HomeMy WebLinkAbout8-15-1991 P&Z MINUTES ° _ �LANNING AND ZONING COI�IlKIS�N
MINUTES
Meeting of August 15, 1991
Present: Chairman Chuck Randolph, Rita Earl. Tom Ensley, George
Banta and Bob Carpenter.
Absent: Wand�a Anthony, Tom Page and Mary Higdem.
The meeting was called to order by the Chairman, Chuck Randolph,
at 7:00 p.m. in the City Hall Council Chambers.
The first item on the agenda was the minutes of tha July 18, 1991
regular meeting of the Planning and Zoning Commission. With no
corrections or additions offered by the Commission members, Bob
Garpenter made a motion to approve the minutes as distributed.
George Hanta seconded the motion. A vote was taken and the
motion passed unanimously.
The first public hearing was a Comprehensive Plan land use
designation involving property under consideration for annexation
located at the northwest corner of Larch Street and Indiana
Avenus. Gene Graves, applicant. tContinued from July 18, 1991)
A companion case includes a Zone Change from County R-1 to City
of Caldwell R-1 (Low Density Residential) for the same property.
Gene Gxaves, applicant.
Dennis-explained to the Commission that a representative for the
app2icant has requested that this item be continued indefinitely. "
Wi�th� no further discussion Tom Ensley made a motion to table the
item to a future meeting of the Planning and Zoning Commission.
George Banta seconded the motion. A vote was taken and the
motion passed. Rita Earl abstained from voting.
The next public hearing was a Special Use Permit application to
a1i•ow a convalescent/nursing home for the elderly on property
located at 1408 Arlington. Ann Faulconer, applicant (Continued
from July 18, 1991.)
De�rinis•�explained that this item was continued from the Planning
and �Zoning Commission's meeting of July 18 in order for the City
Attr��ney to provide input on material presented by Ms. Faulconer. :
The City Attorney indicated in a written opinion provided to the �
Commission members that it is proper for the Planning and Zoning
Commis�.i,on to continue the public hearing and render a decision
on this case. Dennis further explained that the applicant and
her :attorney have requested another continuance due to the
appl.#cant's illness. '
�
t
Bob Catrpenter made a motion to deny the request to continue the
hearing t�nd take action on this item at this meeting. With no �
second the motion died. '�
. ; �
Rita Edrl`commented that she felt the hearing should be continued
ta afford the applicant an opportunity to be present and have ; i
questiane'�asked of �her before a final decision was made. l
�' '
�:
1
�
� �F '�
-, B�}�i Carpenter st�ed that he felt the appPl�:ant. present.ed her
� point of view at the previous public hearir�g and that th� item '
was continued for the single reason of getting the City
Attorney's opinion on the authority of the Commission to make a
decision on this matter.
George Banta made a motion to continue the hearing to the meeting
of the Commission on September 5, 1991. Rita Earl seconded the
mation.
A vote was taken and the motion passed. Bob Carpenter voted in
oppositian to the motion.
The next public hearing was a Comprehensive Plan amendment to the
land use component from High Density Residential to General
Commercial involving property located at the southwest corner of
Tenth Avenue and Everett Street (918 and 924 Everett>. Charles
and Ardis Karn and Gena and Phyllis Baxter, applicants.
Dennis explained the request, reminding the Commission members -
that changes to the Comprehensive Plan are affected by State law.
Recommendations to the Council to change the Plan may not occur
more frequently than every six months. The next period of time
for making those types of recommendations to the Council is
September-October. Dennis further explairied to the Commission
�.hat if this request is ultimately approved the property in
question would most likely be completely surrounded by other
zoning districts and therefore considered "spot zoning". The
predominant land use pattern in this area rem�ins residential. -�
- The character of Tenth Avenue should be taken into consideration. ,;�
Also, Dennis stated that there is no-specific site plan for this TM�;
property and if the land use component of the Plan is changed and
the property is Eventially rezoned there are a number of �
different types of uses that could be placed on the property. �.
,�
Dennis indicated to the Commission that there is new state
legislation concerning development agreements that can be of use
in changes of zoning by limiting the subject property to a
certain type of project. However, the City of Caldwell has not
incorporated this into their Municipal Code and this option is
not available ta the City at this time.
Rita Earl asked Dennis if the Golden West property is zoned
Commercial. Dennis stated that the zone is R-3 (High Density
Residential) and office use is a special use in the R-3 zone. -
Dennis stated that there was correspondence received concerning
this item. Copies of that correspondence were distributed to the
Commission members. '`�
The first person to offer public testimony was the applicant, .
Chuck Karn, 2024 Brookside Dr. Mr. Karn requested to review the
written communication presented to the Commission.
Chairman Randolph read the written communication including on�
from C.E. and Doris Frost, 1000 block of Everett Street and
William �':� Gigray Jr. acting as legal council for Betty Moore.
2
�. _ Mr. Karn stated t he has tried to market this property with an
R-3 2oning classification and those prospective buyers that have
inquired about the property were interested in it for uses that
were not permitted in the R-3 zone. Therefore, he felt that the
property would be more marketable if the zoning classification
was changed. �
Rita Earl asked Mr. Karn to explain how this request would meet
the spirit and purpose of the Comprehensive Plan. Mr. Karn
stated that the staff report prepared by the Planning and Zoning
Department has validity but does not solve the problem of
marketing this p�ece of property.
Chairman Randolph read the letters received by the Planning and
2oning Department. The first letter was from C.E. Frost. The
letter stated that they were in opposition to the request before
the Cornmission. The second letter was from Mrs. Betty Moore.
Ms. Moore was also in opposition to the approval of this request
and requested to retain the R-3 zaning classification on the
subJect property. The third letter was from Mr. Gigray Jr.,
representing Owen and Betty Moore. Mr. Gigray stated that Mr. &
Mrs. Moore were in opposition to the approval of this request.
Mr. Karn stated that they have attempted _to keep the property
clear of weeds and to be good neighbors to surrounding property
owners.
The next person to offer testimony was Betty Moore, 914 Everett. -
Mrs. Moore stated that she is in opposition to the approval of �
this request. She stated that she has owned her home for 38 -
years and would not like to see any further commercial facilities
in that area.
The next person to offer public testimony w�s Enoch 4gstad, 1008
Everett. Mr. Ogstad stated that although Mr. Karn has cleaned up
the sub�ect property he is in opposition to the approval of this
request and the additional traffic thdt corcunercially designated
property would generate.
The next person to offer public testimony_` Sue Smith, 1015
Everett. Ms. Smith stated that'the additi.onal traffic generation
is her main concern. Ms. Smith further stated that Mr. Karn has
maintained the property in good condition but the type of
business that would be allowed on that site is of concern to the
surrounding property owners. She furthe� etated that the area
is ideally suited for residential uses for seniors due to the
proximity of the senior center and the library.
.
Chairman Randolph asked Mr. Karn if the po�et�tial buyers have had
a specific type of business that they would like to build on the
site. Mr. Karn stated that they do not have a prospective buyer
at this time with a specific type of facility in mind. Some of
the previous potential buyers have indicated possibilities of a
retail business. _
3
•, • Rita Earl stated•that she has concerns a�ociated with this
� request. She further stated that there are dther areas in the
city that are already zoned for commercial use and those
businesses looking to place a business within the City limits
have a number of areas to consider without changing the zoning of
a residentially zoned area. She further stated that the
additional traffic generation is a concern and all the uses that
would be allowed in a commercial zone should be viewed as a
possibiiity for this property. Rita furthers stated that the
land use sub-committee for updating the Comprehensive Plan should
give this area an intensive review and recommend any changes at
that time that would be beneficial to the entire neighborhood. `
�
Dennis' that the membership of that sub-committee has been
formed, and should begin their study of the portion of the
Comprehensive Plan that involves land use appraximately in
September or October.
Tom Ensley stated that he also has several concerns about this
piece of property creating a"spot zoning" affect and the use of
the property generating additional traffic in the neighborhood.
Dennis stated that the options to the Commission on this item are
1 � to continue the item indefinitely to give the Iand use sub-
committee time to evaluate the area and make a recommendation; 2)
to have'a favorable recommendation to the City Council to amend
the Comprehensive Plan or 3) choose not to forward a favorable `
- recommendatior� to the City Council for amending the Plan. -
Rita £ar1 asked Dennis if the land use sub-committee will get
communi`ty input before making recommendations for land use
changes"to the Comprehensive Plan. Dennis stated that tha sub-
committee can solicit input from property owners in connection
within' a review of the land use designation. Input is prefered
on a neighborhood or area as a whole but not necessarily on
individual properties.
Bob Carpenter made a motion to forward the request to the land
use sub-�COt�nittee for further study and a recommendation that no
action be t�ken on the request �y the Commission at this time.
��_
A vote was taksn and the motion passed. George Banta abstained
from voting.
The next,public hearing was a Special Use Permit application to
allow a�r,esidential expansion involving conversion of two (2)
single fa�rAi�ly detached residences into a three-family dwelling
unit on,�roperty located at 210 3rd Avenue. George Randall,
applicanC.`
Dennis + explained the request and locat,ion of the sub�ect
property.� Dennis stated that the property is currently
designated as a C-3 zoning classification and the site is
developed with residential uses. A three-family dwelling unit is
a special use in the C-3 zone.
..�
4
'. Ghairman Randol h•sked Dennis if the setbac• are accordin to
� Code regulations. Dennis stated that the �
property is
appraximately 9000 square feet, there is no rear yard on the
property and changing this property to a three-family dwelling
will create a transition to a higher density type use.
Rita Earl asked Dennis if the parking spaces should be paved in a
C-3 zone. Dennis stated that the Code does not require single-
family, two-family and three-family residences to pave parking
areas.
The first person to offer public testimony was Eldon Shields, 212
18th Ave. South, Nampa. Mr. Shields was representing Mr.
Randall. Mr. Shields stated that Mr. Randall is in agreement
with the recommendations offered by staff and the property will
be improved because of the remodeling associated with this
project. Mr. Shields further stated that this pro�ect will
enable Mr. Randall to have someone live at the residence to care
for him.
Chairman Randolph asked Mr. Shields if the parking spaces
illustrated in the provided material are adequate for the
development of the property. Mr. Shields stated that the parking
spaces illustrated are adequate and will not jeopardize the
proJect in any way.
Chairman Randolph asked Dennis if the parking spaces, as
illustrated, are acceptable to the City. Dennis stated that the
concept illustrated is acceptable with the exception of staff's
recommendation for the parking to be placed off the alley as
opposed to being placed off 3rd Strset.
The next person to offer public testimony was Mr. Ed Thurston,
2111 Ray Ave. Mr. Thurston stated that he owns property adjacent
to Mr. Randall's. He further stated that he has no objection to
the request before the Commission.
The next person to offer public testimony was Lorraine Thurston,
2111 Ray Ave. Ms. Thurston stated that as co-owner of the
property adjacent to Mr. Randall she also has no objection to the
request.
Dennis stated that there was no other communication received by
staff regarding this issue.
Chairman Randolph asked Mr. Shields if the recommendations
offered by Staff were acceptable to Mr. Randall. Mr. Shields
stated that all of the recommendations were acceptable.
Rita Earl asked if Mr. Randall was the only occup�nt in this
facility. Mr. Shields stated that there were two other occupants
and the third occupant will be responsible for taking care of Mr. �
Randall.
�
5
- Rita Earl asked �nis if another conditia�ould be placed on
- the request that t.he Special Use Ferrnit be restricted to Mr.
Randall's use and nUt t�ansfera�le ta another propeity owner
Dennis stated that when a special use permit involves new ar
expanded construction in addition to the use of the property, it
is not appropriate or practical to view the use as temporary and
restrict approval of the permit to the applicant only.
With no further discussion George Banta made a motion ta approve
the Special Use Permit with the terms and conditions affered by
Staff. Tam Ensley seconded the motion. A vote was taken and the
motion passed unanimously.
The next item of business was the miscellaneous item an the
agenda. The first miscelianeous item was a report on City
Council action. Dennis stated that there were no items acted
on by the City Council to report at this time.
The next miscellaneous item was an init�ation of an amendment to
the Caldwell Zoning Ordinance pertaining to development and
design standards for the placement of residential mobilei
manufactured homes on individual lots outside of mobile home
parks.
Dennis stated that this item was brought before the Commission
for direction to Staff t.o review this issue and consi�er
modification or additional standards into the Code.
After brief d�scussion, Rita Earl made a motion to direct staff
to begin a review of design standards. Tom Ensley seconded the
motion. A vote was taken and the motian passed unanimouwly.
The r�ext miscellaneous item was a Variance application to create
sub-standard lot to accommodat� placement of a mobile home
involving property located on the east side of South Indiana
Avenue south of Beech Street ( 3221 South Indiana).
Dennis explained that this item is brought before the Commission
because a request was submitted to the City for a Variance to
place a mobile hame on a lot in an R-2 zoning district. He
further stated that the Staff determined that a Variance was not
an appropriate request to make in this matter and would like
direction from the Commission on this item. Dennis continued by
stating that a Variance is appropriate for a modification of the
technical requirement of the Code, such as lot size, lot
coverage, setbacks and types of things that involve technical
application of zoning pr�visions. TY�e request that this issue
involves is for placing a mobile home on property that does not
have a T-overlay zone. This request is asking for a change in
the use of the property as opposed to a waiver of a technical.
aspect of the Code. A Variance is not the appropriate request to
place a mobile home on a lot that is not in a zoning district
which allows mobile home use.
�I
i
�,
6
`. Ms. Diane Johnsan�1321 S. Indiana addressed�he Commission. Ms.
� Jahnsan stated that the request is to place a 10' x 40' mobile
home in the rear yard of the existing residence and connect all
utilities to the residence. This mobile home is for a 93 year
old family member with limited income and unable financial2y to
enter a nursing horne. She stat.zd that. they are planning to
install a six foot (6'} cedar fence around the entire property
and the mobile home would not be visible from surrounding
properties.
Tom Ensley asked Ms. J�r�nson how the remainder of the property is
being used. Ms. Jarins�n stated that the remainder of the
property is pasture land.
Tom Ensley asked Ms. Johnson if there were future plans to
subdivide the property. Ms. Johnson stated that there are
possible plans to subdivide the propzrty for another family
member. Ms. Johnson further stated that when the mobile home
will no longer be used by the family member it is now intended
for, it will be removed f�orn the property.
George Banta asked Dennis if a conditior, could be stipulated that
the mobile home be removed when the existing residence no longer
needs it. Dennis stated that when dealing with the use of the
property a Variance is no� the appropriate request. The concept
of a temporary use is a�ossibility but that option involves a
development agreement whi�h is not in currently in the City Code.
Another aption wouid be to put a T—overlay zoning classification
an this piece of pro�er�y so a Variance request would not be �
neeessary.
Rita Earl commented that she felt the land use is an issue that
does not fall into the category of a Variance request.
Tom Ensley asked Ms. Jo�nson if there were other options that
cauld be explored by Staff to enable the mobile home to be placed
on this particular piece of property, other than a Variance
request, would the applicant be willing to allow Staff to study
the different types of options and make a recommendation. Ms.
Johnson stated that the applicant would be willing to look at all
options for reaching a decision that would allow the mobile home
to be placed on this property.
Rita Earl stated that the Commission must recognize that ,
precedents are being set by their decisions and must be careful '
about making exceptions to the Code regulations. '
There was discussion regarding the construction of a manufactured
home. Dennis stated that if a manufactured home were constructed
on a conforming lot it would not be necessary to come before the
Commission. Ms. Johnson stated that a constructed manufactured
home would be out of the financial capability af the applicant.
,
�
'', After further dis�ssion regardin the o t.io� avaiiabie t.o tt7r
_ g p
applicant. it was the consensus of t.he Gammission that a Variar�ce
application was not the appropriate request f�}r this particular
issue. The Commission, however, was sensitive to the nature of
the request and therefore, directed Staff to review the issue and.
continue to search for an option that will be agreeable to both
the City and to the applicant.
The next item on the agenda was the tentative agenda for the
Commission meeting in September. Dennis stated that due to the
large number of requests to come before the Commission it will �e
neGessary ta hold two meetings in the month of September. The
first meeting will be held September 5th and the second meeting
will be held September 19th. Dennis outlined the possible items
that will come bsfore the Commission in those two meetings.
There wa� discussion regarding Code vialations involving animals,
weeds, vacant properties not being maintained, and the use of the
property. Dennis stated that complaints from the community
regarding these issues are received by Staff on a constant basis.
With na further discussion, the meeting was adjourned at 9:25
p.m.
Respectfully submitted
Sue Mullen, `
Recording Secretary
Approved by,
Chuck Randolph, Chairman
B