Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout7-21-1994 P&Z MINUTES _ PLANNING AND ZONING COIVIIVIISSION MINUTES Meeting of July 21, 1994 Present: Chaurnan Tom Ensley, Dorothy Davidson, Terry McConnell, Reed Taylor Absent: Mary Higdem, Madeline Buckendorf, Bettie Pilote, Rick Wells Staff: Dennis Crooks, Liz Yeary The meeting of the Planning and Zoning Commission was called to order by Chairman, Tom Ensley, at 7:15 p.m. in the City Hall Council Chambers. The first item of business was the approval of the minutes far July 7, 1994. Dorothy Davidson ', made a modon to approve the minutes. The motion was seconded by Terry McConnell and ' passed unanimously. ' The first public hearing was a proposed amendment to the Caldwell Zoning Ordinance pertaining to Variance procedures. Dennis explained that the purpose of the request was to consider minor adjustrnents to the variance procedures section of the Code. One of the criteria in the existing ordinance is "undue loss and value of property and inability to preserve property rights of owners." These are extremely subjecdve, difficult to work with and actually go above and beyond state requirements. Since there was no public testimony, other than from Staff, the public hearing was closed. lheed Taylor commented that the amendment appears to be aimed at helping the Commission to review cases and this would make that job easier. Terry said that it was important to ha.ve the Code be more consistent with State Iaw requirements. Reed Taylor then offered a Motion to recommend approval of the Code Amendment to City Council. Terry McConnell seconded the Motion. ROLL CALL V01'E. Those voting yes: Taylor, Davidson, McConnell. Those voting no: None. Absent and not voting: Buckendorf, Higdem, Filote, Wells. MOTION CARRIED The next item was a request for Prelirninary Plat approval of Weatherby Cove to allow the subdivision of 7.15 acres of property into 17 residential lots. The subject property is located north of Jefferson Park Subdivision, west of Willowbrook Estates Subdivision. The applicant is Bob Hibbazd of Hibbazd Construction. Dennis explained that the developer is proposing single family residences on the property. He stated that conespondence had been received from an adjacent property owner addressing the issue of traffic circuladon. The same correspondence also contained a recommendation for the extension of Ray Avenue to Linden Street. Staff also received telephone enquiries and comments expressing strong opposition to such an extension. Bob Hibbard testified, stating that he is developing an"upper end" housing community. He would not be in favor of extending Ray Avenue, because the property owners who own the land where the extension would go, object to that extension. He agreed that there are traffic problems MINUTES P&Z 7-21-94 Page 1 � in the area and that the City should evaluate a right-of-way between lOth Avenue and Montana Avenue in the area of the Junior High School. He felt that Spruce Street should be opened up both at its western end and on the eastern portion north of the Junior High School. In addition, he felt the Linden/lOth Ave intersection should have a traffic control device. Dennis commented that the extension of Ra.y Avenue north has never been seriously considered. Also, when Jefferson Park Subdivision was approved a Development Master Plan was adopted by the Planning and Zoning Commission which did not include extension of Ra.y Avenue. Rather, outletets to the west and lOth Avenue were anticipated. Weatherby Cove is part of that Master Plan. Furthermore, for Ray Avenue to extend to Linden involves other property owners. Also, the sight distance at that point is questionable. He reminded the Commission that Forest Green Park Subdivision is in the process of being annexed into the City which would allow for the extension of Spruce to the west. Extension of Spruce Street between lOth and Montana., however, is more complicated and the City is evaluating opdons at this time. After some fiuther discussion, Reed Taylor offered a Motion to approve the Preliminary Plat subject to suggested conditions. Terry McConnell seconded the Motion. ROLL CALL VOTE. Those voting yes: Taylor, Davidson, McConnell. Those voting no: Nmne. Absent and not voting: Buckendorf, Higdem, Pilote, Wells. MOTION CAItRIED Before the next item, concern was expressed by the Commission that the people in the audience had no opportunity to comment on the subdivision. Dennis assumed that they had come to oppose any extension of Ray Street north but reminded the Commission that preliminary plats , were not considered under a public hearing process. There is a plan to update the Subdivision Ordinance at some future date and at that tune, consideration will be given to making some ', subdivision applications a public hearing process. i I The second Miscellaneous item was a request for Preli�unary Plat approval for Airport Estates '� Subdivision, located generally south of Linden Street and east of S. Airport Avenue (2600 Block I of S. Airport Avenue). The applicant is Gerald Magee. Dennis explained that this is a two lot subdivision to create two parcels of record. Since the applicant had requested a Variance to the ! Subdivision Ordinance concerning sewer line extension, the prelirninary plat has to be forwarded to City Council for approval with the Subdivision Ordinance Variance request. Dennis said that Manchester Pazk is required to improve a 20' wide strip on Airport Avenue as part of Phase I of that project. Other street improvements are proposed to be waived until a Loca1 Improvement District can be formed which involves all parties along this section of Airport Avenue. In this case, it seems reasonable to defer those improvements to a later date. A more involved issue is extension of the sewer. Terry McConnell commented that the property �, is large enough to divide into three lots. Frank Buturla, engineer for the applicant, explained tha.t � this is an infill project, and that the owner cannot afford to bring 700 feet of sewer to the I property. The plan is to install septic systems until the sewer line is extended. This would be I , MINL7TES P&Z 7-21-94 I �� Page 2 �i , the most economic way to proceed. Ultimately, the sewer would serve all the lots north of the Manchester Park Subdivision on Airport Avenue to Linden Street. I Dennis said that there has been a lot of recent construction in the azea and man ro ert II ! � YP A Y owners have signed deferral agreements for street improvements, sewer and water hookup, which ' makes an LID probable and easier to begin. In response to a question from Tom Ensley, Reed said that he felt an LID was an easier way to manage future improvements. Terry agreed. Dennis said that there is a benefit to the City in getting necessary improvements developed. In this instance, there is a greater degree of predictability when those unprovements will ha�ipen, because Manchester Park is being developed and has a five year time frame to upgrade Airport Avenue. LIDs will be an appropriate mechanism for full street and sewer improvements within four years. Frank Buturla questioned whether by requiring expensive improvements for infill projects such as this is against the policy of the Comprehensive Plan for infill development. Terry commented that the price of improvements is added to the price of the lot. Dennis stated that LIDs are extremely expensive for the City to manage. When properties develop, preference is to get the improvements done immediately in conjunction with the development. As stated in the Subdivision Ordinance, when a subdivider elects to subdivide there is an obligation to provide the unprovements. Part of the City's current infiastructure problem is that street improvements and other obligations are constantly being deferred. He reminded the Commission that in evaluating a variance the Commission must look at unique circumstances. These special circumstances may involve other properties in the azea and not just the subject property. Dennis explained that option #2 waives sewer line extension and connection until such time as an LID takes place. In this case we can be relatively certain that an LID will be formed in four years. An attempt to fully disclose to future property owners of these improvement obligations is made as part of recordation of the final plat. Dorothy Davidson said that she would be in favor of option #2. Dennis said that option #3 also defers sewer line extension and connection in favor of an LID. However, those two lots would not have to participate in the sewer LID because they will already have paid their fee. After some fiurther discussion concerning the various options, Terry McConnell offered a motion to recornmend approval of the preliminary plat to City Council with option #2, replacing condition #8, but other recommended conditions standing. Reed Taylor seconded the Motion. ROLL CALL VOTE. Those voting yes: McConnell, Taylor, Davidson. Those voting no: None. Absent and not voting: Buckendorf, Higdem, Filote, Wells. MOTION CARRIED MINUTES P&Z 7-21-94 Page 3 . Dennis reviewed items decided by City Council, and potential agenda items for the Cominission. He reminded the Commission that the next meeting would be on August 11 and that there would l almost certainly be two meetings in September, the lst and the 15th. ' With no fizrther business the meeting adjourned at 9:00 p.m. i Recording Secretary, Chairman, Liz Yeary ` Tom Ensley MINUTES P&Z 7-21-94 Page 4