HomeMy WebLinkAbout7-18-1991 P&Z MINUTES � ` � �
pLANNING AND ZONING COMMISSI�N
MINUTES
Meeting of July 18, 1991
Preaent: Chairm�n Ghuck Rand�,lph. P.ita Earl, Wanda Anthany,
George Banta and Bob Carpenter.
Absent: Tom Ensley, Mary Higdem and Tom Page.
The regular meeting of the Planning and Zoning Commission was
called to order by Chairman Chuck Randolph at 7:00 p.m. in the
City Hall Council Chambera.
The first item of business was the approval of the minutes from
the regular meeting of the Corrunission on June 13, 1991. With no
corrections or additinns offered by the Cammissian members, Rit.a
Earl made a motion to approve the minutes as distributed. Wanda
Anthony second�d the motion.
Chairman Chuck Randolph reco_qnized Les Carter fox� his yeara of
service with the Planninq and Zoning Cornmission. Chairman
Randolph presented Les with a certificate and plaque and publicly
thanked him for his contribution to the Commission.
Chairman Randolph welcamed Bob Carpenter to th� Commission as an
alternate member. ,
The next item of business was the public hearings. The. first
public hearing was a Cc.�mprehensive Plan land use designation of
property under consideration for annexation located at the
northwest corner of Larch Street and Indiana Avenue. Also
associated with this he�rinq was a Zone Change frc�m County R-1 to
City of Caldwell R-1 (Sinqle Family Residential) for� property
located at the northwest corner of Larch Street and Indiana �'
Avenue. Gene Graves, applicant of both requests.
Dennis explained the reqtiest and location of the subject
property. Dennis stated that the applicant's representative made �
a request to continue the hearing to the next scheduled
Commission meeting in August. After brief discussion a motion
was made and secanded to continue the hearinR to the August
meeting of the Planning and �oning Commission.
The next public hearing was a Special Use Permit applic�tion to
allow a car impound and storage facility on the southeast corner
of 10th and Albany Streets. Canyon County, applicant.
Donnis explained that the applicant elected to withdraw the
request upon discovery that the site was not large enough to
accommodate expected needs. The Commissic�n accepted the
withcirawal request.
T'he next public hearing was a Special Use Permit application to
allow a convale�cent/nursinq home far the elderly on property
located at 1408 Arlington Avenue, Ann Faulconer, applicant.
1
�� � i
D�nnis �x�il�inecl the r t.r�F lacation of the subject
property and characteristics associated with the praperty and
surrounding land use. Dennis ctated that t.here had been both
written correspondence and phone contact with surrounding
property owners. Llennis distributed capies of the written
correspondence to the Cc�mmissior� members. Dennis also
distributed capies of a written staternent from the applicant.
The first person to offer public testimony was the applicant, Ann
Faulconer, 1914 E. Lewis Latte, Nampa. Ms. Faulconer stated that
sh� wauld like to cl�x�ify that the request is for a"Residential
Care Home" not a nursing home. Ms. Faulconer stated that she did
not understand why she was required tn come before the Commission
with this request. She then read to the Commission a copy of
House Bill No. 1�3 pertaining to group residences for mentally
and/or physically handicapped persons.
Bob Carpenter asked Dennis what zone the �ubject property was
located in. Dennis stated that it was located in an R-2 zone.
Wanda Anthony asked Ms. Faulconer if she was living in the
subject residence. Ms. Faulconer stated that she lives in Nampa
and has another facility that she operates there but will be
worl€ing at the subject re�idence as �art of the staff on a Fart-
time basis.
Chuck Randolph asked Ms. Faulc�ner if the facility in Nampa will
continue to aperate. Ms. Faulconer stated that it will continue.
,
Bob Carpenter asked Ms. Faulconer if the facility in Caldwell is
operated for profit. Ms. Faulconer stated that the facility is
nc�t highly profitable but is intended to operate for profit.
Ms. Faulconer stated that she was employed by Mercy Medical
Center far 25 years and has seen the need for the elderly to have
a facility to go to while rec�vering from an illness.
ThPre was discussion rec�arding the Hnuse Hill read by Ms.
Faulconer and the impact �n Cit.y zoning regulations. Dennis
stated that he had previously cc�ntacted the City Attorney to �
discuss the matter of residential shelter homes for the elderly
and state legislation. The Attorney indic�-�ted that he was not �
aware of any conflict in legislation between the state and local
level that would supersede City Zoning regulations.,_The House
Bill presented by Ms. Faulconer, however, was new information and
Dennis recommended contacting and receiving input from the City
Attorney about this material before a decision was made by the
Commission.
Ms. Faulconer stated that she would like a decision as soon as
possiUle because the delay in beginning the facility is
financially a burden to her.
2
• •
The next �erson ta offer public testim�ny was Roy Payne, 312 E.
Morrison. Mr. Payne stated that he has no vbjections to this
type �f facility and to the number of residents in this
particular property if it were associated with a single family
residence. However, he feels that this property is too small f�r
this type of business. He stated that there is very little yard
space and there are very crowded conditions for parking and
tratfic.
Chairman Randalph rec�gnized Ar�n Faulcaner again. She stated
that the State requires each roam of the home be measured for
livinq space and has authorized her to conduct this type of
business in this particular building.
The next person to offer public testimony was George Hershey,
1423 Arlington. Mr. Hershey stated that he also feels that this
property is inappropriate for this type of business primarily
because of lack of yard space.
The next person to offer public testimony was Wayne Monk, 2113 S.
Juniper, Nampa. Mr. Monk stated that there is approximately 24U0
square feet in the building on the subject property. He further
stated that he feels that there is adequate room for the proposed
6 residents and that because the residents are elderly people
they will most likely stay on the property and not be a nuisance
to anyone in surrounding properties.
Chairman Randolph read correspondence from neighboring property
owners Lola A. Moore and Robert F. Payne. Both letters expressed
opposition to the special use permit request.
Dennis read excerpts from a phone conversation taken regarding
this matter from John Dillon. Mr. Dillon, also a property owner
in the area, indicated he felt this particular property is nat
appropriate for this type of facility due to the parking, traffic
and ina�equate yard space.
There was discussion regarding the Commission taking action on
this issue or continuing the hearing to another meeting either
the next regular meeting or a special meeting.
Rita Earl stated that she would like the Attorney's opinion
before making a decision.
After further discussion, Bob Carpenter made a motion to continue I I
the hearing to the next regular meetinq of the Commission in '�
August and receive input from the City Attorney reqzrding the ',
House Bill read by Ms. Faulconer. Wanda saconded the motion. A ;
vote was taken and the motion passed unanimously. ',
Ms. Faulconer asked if she could removP the posted.sign on the
property. Dennis stated that the sign could be removed and that
Staff would re—post the site one week prior to the next public �!
hearing. j
3 '
. � �
The next public hearing was a proposed arnendment to the City
Subdivision c�rdinance involving standards and regulations for
maximum block length, maximum cul-de-sac length, maximum loop
street length and also lot dimensions for lots associated with
platted subdivisians and utilized for landscaping, recreation or
other common purposes. City of Caldwell, applicant.
Dennis explained the purpose of the request and identified the
recommended._changes.
After brief �iscussion regarding the purpose of the proposed
amendments Wanda Anthony made a mo�tian to make a recommendation
of approval to the City Council. George Banta seconded the
motion. A vQte was taken and the motion passed unanimously.
Miscellaneous items were next on the agenda. Dennis provided
information regarding the Indian Creek Mobile Home Estates and a
phase of new development that has been started. Dennis provided
background information on the previc�usly granted special use
permit and the imposed condition requiring Commission review of
each new phase of development.
Rob Carpenter made a motion to accept the recommendations af
Staff as detailed in the report to the Commission. Wanda Anthony
secanded the motion. A vote was taken and the motion passed
unanimously.
Dennis indicated that there were no specific City Council action
or items pertaining to the Planning arid Zoning Cammission.
The tentative agenda for the meeting in August was discussed
briefly.
There was discussion re_qarding a work session to be held for the '
Commission members. It was the consensus �f the Commission to I
have a work session sometime in October, after the RUDAT study is �
complete.
With no further business the meeting was adjourned at 8:15 p.m.
Respectfully submitted,
Sue Mullen,
Recording Secretary
Approved,
Chuck Randolph, Chairman
Planning and Zoning Commission
4