HomeMy WebLinkAbout11-21-1991 P&Z MINUTES � � PL,Al�TG AND ZONING COIV�ISSION
„ MINU'I'ES
f
Meeting of November 21, 1991
Present Chairman Chuck Randolph, Bob Carpenter, Rita Ear1, Mary
Higdem, Tom Ensley, Wanda Anthony and Carlos Ferreira. !,
Absent George Banta
The meeting was called to order by Chairman Chuck Randolph at 7:15
p.m. in the City Hall Council Chambers.
The first item of business was the approval of the minutes of the
regular meeting of the Planning and Zoning Commission of October
17, 1991. With no additions or corrections being offered by
Commission members, Carlos Ferreira made a motion to approve the
minutes as distributed. Rita Earl seconded the motion. A vote was
taken and the motion passed unanimously.
The next item of business was the approval of the minutes from the
Planning and Zoning workshop held on November 6, 1991. With no
corrections or additions being offered by Commission members, Bob
Carpenter made a motion to approve the minutes as distributed.
Rita Earl seconded the motion. A vote was taken and the motion
passed unanimously.
The f irst public hearing on the agenda involved a Comprehensive
Plan land use designation of property under consideration for
annexation of a 23.55 acre parcel of land which runs from Tenth
Street on the West to the Dixie Drain on the East and from
Jefferson Junior High School on the south to the Willowbrook
Estates on the North (3019 S. lOth). Marvin B. Wampler, applicant.
Also associated with this request was a Zone Change reguest from
County R-1 to City of Caldwell R-1 (Single Family Residential) or
other zoning classification deemed appropriate for the above
mentioned property. Marvin B. Wampler, applicant.
Chairman Randolph stated that these two items will be considered
under one public hearing and action will be taken separately on
each request.
Dennis explained the request and location of the subject property.
He stated that this request for annexation was presented to the
City Council. The City Council directed Staff to begin the
annexation process and asked for a recommendation from the Planning
and Zoning Commission as to the land use designation and zoning
classification. Dennis further stated that this property lies
within the City's impact area and is currently designated as
Residential on the Comprehensive Plan.
�. Bob Carpenter a�i Dennis if a plat has b� received for this
property. Dennis stated that an application for a plat has been
received and will be considered at a later date should the
� annexation be approved.
Chairman Randolph stated that Rita Earl is abstaining from
discussion and the voting process.
The first person to offer public testimony was Chuck Karn, 2024
Brookside, Caldwell. Mr. Karn was representing the applicant in
this matter. Mr. Karn stated that if the annexation and zone
change is approved, the property will be subdivided for a
residential development and a preliminary plat will be submitted.
There was no other public testimony offered.
Dennis stated that there was no other correspondence received by
Staf f .
With no further discussion Carlos made a motion to approve the
Comprehensive Plan land use designation as recommended by Staff.
Tom Ensley seconded the motion. Bob Carpenter commented that he
was voting in favor of the motion with the intent that the property
remain residential throughout the project. A vote was taken and
the motion passed unanimously. Rita Earl abstained from the voting
process.
Tom Ensley made a motion to approve the Zone Change from County R-1
to City of Caldwell R-l. Wanda Anthony seconded the motion. A
vote was taken and the motion passed unanimously. Rita Earl
abstained from voting.
The next public hearing was a Special Use Permit to allow the
installation of a freestanding pylon sign 100 feet high which
exceeds the maximum sign height requirement of forty-five feet
within the C-2 (Community Commercial) zoning district, on property
located at the southeast corner of lOth Avenue and Freeport Street
(614 N. lOth). Gem Stop, by Young Electric Sign Company,
applicant.
Dennis explained the request and the location of the subject
property. He stated that the intent of the applicant is to
attract the freeway and traveling public. He further stated that
surrounding properties have previously received approval for
similar requests and therefore have set a precedent in the area.
The first person to offer public testimony was Roger Huber, 5511 W.
Lockport Dr., Boise, Idaho. Mr. Huber stated to the Commission
that he was available for any questions they may have.
Carlos asked Dennis to comment on the issue of sidewalks as
addressed in Staff's report. Dennis stated that Staff's
recommendation as a condition attached to the approval of the
request was for completion of a missing section of sidewalk on the
Freeport Street frontage.
Carlos stated that he has concerns about setting a further
precedent for future requests of a similar nature.
'. Rita asked what �e distance of the sign � f=om the freeway.
Dennis stated that the distance is within one block (300-400 feet)
f rom the f reeway .
Chairman Randolph asked Dennis if a distinction is made in the
current Sign Ordinance regarding signs within the visibility of the
freeway. Dennis stated that a distinction is not made in the
current Sign Ordinance. Dennis further stated that the Sign
Ordinance is scheduled for revision in the near future and perhaps
the issue of freeway visibility related to signs could be addressed
during that revision.
Rita Earl asked Dennis if a condition could be attached to the
approval requiring that the sign and/or support pole be removed
should the ownership of the property change.
Bob Carpenter stated that the Special Use Permit should not be
transferable and the property owner should be required to come
before the Commission with another Special Use Permit to show cause
for leaving the sign and/or support pole in place.
Rita stated that the condition should contain a time frame in which
the sign and support pole should be removed.
Dennis stated that Staff received a phone inquiry regarding this
matter. The inquiring person did not have any objections to the
proposed request but commented the sign on the property displaying
gas pricing impairs visibility when turning onto lOth Avenue.
Dennis stated that he surveyed the area and did not find vision
� impaired to a great degree.
Chairman Randolph asked Dennis if any additional signs will be
requested for the property. Dennis referred the question to the
representative for the applicant. Mr. Huber stated that it is the
intention of the applicant to change the sign displaying the
pricing and this change will be discussed with the Planning and
Zoning Department before any changes are made.
Bob Carpenter stated that any additional sign changes would have to
come before the Commission via a Special Use Permit.
With no further discussion Bob Carpenter made a motion to approve
the Special Use Permit with the conditions recommended by Staff
and the addition of a condition stating that in the event that the
business closed, the property owner would have thirty days to
request an extension of the Special Use Permit or to remove the
sign and support pole. Mary seconded the motion. A vote was taken
and the motion passed unanimously.
The next public hearing was a Special Use Permit to allow the
construction of a recreational facility (two baseball batting
cages) and a new warehouse building in an M-1 (Light Industrial)
zone. The subject property is located on the southwest corner of
Paynter Avenue and Holly Street (708 Paynter). Bryan Riser,
applicant.
� Dennis explaine e request and location of�ie subject property.
' He stated that�resently on the property is a single family
residence that is currently being used in a manner of a warehouse.
� He further stated that the Engineering Department reviewed this
request for possible street improvements and indicated that Paynter
Avenue is the subject for an improvement plan within the next 3-4
years. Staff from the Engineering Department requested that a
condition be associated with this permit to require the applicant
execute an agreement with the City stating a willingness to
participate in an LID if such district were to be established.
The first person to offer public testimony was Bryan Kiser, 710
Paynter, Caldwell, applicant. Bryan stated that he felt this
facility will meet a recreational need within the City and its
direct physical relationship to the City park will enhance the
recreational activity in the City.
Tom Ensley asked Mr. Riser to explain how the facility will
operate. Mr. Kiser stated that the batting cages will be open
during daylight hours and have adult supervision at all times.
Mary Higdem asked Mr. Kiser what kind of surface the batting cages
will have. Mr. Kiser stated that there will be a hard surface with
either blacktop or concrete.
Mary asked Mr. Kiser what kind of fencing is propased. Mr. Riser
stated that the batting cages will be completely fenced.
Carlos asked Mr. Kiser if there was adequate parking spaces. Mr.
Kiser stated that he felt the four spaces proposed will be adequate
for the two batting cages.
Tom Ensley asked Mr. Kiser what the usage will be for the proposed
building on the site. Mr. Kiser stated that it will be used for
storage and to take payment for the use of the batting cages. He
further stated that there will be no retail business conducted from
the facility.
Carlos asked Dennis if retail business was conducted would there be
adequate parking. Dennis stated that a retail business would
affect the parking spaces required but this facility is located in
an M-1 zoning classification and retail sales is not a permitted
use.
Rita asked Dennis if the applicant extended the hours of operation
into the evening hours would specific lighting requirements need to
be met. Dennis stated that should the applicant wish to extend the
hours it should come back before the Commission for further review.
Dennis stated that there was no other communication received by
Staff regarding this matter.
With no further business Carlos made a motion to approve the
Special Use Permit with the addition of condition number 6 stating
that if the hours of operation are extended the item will come
before the Commission for consideration and be readvertised as a
public hearing. Wanda stated that she would like language to be
added to condition number 2 that requires a hard surface will be
installed in the batting cages. Wanda seconded the motion.
. Chairman Randolp tated that it was the in of the Commission
' members to refle�in the minutes a concern�arding the parking
� spaces for this facility.
With no further discussion a vote was taken and the motion passed
unanimously.
The next item of business was miscellaneous items on the agenda.
The first miscellaneous item was a report on City Council action.
Dennis reported that there are no items to report on City Council
action related to Planning and Zoning. The next miscellaneous item
was the tentative agenda for December 19, 1991. Dennis briefly
outlined the applications that have been received by Staff for the
next regular meeting. Dennis stated that there are other items
tentatively scheduled for the next meeting but those applications
have not been received at this time.
With no further business the meeting was adjourned at 8:25 p.m.
Respectfully,
ll�
Sue Mullen,
Recording Secretary
I
Approved by, ''�
Chuck Randolph,
Chairman