Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout5-21-1992 P&Z MINUTES 1 CPTY OF C.ALDWELL PLANNIlVG AND ZONING CONIlVIISSION 1��IIIVUTES MAY 21, 1992 COMMISSION PRESENT: ABSFNI': STAFF PRESENT: Chairman Chuck Randolph, Jim Blizzard, Liz Yeary Rick Wells, Rita Earl, Tom Ensley, Mary Higdem, Phil Frye, Wanda Anthony, Carlos Ferreira ITEM ACITON/FOI.LOW-UP 1. PRE-AGENDA: City Council Conference Room 7:00 p.m R.ita Earl pointed �out on the March 19 Minutes that she had abstained from voting on Hafen Hills Subdivision. Rita Earl indicated that she would abstain from voting on the Lasher PUD Special Use Permit and the Rojmar Subdivision. Tom Ensley indicated that he would abstain from voting on the Marjorie Bushnell Community Center Special Use Pernut. Jim Blizzard pointed out that the Staff Report on the Lasher PUD showed the zoning as R-3 when it is R-2. Carlos Ferreira felt that Pioneer Irrigarion concerns had not been addressed by the Staff Report on the PUD but Chairman indicated this could be addressed under the conditions of the Special Use Permit. The Director indicated an error on page 2 of the Lasher PUD Staff Report that identified the area east of the proposed 4 f�l development as unincorporated when it is within City limits. The Commission agreed to hear the Lasher PUD application at one time but would vote first on the Special Use Pemut and then vote whether or not to recommend the Plat subdivision be forwarded to City Council with recommendation for approval. Commissioner Earl stated that Jerry Earl would be speaking in reference to items on the agenda and that his opinions were his own. 2. ROLL CALL 3(a) MINUTES: Approval of Minutes from the Anproved, Planning and Zoning Commission Meeting of 03-19-92. Meeting Minutes of March 19, 1992. A morion was made by Rita Earl and seconded by Wanda Anthony to adopt the minutes with the exception of Page 13, showing abstention of Commissioner Earl, and unanimously passed. 3(b) MINUTES: Approval of Minutes from the Approved, Planning and Zoning Commission Meeting of 04-16-92. Meeting Minutes of April 16, 1992. A motion was made by Rita Earl and seconded by Mary Higdem to adopt the minutes as submitted and unanimously passed. 4. PUBLIC HEARINGS Chairman R.andolph indicated that since Commissioner Earl will be abstaining from voting on items 4A and 5A and Commissioner Ensley will be abstaining from voting on item 4B, alternate Commissioner Ferreira will vote on those items. 4A. Case No. 92-SUP-10 Special Use Pemut application to allow a Manufactured Home Planned Unit Development 3 on Florida Avenue between Cherry Street and Beech Avenue. Applicant, Gary D. Lasher. Jim Blizzard presented the background to the request and location of the project. He explained that the project will be developed in Phases and that street improvements will be provided as each phase develops. Gary Lasher, applicant, further outlined the proposal, stating that it will be an adult-only facility, which will fulfill a need in Caldwell. The internal infrastructure will be the property of the owner and will be maintained by him, that he would come to an agreement with Pioneer Irrigation to address their concerns, and that he will comply with all City identified concerns. Street lights will be provided throughout the development and on Beech, Florida and Cherry. Gerry Earl testified as surveyor of the project, and clarified for the Commission the requirements regarding water rights identified by Pioneer Irrigation. A developer is required to provide each lot with irrigation water. The water does not have to be Pioneer Imgation water and this development will use City water to landscape etc. Pioneer Irrigation will be notified if any lots are sold so that they may obtain the assessment fee prescribed. Gerry Earl, as homeowner, Dick Winder and Gary Falen testified in favor of the project. Brian Finley testified against the project citing a projected devaluation in his properry values. Dick Phillips testified concerning the difference between mobile homes and manufactured homes, and the legality of adult-only developments, stating that Mr. Lashex's project appeared to be -- a quality project. 4 T'he applicant requested that the setbacks be MOTION to amend side setback requirement in reduced from the required 4(8) =12 foot stated � Conditions of Approval from 12' to 8' carried. in the Staff Report and on the clarification of the Building Inspector it was agreed to modify this requirement to four feet on both sides. Motion was made by Carlos Ferreira and seconded by Phil Frye to amend the setback requirement. Vote was unanimous. In response to a question from Tom Ensley, the applicant confirmed that there will be covenants ' on the properry which would identify the adult- only requirement and that these covenants would be passed by the City attorney for legal compliance. Tom Ensley added that the age requirement could be added as a 16th condition. Regarding the street lighting plans, the applicant and the City will have to reach an agreement on placement and standard. Motion made by Carlos Ferreira and seconded by MOTION to approve Special Use Permit carried Tom Ensley to approve the Special Use Permit subject to the following ternis and conditions: based on the finding that the proposal satisfies the requirements of Section 6-3-4 of the Zoning Ordinance, subject to the stated conditions, amended as shown in the list. The vote was unanimous apart from the abstention of Rita EarL 5 ITEM ACTION/FOLLOW—UP 1. The following site development standards will apply to the planned unit development: a. Setbacks for structures, all residential lots Front 10', Rear 10', Side 4'and 4'; b. Setback for Lot 1 Block 3 (Recreational Facility) Front 15', Rear 10', Side 15' c. Maximum coverage of any lot by structures shall not exceed 50% of the total lot area; 2. The divided entry into the development from Florida Avenue shall be constructed providing a minim� width of twenty feet, from curb to curb, for each lane; 3. The owner will designate "no parking", by signs or marked curbs, along one side of each of the local streets within the development, as approved by the City Fire Department; 4. Prior to the sale or lease of any lots, the owner will install fire hydrants located and sized to the specifications approved by the City Fire Department and Water Department; 5. Landscaping will be provided around the recreation facility, the median dividing the entry into the development and along adjacent public streets. A piped irrigation system shall be provided for all landscaped areas. Selection and installation of trees or shrubs along public streets shall be 6 ITEM ACTION/FOLLOW—UP - subject to approval by the City Forester; 6. The owner shall install street lighting along public streets to satisfy standards approved by the Police Department and City Engineer; 7. Paved off-street parking spaces, designed to City standards will be constructed at each space and the recreation facility; 8. The developer will participate with the construction street improvements, including curb, gutter, paving and sidewalks where the development is adjacent to Cheny Street and Florida Avenue. Construction plans for public improvements will be approved by the City Engineer; 9. The developer will provide all easements necessary, approved by the City Engineer, for stormwater drainage and utility service; 10. A drainage plan will be submitted to the City Engineer and approved prior to any grading or construction; 11. The use of Lot 1, Block 1 shall be as a common area used for the storage of recreational vehicles and equipment; 12. The use of Lot 1, Block 3 shall be a common area used for recreationalactivities; development of this recreation area will be completed prior to the sale or lease of more than 30 lots; 7 ITEM ACTION/FOLLOW-UP 13. The developer shall install a 6' high wood perimeter fence, finished side facing public streets, around the development prior to the lease or sale of any lot. 14. The development may be constructed in two phases. (Phase I- Block 1 Lots 1-4, 13-29, Block 2, Lots 7-12; Block 3, Lots 1-11; Phase II - Block 1, Lots 5-14; Block 2, Lots 1-6) . Proposed and required improvements for each phase will be completed prior to the lease or sale of any lot. 15. All residences and the recreation building shall be constructed in conformance with the standards of the Uniform Building Code or be a Class A Manufactured Home as defined by Section 6-6-1 CMC. All manufactured homes shall conform with the development standards for manufactured homes on an individual lot established by Section 6-5-4 CMC. 16. Applicant will provide a copy of covenants, to be approved by staff and City attorney, which will include requirement of adult-only aspect of the development. 17. Applicant will come to an agreement with the Planning and Zoning Director and Pioneer Irrigation District to address irrigation concerns. Chairman Randolph then asked the Conunission to address the subdivision aspect of the Plat. 8 ITEM ACTION/FOLLOW—UP The Director clarified the recommendations MOTION to forward plat to City Council with outlined in the Staff Report asking that the recommendation for approval subject to the Commission reword certain items. following conditions: Motion made by Wanda Anthony and seconded 1. All streets, water and sewer systems, by Carlos Ferreira that the plat be forwarded to fences and other improvements within the City Council with a recommendation for approval development shall be privately owned and subject to the conditions listed. Vote was maintained; unanimous with Rita Earl abstaining. 2. A revised final plat will be prepared for approval by the Council; plat will show setbacks; plat will have wording indicating that roads and utilities will be privately owned and maintained. 3. Prior to certification of the plat by the City Clerk, the developer shall execute an agreement of performance approved by the City Engineer and post a performance bond or sinular financial instrument, the amount of which will allow for completion of all required public improvements. 4. Applicant will come to an agreement with the Planning and Zoning Director and Pioneer Irrigation District to address irrigation concerns. 4B. Case No. 92-SUP-11 Special Use Pernut application to allow the operation of a gymnasium facility in the Marjorie Bushnell Community Center facility on 12th Avenue between Dearborn and Everett. Applicant, City of Caldwell, agents, Teri Ottens and Tom Wheeler. Mr. Blizzard gave the background to the request, emphasizing that the permit will open the 8900 sq.ft. gynuiasium only and any other portion of the building will not be used without another Special Use Permit. - 9 IT� ACTION/FOLLOW The Director referred to the narrative portion of the application which describes some of the proposed uses, parking plans and other aspects of the development. Some of the potential concerns raised by staff were parking space availability, which staff identify as 84 developed off-street spaces at the senior center, library and the gymnasium facility itself. Staff recommend approval of the Permit subject to the conditions outlined in the Staff Report. The Chairman requested that the record show that the Engineering Report portion of the Staff Report be entitled "Engineering". Mr. Randolph indicated that the Director recommends assessing the viability of the Special Use Permit based on Page 4 of the Staff Report taken from the Caldwell Zoning Ordinance. Phil Frye asked if a detailed Plot Plan was submitted and was advised that Attachment A was the Plot Plan and there was nothing more detailed, no elevation drawing or landscaping plans. Mr. Frye expressed concern that such details are required from regular businesses when making application and similar information should be required of city faciliries. Rita Earl pointed out code deficiencies itemized in the Staff Report and asked if these had yet been addressed. Mr. Blizzard reported that they had not yet been addressed, but that landscaping plans aze submitted generally on a conceptual level initially and then in greater detail as a project is developed. Wanda Anthony noted that recommendation #9 of the Report asks for a year in which to complete landscaping plans, whereas normally the time frame is a lot less. 10 ITEM ACTION/FOLZOW—UP In response to a question from Rick Wells, Mr. Blizzard explained that item # 7 of the evaluation criteria should be construed as evaluating the minimum standards required. Teri Ottens presented the background to the case, explaining that the 4C Committee has been given responsibility by the City Council to design and raise funds in order to complete the facility. The use will not be a spectator use and the times scheduled will be organized so as not to conflict with the Senior Center. Some of the uses of the gymnasium would be basketball, volleyball, open gymnasium, senior walking track, potentially some teen dances and such, and programs connected with the Youth Advisory Board and Gang Prevention program. Landscaping plans cannot be provided as plans for the rest of the facility have to be addressed first. Initially plans are to put u1 minimal landscaping as to invest money in extensive landscaping at this time would be a waste of money. As the Staff Report states, in a year landscape and design plans will be ready and available and the 4C Committee will be in a position to submit plans for the remainder of the building. Handicapped access to the gymnasium will be temporary until the rest of the building is planned and ADA standards will be met. While she did not feel that the Planning and Zoning Commission should be concerned with structural design, an architect, though not a structural engineer, had looked at the building and indicated that it appeared to be sound. Everyone who has looked at the building has said that it is structurally sound and we do have that in writing. Concerning parking, they do not anticipate more than 40 cars at one time. They do plan to approach the Traffic Commission to allow diagonal parking on Everett which will add some 11 ITEM ACTION/FOLLOW-UP spaces. They also plan to use Sebree Park spaces to alleviate any problems. Regarding the sign, it has served a very useful purpose in promoting and encouraging funding for the project and the Committee would like to continue to display the sign. Ms. Ottens explained that the debris is part of the construction phase and will be cleared away as soon as feasible. BFI have donated a � dumpster to assist in the process. The 4C Comnuttee find nothing they would be unable to comply with in the suggested conditions in the Staff Report. In response to a question from Chuck Randolph, the applicant indicated that they are looking at an August 1 opening for the gym only, and that there would be restrooms for use in the basement area. Rita Earl raised the question of what would happen if it was determined not to use the remainder of the facility, and Ms. Ottens confirmed that the gym could stand alone, although the hope is that the rest of the facility will be viable. In response to a question from Mary Higdem, Ms. Ottens explained the timing of the American Disabilities Act and the deadline for preliminary plan design by July 1992 and all buildings to be handicapped accessible, according to ADA standards, by 1995. Commissioner Earl questioned the Traffic Commission's input on traffic and on-street parking design and the applicant explained this was in process. Commissioner Frye cited the narrative's proposal of "teen dances" but the applicant stated that this is only in the ideas stage and under discussion with Parks and Recreation. Commissioner Frye also questioned obtaining a building pernut but Tom Wheeler, Project Manager, confirmed that this is not necessary at this time. In response to a question 12 IT � ACTION/FOLLOW from Carlos Ferreira, the applicant stated that they do not anricipate more than the numbers of two basketball teams using the gym at one time and schedules would be attempted to work with ; adjacent facilities to ease traffic and parking problems. Commissioner Ferreira questioned costs involved in total upgrading, particularly of sidewalks and landscaping. Mary Higdem referred to the auditorium and t questioned possible parking, and Ms. Ottens mentioned some of the possibilities but that that is in the design stage. Commissioner Higdem responded that she felt an overall complete plan should be designed and accepted rather than completing parts a piece at a time. Ms. Ottens replied that the Council recognized the need for the gyrcuiasium facility and since funding is a problem it was decided that the City should go ahead with the gymnasium portion. Because the Council made that decision more donations are being granted. Rita Earl concurred with Mary Higdem that an overall plan was necessary before the piecemeal portions could be addressed and that there are other facilities available which could be used until the whole project design is complete. Phil Frye mentioned the parking availability and the evaluation by staff. The applicant responded that discussions are under way with the LDS Church to share their parking facility at times of high usage of the proposed gynulasium. In response to a question from the Chairman, Ms. Ottens stated that Council advised them not to apply for a Special Use Pernut from Planning and Zoning Commission until Council had decided that it was a viable proposition. Commissioner Higdem felt that it was impossible to evaluate the gymnasium Special Use Permit without evaluating the whole facility. Tom Wheeler then came to the podium. He stated that after conferring with the Fire 13 ITEM ACTION/FOLLOW Marshall any kind of dances would be severely limited by the occupant load. The main purpose of opening the gym is as a gymnasium facility in response to a stated need, and as the facility is seen to be functioning, more interest and donarions will be generated. In response to a question from Wanda Anthony, Mr. Wheeler confirmed that apart from one wall which would have to be partially rebuilt, the columns of the gynuiasium will support it on its own. Lane Thomas addressed the Commission speaking in favor of the facility and as a member of the 4C Committee. He described the concept of the Community Arts and Recreation Center and funding and need for such a facility. In response to a question from Rick Wells, Mr. Thomas confirmed that the gymnasium will not _ be used for theater unless it is brought back to the Conunission as part of a master plan. Commissioner Ferreira raised the possibility of temporary parking availability and Tom Wheeler indicated on the plan where such areas might be. Geny Earl spoke to the Conunission in opposition to the request reading from a report which is attached to the record as Exhibit A. There were various questions raised concerning the report which Mr. Earl answered. Kathleen Lamm testified in opposition to the request. She is concerned that Sebree Park remain a park as a service to the community and recommended that the block between Cleveland and Dearborn be demolished to provide necessary parking. In response to a question from R.ita Earl, she described the parking situation at her daycare facility and at the Library and Senior Center. She added that non- spectator sports in fact do generate spectators and that this whole facility needs to be addressed 14 IT� ACTION/FOLLOW-UP in granting the Special Use for the gymnasium to alleviate problems in the future. The Chairman noted the testimony concerning Sebree Park is in reference to the applicant's narrative statement submitted as part of the application. Enoch Ogstad testified in opposition to the request based on parking problems in the area. He itemized the LDS Church, First Christian ` Church, Senior Center and Library as being in the area and having functions at the same time. He suggested that the grass strip on the sidewallc be eliminated and the area used for diagonal parking. Sue Smith testified about the request, citing parking and traffic as a major problem now and with the gymnasium it will be worse. Steve Maggio testified about the request, citing parking and trash problems associated with such a facility. He is looking to the Conunission for leadership in directing the planning of the facility. Carol Skinner testified about the request, citing a lack of overall planning and cost estimating. She also cited concerns about the parking situation and the alleged non-spectator sports and that Sebree Park should not be made available as a parking lot. Ms. Ottens handed a copy of a proposed community center budget which is attached to the record as Exhibit B. Dick Winder testified about the request, stating that the City should abide by a higher standard than that required of the private sector, that if private citizens are required to provide adequate parking, then the City should also. He stated that the Cominission has the authority to limit the use of the complex and should use its authority in this case limiting the use to two or three specific cases. 15 YTEM ACTIAN/FOLLOW-UP Mr. Winder also refened to asbestos in the building and the results of the study done during his tenure on Council 1987-89. Ms. Ottens responded regarding the asbestos saying that there are plans to deal with the asbestos, but that the only asbestos in the gym is in the roof tile which is treatable by covering it. The Report on Asbestos is attached to the record as Exhibit C. A letter was submitted to the Commission, attached to the record as Exhibit D, from LeAnn Simmons, e�ressing concern over the preservation of Sebree Park as a park and that the City should explore other alternatives to alleviate the parking problem. The public hearing phase , of the meeting was closed. Commissioner Earl asked for the Fire Marshall to answer questions. Mr. Dilley pointed out on the plan the area where fire lanes would best be situated, and stated that the City had met with him and discussed all his concerns and come to an agreement. He further stated that there would have to be area separation between the gym and the rest of the building to meet fire code. He has not yet figured out the total occupancy of the building. Rick Wells asked if the Fire Department had been involved in the initial planning for this. Mr. Dilley replied that it had not and that he has not seen a set of plans. Rita Earl asked for a representative of the Engineering Department to address the Commission. Mr. Enebo stated that any changes in parking or traffic flow will go through the Traffic Commission and this is addressed in the Staff Report recommendations. After a cursory inspection of the parking situation on Everett Street, it would appear that there is room for 16 ITEM ACTION/FOLLOW-UP diagonal parking on one side and parallel parking on the other side apart from areas designated as fire lanes. Rick Wells asked if the Engineering staff had been involved in the planning stage of this facility to which Mr. Enebo said not at this time. Phil Frye asked that Ms. Ottens retuxn to the podium and asked how she felt so far about the application. She stated that the Planning and � Zoning Commission have to give direcrion on the parking issue as there is no standard. Regarding landscaping, the 4-C Committee does not want to expend funds on this, if in the future that landscaping has to be torn out to accommodate future use and changes. She said there has been a feasibility study which includes cost estimates. She asked that before the Commission deny the request they might let the Committee know what more information they need to make a decision so that the opening date may go ahead as planned. Commissioner Frye asked the applicant if she would like the application to be considered as submitted. She stated that she would. Carlos Ferreira stated that it is difficult to make a decision within a couple of hours about something which has taken months to consider by other entities. He felt that the project seems very worthwhile but there are many questions which need more time to answer. Rita Earl stated that she had heard from people about how the project should proceed, that the City needs to do more in a public relations forum to inform the City of plans. Commissioner Frye suggested that with the testimony presented, the applicant should submit a more detailed plan addressing the concerns outlined. Rita Earl made a motion to table the request and form a subcommittee to meet with representatives of the 4C Committee, 17 ITEM ACTION/FOLLOW-UP Engineering, Fire and members of the public to assist in the overall planning of the facility. Motion was seconded by Wanda Anthony. Phil Frye questioned the legality of such a subcommittee with membership of Commission members being a part of the plannuig process which would eventually be approved by the Commission. Chuck Randolph suggested amending the Motion. Mary Higdem felt there was insufficient information for the Commission to make a decision and that the application should be tabled, because of the importance of the project to the community and the need for good planning. Carlos Ferreira felt the applicant should be given an opportunity to bring back an appropriate plan for the Commission to consider. The motion was withdrawn. Chuck Randolph offered the applicant the choice of withdrawing at this point, or continue to try to act. Applicant indicated they would welcome a decision of the Conunission. Carlos Ferreira made a motion to table the MOTION: To table the request until such time as request until such time as staff is satisfied that a as staff is satisfied that a proposal is retumed to proposal is returned to the Commission that the Commission which meets the concerns meets the concerns voiced. Rick Wells seconded voiced. Approved. the motion. Rita Earl, Phil Frye, and Wanda Anthony voted in favor of the motion and Maxy Higdem voted against the motion based on the finding that there is no master plan for the facility. Tom Ensley abstained. Chairman stated that in his opinion the Commission were not against the project but that concerns were voiced which need to be addressed. 18 ITEM ACTION/FOLLOW-UP 5. NEW BUSINESS Chairman, citing the late hour, suggested that the Comnussion consider items SA and 5C and other items be tabled to the next meeting. 5A. Case No. 92-5-06 Preliminary plat approval of Rojmar Subdivision involving the subdivision of approximately 0.84 acres into 5(five) residential lots on property located on South Illinois. Jim Blizzard gave the background to the request, referring to the review and correspondence received from Pioneer Imgation. Staff recommend approval subject to conditions listed. Mary Higdem commented on the report of the potential landlocking of the parcel to the east. � The Director stated that while it is a concern to staff it is not illegal for the landowner to do this. Gerry Earl, the surveyor for the project, agreed and confirmed that the landowner has been apprised of the potential problem. 19 ITEM ACTION/FOLLOW-UP Tom Ensley made a motion, seconded by Carlos MOTION: To approve the preliminary plat and Ferreira, to approve the preliminary plat and forward the final plat to City Council, subject to forward the final plat to City Council for the following conditions: approval with the recommendations as listed by staff. The vote was unanimous with Rita Earl 1. The applicant shall provide utility service abstaining, and noting Commission's concern and utility easements to the individual regarding the potential landlocking of the eastem lots subject to approval of affected parcel. utilities and the City of Caldwell. Phil Frye asked that a fifth condition be added 2. Prior to certification of the plat by the addressing the concerns of Pioneer Irrigation and City Clerk, the subdivider shall execute an the maker and seconder of the Motion agreed. agreement of performance to assure the completion of required street and sidewalk improvements and a performance bond, cash, letter of credit or other form of City-approved financial instrument, or a deferral agreement to enter into a Local Improvement District, which will allow for completion of all required improvements as approved by the City Engineer. 3. The applicant shall install a fire hydrant at the intersection of Helena and Missoula in conformance with fire department standards. 4. The plat will be revised to clearly indicate the United States Exclusive Dixie Drain Right of Way laying 50 feet from the drain centerline. 5. The concerns of Pioneer Irrigation District be addressed prior to final plat approval. 5C. Review of Amendment to Subdivision Regulation re ag rding Street Li�g The Director e�lained the background to this item, adding that Council has already passed the first reading of the bill to mandate installation of private and public street lighting in all subdivisions. 20 ITEM ACTIO�/FOLLOW-UP Rita Earl raised the question of the wording allowing a year in which to install lighting. Mr. Blizzard explained that this is a time frame rather than a requirement and that the developer, Engineering and Public Works work together on a schedule to coordinate such improvements. In response to a quesrion from Rick Wells, Mr. Blizzard commented that design standards are not included in this. Tom Ensley made a motion and Wanda Anthony MOTION: To forward draft subdivision seconded to forward the draft subdivision regulation amendment to City Council for regulation amendment to City Council for approval. approval. Vote was unanimous. 8. Chairman and Director will meet and discuss tabled items to place on upcoming agenda. Meeting adjourned at 12:15 a.m.