HomeMy WebLinkAbout1-19-1995 P&Z MINUTES I 4
PLANNING AND ZONING COMMISSION
MINUTES
Meeting of January 19, 1995
Present: Madeline Buckendorf, Dorothy Davidson, Sonia Huyck, Terry McConnell, Bettie
Pilote, Ken Rivers, Rick Wells
Absent: None
Staff: Dennis Crooks, Liz Yeary
The regular meeting of the Planning and Zoning Commission was called to order by Secretary, Rick
Wells, at 7:15 p.m. in the City Hall Council Chambers.
The first item of business was the election of a Chairman pro tem to conduct the meeting. Terry
McConnell offered a Motion nominating Rick Wells to act as Chairman pro tem. Madeline
Buckendorf seconded the Motion.
ROLL CALL VOTE. Those voting yes: McConnell, Buckendorf, Pilote, Rivers, Davidson, Wells,
Huyck. Those voting no: None. Absent and not voting: None.
MOTION CARRIED
The Chair then called for nominations for the position of Chairman. Madeline Buckendorf nominated
Rick Wells. Dorothy Davidson seconded the motion. There were no other nominations.
ROLL CALL VOTE. Those voting yes: Buckendorf, Pilote, Rivers, Davidson, Wells, Huyck,
McConnell. Those voting no: None. Absent and not voting: None.
MOTION CARRIED
The Chair than called for nominations for the position of Vice-Chairman. Bettie Pilote nominated �
Terry McConnell. Dorothy Davidson seconded the Motion. There were no other nominations.
ROLL CALL VOTE. Those voting yes: Pilote, Rivers, Davidson, Wells, Huyck, McConnell,
Buckendorf. Those voting no: None. Absent and not voting: None.
MOTION CARRIED
The next nomination was for the position of Secretary. Terry McConnell nominated Bettie Pilote.
Madeline Buckendorf seconded the Motion. There were no other nominations.
ROLL CALL VOTE. Those voting yes: McConnell, Buckendorf, Pilote, Rivers, Davidson, Wells,
Huyck. Those voting no: None. Absent and not voting: None.
MOTION CARRIED
MINUTES P8Z 1-19 95
Pa�e 1
The next item on the agenda was approval of the minutes for the meeting of December 15, 1994.
Bettie Pilote made a motion to approve the minutes. The motion was seconded by Terry McConnell
and passed unanimously.
Before the public hearing section of the agenda, the Chairman outlined the procedure for those
present.
The first item of public hearing concerned a request for a Variance to allow a division of an e�sting
lot to create a parcel of record which would not satisfy minimum lot area requirements. The applicant
was Dennis Dodd, and his representative was Mark Klaudt of Re/max of Nampa/Caldwell.
Dennis explained the background to the request and pointed out the parcel on the map and
highlighted staff s concerns about lack of access to the alley for the resultant parcel particularly in
terms of sewer access.
Mark Klaudt stated that in attempting to find the most advantageous solution for his client they have I
considered a triplex, but such a development would entail backing out onto Linden Street. Since they �
made their application they had discovered the land which the County now owns and are attempting
to purchase that which would provide the access to the alley. Mr. Klaudt added that the applicant is
planning to provide sidewalks.
In response to a question from Rick Wells, Mr. Klaudt said that if they can obtain the surplus
property, they would split off the property to make another single family residence lot, which is what
the application reflects.
Mrs. D. Larsen of 1205 Linden spoke, as owner of the adjacent property to the west. She stated that
she was not at the hearing as an adversary but was concerned about the use. She prefened to have a
single family residence on the property because of privacy and property values. She is hoping that
Mr. Dodd will come to an agreement with her to trade property as a means of obtaining a11ey access
and increasing the size of her side yard.
NIr. Klaudt agreed that his client is attempting to come to terms with the Larsens. In response to a
question from Terry, Dennis Crooks said that the County-owned property which abuts the a11ey is
about 20 feet wide. The property owner north of the subject property appears to have illegally fenced
the alley and the land. Terry commented that before the applicant can purchase the property, the
County have to go through a bid process.
It was generally agreed that the a11ey should be re-opened for everyone's use and that steps should be
taken immediately to accomplish that.
Rick asked for clarification of the item in the Staff report concerning the possibility of a triplex being
built. Dennis explained that in the R-2 zone a triplex was permissible. However, parking and
setbacks would have to be considered for a waiver, and due to the narrow configuration of the lot,
and the question of an unsafe access onto Linden would likely not support such a waiver. With a land
swap between the Larsens and Mr. Dodd the configuration of the property would be more workable
1AINUTES P8Z 1-19 95
°ae�' .
and advantageous for both parties. It is not definite that the two parties can negotiate a deal, even
though there are two agreeable parties at this point in time. The Commission could approve the
variance as long as it is appropriately conditioned. The City is asking for a record of survey which
would show easements for the property and access to the a11ey through easement or trade of property
and that information is to be submitted to the City and the Engineering Department before it is
recorded.
Bettie Pilote said that there are a lot of unknowns and she would like more information before making
a final decision.
Madeline Buckendorf agreed that there are a lot of unanswered questions but that with existing
conditions was comfortable with the concept.
Madeline offered a Motion to approve the requested Variance subject to suggested conditions.
Dorothy Davidson seconded the Motion.
ROLL CALL VOTE. Those voting yes: Buckendorf, Rivers, Davidson, Huyck, McConnell. Those
voting no: Pilote. Absent and not voting: None.
MOTION CARRIED
Bettie explained that while she is not opposed to the concept of dividing the lot, she felt that approval
was premature in view of the unknown factors such as potential property swaps and easement
decisions.
The second pub�ic hearing was a request for a Variance to allow a reduction of the required lot
dimensions for three lots which are part of the proposed Madison Estates Subdivision. The applicant
is Bob Bushnell, and his representative is Skinner, Earl & Assoc. Bettie Pilote stated that she would
abstain from participation due to conflict of interest.
Dennis explained the nature of the request and the location of the property. Rita Earl, on behalf of
the applicant, stated that Mr. Bushnell has owned the property for some time, and that the property is
somewhat unique since the property sunounding it has been developed for several years, particularly
the Benito Juarez Subdivision immediately to the north. Utilities and street improvements are in place
for the most part. A sewer line runs through the middle of the property. With a R-2 zoning, density
pernutted is 7-9 dwelling units per acre, but because of existing improvements and the sewer line, the
permitted density cannot be achieved without reducing fractionally the lot dimensions requested.
In response to a question from Terry, Dennis said that the request is minimal, the e�sting Block
length is awkward and Staff does not anticipate adverse effects on surrounding neighboring
properties. Madeline Buckendorf agreed. Terry McConnell offered a Motion to approve the request
subject to suggested conditions. Dorothy Davidson seconded the Motion.
VIINUTES P8Z 1-'995
ij.�
�
ROLL CALL VOTE. Those voting yes: McConnell, Buckendorf, Rivers, Davidson, Huyck. Those
voting no: None. Abstain_ Pilote. Absent and not voting: None.
MOTION CARRIED
This concluded the public hearing portion of the agenda. The next item was a request for Preliminary
Plat approval for Madison Estates Subdivision as referred to above. Bettie claimed conflict of interest
and abstained from participation.
Dennis stated that the only comments received had been of an enquiring nature. Jerry Earl testified
on behalf of the applicant, explaining that this was redesigned previously, and that the Fire
Department had agreed to accept the existing cul-de-sac. Mr. Bushnell was in agreement with the
conditions suggested.
Madeline Buckendorf offered a Motion to approve the Preliminary Plat according to suggested
conditions. Terry McConnell seconded the Motion.
ROLL CALL VOTE. Those voting yes: Buckendorf, Rivers, Davidson, Huyck, McConnell.
Those voting no: None. Abstain: Pilote. Absent and not voting: None.
MOTION CARRIED
The next item was a request for Initiation of an Amendment to the Sign Schedule pertaining to
setbacks and illumination standards for signs within the R-3 zone. Dennis explained that property
lines vary tremendously in the R-3 zone and Staff would like to explore a standard that would look
into a.11 the variables and try and eliminate unnecessary Variances and Special Use Pernut requests for
this zone. In response to a question from Madeline, Dennis explained how illumination standards
have changed within the industry since the code was originally adopted.
Bettie Pilote then offered a Motion to initiate the suggested amendment. Terry McConnell seconded
the Motion.
ROLL CALL VOTE. Those voting yes: Pilote, Rivers, Davidson, Huyck, McConnell, Buckendorf.
Those voting no: None. Absent and not voting: None.
MOTION CARRIED
In reporting on City Council action, Dennis stated that Council had approved the final plat of Phase II
of Manchester Park Subdivision, and the final plat of Weatherby Cove Subdivision. The Bushnell
Community Center had been the subject of a report and the Council asked the 4C Committee to bring
the matter to the Planning and Zoning Commission for them to forward a recommendation to City
Council of what the Commission finds to be a reasonable concept plan for that area. Things to look
MINUTES P&Z 1-1995
at include parking, traffic, land use, access, circulation and future needs of the Senior Center and the
Library.
A Transportation Workshop between the Planning and Zoning Commission and the City Council is
scheduled for January 30 at 7:00 p.m. in the City Council Conference Room and Dennis is preparing
information for that item.
Some discussion ensued about the possibility of a workshop for the Commission, particularly in view
of the new membership. Dennis felt that March or April might be convenient. Bettie asked for
particular reference to plats and planned unit developments.
There being no further business the meeting adjourned at 9:00 p.m.
Respectfully Submitted,
�-��,' `���.�.:;
Liz Yeary, �� Rick Wells
Recording Secretary Chairman pro tem
.
�
MINUTES P&Z 1-19 95
D,