HomeMy WebLinkAbout12-15-1994 P&Z MINUTES �
� PL,ANNING �ND ZONING COMNIISSION
MINUTES
Meeting of December 15, 1994
Present: Chairman Tom Ensley, Dorothy Davidson, Terry McConnell, Bettie Pilote, Rick Wells
Absent: Madeline Buckendor� Ylary Higdem
Staff: Dennis Crooks
The re�ular meeting of the Planning and Zoning Commission was called to order by Chairman Tom '
Ensley, at 7:15 p.m. in the City Hall Council Chambers.
The first item of business was the approval of the minutes for the meeting of December 1, 1994.
Terry McConnell made a motion to approve the minutes. The motion was seconded by Dorothy
Davidson and passed unanimousiy.
The only item of public hearing concerned a request for a Special Use Permit to operate a church on
property located at the northeast corner of Summit and Ohio in the R-1 zoning district. The
applicant is Give Glory to God Church, represented by James and Juanita Jennings.
Dennis gave the background to the request, identifying the location and stating that the existing
building was previously used as a Circie K convenience store and has been vacant for over two years.
The present nonconforming commercial use would not allow to be re-established. Site layout and
design do not meet current development standards, particularly parking design and location. A
number of items were refened to from Sta$'s report. The building has sustained some damage which
will have to be repaired both on the interior and on the exterior subject to approval of the Building
and Safety Depa.rtment.
The Chairman opened the public hearing. Dennis reported that Staff received a number of phone
calls from people in the area indicating their inability to be present at the hearing. Mr. and
Mrs. Santiago, Marvin Kuhlman, and Evelyn Raymond, indicated their support of the church and hope
it will help maintain the property better and improve appearance.
Jim Jennings, pastor of the church, testified that they had contacted Mr. Beem, the owner of the
property, and felt they could come up with an agreement financially to operate this use. He
appreciated the City's concerns about parking. The floor plan seems potentially ideal for a church
use. He understood there is a lot of work to be done, windows to be repIaced, cleaning up and
electrical fixtures but needs time to comple�e these requirements within a reasonable time period. The
congregation is presently small, not e�cceeding 20 but they anticipate growth.
Terry asked the applicant if he had read the recommendations and would have any problems meeting
those conditions. Mr. Jennings referred to the requirement to remove the signs. He expressed
concem about the time in which he would be allowed to comply. To bring the inside up to Code they
would have to have some time to be financially able to comply before occupancy. The congregation
possesses a licensed construction worker who can do the work. Nme months would appear to be a
reasonable time frame to complete the outside renovations.
Ul`+I;TES P&Z 12-19-94
Pa;e 1
�I
A lot of the work will be done on a voluntary basis. Tom Ensiey commented that a lot of work will I I,
have to be done before occupancy. The con�,regation would like to move in before the end of winter.
Mr. Jennings said that the Building and Safety Department had indicated they will have to inspect the
inside before occupancy is granted. In response to a question from Terry, six months would be
adequate to comply with the majority of the requirements. �
Dennis reviewed the conditions and Staffs expectations. He explained that occupancy means when
the church opens for services and related activities begins. Occupancy is not during the construction
phase. He referred to the suggested site plan and the potential for parking. There is also a possibility
that the 90 degree spaces can be angled for safer parking, but would not have to be done at this time.
Staff can monitor and if it becomes a problem action can be taken. The intent of re-striping is that
they will have to do some repainting and re-striping which should not involve a lot of money. This
would best be done in the spring or eariy summer.
Landscaping should be done and maintained and the conditions suggest six months after occupancy
which would make the time frame toward the end of summer. However, contractors and builders
will be pernutted to go into the building to work. Other time requirements are flexible. The fencing
requirement would have to be complied with prior to occupancy.
Howard Wright, 2003 Summit Drive, testified, applauding the improvements to the building. He
expressed concern about the parking situation, should the congregation �row. Summit is narrow as is
Ohio and should be taken into consideration. That was his only concem. Rick Wells asked him to
point out on the map location of his property. He responded that he would not object at all to the
use.
Refemng to the eastem property, Dennis confirmed that there is a 45 foot wide strip which could
provide sufficient room for parking 7 or 8 vehicles if needed.
Stacy Beem testified representing the owners. The building was developed as a gocery store and
later bought by Circle K. Ms. Beem asked if the windows could be replaced with "plexi glass" rather
than regular glass. The Chairman said that this issue would have to be addressed by Building
Department. Boarding up broken glass on an interim is OK but would have to be removed before
occupancy. Ms. Beem asked what idnd of thing they could do in the landscape area. Dennis
explained that the landscaping ordinance does allow flexibility to use hardscape materials, such as
decorative rock materials. He said that it is possibie to do a combination lava rock and drought
tolerant shrubs.
Ms. Beem also questioned the possibility of a sign since she understood this was not possible.
However, Dennis explained that they could have a sign not to exceed 32 sq.ft. in size..
Mr. Jennings was called back to the podium. He referred to the hanging lighting outside the building
stating that he would like to use the fixtures to provide outside lighting if possible. Dennis explained
that the lighting could be retained but would have to be updated to comply with Building Codes.
'1i�I;TCC ?y� :.. - . .- .
Terry stated that he was in favor of the Permit and that it would be an improvement to the area. He
was concerned about parking but in view of the size of the congregation and the conditions imposed,
the City should be able to review the situation.
Bettie agreed with Terry stating that with the annual review process there should be no problems.
Dorothy agreed with both Terry and Bettie. Rick stated that he had been concemed about time limits
but when ciarified to state that occupancy means when church services and related activities can
begin, he had no further concem.
Bettie Pilote then o�ered a Motion to approve the Special Use Permit subject to recommended terms
and conditions. Terry McConnell seconded the Motion.
ROLL CALL VOTE. Those voting yes: Pilote, McConnell, Wells, Davidson. Those voting no:
None. Absent and not voting: Buckendor� Higdem.
MOTION CARRIED
The next item on the agenda, involved review of the Mas�er Plan of Paradise View Subdivision. Terry
commented that he liked the concept. Tom confirmed that it would come back as a plat before any
development occurs. Bettie agreed with Teiry concerning the commercial site and the probable
reaction of the neighbors. Dennis explained that during the hearing process before the City Council,
the Comprehensive Plan was changed to Commercial for the corner, although the zoning is still R-1.
Dennis also explained that the zoning shown on the concept plan was wrong.
Tom asked Dennis to clarify what ha.d happened at Council. Dennis said that the neighborhood
0 oups had met with Staff and went over everything that had happened before the Commission. At
the City Council meeting, the City Council did not accept the R-S-1 sub-zone. They felt it created
too large of a lot as a minimum lot size and changed this to an R-S-2 zone which has a 20,000 square
foot lot size. The Council also responded somehwat to the neighborhood group and �anted an R-S
zoning adjacent to the Rosewood and McCarthy subdivisions but did not expand the R-S zone north
of the Cana1. They also felt they could live with a commercial designation on the plan either at
Kimball or l Oth/Usrick. Such a designation pemuts the city to require a zone ciia.nge which would
enable us to obtain a development agreement and better oversee any commercial development.
Teiry said that he had no probiem with the R-1 northeast of the Canal, versus the R S wluch is what
is already in place. Dennis explained that this was incoirectly marked on their plan. The zoning that
was adopted by Council reflected their original plan. The adopted zoning is as shown on the zoning
map. The R-S zone can be used to negotiate density transfer for a park site to compensate the
developer for the park site.
Dennis said that the Commission will be kept informed on this Master Plan.
The next item was the R-2 zoning district and potential development modifications. Dennis explained
that Staff are trying to solicit input from the Commission. One concept is to evaluate smaller
minimum lot sizes for a single famiiy dwelling because in certain areas such as the area south of the
.11VliTES P&Z !�-t9-9a
-.1F �
�
College there are older subdivisions with small houses on 10,000f sq.ft lots. These lots could be
subdivided and accommodate another house but they would be fractionally short of current minimum
lot sizes. For a medium density zone, slightiy smaller lots could provide another means of affordable
housing and also might inject some new development in these older neighborhoods.
Tom stated that he thought this made a lot of sense and Terry expressed support for the concept. In
response to a question from Tom, Dennis said that Staff feels this has a reasonably high priority and
could possibly come before the Commission in February or March.
Regarding the home occupation item, Dennis said that he presumes the property owner has
reconsidered and will review the possibility of opening a photographic studio in a commercial zone.
Dennis commented on items acted upon by Council. The Council approved the final plat of Phase III
of Jefferson Park. Also the final reading of the Logan-Marshall annexation had taken place.
January 19 is the next meeting of the Commission when Commission re-oraanization will take place.
Madison Estates Subdivision, and Jefferson Park Subdivision, Phase N time extension are part of
that agenda. New copies of the zoning ordinance will be distributed at that meeting.
With no further business the meeting adjourned at 8:30 p.m.
Chairman,
Tom Ensley
NINUTES P&2 1':-19-94
�_�� �