HomeMy WebLinkAbout1-21-1993 P&Z MINUTES , � � �
PLANNING AND ZONING COMMISSION
1blIl�itl'I'ES
Meeting of January 21, 1993
Present: Wanda Anthony, R.ita Earl, Tom Ensley, Phil Frye, Mary Higdem Teny
McConnell and Rick Wells.
Staff: Dennis Crooks and Liz Yeary
Absent: None
A pre-agenda meeting was held at 7:00 p.m. where general agenda items were discussed.
The regular meeting of the Planning and Zoning Commission was then called to order by I
Tom Ensley, �ce Q�airman, at 7:15 p.m. in the City Hall Council Chambers.
The Minutes of the Planning and Zoning Commission meeting of December 17, 1992 were
approved as submitted.
The next item on the agenda was the Commission Organization. Chairman pro tem Tom
Ensley advised the Commission of the reappointment of Commissioners Phil Frye and Rick
Wells and the new appointrnent of Terry McConnell to replace Chuck Randolph.
There followed election of officers. Mary Higdem nominated Tom Ensley as Chairman,
citing his years of service on both Planning and Zoning and Historic Preservation, his
professional abilities and his contributions to the community as a whole. Wanda Anthony
seconded the nomination. There were no other nominations. Commissioner Ensley
accepted the nominarion on the understanding that the appointment would be for one year
only and spoke in favor of other Commissioners having the opportunity to serve in the role
of Chair. He then nominated Mary Higdem as �ce Chair which she accepted. There were
no other nominations. Wanda Anthony then moved and Rita Earl seconded a motion to
appoint Tom Ensley as Chairman wluch was approved unanimously. Rita Earl moved and
Wanda Anthony seconded a motion to appoint Mary Higdem as Vice Chair which pas.sed
»n�m_ously. Rita Earl then moved to appoint Wanda Anthony as Secretary, which 1Viaiy
Higdem seconded and wluch passed unanimously There were no other nominations.
The meeting then proceeded to the public hearing portion of the agenda. ChaiYman Ensley
explained the purpose of hearings and the procedure to be followed. He reported that staff
had received a letter withdrawing the Noah Special Use Permit application, and that item
was therefore removed from the agenda.
The first item on the agenda was a Special Use Permit application to operate a professional
office in the R 3 zoni�g district and to locate a sign within the required setback area.
Applicant: Jack Swafford. This item was a continuation from the December 17, 1992
meeting. Dennis Crooks gave the background io the request outlining the identified items
of concern: the placement of the sign, the results of the inspection by the Building Official,
the multiple uses on the properry, site improvements, and the height of the hedge on the
south properry line.
MINUT'ES P&Z Ol/21/93
Page 1
r � t
The applicant, Jack Swafford, gave testimony, commenting that he had hired a professional
to install the sign and assumed that this person would be cognizant of local regularions.
Since the sign is now placed in concrete he would appreciate the Commission pernutting
the sign placement to remain with recommended conditions of staff. Mr. Swafford then
presented a letter, attached to the file as Exhibit A, from his northern neighbor requesting
Commission not require a solid fence between the two properties since they prefer the
existing chain link fence.
In reference to the day care use, the applicant explained that the garage is not used for the
day care operation and has not been altered to accommodate that use. He commented that
his wife wishes to continue the child care and would like a group day care facility, for
which she is licensed by the State. The child care use takes place within the kitchen,
eating area, separate dining room and a room adjacent to the garage. He outlined the
times of operation for the child care facility and the law practice.
Mr. Swafford accepted the fact that he has to comply with handicapped accessibility
requirements and has already requested bids to make alterations.
In response to a question from Commissioner Higdem the applicant stated that the ground
floor comprises approximately 3100 sq.ft. The lower floor comprises 1,000 sq.ft which is
the living area for the family.
The applicant stated a willingness to reduce the size of the child care facility to a day care
home. In response to a question from Conunissioner Earl, Mr. Crooks quoted from the
code stating that the northern fence requirement could be modified upon written consent
of the adjoining property owner. In response to a question from Commissioner Anthony
the applicant stated that the sign was installed to advertise his business. In answer to a
question from Rita Earl, staff confirmed that the group day care facility was not part of the
legal notice of hearing since the use has been an ongoing use. It may be a discretionary
consideration when taken into account with the multiple uses on the properry. For
example, if the office were approved as a special use, the property could be limited from
other mulriple uses such as the daycare.
The applicant did not feel there was any problem with parking. With no other testimony
the public hearing was then closed. Commissioner Wells asked staff whether there had
been any phone calls in opposition. Staff replied that there had been a call which
expressed concern about the day care operation.
Commissioner Higdem commented about the heavy traffic on lOth Avenue and expressed
concern about the width of the driveway approach.
Commissioner Higdem then offered a motion to approve the Special Use Pernait subject to
the following additions and amendments to condirions suggested by staff. These include
a requirement to change the group child care facility to a family day care home caring for
not more than six children in addition to their own children; remove condition #3
requiring a fence on the northern properry line; strike the word "approximately" and
MINUTES P&Z Ol/21/93
Page 2
. .
replace with "not less than" on the driveway approach; require that the hedge/shrubbery
on the southern property line be trimmed to 36" in compliance with the Code, contingent
on the hedge being on the applicant's property.
Rita Earl seconded the motion which passed unanimously.
The next item on the agenda was a request by the City for Comprehensive Plan Land Use
Designation and Zone classification for appro�mately 68 acres under consideration for
annexation by City Council. The properry is owned by the City apart from one small
residential enclave. This enclave is recommended to be zoned R-2F (Medium Density
Residential; Flood Plain Overlay) to protect the viabiliry of the residential use. In response
to a question from Phil Fry, Dennis explained that the shooting range in the proposed M-1
(Light Industrial) portion had received a conditional use pernut from Canyon County and
would, therefore, be considered a legitimate use by the City. He explained that the "F"
Flood Plain Overlay is a designation for safety and insurance purposes and requires
particular protection such as raising finished floor elevations when structures are located
in those areas.
Dick Winder, on behalf of Caldwell Unlimited, spoke concerning the possibility of
constructing an alternative route for fann related traffic into the City through this area, in
order to avoid such vehicles using the Freeway. Mr. Winder requested the Commission
consider a link to Highway 20/26 along the south boundary of the gravel pit area citing
future benefits to Caldwell. Mr. Crooks felt this could be included in upcoming
Comprehensive Planning efforts in connection with the transportation or parks component
of the Plan. In this way, as development occurs in that sector, such a route could be taken
into consideration.
Mr. Winder also expressed concern about the Greenbelt Master Plan and the fact that there
has never been any public hearings on the Plan or official endorsements of the Plan by the
City.
Commissioner Frye then offered a motion to forward to City Council the proposed
Comprehensive Plan Land Use Designations with the proviso that a future connection from
Highway 20/26 to Chicago Street be given consideration and included in future planning.
Commissioner McConnell seconded the motion which passed i�nan�mously.
Commissioner Frye then offered a motion to forward to City Council the proposed Zone
classificarions of M1F (Light Industrial; Flood Plain Overlay) and RZF (Medium Density;
Flood Plain Overlay) which Commissioner Anthony seconded and which passed
iinanimously.
The final public hearing was a proposed ordinance concerning development agreements.
Mr. Crooks explained the history and purpose of the proposal and the benefits to both
developers and the City. Commissioner Higdem asked for clarification on some points and
Commissioner Earl also requested clarification. Commissioner Frye asked staff to comment
MIIVUT'ES P&Z Ol/21/93
Page 3
. .
on "contract zoning". Dennis explained that with a"conventional" zone change conditions
cannot be placed on development. However, with "development agreements" a city and
a developer can come to an agreement as to use of the properry, particularly in areas
where zoning districts are adjacent and where pernutted uses in the respecrive zoning
districts may not be compatible.
Dick Winder testified as a representative of the Board of Realtors requesting that the
Commission not act on the proposal until the Board has an opportunity to review the
ordinance. He also expressed concern that prospecrive developers on being asked to
divulge details of proposals might simply withdraw a project. Dennis indicated that the
Code Amendment was not a matter of urgency and that additional input would be
encouraged and welcomed.
Commissioner Earl commented that the Commission cannot deny a zone change simply
because it does not know plans for the proposed zone.
Commissioner Frye moved to continue the hearing until a convenient future date and asked
staff to send copies of the proposal to developers such as Bob Hibbard, Chuck Karn and
Gary Lasher for their comment. Mary Higdem seconded the motion which passed
unanimously.
Under miscellaneous items staff reported on a request to extend the time frame required
for Jefferson Pazk Subdivision to present final plans for recordation of the remaining phases
of development. Dennis Crooks explained that the final plat for the first phase had been
approved by City Council with conditions but that the developer was not yet ready to
record the remainder of the project. At some point in the future, with the growing trend
to larger developments, the Commission will have to deal with phased development and
look toward amending the Cit�s subdivision ordinance to address this issue.
Commissioner Higdem offered a motion to grant a 12 month time extension for the
Preliminary Plat, which Commissioner McConnell seconded, and which passed unanimously
with Commissioner Earl abstaining.
The next item was the applicability of the Infrastructure Ordinance to the Planning and
Zoning Commission. Mr. Crooks explained that the City Council adopted this Ordinance
in October, 1992. However, it did not appear that the Commission was afforded an
opportunity to review or provide input into the document. Dennis further stated that the
Infrastructure Ordinance is intended to address improvements on incremental or in-fill type
development but does have an impact on Planning and Zoning decisions, particularly
special use permit requests. The Infrastructure Ordinance sets minimum standards and
Idaho Code as well as the Cit�s Zoning Ordinance, allows the Commission through project
cnditioning to require more stringent standards when warranted. The Commission
indicated that in the future they would like to have the opportunity to review ordinances
that have a potenrial influence on their ability to review and render a decision on certain
items.
MINUTES P&Z Ol/21/93
Page 4
• ' , .
Commissioner Earl questioned the street lighting Onlinance which refers to street lighting
specifications but stated that no specifications have been published. In the same instance,
there are no published specifications for infrastructure improvements. Tom Ensley
suggested that City Council should be made aware of this deficiency and that the
specifications be made available as soon as possible.
Dennis discussed the Impact Fee Legislation which was adopted by the State in 1991 and
its possible future application for Caldwell.
The next miscellaneous item was the School Facilities and Transportation item which, as
a result of an Amendment to the Idaho Code, is now a required component of a
communit�s Comprehensive Plan. Dennis indicated that this should be made a part of
Caldwell's Plan by fall of 1993. In addition, we hope to have the whole Plan updated by
the end of 1993.
Recent action taken by City Council was reported and the tentarive agenda for the meeting
on February 18 was outlined. In view of several upcoming projects it was agreed to hold
a Planning and Zoning Commission meeting on March 4 in addition to the regular meeting
on March 18. A workshop for February 10 from 3:00 p.m. to 6:00 p.m. was also
scheduled.
There was no other business and the meeting was adjourned at 9:45 p.m.
�� ' �
�
Recording Secretary, Chairman,
Liz Yeary Tom Ensley
MINUTES P&Z Ol/21/93
Page 5