HomeMy WebLinkAbout10-7-1993 P&Z MINUTES r
PLANNING AND ZONING COMMISSION
' MINUTES
� Meeting of October 7, 1993
Present: Chairman Tom Ensley, Rita Earl, Phil Frye, Mary Higdem, Terry McConn�Ll,
Reed Taylor, Rick Wells
Absent: None.
Staff: Dennis Crooks and Sue Brown
The regular meeting of the Planning and Zaning Commission was called to order by Ch�air�a_.r:x
Tom Ensley, at 7:15 p.m. in the City Hall Council Chambers.
Tom Ensley advised the Commission that Wanda Anthony had resigned her appointment to th�
Planning and Zoning Commission and that Reed Taylor had been appointed as her replaceme��
by the City Council upon recommendation of the Mayor. The appointment was conf'umed by
City Council at its meeting of October 4, 1993. Tom welcomed Reed to the Commission.
The Chairman reported that the item concerning Sunridge Subdivision Preliminary Plat was
withdrawn from the agenda at the request of the applicant. Correspondence from the appli�a.rr.t'�
engineer requesting the withdrawal was entered into the record.
The Minutes of the Planning and Zaning Comrnission Meeting of September lb, 1993, were
approved, with motion submitted by Mary Higdem and seconded by Rita Earl.
The first public hearing on the agenda was a request for a Special Use Permit to construct �
accessory building of 21' in the R-1 zoning district which would exceed the required height
maximum of 15' by 6'. The location of the property is at 2521 Norman Street. Applica�t: �rt
Scovell.
Dennis described the request, illusrtrating the subject property on the overhead projector, pa�.t��.�
out the portion of the property to the rear which the applicant purchased for this use.
The a licant Mr. Scovell ex lained the reasons for his r uest that the buildina would be us�d
PP , � P � , �
for covered storage for his motorhome and boat and that the area would be landscaped �ith
trees, grass and decorative rock
In response to a question from Mary Higdem, the applicant indicated where the present
screening is and explained that the height of the buildin� is to accommodate his motorhome. '�1�.�
building is prefabricated and thus cannot be made smaller.
In response to a question from Reed Taylor, the applicant stated that there would be no
bodywork done in the buiiding. In response to a question from Rita Earl, Dennis explainec� thax
the terms and conditions of the permit run with the land and the use would therefore be
transfera.ble on transfer of ownership. Mr. Scovell stated that he was in agreement with aIl
conditions set down in the Staff Report.
MINLTTES P8c2 10-07-93
Page 1
� Nola Waite, 116 Mountainview, then testitied expressing concern about potential commerci�
use of the property and tr�c. She was satisfied that the conditions of the permit would deal
' with these issues.
There being no conespondence or telephone calls the public hearin� was then closed.
After some discussion Rita Earl suggested that a condition be added restricting commercial u��
of the building in order to protect the interests of the neighborhood in the future. Phil Frye
agreed with this sugoestion. Reed Taylor considered the neighborhood was already protected
under the proposed terrns and conditions.
After some further discussion, Rick Wells offered a Motion ta approve the Special Use Per��
subject to amended terms and conditions, notably
"1. That the Special Use Pemut is granted for the construction of an accessory
building for the sole purpose of non-commercial stora.ge, meeting all zoning
requirements except that the structure may be 21 feet in height and as indicated on
approved site plan labeled Fxhibit "A".
Motion was seconded by Mary Higdem.
Rita Earl asked Dennis if he felt with that wording they are opening the door for business type
uses. Dennis sugaested the Commission might want stronger language to have the storage
incidental to the residential use and that commercial uses or activities be prohibited.
R.ita Earl offered a motiou to amend the wording to reflect the stronger language. Reed
Taylor seconded the motion.
ROLL CALL VOTE. Those voting yes: Earl, Higdem, Wells, Frye, Taylor, McConnell.
Those voting no: None. Absent and not voting: None.
MOTION C �
A vote was then taken on Rick Wells' Motion. Final wording to read:
"1. That the Special Use Permit is branted for the construction of an accessory buildizig f�r
the sole purpose of non-commercial storage, incidental to the principal residential use on
the property, meeting all zoning requirements except that the structure may be 21 feet ira
height and as indicated on approved site plan labeled Exhibit "A". Cornmercial uses r��
activities within said building shall be strictly prohibited."
ROLL CALL VOTE. Those voting yes: Wells, Frye, Taylor, McConnell, Earl, Higdem.
Those voting no: None. Absent and not voting: None.
MOTION C �
MINUTES P&Z 10-07-93
Page 2
.
Dennis then reviewed City Council action. He advised the Commission that the Council had
.
again continued the item involving potential use of a portion of Sebree Park for a parki�g 1��.
He also reported that the City Couucil appealed a decision of the Canyon County
Commissioners in approving a Plan amendment, zone chan�e and conditional use pernut for
property next to Whittenberger Park from agricultural to commercial for an auto truck repair
facility. This case will be heard by the County Commissioners on October 14. Although the
area is not in our impact area it is in our requested impact area and our request was submitted
prior to the decision to rezone the property.
Dennis reviewed potenrial items for the October 21 and the November 18 agendas.
He reminded the Commission that a work session with the Traffic Corr�mission ha.s been
tentatively proposed for Thursday evenin„ November 4 to discuss issues related to transportatian,
traffic, streets and circuiation.
Rick Wells discussed the need for park space in areas of o owth and Dennis said that more will
be discussed on this issue when the Subdivision Ordinance is updated. Phil Frye questioned the
concept of park sites developing in conjunction with new schools and whether it had ever been
given consideration.
Dennis then reported on his participation in the Idaho Planning Conference and distributed capies
of changes to the Idaho State Local Plannuig Act. There will have to be some Code
Amendments to the Zoning Ordinance to bring the Zoning Ordinance into compliance with tl�.e
revised Act.
Rita and Tom reported on calls concerning Tuming Point. Dennis reminded the Commission that
all contacts from the applicant should be disclosed at subsequent public hearings.
With no further business the meeting adjourned at 8:35 p.m.
SS � ��
��.e.�b � �.,�:. �
Recordin Secret , � Chairman,
g �Y
Sue Brown Tom Ensley
MINUTES PBr.Z 10-07-�
Page 3