HomeMy WebLinkAbout4-17-1994 P&Z MINUTES f
� PLANNING AND ZONING COMIVIISSION
,.
MINUTES
Meeting of April 7, 1994
Present: Chairman Tom Ensley, Madeline Buckendorf, Dorothy Davidson, Mary Higdem,
Terry McConnell, Bettie Pilote, Rick Wells
Absent: None
Staff• Dennis Crooks, Liz Yeary
The regular meeting of the Planning and Zoning Commission was called to order by Chairrnan
Tom Ensley, at 7:15 p.m. in the City Hall Council Chambers.
The first item of the business was for the Commission to welcome Dorothy Davidson to the
Commission.
The Minutes of the Planning and Zoning Commission meeting of March 17, 1994, were approved
as distributed with motion by Mary Higdem and seconded by Terry McConnell.
The first public hearing was a request for a Special Use Permit to extend the temporary operation
of a golf driving range on property located on the northeast corner of Chicago Street and 21st
Avenue; applicant: Brad Anselmo.
Dennis explained to the Commission that the Planning and Zoning Commission ha.d originally
approved a Special Use Permit to authorize the temporary operation until January 1, 1994, and
that the applicant had applied for pernussion to extend the use for a further two years.
In response to a question from Rick Wells, Mr. Anselmo said that to make such a facility
permanent would require a large cash flow, which is not available at the current time. To have
the requested tune extension wouid enable them to assess the financial viability of the facility.
Mary Higdem and Madeline Buckendorf agreed that a one year pernut seemed reasonable and
should allow the developers to assess project viability.
Mary Higdem offered a Motion to approve the Special Use Pemut for one year subject to
suggested terms and conditions. Rick Wells seconded the Motion.
ROLL CALL VOTE. Those voting yes: Higdem, Buckendorf, Wells, Davidson, Pilote,
McConnell. Those voting no: None. Absent and not voting: None.
M4TION CARRIED
The second public hearing was a request for a Special Use Permit for a Planned Unit
Development of a subdivision on property located at the western tern�inus of Morrison north of
Parker and Sunset between Kimball and Airport �4venue and a companion Preliminary Plat for
the subdivision, applicant: Briggs Engineering on behalf of Jerry Nemec and Roy Roark.
Before proceeding Tom Ensley stated that he understood letters were sent to some
commissioners, concerning this case, and would be considered ex parte contac� Mary Higdem
MINUT'ES P&Z 4-7-94
Page 1
,
� said that she would rather exclude this information from the public record, since the applicant
'' had not had the opportwuty to review the content of the correspondence. Also, the correspondent
was at liberty to present the information in public testimony.
Mary Higdem then offered a Motion to strike the information from the record. Madeline
Buckendorf seconded the Motion.
ROLL CALL VOTE. Those voting yes: Higdem, Buckendorf, Wells, Davidson, Pilote,
McConnell. Those voting no: None. Absent and not voting: None. �
MOTION CARRIED
Dennis then explained the background and nature of the request, that it was a Special Use Pemut
for a Planned Unit Development and a Preliminary Plat of the same property for Park View
Subdivision. He reported on the discussions between the applicant and the City and some of the
concerns about pazking, traffic circulation, and the grading concept particularly in regard to ,
location of property lines in relation to tops of slopes, to ensure adequate mauitenance and �
location of fencing. �
In response to a question from Mary Higdem, Dennis explained that Morrison Street had been
vacated between Parker and Sunset in order to unprove traffic flow accessing the subdivision
from Kimball on the substandard Morrison Street. The vacation is to be recorded in conjunction
with the recordation of the plat. One of the conditions requires the developer to remove the curb
and gutter and as part of the street improvements, install new drive approaches and curb and
gutter on those frontages so that it will appear as if there had never been a street.
In response to a question from Madeline Buckendorf concerning the park site dedication, Dennis
stated that when the plat is recorded the property will come into City ownership and the City will
hold it in reserve as a park or open space site.
Dennis distributed copies of the Findings of Fact/Conclusions of Law which had been written in
connection with the Oddfellows property zone change several years previously. Conespondence
had also been received from the Bureau of Reclamation, and these were distributed to the
Commission and the applicant.
Van Elg, on behalf of the applicant, described the procedures taken to reach this point in the
public hearing process. He did not see any major obstacles in StafPs sugaested conditions,
although there was concern about providing two parlang spaces per unit. To increase parking, he
felt that if the garages were constructed as carports, this would give them more area, but
preferred garages. He did not see any difficulty in complying with the Bureau of Reclannation's
suggestion for easement for the park site, but did ask that setbacks be retained as proposed. He
said that they could work with staff to arrange everything to everyone's satisfaction before final
plat approval.
MINUTES P&Z 4-7-94
Page 2
;
They had comrnissioned a traffic study and discovered that the level of traffic was sufficiendy
� J rninimal and that a development of the size proposed would not seriously jeopazdize the quality
of life for the neighbors.
In response to a question from Madeline Buckendorf, Mr. Elg stated that he could not see major
difficulty in redesigning the eastern five units to accommodate a private driveway.
The next person to testify was Hal Hogan who is the HUD Housing Consultant for the
Oddfellows. He expressed concern about the rear portion of their property being landlocked. He
presented a letter from Jerry Nemec concerning access from the northern portion of the property.
The letter was entered into the record. Mr. Hogan was not satisfied with Mr. Nemec's offer to
sell them a lot for the access. Mr. Hogan indicated he had attempted to contact the western
property owner, Mr. Mendoza for the possibility of access from Logan Street. He expressed the
Oddfellow's willingness to buy a right-of-way piece but the price of a lot was outside their
budget.
Cliff Horn of Friendship Manor concurred with Mr. Hogan. Mr. Robert Schaffer apologized to
the Commission for the ex parte contact and said this was something he was not aware of. He
had been led to understand that there would be access provided for Oddfellows. He expressed
frustration with the City in allowing them to build their present building which blocked access to
the rear parcel. He asked the Commission to table this request until the question of access be
resolved.
Madeline Buckendorf refened to the Findings of Fact/Conclusions of Law adopted by Council
concerning the Plan amendment and zone change approved for the Oddfellows for their property.
Mr. Schaffer said that at that tune they were only planning to build the one facility.
Mr. Joe Frost then spoke expressing concern about traffic. Jerry Nemec, one of the applicant's
then spoke, sa.ying that the Oddfellows did not mention cost of how access would be provided for
expansion of their facility. The developers decided to go forwazd and if at some ti.me in the
future the Oddfellows wanted to buy a lot to gain access they could work that out then.
In response to a question from Terry McConnell, Mr. Nemec stated that they would be willing to
look at options to help the Oddfellows with access. They would not look at selling a lot below
ma.rket price.
Van Elg responded to testimony stating that he had been asked by Oddfellows to provide a letter
for HUD stating that they would be able to gai.n access off the proposed development. The
Oddfellows cited an address as 321 Morrison Street, but there is no such address. The letter
from Mr. Nemec was an effort to help the Oddfellows retain their grant and continue on with the
project. They thought there could be an equitable contribution. He felt the Oddfellows project '
was a non-issue for the subject request. The application has to be considered on its own merits.
Another option would be for the Oddfellows to find access off Logan Street.
The public hearing was then closed. In response to a question from Madeline Buckendorf,
Dennis said that the Findings of Fact/Conclusions of Law was adopted by the City Council in
MINUTES P&Z 4-7-94
Page 3
,�, connection with the amendment to the Comprehensive Plan which reclassified the property from
Low Density Residential to High Density Residential. This is the official supporting document
which explains the reasons and rationale upon which the Council's decision was made. One of
those states that the Council finds traffic to and from the senior residence would be to and from
Logan.
Staff cannot substantiate other conversations with other people. There is no public record that
any of that took place except for the Minutes and the Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law
connected with the public hearings. There are a number of concerns about the Oddfellows
property. The rear lot is not a legal lot because it has no street frontage. It is not recognized as
a separate lot. A 20' driveway access does not satisfy code. This is a Planned Unit
Development, a concept which comes from State Code and recognizes requires an ownership and
a participation by a single entity to ensure that the project comes out in a way it was intended.
One option could be to work with this applicant after it is resolved and to come back at a later
date and become part of the Planned Unit development. There was further discussion concerning
access for the Oddfellows. No action was taken.
Rick Wells commented that he felt the subdivision was a good project. Terry McConnell agreed.
Mary Higdem also agreed, stating that it complies with aspects of the Comprehensive Plan
Housing Policies and cited the developers' willingness to work with the City. There was a brief
discussion between Mary and Rick over the possibility of tabling a decision so that something
could be worked out with the Oddfellows. Dennis said that the project stands on its own and
other issues could be dealt with privately between the developer and the Oddfellows.
After some further discussion Terry McConnell offered a Motion to approve the Special Use
Permit with the conditions recommended by Staff and that the developer and architect will work
with Dennis re staff concerns. Bettie Pilote seconded the Motion.
ROLL CALL VOTE. Those voting yes: McConnell, Higdem, Buckendorf, Pilote. Those
voting no: Wells, Davidson. Absent and not voting: None.
MOTION CARRIED
Mary Higdem then offered a Motion to approve the Preliminary Plat for Park View Subdivision
with the 14 listed terms and conditions in the Staff Report including the Bureau of Reclamation
concerns about the easement alang the natural drainage. Madeline Buckendorf seconded the
Motion.
ROLL CALL VOTE. Those voting yes: Higdem, Buckendorf, Wells, Davidson, Filote,
McConnell. Those voting no: None. Absent and not voting: None.
MOTION CARRIED
The next public hearing was a request for a Special Use Pernut to expand a mobile home park on
Ustick Road. Dennis explained the loca.tion of the park and the concerns e�ressed by staff.
MINUTES P&Z 4-'7-94
Page 4
.
Mary asked Dennis what current requirements exist for park setbacks. Dennis stated that they are
currently 25'. He fiuther stated that street unprovements for Ustick Road could be made under a
deferral agreement.
Grover Lewers of Blakley Buturla Engineers appeared on behalf of the applicant. Mr. Lewers
referred to the Staff Report and said that while they had requested a 15' setback from Arthur
Street, they really want a 10' setback. They would like to enter into a deferral agreement to
improve Ustick Road. For Arthur Street, the City has a 4Q' easement to the north boundary of
the subject property. They do not want to build the street further because that would not serve `
the subject property and are asking for the street to be terminated at that location. He expressed
a willingness to supply a walkway either internally or externally.
With reference to the letter from the Fire Department concerning a 36' wide right-of-way, the
code calls for a 30' wide right-of-way but they will work with the Engineering Depamnent and
the Fire Department to come to a mutually acceptable solution.
Mary Higdem said that she felt 10' was a reasonable setback from Arthur, particularly since this
would include landscaping which would soften the streetscape. She asked Mr. Lewers if the
pathway would go through the landscape area. He stated tha.t he would be willing to work with
the City on that aspect but they do not want to isolate people from the recreational azea.
Dennis reminded the Commission that the Code requires a 25' setback Mr. Lewers said that
since Arthur Street is industrial and the traffic would be industrial he felt a reduction in setback
is warranted.
Madeline Buckendorf commented that it would make a difference if there were a walkway on the
outside of the fence, in which case 15' should be required. If the walkway is interior then 10'
would be acceptable. Mary said that she would like to see some means of going through the
northern portion of the pazk to the southern portion.
Terry commented that he felt a 5' width is sufficient for landscaping.
Mary said that the development is stark and unattractive and there ha.s to be some landscaping.
She also felt it was preferable to ha.ve an interior walkway from a safety point of view.
In response to a question from Tom Ensley, Terry stated that he felt it would be appropria.te to
terminate Arthur at that point, as long as the developer lrnows that if Arthur is developed he is
responsible for his share of the costs, that is, some sort of defemal agreement. Gordon Law
agreed that there would be no difficulty with a deferral agreement.
Rick Wells asked Dennis about the possibility of Ustick Road and the anticipated increase in
traffic for what will be a major arterial within a few years. It is designated as a principal arterial
roadway on all cities' plans. For this reason a 25' setback is mandatory. Rick said that he would
like to see a berm feature along Ustick in view of projected traffic flow, which would be more
attractive and safer. Terry McConnell disagreed with this since the lots are situated away from
the Ustick Road frontage behind ancillary buildings.
MINUTES P&Z 4-7-94
Page 5
.
� Dennis said that a berm feature is not a safety feature but would provide a more attractive
` ' streetscape.
Bettie Pilote offered a Motion to approve the Special Use Permit with conditions as set forth by
staff except for a 10' setback on Arthur Street for the park, that an interior walkway be included
and a deferral agreement be signed for street improvements on the northwest section of Arthur
Street and Ustick Road. Teny McConnell seconded the Motion.
�
ROLL CALL V01'E. Those voting yes: Pilote, McConnell, Higdem, Buckendorf, Wells,
Davidson. Those voting no: None. Absent and not voting: I�1one.
MOTION CARRIED
The next public hearing was a Code Amendment to reflect changes in Variance procedures to
reflect amendments to the State Code. Mary Higdem suggested that she would like the
opportunity to fiirther review this item.
Mary Higdem then offered a Motion to continue consideration of the proposed amendments to
the Caldwell Zoning Ordinance pertaining to Variance Procedures to a convenient date. Madeline
Buckendorf seconded the Motion.
ROLL CALL VOTE. Those voting yes: Higdem, Buckendorf, Wells, Davidson, Filote,
McConnell. Those voting no: None. Absent and not voting: None.
MOTION CARRIED
The next item was a preliminary plat of Sunridge Subdivision. Bettie Filote excused herself from
discussion citing conflict of interest.
Dennis reminded the Commission of what had transpired previously, and that this is a new
preliminary plat submitted for single family residential units. Mary Higdem asked what was the
concern about irrigation. Dennis stated that the City prefer that this development use irrigadon
water or other source of water, rather than City water to irrigate, since the water pressure in the
area is very low. Mr. Solis said that he is agreeable to this. Dennis explai.ned, in response to a
question from Mary, that details concerning this can be worked out between preliminary and final
plat stage.
After some further discussion, Mary Higdem offered a Motion to approve the Preliminary Plat for
Sunridge Subdivision with recommended temis and conditions. Terry McConnell seconded the
Motion.
ROLL CALL VOTE. Those voting yes: Higdem, Buckendorf, Wells, Davidson, McConnell.
'Those voting no: None. Those abstaining: Pilote. Absent and not voting: None.
MOTION CARRIED
MIIdUTES P&Z 4-7-94
Page 6
!
f .
The final item was discussion of items acted on by City Council. Dennis then reviewed agenda
items for the meeting agenda on April 21, 1994.
With no er business the meeting adjourned at 11:00 p.m.
Re g e ��1,
� Liz Yeary Tom Ensley
MINUTES P&Z 47-94
Page 7