing residential restrictions on a commercial use and since the request is away from the residential uses the request seems reasonable. He added that in his opinion the area is becoming increasingly commercial. Madeline disagreed strongly that the area was becoming commercial. Reed referred to an earlier case where a variance for a reduction of one foot had been granted but Madeline said that each case has to be looked at on its own merits and with current rules and ordinances. Sonia commented that neighboring properties have not expressed any interest, apart from the neighbor to the south and his concern about fencing, and the letter from the Hartwell Corporation. Rick agreed with Madeline concerning reviewing cases independently of each other, but felt that if it were a different type of commercial business being proposed there would be less opposition. Since the use is not within the Commission's purview he felt the Commission have to evaluate it in terms of safety and access. With some further discussion Reed Taylor offered a Motion to grant the Variance as requested, amending condition #1 to read eighteen feet rather than twelve feet, amending condition #5 to require a 45' wide drive approach. The curb return requirement on 12th Avenue can be addressed during the Building Pernut process as a requirement. He stated that the reason for the Motion was that the sidewalk design offered its own buffer, there will not be a traffic problem from 12th and Cleveland, turning ratios will be safer, the applicant had put a lot of money into the project, and the setbacks as approved by Staff are in conformance with the Comprehensive Plan. Dorothy Davidson seconded the Motion. Sonia asked whether Reed would agree to adding a requirement MINUTES P8Z 03-28-95 Page 3 � � i to extend the fence on the alley to within 5'-10' of the sidewalk to provide an added buffer. Reed and Dorothy agreed. ROLL CALL VOTE. Those voting yes: Taylor, Davidson, Huyck. Those voting no: Buckendorf. Absent and not voting: McConnell, Pilote. MOTION CARRIED Madeline commented that her objections had nothing to do with the type of business but the role of the Commission. There being no further business the meeting adjourned at 1:15 p.m. Respectfully Submitted, �, ( Liz �Yea , Rick Wells ry Recording Secretary Chairman . MINUTES P8Z 03-2&95 Page 4