Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout3-17-1994 P&Z MINUTES • PLANNING AND ZONING COMNIISSION MINUTES Meeting of March 17, 1994 Present: Chairman Tom Ensley, Mary Higdem, Terry McConnell, Bettie Pilote, Reed Taylor Absent: Madeline Buckendorf, Rick Wells Staff: Dennis Crooks, Liz Yeary The regular meetuig of the Planning and Zoning Commission was called to order by Chairrnan Tom Ensley, at 7:15 p.m. in the City Hall Council Chambers. Minutes of the Planning and Zoning Commission meeting of March 3, 1994, were approved as distributed with motion by Mary Higdem and seconded by Terry McConnell. The Commission reviewed the agenda and suggested that perhaps the item under Miscellaneous I SA Pot Bellied Pigs should be moved to an earlier place in the agenda since an initiative has already been made to amend the Code pertaining to farm animals within City limits. The request centers on whether or not to classify these animals as a pet or a farm animal. After moving the item to the first discussion on the agenda, the Commission unanimously agreed, with Motion by Mary Higdem and seconded by Terry McConnell, that this should be considered as part of the proposed Code Amendment on Animals in residential zones and would be addressed at a future public hearing. ROLL CALL VOTE. Those voting yes: Higdem, Taylor, Filote, McConnell. Those voting no: None. Absent and not voting: Buckendorf, Wells. MOTION CARRIED The next item was a request for a Variance by Orval Willis of 2504 Syringa to construct an I accessory building in the rear yard of his property in excess of the regulated height and square footage limitations. Dennis expla.ined the background to the request and added that the Engineering Department and the Fire Department had modified their suggested condirions. The applicant then testified on his own behalf and in response to a question from Mary Higdem concerning potential residential development on the west side of the currently undeveloped Georgia Avenue, Mr. Willis stated that he plans to build a nice building. Leland Van Slyke, a neighboring property owner, expressed some concern that the use might be changed to a commercial use but was assured by the Commission that this the residential zoning restricts such uses. Mr. Van Slyke then withdrew any objection to the request, adding that it would be a positive addition since it would house Mr. Willis' several vehicles. Mr. Willis confumed that he has no intention of doing business out of the building. Reed Taylor expressed concern that the height of the building was excessive for a residential azea but that the slope of the ground would mitigate that. Terry agreed stating that the property would present a better appearance viewed from the freeway. Mary Higdem also agreed and offered a MINiJTES P&Z 3-17-94 Page 1 ' motion to grant a variance to allow a structure to exceed the height and square footage limitation. The topographic features and the size of the lot are such that this produces special circumstances. She could not see any conflict with the Comprehensive Plan, nor did it present a change in zoning. Also, it is not detrimental to public health, safety and welfare. The Variance would be contingent on compliance with the suggested terms and conditions, with the rearyard setback requirement of 7.5 feet and that the applicant will comply with all the mociif'ied conditions of the Fire Department and the Engineering Department. Terry McConnell seconded the Motion. ROLL CALL VOTE. Those voting yes: Higdem, Taylor, McConnell. Abstain: Pilote. Those voting no: None. Absent and not voting: Buckendorf, Wells. MOTION CARRIED The second public hearing was a two part request for a Special Use Pemut to convert a two family dwelling into a three family dwelling at 1021 N.9th Ave., and a Variance to address front, reaz and side yard setback modifications. The applicant was Claude Brumfield. Dennis reminded the Commission that they had recently granted a Special Use Pemut to the , Jehovah's Wimesses Congregation to build a church on adjacent property, and that Mr. Brumfield , had been granted a Special Use Permit in 1992 to build the existing duplex. Dennis explained ' that when the duplex was reviewed the vacation of Joliet Street, which had changed the lot ; classification from a corner lot to an interior lot, had been overlooked when checking setbacks ' for that property. This oversight was the reason for the variance to correct that situation. ' Mr. Brumfield then test�ed, stating that if he had lrnown then about the vacation he would have ' moved his building closer to the northern property line, giving him more area to expand to the south. He asked the Comrnission for relief from the requirement to construct sidewalk, curb and !� gutter along the whole frontage, because the street was a dead-end street. '� I I In response to a question from Mary Higdem and Reed Taylor, Mr. Bnunfield explained that he owned property on both sides of the street, and the only people to use such a sidewalk would be his own family and tenants of his property. There was further discussion among the Commission concerning the requirement for sidewalk but I ' all agreed that there was a potential for young children to be using the street to access the neighboring park and store and a sidewalk would provide some measure of safety. Also, the I� church was installing sidewalks and there was still vacant property in the azea that could benefit '� from the sidewalk. � Terry McConnell then offered a Motion to approve the Special Use Permit subject to suggested tem�s and conditions. Bettie Pilote seconded the Motion. I ' ! MIlYUTES P&Z 3-17-94 Page 2 ' ROLL CALL VOTE. Those voting yes: McConnell, Higdem, Taylor, Pilote. Those voting no: None. Absent and not voting: Buckendorf, Wells. MOTION CARRIED Terry McConnell then offered a Motion to approve the Variance subject to suggested terms and conditions. Reed Taylor seconded the Motion. ROLL CALL VOTE. Those voting yes: McConnell, Higdem, Taylor, Pilote. Those voting ' no: None. Absent and not voting: Buckendorf, Wells. MOTION CARRIED The next public hearing was a request for a Special Use Pernut to develop a mobile home park on the south side of Linden Street between the railroad tracks and Indian Creek. Gary Lasher: applicant. Dennis explained the nature of the request, and demonstrated the location in relation to the Indian Creek Mobile Home Estates. Before testunony was opened, the Commission asked Dennis to explain for the record what could be done to address at some tune substandard streets and transportation in the community. Dennis said that he could convey in a memo to the Council the Commission's concerns. Dennis stated that the applicant wished to amend the conditions, specifically that condition #5 be amended to require a five foot (5') setback from interior side lot line instea.d of 7.5 feet but with a fifteen (15) foot separation between units. Mary Higdem asked what the decorative slat inserts cited in condition #3 would be made of and was advised that there aze cedar slats and plastic slats and this would be up to the discretion of the applicant. Gary Lasher then testified in his own behalf. He said that he has an option to purchase the 20 acres along Linden and owns the southern 20 acres. There is a tremendous demand for this type of housing and his four phase development to the south is almost full. This project would be developed over a period of 4 to 5 years in 50 space phases. He plans to irnprove Linden with curb, gutter and sidewalk and give the city 40 foot half right- of-way but he objects to the 25 foot setback for the mobile home park off Linden which further reduces his property and he asked the Commission to reduce that requirement to a fifteen foot setback from the right-of-way. He said that the fencing will have vinyl slats, rather than having a wood fence which would require more maintenance. There will be 3'/2 acres of greenbelt along Indian Creek and storage for recreational vehicles. In response to a question from Mary, Mr. Lasher stated that he will come to an agreement with Pioneer Irrigation to provide an easement for access for irrigation purposes along the canal bank. He considered the road width adequate to handle the projected traffic since both Cleveland Boulevard and Chicago provide access to Caldwell. He did agree that Aviation Way and Linden, and Chicago and Linden are bad intersections. Bill Gilbert then testified as an owner of adjacent property and is supportive of the development. MINLJTES P&Z 3-17-94 Page 3 • Pete Echevarria then spoke in opposition, citing a need for a public road between Linden and Ustick through the subject property. He felt there are not enough roads to handle the growth and he cannot access his own property. Dennis Scott then spoke. He stated that there is no access to his property without building a bridge across Indian Creek. However, he is not against the proposal. He expressed concern about the intersection of Chicago and Linden especially for large semis. Terry McConnell commented that as growth occurs and tax dollars come into the county, money will be provided to improve streets. S Gary I.asher then responded to testimony, stating that Mr. Echevarria acquired his property after the freeway was constructed knowing it was already landlocked. He had acquired the option on the Linden 20 acres to gain access to his southern 20 acre portion and Mr. Echevarria could do the same thing. Mr. Echevarria commented that he wants his property fenced to protect it from vandalism. The public hearing was then closed. Bettie Pilote complirnented Mr. Lasher on his previous development and stated that it would be a positive improvement with common areas, playgrounds, etc. Terry McConnell agreed stating that he had met with people in Mr. Lasher's other developments, and they had nothing but praise. He agreed that we do need to look at upgrading the roads in the azea. Reed Taylor commented that this is a good use of property. He sympathized with the landlocked pazcel owners but was hopeful that something could be worked out. Mary Higdem agreed, asking whether we sit back and wait for roads to improve or allow development anticipating an upgrade in road conditions later. There is a challenge to provide affordable housing of many varieties. She did not feel it was the responsibility of the Planning and Zoning Commission to work out Mr. Echevarria's problems and hoped that he and Mr. Lasher could work something out. Terry McConnell then offered a Motion to approve the Special Use Pernut with an amended condition #2a) requiring a 15 foot setback for the mobile home park from Linden Road rather than a 25 foot setback; an amended condition #Sd) requiring a five foot setback rather than a 7.5 foot setback from any interior side lot line and a new condition #11 requiring the applicant to work with Pioneer Irrigation to satisfy their needs for access for the waterway. Reed Taylor seconded the Motion. In response to a question from Mary Higdem, Dennis stated that the 25' setback required is for landscaping and a buffer for aesthetics. He did not agree with Mr. Lasher that it is an excessive requirement. He cautioned the Commission to look at that carefully because that is the only substantial landscaping and screens the park from the public right-of-way. Any residential uses would have a 20' or 25' setback. In the ordinance, there are provisions to grant exceptions if the circumstances are warranted. Reed Taylor asked if there would be a berm feature there. Dennis commented that there is a condition to have a landscaping plan approved. Mary Higdem asked if a 40' dedication were MINUT'ES P&Z 3-17-94 Page 4 . sufficient for road construction. Dennis stated that it will provide an 80' right-of-way. If the Airport expansion goes through, Linden will terminate on the other side of the freeway and become a frontage road to Highway 20/26. An 80' right-of-way meets the standard for an arterial. Bettie Filote stated that 15 feet with landscaping and fencing and the 10 feet for individual units is a su�cient setback, � Terry McConnell then offered a Motion to approve the Special Use Permit subject to suggested amended terms and conditions. Reed Taylor seconded the Motion. ROLL CALL VOTE. Those voting yes: McConnell, Higdem, Taylor, Pilote. Those voting no: None. Absent and not voting: Buckendorf, Wells. MOTION CARRIED The final public hearing was a request for a variance to allow a stairway to encroach into the street side setback at 1301 Cleveland. Applicant was Robert Preece. Dennis explained the request indicating on the plan the location of the stairway in relation to the porch of the building. Mr. Preece then spoke, stating that he is a representative of his brother who owns the property. He agreed that the porch, which was constructed prior to zoning regulations, encroaches into the side setback more than would the stairway. In response to a question from Mary, Mr. Preece conf'u�med that he is renovating the whole building, painting the outside, landscaping and providing an automatic sprinkler system. Parking will be off the alley. Mary Higdem felt that there were exceptional circumstances due to the age of the building, that the location for the stairway is better than elsewhere on the property for security purposes, that it is not in conflict with the Comprehensive Plan and that the improvements to the house will be an asset to the neighborhood. Teny McConnell commented that if the request had been presented prior to construction of the stairway, it probably would have been approved due to the location of the e�sting porch. Bettie Pilote then offered a Motion to approve the variance to allow the exterior stairway to encroach into the street side setback with suggested terms and conditions. Terry McConnell seconded the Motion. ' ROLL CALL VOTE. Those voting yes: Filote, McConnell, Higdem, Taylor. Those voting no: None. Absent and not voting: Buckendorf, Wells. I MOTION CARRIED The public hearing portion of the meeting was then closed. Brad Anselrno was present to request permission to temporarily reopen the golf driving range at Chicago and 21st Avenue prior to the Commission reviewing his request for an extension of his temporary permit, which had expired January 1, 1994. Mr. Ar�selmo had understood that this was being reviewed at this meeting, but it was explained that it had to be at a public hearing and the earliest date possible was April 7, MINUTES P&Z 3-17-94 Page 5 . 1994. He was being requested by many people to reopen the range and asked the Comrnission if it were possible. Dennis said that there had been no complaints during the previous operation and the use had proven a suitable one. The Comrnission could see no reason why opening early could cause a problem. The buildings are there, the facilities are there and operating the facility does not incur upon him a major investment which will put the Planning and Z,orung Commission in an awkward position when re-evaluating this request at the forthcoming public hearing. No motion or action was taken by the Cornmission. Dennis then reviewed potential items for upcoming agendas, and the need for two meetings in April. He also reported on actions taken by Council, including the closure on the Turning Point homeless shelter, whose occupancy was reduced to 1 S by action of the Council. The Commission restated its concern about substandard streets and asked Dennis to relay them to Council in a letter. With no further business the meeting adjourned at 10:00 p.m. Recording Secretary, �� L � Ye �' Tom Ensley � # i MINUTES P&Z 3-17-94 Page 6